Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealDismissedCivil Appeal No. 62 of 2015· [2016] KECA 546 (KLR)

Bamburi Cement Limited v William Kilonzi [2016] KECA 546 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
27 May 2016
4,038 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~16 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal upheld a Kshs.10 million award against Bamburi Cement because the company could not prove an employee actually committed the misconduct he was fired for.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This was an employer's appeal against a decision of the Employment & Labour Relations Court at Mombasa (Makau, J.) awarding William Kilonzi, a weighbridge clerk dismissed after 22 years of service, approximately Kshs.10.2 million for wrongful summary dismissal. The employer alleged that Kilonzi issued irregular weighbridge tickets for two trucks and generated fictitious tickets for scrap tyres never delivered, amounting to gross misconduct under section 44 of the Employment Act. The Court of Appeal, in a unanimous judgment, re-evaluated the evidence afresh and affirmed the trial court. It held that although the procedural requirements of sections 41, 45(5) and 51 were met, the employer failed to discharge its burden under section 47(5) of proving reasonable and sufficient grounds for dismissal: the weighing system was automated, the relevant delivery and inspection functions were performed by outsourced personnel and one Lazarus Mrabai who was never called as a witness, and no financial loss was demonstrated. Applying the contextual test approved in Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei (adopting McKinley v B.C.Tel.), the court held the alleged misconduct did not fundamentally breach the employment relationship. The court upheld the awards of gratuity of Kshs.7,562,544 under clause 30(a) of the CBA, two months' notice pay, and 12 months' compensation, subject to statutory deductions under section 49(2), and added the admitted but omitted meal allowance of Kshs.7,200 to the decree. The appeal was dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the summary dismissal of the respondent was justified

Holding

The dismissal was wrongful; the employer failed to prove gross misconduct on reasonable and sufficient grounds.

Reasoning

Although the procedure under sections 41, 45(5) and 51 of the Employment Act was followed (the employee was heard), there was no evidence linking the respondent to wrongdoing. The system was automated; the duties of inspecting goods, issuing delivery notes and recording vehicles in the register belonged to outsourced Marshalls and one Lazarus Mrabai, whom the appellant failed to call. No financial loss was demonstrated. The grounds of suspicion were therefore unreasonable and insufficient.

p. 5
02

The applicable test for summary dismissal for suspected criminal misconduct

Holding

The context-based test from McKinley v B.C.Tel., approved in Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei, applies; summary dismissal requires gross misconduct fundamentally breaching the employment relationship.

Reasoning

Section 44 permits summary dismissal only for gross misconduct, including a criminal offence committed against, or on reasonable and sufficient grounds suspected to have been committed against, the employer's detriment. The Shollei case adopting the Canadian McKinley test frames the inquiry as whether the dishonesty gave rise to a breakdown of the employment relationship.

p. 3
03

Whether the respondent was entitled to the awards of gratuity, notice pay and compensation

Holding

Yes; the awards of gratuity (Kshs.7,562,544), two months' notice pay (Kshs.365,810) and 12 months' compensation (Kshs.2,194,861.92, subject to statutory deductions) were upheld, and meal allowance of Kshs.7,200 was added.

Reasoning

Section 49 remedies are discretionary, guided by section 49(4) factors including length of service (22 years), age and prospects of re-employment. Clause 30(a) of the CBA provided gratuity of three months' basic pay per completed year for over twenty years of service, and the respondent was not shown to have joined the pension scheme. Clause 19 of the CBA entitled him to two months' notice pay. Meal allowance was admitted and wrongly rejected below.

p. 6
04

Whether the first appellate court should interfere with the trial court's factual findings

Holding

The court re-evaluated the evidence afresh to reach its own conclusion while bearing in mind it neither saw nor heard the witnesses.

Reasoning

As a first appellate court it must evaluate the evidence presented to the trial court and draw its own independent conclusions, subject to the absence of the advantage enjoyed by the trial court of seeing and hearing witnesses, as per Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • An employer may only resort to summary dismissal when the employee's conduct constitutes gross misconduct amounting to a fundamental breach of the contract of service.
  • The burden of proving that a dismissal was wrongful rests on the employee, while the burden of justifying the grounds of dismissal rests on the employer; it is a shared burden.
  • The test for justifying dismissal for dishonesty is contextual: it asks whether the alleged misconduct gave rise to a breakdown in the employment relationship.
  • Where a dismissal is wrongful, an employee is entitled to gratuity if it is provided for in the contract of employment, notwithstanding that the dismissal was summary.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal is dismissed
  2. 2.No orders as to costs
  3. 3.The amount of Kshs.7,200/- (meal allowance) shall be included in the decree
  4. 4.The award of Kshs.2,194,861 for wrongful dismissal compensation shall be subject to statutory deductions under section 49(2) of the Employment Act

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment Act, 2007section 41
  • Employment Act, 2007section 43
  • Employment Act, 2007section 44
  • Employment Act, 2007section 45
  • Employment Act, 2007section 45(5)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 47(5)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 49
  • Employment Act, 2007section 49(1)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 49(2)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 49(4)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 51

Cases cited (3)

  • Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei
    Civil Appeal No. 50 of 2014
  • McKinley v B.C.Tel.
    (2001) 2 S.C.R. 161
  • Selle vs Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd
    (1968) EA 123
On appeal from
Employment & Labour Relations Court of Kenya at Mombasa
E.& L.R.C. Cause No. 465 of 2014
Jurisdiction invoked
First appellate appeal from the Employment & Labour Relations Court under the Employment Act and applicable civil appeal procedure

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (25)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Bamburi Cement Limited v William Kilonzi [2016] KECA 546 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Civil Appeal No. 62 of 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2016/546/eng@2016-05-27

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.