Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Kikimcon Building and Engineering Ltd v Registered Trustees Muthambi Catholic Parish & another (Commercial Case E125 of 2025) [2026] SCC 201 (KLR)

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT CHUKA COMMERCIAL CASE NO. E125 OF 2025 KIKIMCON BUILDING AND ENGINEERING LTD…………………………..………………………...……..CLAIAMNT VERSUS REGISTERED TRUSTEES MUTHAMBI CATHOLIC PARISH………………………………………………………1ST RESPONDENT MICHAEL KABERIA MWENDA……………………………….……….2ND RESPONDENT JUDGMENT Background of the case Claimant filed a claim dated 5/11/2025 and averred that the Respondent failed to pay him for the services rendered by failing to provide materials to conclude the phase of plastering and later on terminated his contract without notice. It was his position that there was no notice issued too him and he sought Kshs.630,000/- in compensation. The Respondent vide a Respondent Denied owing money and indicated that it is the Claimant who owes them Kshs.1,033,700/- and that the labour contract was not fully complied with due to the inaction by the Claimant who was to conclude the project within 16 weeks and that by 2/05/2024, plaster works were yet to commence and therefore the Respondents were forced to terminate the contract. The Claimant filed a response to the counterclaim and termed the claim as an afterthought and maintained the breach was caused by the Respondents. Further, the Claimant raised that the amount claimed was above the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court. Issue for determination Whether the Claimant has proved his case and is entitled to the reliefs sought Whether the Respondent is entitled to the reliefs sought in the counterclaim Costs of the suit

page 1 of 3

Analysis While the Court notes the Claimant failed to attach a CR12 to prove his rank in the company, the Claim as to the Claimant not having express authority to represent the Claimant company is untenable as the Respondents entered into the contract stating him as a director and also notes that he executed the contract before an advocate as representing the company. To this Court, a director has ostensible authority to represent a company. The Court notes that the contract included a clause as to a timeline and it is agreed upon that the project took longer than was agreed upon. To this Court, the Claimant did not satisfy this Court that the Respondents agreed to the extend the project. He did not substantiate the fact that the Respondents made payments after the contract term. Further, the Claimant did not produce evidence that the Respondents received the letter. Neither did he bring any of the labourers to testify in support of this claim of delay as to the Respondents agreeing to the extension of the contract period by way of their conduct. As to the Kshs. 630,000/- it was brought out in evidence that payment was made after each phase was complete and the Claimant holds the position that he did complete the project while the Respondents maintain that he only did half hence the contract was terminated and payment not made. To this Court, the Claimant bore the burden in the first instance to ensure that as an engineer, he presented this Court with a report from an independent engineer certifying the works he had done on the project and the level of completion as at the time he left the project. This is noting that he cannot provide expert evidence as to the work he did himself and could not be an expert witness inn his own case. Therefore, this Court cannot make inference as to the level of works and will refrain from being called to analyze such assertion as to completion. Therefore, the Court dismisses the claim. Counter-claim The Court notes that the same was equally defended in trial.

page 2 of 3

Court has noted that the labour costs produced in Court were not certified by the person who took over the project and it was indicated that the same were lifted from a handwritten book and presented to court as the extra costs incurred to finish the project. To this Court, the 2nd Respondent was not qualified to give evidence as to the costs incurred to finish the project and that the volunteer engineer or contractor ought to have first provided a report as to what percentage the project was as to completion and what remained and what costs would be incurred to conclude the project. To this Court neither the volunteer, the foreman who was at the project form the start or any labourer was called to ascertain the same. The Court is unable to look at the photographs produced into evidence and determine the percentage of completion of works without a certificate of completion or a report indicating what costs would be incurred to complete the project based on a certificate of completion prepared by the engineer/contractor who took over the project after the termination of the services of the Claimant. Therefore, the counter-claim is dismissed. Costs Noting the circumstances of this case, each party shall bear its own costs. In conclusion: A. The claim is dismissed; B. The Counterclaim is dismissed; and C. Each party shall bear its own costs. It is so ordered. Dated and delivered virtually at Chuka Small Claims Court by Hon. Tracy Wanjiku Wachira (RM/ADJ) this 5th day of February 2026. In the presence of :Counsel for the Claimant Evans Mwenda-Court Assistant

page 3 of 3

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.