REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT CHUKA SCCCOMM E008 OF 2025 JAMES KIMATHI NKONGE…………….…………………………………..CLAIMANT VERSUS LEE CONSTRUCTION LIMITED……….…..………….……………………RESPONDENT JUDGMENT Background of the case The Claimant filed a claim dated 13/02/2025 seeking relief in the sum of Kshs.1,000,000/having forfeited his claim in excess of what the Small claims court can award for breach of contract as alleged in paragraph 4 of the Claim. It was his position that the Respondent contracted the claimant to purchase gravel materials to be excavated from his parcel Kathwana/238 for use in the construction of Kathwana-Makutano road at an agreed rate of Kshs.1,280/- per load of 16 tonnes exclusive of VAT. The Respondent filed an amended response and counterclaim dated 17/04/2025 and sought that the Claimant’s claim be dismissed and that the Claimant be ordered to pay for Kshs.421,730/being overpayment to him and Kshs.936,000/- for loss of use of the excavators. The matter proceeded for hearing where witnesses tendered in oral testimony in support of their documentary evidence. Both parties filed their submissions and this Court has considered both in its determination of this suit. Issues for determination 1. Whether the Claimant is entitled to reliefs sought for breach of contract 2. Whether the Respondent is entitled to the reliefs sought as to the counterclaim. 3. Costs Analysis The Court will deal with the issues in the claim and counterclaim jointly. Neither party to the suit denies the contents of the agreement as to its terms and execution. On the issue which is claimed to be payment for machinery used on the site and the NEMA fee on the part of the claimant which was countered as an expression of good will by the
page 1 of 5
Respondent, the Court notes that the burden in the first instance was on the claimant to show that the request was made by an agent of the Respondent, to see to it that there was evidence of an agreement that he would be paid for leasing out some machinery for the project in question or a witness to corroborate the fact that part of the payment would go to the third party lessor for the mentioned equipment. Moreover, the Claimant did not show any communication with the lessor of the equipment as to a payment plan or communication evidencing the lease arrangement with the lessor. To this Court the same was not substantiated and the Court is not satisfied as to the assertion that the prior part payment was to ensure there was equipment hired by the Claimant for the project in question. In making the above decision, the Court does not find the breakdown of the payments as per the tabulation of the Claimant in his submissions which included payment to the owner of the said equipment said to have been procured by himself for this project. The Court notes that payment to the Claimant was made for the sums presented to the contractor who submitted the same to the Respondent company for payment. The same was confirmed by the claimant himself who indicated that payment would happen once the contractor made the requisition to the company for payment to be made. Court notes that while the contract was to lapse as per the specification in the written agreement, through the conduct of the parties, it is clear that there was collection of the raw material (gravel) after the lapse of the contract period which indicates an extension by conduct. As none of those at the site daily were able to come to testify in Court, the Court will not attempt to read into whether the same was merely as to collection of the already excavated heaps of gravel or if there was active excavation during this time. This fact to this Court, would negate the claim for overpayment made by the Respondent in the Counterclaim.
page 2 of 5
The Court will also not look into the number of days the collection happened as there are competing claims on the same. Notably, the Respondent in discrediting any work being done over the weekends ought to have attached its policy as to working days for its contractor as well as those it assigned this particular project. The same was not provided. Moreover, the Court will go by the payments received as to any claim of overpayment noting the Claimant and an agent of the Respondent further renegotiated the terms of the agreement upon its expiry period and the same is evidenced by the fact that there were payments made and collection of raw materials from the site whether already excavated in heaps or not. Further on this issue of overpayment, the Court notes that the Respondent's witness testified that they would release funds upon being prompted by their contractor. To this Court any overpayment which is claimed to have been made to the Claimant ought to be pursued as against the person who requisitioned funds in excess. Notably, the Court through the testimony of the Respondent’s witness was able to establish that the said contractor was no longer working for the Respondent company. The issue that the Claimant prepared invoices in both his name individually and in the business name is not an issue for the Court to ascertain as to the claim of forgery as the contractor accepted them and forwarded a requisition for the Claimant to be paid further noting no audit queries were raised as to this discrepancy and no claim brought against the Claimant on the same until this suit was filed by the Claimant. Further on the issue of fraud as to the signatures in the records of the Claimant, the court holds that the burden of proof for the Respondent who alleged the same is higher than on a balance of probabilities. To this Court the same was not satisfactorily proved. The law on the issue of standard of proof is as supported in the case of Vijay Morjaria vs Nansingh Madhusingh Darbar & Another [2000] eKLR, where Tunoi, JA. (as he then was) stated as follows: “It is well established that fraud must be specifically pleaded and that particulars of the fraud alleged must be stated on the face of the pleading. The acts alleged to be fraudulent
page 3 of 5
must, of course, be set out, and then it should be stated that these acts were done fraudulently. It is also settled law that fraudulent conduct must be distinctly alleged and distinctly proved, and it is not allowable to leave fraud to be inferred from the facts.” Kinyanjui Kamau vs George Kamau [2015] eKLR expressed itself as follows;“…It is trite law that any allegations of fraud must be pleaded and strictly proved. See Ndolo vs Ndolo (2008) 1 KLR (G & F) 742 wherein the Court stated that: “...We start by saying that it was the respondent who was alleging that the will was a forgery and the burden to prove that allegation lay squarely on him. Since the respondent was making a serious charge of forgery or fraud, the standard of proof required of him was obviously higher than that required in ordinary civil cases, namely proof upon a balance of probabilities; In cases where fraud is alleged, it is not enough to simply infer fraud from the facts." Christopher Ndaru Kagina -V- Esther Mbandi Kagina & Another [2016] eKLR where the court stated that: “It is trite law that he who alleges fraud must prove fraud. Allegations of fraud must strictly be proved. Great care must be taken in pleading allegations of fraud or dishonesty. In particular, the pleader needs to be sure that there is sufficient evidence to justify the allegations. In the Case Central Bank of Kenya LTD -V- Trust Bank Ltd & 4 Others [26] the Court of Appeal in considering standard of proof required where fraud is alleged state that fraud and conspiracy to defraud are very serious allegations. The onus of prima facie proof is much heavier on the person alleging than in an ordinary Civil Case. The burden of proof lies on the applicant in establishing the fraud that he alleges. Therefore, in closing, the claim for overpayment of the Claimant which was made by the Respondent company fails. There is also a second issue in the counterclaim as to the cost incurred to hire the services of other excavators so as to continue the timely completion of the project. The Court does acknowledge the wording of the Claim, and claimant witness statement, the application filed in the Meru Court all indicate that the 2 excavators used in the project were held in lien by the Claimant when he sought to have the Respondent company pay him for amounts he claimed were owing.
page 4 of 5
The Court has taken a look at the invoice dated 22/08/2023 and that it does indicate a demand for payment addressed to the Respondent company for excavators. To this Court it is not enough that the invoice is dated 22/08/2023 to connect these excavators to the said project which is the subject of this suit as an invoice is a demand for payment that can be made after the completion of a service or supply of items. Further in cross-examination, the Respondent’s witness indicated that there was no evidence of a contract between Libs and the Respondent company and that the said invoice was not received by the Respondent company by way of affixing a stamp. To this Court, it would have been prudent for the Respondent to supply this court with communication that upon the holding of their excavators by the claimant, the decision to procure the additional excavators was made in order to complete the very project in good time. The same to this Court has not been discharged satisfactorily. On this ground, the counterclaim for the Claimant to pay for the cost of the hired excavators fails. Who is to bear costs Based on the circumstances of the case and noting neither party has been able to satisfactorily prove its Case as to the claim and counterclaim, each party shall bear its own costs. Orders Judgment is hereby entered as follows:1) The Claim is dismissed with no orders as to costs; and 2) The counterclaim is hereby dismissed with no orders as to costs. This is the order of this Court. Dated and delivered virtually at Chuka Law Courts by Hon. GTracy Wanjiku Wachira (RM/ADJ) this 7th day of August 2025. In virtual court in the presence of Counsel for the Respondent Kelvin Mawira-Court Assistant
page 5 of 5