Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedELRC Cause (Nairobi), memorandum of claim filed 19.04.2018· [2018] KEELRC 692 (KLR)

Vicky Kemunto Ocharo v Independent Policing Oversight Authority [2018] KEELRC 692 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
9 November 2018
7,150 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~29 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Employment Court reinstated a dismissed HR officer, ruling her employer's disciplinary process was unfair and she couldn't be punished for the employer's own staffing failures.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The claimant, confirmed in 2014 as Senior Human Resource Officer and promoted in 2016 to Principal Human Resource Management Officer with a clean service record, was appointed to act as Head of Human Capital in August 2017 after the substantive holder resigned. She lost the competitive recruitment for the substantive post to Rhoda Ochira, who reported in January 2018. Following a show-cause letter of 27.12.2017, the claimant was interdicted on 16.02.2018 on half pay - the interdiction letter introducing five fresh allegations - and was summarily dismissed on 13.04.2018 for insubordination, incompetence and neglect of duty. She sued for declarations of unfair interdiction and termination, reinstatement, notice pay, damages and costs. The Court held the interdiction was a lawful, agreed preliminary step in the disciplinary process requiring no prior hearing. However, the dismissal was procedurally unfair because the fresh allegations in the interdiction letter were never subjected to a show-cause process as the respondent's HR manual required; the disciplinary process was also impaired by a conflict of interest, the new Head of Human Capital having done desk work on the case despite a resolution that she step aside, and by the Committee's misdirection. Substantively, no genuine reasons were established: the claimant was overwhelmed by duties beyond her capacity owing to the respondent's understaffing, an operational deficiency for which she could not fairly be punished, and she exculpated herself on the payment allegation. The Court refused the declaration on interdiction and the claims on working conditions and discrimination, but granted reinstatement with full back pay from interdiction as an exceptional-case remedy, or in the alternative Kshs.2,140,116.00 in lieu of notice and compensation plus withheld half salaries, with payment due by 05.12.2018 and costs to the claimant.

Key legal issues

#
01

Fairness of the interdiction

Holding

Interdiction was not unfair or illegal; it was an agreed preliminary investigative step

Reasoning

Interdiction formed part of the agreed terms of employment under the respondent's HR manual and PSC Discipline Manual, with safeguards on when it applied, payment during interdiction and a 3-month limit. No breach of those safeguards was shown. Relying on Evans Rees v Richard Alfred Crane, an initial step in a disciplinary sequence does not require a hearing if the employee will be heard at a later stage.

p. 3
02

Procedural fairness of the dismissal

Holding

Termination was procedurally unfair under section 45(2)(c) of the Employment Act

Reasoning

The interdiction letter introduced five fresh allegations but did not invite a reply as required by clause 10.7.4(i) of the HR manual, amounting to serious procedural unfairness. The disciplinary process was further impaired by a conflict of interest - the new Head of Human Capital did desk work on the case despite a resolution that she step aside - and by the Committee's misdirection in focusing on the interdiction-letter allegations rather than the show-cause letter the claimant had been invited to answer.

p. 4
03

Genuine and valid reasons for termination

Holding

No genuine or valid reasons were established; the dismissal was substantively unfair

Reasoning

The findings founded on the interdiction-letter allegations were a nullity due to conflict of interest and lack of show-cause notice. On the show-cause allegations, the claimant was overwhelmed by duties beyond her capacity because the department was understaffed - operational deficiencies of the respondent - and she exculpated herself on the payment allegation. Her clean record and the circumstances of the new Head of Human Capital's arrival confirmed the dismissal lacked valid reason.

p. 5
04

Exhaustion of internal appeal and service of summons

Holding

Claimant entitled to move the Court without exhausting internal appeal; objection on service cured by participation

Reasoning

Section 90 makes the cause of action accrue on termination; the internal appeal was not time bound and delay would prejudice the claimant, who also sought interlocutory relief. Reinstatement is available within three years under section 12(3)(vii) of the ELRC Act. Failure to serve summons was cured under Article 159 by the respondent's filing a response and full participation without established prejudice.

p. 5
05

Remedies

Holding

Reinstatement with full back pay granted as primary remedy; 10 months' compensation and notice pay in the alternative

Reasoning

Reinstatement was justified in exceptional circumstances: the claimant's excellent service record, the vacancy still available, her willingness to return, the short separation period, and the need to discourage post-recruitment antagonism between public officers. Compensation of 10 months was awarded under section 49, reduced for the claimant's contribution through harsh language in her reply, as an alternative to reinstatement.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • Where an act is only the first step in a sequence of measures culminating in a detrimental decision, the employee need not be heard against the initial act if entitled to be heard later
  • It is unfair labour practice for an employer to visit on the employee adverse consequences for losses attributable to deficiencies in the employer's operational policies and systems
  • An employee exculpated at the end of the disciplinary process is entitled to payment of dues withheld during interdiction or suspension
  • The cause of action for unfair termination accrues immediately termination takes place, so exhaustion of an untimed internal appeal is not a precondition to suit
  • Public officers must settle down and work together after a concluded competitive recruitment process; conduct designed to force a competitor out may constitute exceptional circumstances justifying reinstatement

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the summary dismissal of 13.04.2018 amounted to unfair termination of the contract of service
  2. 2.Reinstatement from the effective date of dismissal with full back monthly payments and other attached benefits or allowances since the date of interdiction, to continue in service on permanent and pensionable basis as Principal Human Resource Officer, with claimant to report to the CEO not later than 15.11.2018
  3. 3.In the alternative to reinstatement, payment of Kshs.2,140,116.00 in lieu of notice and compensation for unfair termination
  4. 4.In the alternative, payment of all half salaries and allowances withheld during the interdiction period from the date of interdiction to the date of the dismissal letter
  5. 5.Payment by 05.12.2018, failing which interest at Court rates from date of judgment till full payment
  6. 6.Respondent to pay the claimant's costs of the suit

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment Act, 2007section 44
  • Employment Act, 2007section 45(2)(c)
  • Employment Act, 2007sections 43 and 47(5)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 46(h)
  • Employment Act, 2007section 49 (including section 49(4)(d))
  • Employment Act, 2007section 90
  • Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, 2011section 12(3)(vii)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 159
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 41(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 232(1)(a) and (b)
  • Public Service Commission Discipline Manual of May 2016paragraph 4.2(a)
  • Respondent's Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manual, 1st Edition March 2017clauses 10.7.4(i), 10.7.5(i), 10.7.9

Cases cited (3)

  • Evans Rees and Others -Versus- Richard Alfred Crane
    (1994) 2 WLR
  • Nancy Makokha Barasa -Versus- Judicial Service Commission and 9 Others
    [2012] eKLR
  • Grace Gacheri Muriithi -Versus- Kenya Literature Bureau
    (2012) eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, 2011, section 12(3)(vii); Employment Act, 2007

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (13)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Vicky Kemunto Ocharo v Independent Policing Oversight Authority [2018] KEELRC 692 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). ELRC Cause (Nairobi), memorandum of claim filed 19.04.2018. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2018/692/eng@2018-11-09

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.