Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Appeal No. 248 of 2015· [2017] KECA 370 (KLR)

Fidelity Commercial Bank Limited v Italian Market Kenya Limited [2017] KECA 370 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
28 July 2017
6,530 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~26 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal confirmed banks must get proper board authorisation before linking directors' personal debts to a company account.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This was a first appeal by Fidelity Commercial Bank Limited against a High Court judgment (Ogola, J.) which found that the bank had negligently debited Italian Market Kenya Limited's account with Kshs 2,889,764 incurred through personal Visa Gold cards issued to two directors, Stephano Sala and Monica Garibaldi, which the bank had linked to the company account without proper corporate authorisation. The High Court ordered accounts to be rendered, reversal of the illegal debits with interest at court rates, and costs. The Court of Appeal, exercising its duty under Rule 29(1)(a) of the Court of Appeal Rules to re-appraise the evidence, found that the Visa cards were personal to the directors (indeed bearing the corporate name of an unrelated entity, Hawal Market Ltd), that the signature mandate did not extend to the auto credit linkage, and that the bank breached its duty of care by failing to insist on a board resolution or enquire of the third director, John Nguli. It held that a bank must protect a company customer from its own wayward directors and cannot blame a customer who had no reason to suspect irregularity, applying the Karak Rubber and Patel authorities. The Court endorsed the finding of negligence but found Nguli himself blameworthy for failing to report the directors' resignations. The appeal was accordingly dismissed on the core findings, but the High Court's post-judgment orders were set aside and substituted: the debits and accrued interest were to be reversed, no interest was payable to the respondent, each party was to bear its own costs both in the High Court and on appeal, and the terms of a consent were to be complied with.

Key legal issues

#
01

Duty of care of a banker where personal debts of directors are loaded onto a company account

Holding

The bank was negligent and breached its duty of care by linking personal Visa cards of two directors to the company account without a board resolution, company seal, or enquiry of the third director.

Reasoning

The Court held that the customer is the company, and the bank's duty of care is owed to the company. Given discrepancies on the face of the cards (bearing the name 'Hawal Market Ltd') and the absence of a directors' resolution, the bank ought to have insisted on a board resolution or sought clarification from the third director. Its cavalier handling of the linkage was an abdication of its duty to safeguard the customer's money, and it must pursue the directors rather than the company for the personal debts.

p. 8
02

Scope of the signature mandate and requirement of corporate authorisation

Holding

The signature mandate (either director could sign) did not extend to authorising the linking of the personal Visa cards to the company account; a board resolution or at least enquiry was required.

Reasoning

The Court found the cards were issued in the personal capacities of Stephano and Monica (or as directors of Hawal Market Ltd, alien to the proceedings), not under the respondent's mandate. Monica was not even an authorised signatory. The mandate operated within the normal banker-customer relationship and did not exclude the bank's duty of reasonable skill and care, so the bank could not rely on Stephano's signature alone to bind the company.

p. 8
03

Effect of the customer's delay in querying bank statement entries (the 21-day window)

Holding

The 21-day window in bank statements did not preclude the customer from raising queries thereafter where the director had no reason to suspect irregularity, since the bank dealt exclusively with the other director and withheld information from Nguli.

Reasoning

Following the persuasive reasoning in Patel v Standard Chartered Bank, the Court accepted that a customer owes an implied duty to report fraud only of which it knew or a reasonable person would have discovered. Nguli had no reason to suspect the account until Stephano resigned; the bank was privy to the dealings throughout and even rebuffed Nguli's enquiries on the ground that card transactions were personal. The bank could not therefore turn around and blame Nguli.

p. 9
04

Existence of the Visa cards prior to the auto credit linkage (ground 7)

Holding

The evidence of the appellant's own witness established that the Visa cards existed and ran for a full year before they were linked to the company account.

Reasoning

The bank's Legal Manager, Stella Mbui, testified on oath that the cards were allowed to operate for over one year before being linked to the company accounts. That sworn evidence could not be negated by counsel's submissions. Further, the letter inviting the directors to apply for the Visa Gold cards pre-dated the auto credit application form. Ground 7 of the appeal therefore had no basis and failed.

p. 7
05

Conduct of the respondent's director John Nguli

Holding

Nguli was not blameless: he failed to show interest in the company's affairs and failed to notify the bank of the resignation of the two directors as required by the debenture, so he should not benefit from the bank's misdeeds.

Reasoning

While the bank bore the primary liability for negligently loading personal debts onto the company account, Nguli ought to have shown more interest in the running of the company and should have informed the bank of the directors' resignations, which would have allowed earlier detection. This finding informed the Court's refusal to award costs to the respondent and its variation of the High Court's costs order.

p. 10

Legal principles established

#
  • A bank must exercise reasonable skill and care in interpreting, ascertaining and acting in accordance with the customer's instructions; where a mandate is ambiguous, the bank must seek clarification from the customer, and if it allows unauthorised transactions to slip through it bears the risk of liability.
  • A bank's duty of care includes protecting a company customer from exposure to fraud by its own directors; the bank should insist on a directors' resolution, company letterhead or seal before binding a company to transactions such as linking personal credit cards to a company account.
  • A customer is not obligated to check its accounts continuously; a customer who acts in good faith and alerts the bank of inconsistencies as soon as possible has met its obligations, and the bank must keep the account safe.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appellant is ordered to reverse the debits loaded on the respondent's account in respect of the two Visa Gold Cards issued in the names of Stephano Sala and Monica Garibaldi
  2. 2.The interest accruing on those debits should also be reversed; interest payable to the respondent does not arise
  3. 3.Each party bears its own costs both here and before the High Court
  4. 4.The terms of the consent referred to in the respondent's submissions be complied with

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Court of Appeal RulesRule 29(1)(a)

Cases cited (4)

  • Karak Rubber Co. Ltd vs Burden
    [1972] 1 All ER 1210
  • Stanbic Bank of Uganda vs Uganda Cross Ltd
    Civic Appeal No. 4 of 2004
  • Simba Commodities Limited vs Citibank N.A
    Civil Case No. 236 of 2003
  • Patel and Others vs Standard Chartered Bank
    [2001] All ER 66
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
HCCC No. 444 of 2012
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal under the Court of Appeal Rules (Rule 29(1)(a)); appeal as of right from the High Court

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (8)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Fidelity Commercial Bank Limited v Italian Market Kenya Limited [2017] KECA 370 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2017). Civil Appeal No. 248 of 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2017/370/eng@2017-07-28

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.