Abubakar Zain Ahmed v Premier Savings & Finance Limited & 4 others [2007] KECA 476 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal dismissed a land-fraud claim because it was filed too late and relied on a Power of Attorney that third parties could validly trust.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Principles governing striking out of pleadings under Order 6 rule 13
Striking out is discretionary, drastic and to be exercised only in plain and obvious cases in the clearest of cases; the principles from D.T. Dobie v Muchina and related authorities govern
The Court traced the settled jurisprudence from D.T. Dobie & Co v Muchina, Wenlock v Moloney, Nitin Properties, and other authorities, holding that parties are not lightly to be driven from the seat of judgment and that striking out is a drastic remedy to be used with extreme caution, only where the pleading is hopeless and beyond redemption by amendment. The Court applied these principles to the High Court's striking out of the amended plaint.
Whether a valid cause of action in conspiracy was disclosed against the respondents
No valid allegation of conspiracy was made out on the pleadings; the respondents acted within their ordinary duties and could rely on the Power of Attorney absent notification of Latifa's death
The Court held that none of the respondents was ever notified of Latifa's death as required under section 116(4) of the Registered Land Act, so the Power of Attorney subsisted under section 117(1). The respondents relied on it properly at face value, their actions were not out of the ordinary, and thus no leg existed for the averment of conspiracy during the loan negotiations, registration of charges, or transfer of the 1st respondent's business.
Limitation of actions in tort
The appellant's claims, being in tort for acts occurring between 1987 and 1998 and within his knowledge by 25th May 1998, were time barred under the Limitation of Actions Act
The Court agreed with the High Court that all the acts on which the appellant built his case were torts actionable only within three years of occurrence unless the period was enlarged under the Limitation of Actions Act. No evidence of enlargement was placed before the Court. The claim was therefore hopelessly time barred and hopeless, and sustaining it would serve no purpose.
Whether the suit was curable by amendment
The suit was incurably bad and beyond cure by amendment; the High Court was right that allowing it to trial would waste the parties' resources on a claim bound to fail
While courts generally grant leave to amend defective pleadings, the facts here - principally hopeless time-bar - militated against further amendment. An amendment had already been made with leave. The Court adopted the High Court's observation that allowing the claim to trial would only waste money on a cause of action that must eventually fail, and allowed the respondents' cross-appeal on this ground.
Legal principles established
#- The power to strike out a pleading under Order 6 rule 13 is discretionary, permissive, and to be exercised only in plain and obvious cases with great care and circumspection
- A suit may be summarily dismissed only where it is so hopeless that it plainly and obviously discloses no reasonable cause of action and is beyond redemption by amendment; a mere semblance of a cause of action curable by amendment should go to trial
- In the absence of notification of the donor's death as required under the Registered Land Act, a general Power of Attorney subsists under section 117(1) and third parties may properly rely on it at its face value
Court orders
#- 1.The appellant's appeal is dismissed
- 2.The Notice of Cross-Appeal by the 1st, 3rd and 4th respondents is allowed on the ground that the proposed amendment could not breathe life into the appellant's claim against them
- 3.The Notice of Cross-Appeal filed by the 2nd respondent is dismissed with costs
- 4.The 1st, 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents shall have the costs of the appeal and of the Notices of Cross-Appeal against the appellant
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Mombasa
- H.C.C.C. No. 327 of 2001
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appeal to the Court of Appeal under the Civil Procedure Act/Rules (provision not expressly stated in the judgment)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Later judgments citing this (21)
#Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.
- Highland Plaza Limited v Ondieki & 6 others[2023] KEELC 17360 (KLR)2 May 2023
- Highbury Properties Limited v Nairobi City County Government & another[2023] KEELC 17146 (KLR)27 Apr 2023
- Tinga & another v Melo Twenty Seven Holding Company & 4 others[2023] KEELC 16015 (KLR)7 Mar 2023applied
- Enkasiti Flower Growers Limited v Protein & Fruits Processing Limited & another [2020] KEELC 2032 (KLR)[2020] KEELC 2032 (KLR)18 Jun 2020
- Not stated in the judgment excerpt (ruling on applications dated 4th July, 2017 and 6th November, 2017)[2020] KEHC 7681 (KLR)5 Mar 2020applied
- Not stated in the judgment excerpt (ruling on applications dated 4th July, 2017 and 6th November, 2017)[2020] KEHC 7681 (KLR)5 Mar 2020
- Jane Wanjiru Gathoni (suing as advocate) v Mbiyu Koinange & 4 others[2019] KEHC 635 (KLR)3 Dec 2019applied
- Jane Wanjiru Gathoni (suing as advocate) v Mbiyu Koinange & 4 others[2019] KEHC 635 (KLR)3 Dec 2019
- Gabrielle Mukele & Another v Anhone Kwena Anyimu[2017] KEHC 1108 (KLR)14 Dec 2017followed
- In re C H (Mental Health Act) - C H v J H & A H[2017] KEHC 904 (KLR)5 Dec 2017applied
- George Mukoma Mwangi v Reuben Kamau Manyeki [2017] KEELC 1078 (KLR)[2017] KEELC 1078 (KLR)18 Oct 2017applied
- Hwansung Industries (K) Limited v Elifurni Furniture Limited[2017] KEHC 8691 (KLR)30 Mar 2017applied
- Hwansung Industries (K) Limited v Elifurni Furniture Limited[2017] KEHC 8691 (KLR)30 Mar 2017
- Investments & Mortgages Bank Ltd v Nancy Wangechi Thumari (suing as the personal representative of the estate of the late Sammy Ndegwa) & 2 others[2015] KEHC 2640 (KLR)6 Jul 2015
- Kutima Investments Limited v Muthoni Kihara & another [2015] KECA 792 (KLR)[2015] KECA 792 (KLR)24 Apr 2015distinguished
- Bender & Co. (K) Ltd v ... (Plaintiff's Notice of Motion to strike out Defence and Counterclaim)[2013] KEHC 65 (KLR)24 Jan 2013
- Plaintiff v. Defendants (Limitation of Actions application - trespass to land suit struck out)[2012] KEHC 3754 (KLR)24 Feb 2012
- (Plaintiff) v (Defendant) - Chamber Summons dated 9th November 2009[2010] KEHC 1436 (KLR)16 Jul 2010
- Stephen Mundia (Plaintiff) v Swara Homes Limited & Others[2010] KEHC 2939 (KLR)3 May 2010applied
- Stephen Kipkebut T/A Riverside Lodge and Rooms & Another v (Defendant)[2009] KEHC 3008 (KLR)5 Jun 2009
- DAVID JAMES MBOGO v JOSEPH ALLISON[2007] KEHC 948 (KLR)27 Nov 2007applied
Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Abubakar Zain Ahmed v Premier Savings & Finance Limited & 4 others [2007] KECA 476 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2007). Civil Appeal 109 of 2004. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2007/476/eng@2007-06-29
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.