Kimwaki v Old Mutual General Insuarance Kenya Limited (Commercial Case E880 of 2025) [2026] SCC 36 (KLR) (28 April 2026) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2026] SCC 36 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT THIKA COMMERCIAL CASE E880 OF 2025 JM MWENDA, RM APRIL 28, 2026 BETWEEN BENEDICT MUTINDA KIMWAKI ........................................................ CLAIMANT AND OLD MUTUAL GENERAL INSUARANCE KENYA LIMITED .... RESPONDENT JUDGMENT 1. The Claimant, vide his Statement of Claim dated 6th June, 2025, seeks judgment against the Respondent for a sum of Ksh 834,418=, being the cost of replacement of the damaged eyesight camera of motor vehicle registration number KDN 931K, together with interest at the rate of 16% per annum from 18th January, 2024 until payment in full, and costs of the suit. 2. The Claimant avers that in the year 2023 he procured a comprehensive insurance cover for the said motor vehicle from the Respondent. He states that on or about December 2023, the motor vehicle’s windscreen was damaged. 3. It is his case that upon notifying the Respondent of the damage, he was referred to Krystal Glass Dealers & Agencies for purposes of windscreen replacement and repair. The said entity was subsequently joined to these proceedings as a Third Party at the instance of the Respondent. 4. The Claimant contends that Krystal Glass Dealers & Agencies negligently and/or recklessly installed the windscreen, thereby occasioning damage to the eyesight camera installed in the motor vehicle. 5. He further avers that upon reporting the said damage to the Respondent, he was referred to Green Shield Motor Limited, who replaced the windscreen but were unable to restore the damaged eyesight camera. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2026/36/eng@2026-04-28 1
page 1 of 4
6. The Claimant states that, according to an assessment conducted by Subaru Kenya Limited, the cost of replacing the eyesight camera was estimated at Ksh 834,418/=. He relies on a service review dated 19th July, 2024 in support thereof. 7. It is further the Claimant’s position that in October 2024 he made attempts to amicably resolve the dispute with the Respondent, but the same bore no fruit, necessitating the institution of the present suit. 8. The Claimant has also filed a list of documents in support of his claim, all of which have been duly considered by the Court. 9. The Respondent filed a reply to the statement of claim dated 25th July, 2025, wherein he denies liability and avers that he does not owe the Claimant the sum claimed or at all. 10. The Respondent maintains that he was not responsible for the damage to the eyesight camera on the Claimant’s motor vehicle. 11. It is the Respondent’s case that the Claimant reported a damaged windscreen on or about 20th December, 2023, and he was duly referred to Krystal Glass Dealers & Agencies, who replaced the windscreen as authorized. The Respondent, however, contends that any damage to the eyesight camera was occasioned by improper installation by the said repairer. 12. The Respondent further avers that following an assessment, he authorized another repairer, Green Shield Motor Limited, to properly reinstall the windscreen. 13. In his defence, the Respondent places blame for the alleged damage squarely on Krystal Glass Dealers & Agencies. 14. Consequently, the Respondent filed a Third Party Notice dated 25th July. 2025 joining Krystal Glass Dealers & Agencies to these proceedings. 15. The Third Party entered appearance and filed their response to the Statement of Claim dated 26th November, 2025. 16. In their response, the Third Party admits that they are a service provider engaged by the Respondent under a subsisting service agreement. 17. They further admit having replaced the Claimant’s motor vehicle windscreen, but assert that the same was done professionally and with due care and competence. 18. The Third Party denies any responsibility for the alleged damage to the eyesight camera or any other electronic component associated with the motor vehicle. 19. They contend that upon completion of the repairs, the motor vehicle was returned to the Claimant in proper working condition that was sound and fit for purpose upon release from the shop. 20. The Third-Party further attributes blame to the Claimant, alleging that he failed to adhere to the instructions issued to him, particulars of which are set out in their response. 21. Consequently, the Third Party prays that the Third-Party Notice be dismissed with costs, that judgment on the main claim be entered in their favor, and that the costs of the suit be borne by either the Claimant or the Respondent. 22. The parties filed their respective submissions, all of which I have duly considered. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2026/36/eng@2026-04-28 2
page 2 of 4
23. From the pleadings, evidence, and submissions on record, the Court is of the considered view that the following issues arise for determination: a. Whether there existed a contract between the Claimant and the Respondent; b. Whether the eyesight camera was covered under the insurance policy taken out by the Claimant with the Respondent; c. Whether the Third Party is liable for the damage to the eyesight camera; d. Who should bear the loss and costs of the suit? 24. During the hearing of this matter, the Respondent’s witness admitted on oath that the Claimant was indeed insured by the Respondent and that the eyesight camera formed part of the items covered under the policy. 25. The said witness further confirmed that the Claimant duly reported the damage to the eyesight camera to the Respondent. 26. In the premises, the Court finds that the first and second issues for determination are settled in the afirmative, namely, that there existed a valid and binding contract between the Claimant and the Respondent, and that the eyesight camera was covered under the said insurance policy. 27. Turning to the third issue as to whether the Third Party was responsible for the damage to the eyesight camera, the evidence on record is instructive. The Third Party’s manager, while testifying on oath, admitted that they had contacted the Claimant with a view to rectifying the damage to the eyesight camera. Further, the second assessment report on the motor vehicle clearly indicates that the windscreen had not been properly fitted, which in turn led to the damage of the eyesight camera. 28. This Court is therefore persuaded, on a balance of probabilities, that the Third Party was negligent in the manner in which it fitted the windscreen, and that such negligence occasioned the damage to the eyesight camera. 29. Be that as it may, it is not lost to this Court that there existed no contractual relationship between the Claimant and the Third Party. The Claimant’s contract was with the Respondent, who in turn referred the Claimant to the Third Party. 30. The doctrine of privity of contract dictates that contractual obligations are enforceable only between the parties to the contract. In the present case, the Claimant discharged his obligation by reporting the loss to the Respondent. It therefore behoved the Respondent to honor its contractual obligations under the insurance policy and indemnify the Claimant for the loss, the same being a risk covered under the policy. 31. The Respondent cannot evade liability on account of the Third Party’s negligence. Any recourse arising therefrom lies as between the Respondent and the Third Party. 32. In view of the foregoing, the issue as to who should indemnify the Claimant is resolved, and it is the Respondent who bears that obligation. 33. Consequently, judgement is hereby entered in favor of the Claimant against the Respondent for a sum of Ksh 834,418/= a judgement sum that shall earn and attract interest at courts rates from the date of filing the statement of claim until payment in full. 34. The Claimant shall also have the costs of the suit as against the Respondent assessed at ksh 83,000/= https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2026/36/eng@2026-04-28 3
page 3 of 4
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY THIS 28TH DAY OF APRIL, 2026 SIGNED BY: HON. JAMLICK MURIITHI MWENDA https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2026/36/eng@2026-04-28 4
page 4 of 4