Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

scc-2025-00077

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MILIMANI SCC CIVIL CLAIM NO. E4924 OF 2024 JANE NTHIKWA NGUI.……....…. ………………………………………………...CLAIMANT VERSUS PROTO ENERGY LIMITED…………………………………………………… RESPONDENT JUDGMENT The Claimant moved this court on behalf of First Assurance Company Limited (the Claimant’s insurer) under the principle of subrogation through a Statement of Claim dated 27th September 2024, praying for judgment against the Respondent for:a) Judgment in the sum of Kshs. 328,350/= b) Compensation c) Costs of the claim d) Interest on all the above The Claimant pleaded that on 01st October 2021, while driving her motor vehicle registration number KDA 691 V, along Savannah road in Buruburu, the Respondent’s driver caused the Respondent’s motor vehicle registration number KCX 065 M to hit her motor vehicle from the right side, causing extensive damage to it. It was the Claimant’s case that the accident was caused by the Respondent’s driver’s negligence as set out in paragraph 4 of the Statement of Claim. Further, the Claimant pleaded that her motor vehicle was insured by her insurer at the time of the accident under P/7079/100/9002/90/32451comp. She added that policy number her damaged motor vehicle was repaired by her insurer at a cost of Kshs. 328,350/= comprising

page 1 of 6

Kshs. 307,400/= repair costs and Kshs. 20,950/= tracing fees hence this claim. The Respondent entered appearance and filed a Response to Statement of Claim dated 29th October 2024 denying the particulars of negligence attributed to them by the Claimant. The Respondent took the position that the accident herein was wholly caused by the Claimant and/or her agent as set out in paragraph 5 of the Response to the Statement of Claim. Claimant’s case CW1 No. 79508 Sgt. Fatuma Tache of Buruburu Police Station produced the police abstract dated 02nd October 2021 blaming the Respondent’s motor vehicle registration number KCX 065 M for the occurrence of the accident. She admitted that she did not visit the scene and that she did not investigate the circumstances under which the accident occurred. CW2 Sophie Omollo from General Assurance Limited produced documents from the Claimant’s insurance company to prove that they repaired the Claimant’s motor vehicle registration registration number KDA 691 V at the cost of Kshs. 328, 350/=. CW3 Dennis Alwanga an internal assessor from First Assurance Company produced a motor vehicle assessment report and a re-inspection report to show that the Claimant’s insurance company repaired the Claimant’s motor vehicle to satisfaction. Respondent’s Case The Respondent did not call any witnesses. ANALYSIS & DETERMINATION This court has duly considered all the pleadings, evidence, submissions, as well as authorities placed before it.

page 2 of 6

It is common ground that this claim is based on the principle of subrogation. Muhochi J in Eastern Produce Kenya Ltd v Rongai Workshop & Transporters Ltd (Civil Appeal 125 of 2018) [2023] KEHC 24810 (KLR) (7 November 2023) (Judgment) rendered himself thus on what the principle of subrogation means:“The principle of the doctrine of insurance was well defined in Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited v Julius Wambale & Another (2019) eKLR where Githua J held; ‘‘The parameters within which the principle of subrogation applies are now well settled. The doctrine applies where there is a contract of insurance and following crystallization of the risk insured, the insurer had compensated its insured for financial loss occasioned thereby usually by a third party. Under this doctrine, the insurer is in law entitled to step into the shoes of the insured and enjoy all the rights, privileges and remedies accruing to the insured including the right to seek indemnity from a third party. The action must however be instituted in the name of the insured with his consent and must relate to the subject of the contract of insurance.’’ It is uncontested that the accident herein occurred and that the Claimant’s motor vehicle registration number KDA 691 V was damaged as a result of the said accident. Further, THE evidence on record shows that after the occurrence of the accident herein, the Claimant’s insurer expended money in repairing the Claimant’s motor vehicle. The only point of departure between the parties herein is who is to blame for the occurrence of the accident and the amount of money spent by the Claimant’s insurer in repairing the Claimant’s motor vehicle. In view of the foregoing, the issues for determination are liability and quantum. Liability

page 3 of 6

The Claimant sought to solely rely on the Police Abstract dated 02 nd October 2021 to prove that the Respondent was solely to blame for the accident. It would appear that the Claimant was urging this court to find that simply because the said Police Abstract had an entry that the Respondent’s motor vehicle was to blame for the accident that was sufficient proof of negligence on the part of the Respondent. Interestingly, the Claimant was never called as a witness in this matter to speak to the circumstances under which the accident herein occurred. It is also noteworthy that CW1 who the Claimant called as a witness, conceded that she neither visited the scene and that she was not the accident’s investigating officer. CW1 also conceded that she had not produced any OB. extract to corroborate the contents of the Police Abstract herein. The foregoing begs the question of whether a mere entry in a police abstract that a party is to blame for the occurrence of an accident is conclusively proof of negligence on the part of the party so blamed. The questioned above was answered in Kennedy Nyangoya v Bash Hauliers {2016} eKLR where the court expressed itself thus:“In this matter, a police abstract was produced by PW1 to show that DW1 was to blame for the accident. DW1 was however not charged with a traffic offence. PW1 in his evidence informed the court that he was not the Investigating Officer. In my considered view, his evidence did not assist in any way to build the plaintiff’s case. PW1 did not visit the scene of the accident or take any sketch plan or map of the area where the accident happened for production in court. Even if the police abstract indicated that DW1 was to blame for the accident, the said abstract was not conclusive proof of liability in the absence of evidence being called to support it. Another shortcoming in the appellant’s case was the unexplained failure to call the Driver who was driving the matatu at the time of the accident.”

page 4 of 6

A reading of the authority above shows that an entry in a Police Abstract blaming a party for the occurrence of an accident, in the absence of evidence to corroborate such an entry, is not of any evidential value. In view of the failure by the Claimant to testify before this court or fail to call the accident’s eye witness, this court holds and finds that the Claimant failed to prove to the required standards the particulars of negligence she attributed to the Respondent. Quantum Had the Claimant proved the particulars of negligence she attributed to the Respondent, this court would have awarded the Claimant repair costs of Kshs. 307,400/= evidenced by the final payment voucher dated 13 th November 2021 and Kshs. 19,900/= tracing fees evidenced by the payment voucher to Investic Insurance International investigations dated 25 th October 2023, making a total award of Kshs. 327,300/=. DISPOSITION The upshot of the foregoing is that this claim is dismissed with costs of Kshs. 30,000/= to the Respondent. This court unreservedly apologizes to counsel and the parties herein since the terms of this judgment are at variance with the terms of the summary of the judgment delivered orally in open court on 28th August 2025. The mistake was occasioned by a clerical error on the part of the court in open court due to the pressure of work of delivering several judgments arising from subrogation claims on that occasion. When the clerical error was brought to the attention of the court by the court assistant, this court proceeded to review the terms of the judgment delivered in open court under the slip rule. Judgment accordingly. Judgment reviewed in chambers at Bungoma this 28 th day of August 2025

page 5 of 6

T.O. OMONO ADJUDICATOR In the presence of: C/A: Albert

page 6 of 6

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.