Mose v Kamunya & another (Claim E5988 of 2024) [2025] SCC 65 (KLR) (26 May 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] SCC 65 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE MILIMANI SMALL CLAIMS COURT CLAIM E5988 OF 2024 TO OMONO, ADJ MAY 26, 2025 BETWEEN MOMANYI EVANS MOSE ....................................................................... CLAIMANT AND WILSON KAMUNYA .................................................................... 1ST RESPONDENT FORWARD TRAVELLERS SAVINGS AND CREDIT CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LIMITED ........................................................................................ 2ND RESPONDENT JUDGMENT 1. The Claimant moved this court through a Statement of Claim dated 29th November 2024 praying for judgment against the Respondents jointly and severally for:a. General damages for pain, loss and sufiering b. Special Damages of Kshs. 6,600/= c. Costs of the claim d. Interest on the above at court’s rate 2. The Claimant pleaded that the cause of action herein arose from a road trafic accident that reportedly occurred on 13th November 2024 at around 0845hrs along Jogoo road within Nairobi when motorcycle registration number KMFX 803 S that the Plaintifi was riding was knocked from behind by motor vehicle registration number KDR 523 H. 3. The Claimant attributed the occurrence of the accident to the Respondents’ negligence as set out in paragraph 4(e) of the Claimant’s Statement of Claim. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/65/eng@2025-05-26 1
page 1 of 6
4. The Respondents entered appearance and filed a Response to Statement of Claim dated 29th January 2025. They denied the occurrence of the accident herein. In the alternative, they pleaded that if at all the road trafic accident herein occurred, then the same was solely caused by the Claimant’s negligence as set out in the Response to Statement of Claim herein. 5. Arising from the road trafic accident, the Claimant reportedly sustained bodily injuries that he seeks compensation hence this claim. 6. On 12th May 2025, the parties herein elected that this matter proceeds by way of section 30 of the Small Claims Court Act. This consent was recorded despite the fact that the Respondents did not file any witness statements. 7. It is the law in this jurisdiction that pleadings are mere allegations. In the absence of evidence to support the allegations set out in the pleadings, such allegations remain as such, allegations. To this end, this court draws inspiration from Janet Kaphiphe Ouma & Another v Marie Stopes International (Kenya) Kisumu HCCC No. 68 of 2007 where Ali-Aroni, J. citing the decision in Edward Muriga Through Stanley Muriga v Nathaniel D. Schulter Civil Appeal No. 23 of 1997 held that:“ In this matter, apart from filing its statement of defence the defendant did not adduce any evidence in support of assertions made therein. The evidence of the 1st plaintifi and that of the witness remain uncontroverted and the statement in the defence therefore remains mere allegations…Sections 107 and 108 of the Evidence Act are clear that he who asserts or pleads must support the same by way of evidence”. 8. Given the foregoing, it follows that the Respondents, having failed to file witness statements, failed to place evidence before this court to support their case. In the circumstances, this court will not consider the contents of their Response to the Statement of Claim herein in determining this claim. Analysis & Determination 9. The Claimant’s pleadings, witness statements, documents, submissions filed as well as authorities relied upon have been duly considered by this court. 10. The Police Abstract (Cexh.2) shows that the accident herein was reported to the police. It also shows that the 1st Respondent was the driver of motor vehicle registration number KDR 523 H at the time of the accident. 11. The copy of records from NTSA (Cexh.6) shows that the 2nd Respondent was the owner of motor vehicle registration number KDR 523 H at the time of the accident. 12. Section 8 of the Traffic Act, Cap 403, provide as follows:“ the person in whose name a vehicle is registered shall, unless the contrary is proved, be deemed to be the owner of the vehicle.” 13. The Respondents did not lead any evidence to controvert the contents of Cexh.6 on the ownership of motor vehicle registration number KDR 523 H. The Respondents did also not lead evidence to controvert the contents of Cexh.2. 14. In the circumstances, this court holds and finds that the accident herein occurred and that the 1st Respondent was the driver of motor vehicle registration number KDR 523 H owned by the 2nd Respondent at the time of the accident. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/65/eng@2025-05-26 2
page 2 of 6
15. The record also bears witness that the 2nd Respondent did not place any evidence before this court to show that at the time of the accident herein the 1st Respondent was not driving motor vehicle registration number KDR 523 H as their agent and/or servant, and for the 2nd Respondent’s benefit. 16. Therefore, if this court finds the 1st Respondent negligent in causing the accident herein, the 2nd Respondent will be vicariously liable for the 1st Respondent’s negligence. 17. For the reasons above, the only issues that commend to this court for determination are liability and quantum. Liability 18. The Claimant’s evidence was that the accident herein occurred when the 2nd Respondent’s vehicle registration number KDR 523 H driven by the 1st Respondent knocked his motor vehicle registration number KMFX 803 S from behind around City Stadium round about along Jogoo road. The Claimant blamed the accident on the Respondents’ negligence. 19. The accident’s investigating oficer made an entry in the Police Abstract (Cexh. 2) blaming the 1st Respondent for the occurrence of the accident. That entry was not controverted by the Respondents. 20. The Respondents in this matter did not adduce evidence on the circumstances under which the accident herein occurred. The Claimant’s version of events on how the accident occurred was uncontroverted. When confronted with such a situation, Makhandia J (as he then was) in Jamal Ramadhan Yusuf & another v Ruth Achieng Onditi & another [2010]eKLR rendered himself as thus: “ The appellants adduced evidence that ousted them from the seat of liability. In the case of Edward Muuga V Nathaniel D. Schuller (C.A. No 23 of 1997 (UR), the Court of Appeal also observed that where a defendant does not adduce evidence the plaintifis’ evidence is to be believed. In this case I would replace the term Plaintifi with respondents. The respondents herein did not adduce any evidence as to what precipitated or circumstances leading to the accident. That evidence was given by the 1st appellant and it was never rebutted. It must therefore be believed.” 21. The reasoning in Jamal Ramadhan Yusuf case (supra) was also adopted by Aburili J in Otieno & another v Odhiambo (Civil Appeal E027 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 7688 (KLR). 22. Having considered the evidence on record and guided by the authorities above, this court finds no reason to disbelieve the Claimant’s version of events on how the accident herein occurred. 23. Given the above, this court holds and finds that the Respondents are jointly and severally 100% liable for the occurrence of the accident herein. Quantum a. General Damages for Pain and Sufiering 24. A reading of the Claimant’s Statement of Claim, P3 form (Cexh.3), Treatment Notes dated 13th November 2024 from Shauri Moyo Health Services (Cexh.4), and the Medical Report dated 27th November 2024 (Cexh.5) by Dr. Titus Ndeti Nzina shows that arising from the accident herein, the Claimant sufiered multiple soft tissue injuries of moderate severity assessed as harm. It was Dr. Nzina’s opinion that the Claimant’s gradual complete healing was expected. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/65/eng@2025-05-26 3
page 3 of 6
25. This court has duly considered the Claimant’s authorities on quantum. Those authorities refer to Plaintifis who sufiered more serious injuries than those sustained by the Claimant in this case. Those authorities are not applicable in this claim. 26. It is the law in this jurisdiction that comparable injuries attract comparable awards. This is the legal position obtaining in this jurisdiction as restated in Simon Taveta v Mercy Mutitu Njeru Civil Appeal 26 of 2013 [2014] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal observed as follows:“ The context in which the compensation for the respondent must be evaluated is determined by the nature and extent of injuries and comparable awards made in the past.” 27. The injuries sustained by the Claimant herein are almost similar to the injuries sustained by the Plaintifi in FM (Minor suing through Mother and next friend MWM) v JNM & another [2020] eKLR, where an award of Kshs 60,000/- was enhanced to Kshs 100,000/- where the minor had sustained soft tissue injuries, which were blunt object injury to the head, neck, limbs thorax and abdomen. 28. Aburili J in Makami v Obong’o (Civil Appeal E062 of 2021) [2023] KEHC 922 (KLR) made an award of Kshs. 80,000/= in 2023 where the respondent sustained soft tissue injuries involving marked swelling and bruises on the forehead, marked neck and chest pain and cut wound on the right elbow joint and right knee joint. He was treated as an outpatient. 29. In light of the authorities cited above and taking into consideration the passage of time and infiation trends in this country, this court is of the considered view that an award of Kshs. 100,000/= will be reasonable compensation under this head. Special Damages 30. Special Damages must be pleaded and strictly proved before they are awarded as restated in Hahn v. Singh, Civil Appeal No. 42 Of 1983 [1985] KLR 716, where the Court of Appeal held as follows:“ Special damages must not only be specifically claimed (pleaded) but also strictly proved …. for they are not the direct natural or probable consequence of the act complained of and may not be inferred from the act. The degree of certainty and particularity of proof required depends on the circumstances and nature of the acts themselves.” 60. The Claimant pleaded for Special Damages of Kshs. 6,600/= in paragraph 4 (g) of their Statement of Claim. He produced a receipt dated 13th January 2024 from Shauri Moyo Health Services of Kshs. 1,050/=, a receipt for Copy of Records dated 20th November 2024 from NTSA for Kshs. 550/=, and a receipt dated 27th November 2024 for the Medical Report for Kshs. 5,000/=. 61. It is against this backdrop that this court holds and finds that the Claimant pleaded and proved Special Damages of Kshs. 6,600/=. Costs of the Claim 62. The general rule is that costs follow the event. The Claimant, having succeeded in his claim, he is entitled to costs. 63. The Claimant submitted that the costs in this claim should be determined in accordance with the Advocates Remuneration Order. Counsel for the Claimant did not cite any legal foundation for that argument. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/65/eng@2025-05-26 4
page 4 of 6
Costs in the Small Claims Court Act are assessed per Section 33 of the Small Claims Act which provides that:- (1) The Court may award costs to the successful party in any proceedings. (2) In any other case parties shall bear their respective costs of the proceedings. (3) Without prejudice to subsections (1) and (2), the Court may award to a successful party disbursements incurred on account of the proceedings. (4) Except as provided in subsection (2), costs other than disbursements, shall not be granted to or awarded against any party to any proceedings before a Court. Rule 37 of the Small Claims Court Rules provides that in assessing costs recoverable under section 33 (1) of the Act, the Court shall be guided by the Second Schedule to these Rules. The above provisions of the law did not import the application of the Advocates Remuneration Order into the Small Claims Court Act. The schedule contemplated in rule 37 above has not been enacted. Further, there are no practice directions on the application of the Advocates Remuneration Order in the Small Claims Court. It is against this background that this court finds that, as of today, assessment of costs in the Small Claims Court is done through judicial discretion as guided by section 33 of the Small Claims Court Act. Guided by section 33 of the Small Claims Court Act, taking into consideration the fees paid by the Claimant in filing documents in this matter, the number of court attendances, the time taken to conclude the matter, the award in this matter, and the fact that the claimant engaged an advocate, this court assesses the costs of this claim at Kshs. 30,000/= Disposition 31. Given the foregoing, judgment is entered against the Respondents jointly and severally for:a. Liability 100% b. General Damages – Kshs. 100,000/= c. Special Damages – Kshs. 6,600/= d. Net Award – Kshs. 106,600/= 32. General Damages will accrue interest at court rate from the date of filing this claim till payment in full while Special Damages will accrue interest at court rate from the date of filing this claim till payment in full. 33. The Claimant will have the costs of this suit assessed at Kshs. 30,000/=. 34. Certificate of Costs and decree to issue forthwith upon payment of the requisite court fees, if any. READ, SIGNED AND DELIVERED IN OPEN COURT AT BUNGOMA THIS 26TH DAY OF MAY 2025 T.O. OMONO ADJUDICATOR https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/65/eng@2025-05-26 5
page 5 of 6
In the presence of: Mongera h/b for Khisa for the Claimant C/A Albert https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/65/eng@2025-05-26 6
page 6 of 6