Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Nduati v Weche (Commercial Claim E14572 of 2024) [2025] SCC 62 (KLR)

Nduati v Weche (Commercial Claim E14572 of 2024) [2025] SCC 62 (KLR) (10 July 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] SCC 62 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE MILIMANI SMALL CLAIMS COURT COMMERCIAL CLAIM E14572 OF 2024 TO OMONO, ADJ JULY 10, 2025 BETWEEN MARY MUKAMI NDUATI ...................................................................... CLAIMANT AND JOHN JULIUS EKESA WECHE ......................................................... RESPONDENT JUDGMENT 1. The Claimant moved this court through a Statement of Claim dated 29th September 2024, praying for judgment against the Respondent in the sum of AED 40,000/= equivalent to Kshs. 1,404,000/= then. 2. The Claimant averred that this claim stemmed from a loan of AED 42,000/= that she reportedly advanced to the Respondent sometime in February 2023 while the parties herein were married for the purchase of a Mercedes GLK motor vehicle. 3. She added that the parties herein orally agreed that the Respondent was to service the loan through monthly instalments of AED 1,020/=. 4. The Respondent dutifully serviced the loan until sometime in May 2023 when the marriage between the parties herein broke down. Thereafter, the parties herein separated with an understanding that the Respondent sells the Mercedes GLK motor vehicle to defray the loan balance. 5. The Respondent did not settle the outstanding loan as agreed, hence this claim. 6. The Respondent entered appearance and filed a Statement of Claim and a Set Ofi dated 24th October 2024. 7. It was the Respondent’s case the Claimant advanced to her a loan of AED 41,500/= for the purchase of a motor vehicle, and that he was to service the said loan through 48 monthly instalments of AED 1,020/= each. He added that he serviced the loan advanced to him until May 2023 when their marriage broke down. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/62/eng@2025-07-10 1

page 1 of 5

8. The Respondent further averred that he could not continue servicing the learn since the Claimant had reportedly made adverse reports against him in Dubai hence he could not earn a living in Dubai. 9. He added that he agreed with the Claimant that the motor vehicle herein be sold to defray the outstanding loan. He alleged that he agreed with the Claimant that the Claimant was to cater for the costs of selling the motor vehicle herein hence his prayer that the Claimant meets the costs of the sale of the motor vehicle herein of Kshs. 208,451.04/= set out in paragraph 6 of his Response to the Statement of Claim and Set Ofi. 10. For the reasons above, the Respondent prayed that judgment be entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent in the sum of Kshs. 609,123.44/=. 11. On 14th October 2024 when the parties herein appeared before Hon. Akinyi, the Claimant waived her claim for any money above Kshs. 1,000,000/=. On that occasion, judgment on admission for the sum of Kshs. 609,123.44/= was entered against the Respondent. The court also directed that the matter proceeds to hearing for the determination of the disputed balance of Kshs. 390,876.56/=. 12. A summary of evidence placed before this court by the parties herein is set out below. Claimant’s Case 13. CW1 Mary Immaculate Mukami adopted her witness statement dated 24th September 2024 as her evidence in chief. She reiterated the contents of her Statement of Claim. She produced the documents set out in her list of documents dated 24th September as exhibits. 14. During cross-examination, she conceded that the documents she filed in this court showed that she had advanced AED 41,500/= to the Respondent. She denied making any adverse reports against the Respondent in Dubai. 15. She admitted that she agreed with the Respondent that the Respondent sells the motor vehicle herein, then the Respondent hands over the proceeds of the sale to a mediator for settlement of the loan herein. 16. She added that AED 41,500/= was the principal loan while the sum claimed of AED 48,000/= was inclusive of interest. Respondent’s Case 17. RW1 Rev. Dr. Julius Weche adopted his witness statement dated 25th April 2025 as his evidence in chief, and produced all the documents he filed in this matter as exhibits. He admitted receiving a loan of AED 42,000/= from the Claimant for the purchase of the motor vehicle herein that was to be repaid through monthly instalments of AED 1,020/=. 18. He added that he serviced the loan until July 2024, when he could not repay the loan due to financial dificulties occasioned by their divorce. 19. He also stated that the parties herein engaged mediators including Adet Kach, Dr. Fred Olang, and Philip Koch in settling the outstanding loan when it was agreed that the motor vehicle herein be sold for settlement of the loan arrears. His testimony was that the Claimant was to meet the costs of selling the motor vehicle herein. 20. Upon cross-examination, he stated that there was no agreement between him and the Claimant that the Claimant was to meet the costs of selling the motor vehicle herein. He added that the alleged agreement was between him and the Claimant’s agent. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/62/eng@2025-07-10 2

page 2 of 5

Analysis & Determination 21. This court has duly considered the pleadings, written statements, documents, written submissions and authorities placed before this court by each party. 22. It is undisputed that sometime in February 2023, the Claimant advanced to the Respondent a loan for the purchase of the motor vehicle herein. It is also common ground that the said loan was to be settled by the Respondent through 48 monthly instalments of AED 1,020/= each. Further, the terms of the loan agreement between the parties herein were oral. 23. Both parties were in agreement that sometime in July 2023, after their marriage broke down, the Respondent failed to service the loan advanced to him as earlier on agreed. This led to the parties herein, through mediators, reaching an agreement that the motor vehicle herein be sold to defray the loan arrears. 24. The above means that the parties herein varied their earlier loan repayment terms of 48 monthly instalments of AED 1,020/= each to the new terms of immediate repayment of the outstanding loan through the sale of the motor vehicle herein. 25. The foregoing inclines this court to find and hold that the only issue for determination is whether the Claimant proved that the Respondent owed her AED 48,000/= at the time of filing this claim and whether the Respondent is entitled to the set ofi of Kshs. 208,451.04/=. 26. It is settled law in this jurisdiction that the legal burden of proof lies upon the party who invokes the aid of the law and substantially asserts the afirmative of the issue. That is the purport of section 107(1) of the Evidence Act (Chapter 80 of the Laws of Kenya), which provides: 107. (1) Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist. 27. Section 109 of the Evidence Act, on the other hand, stipulates that the burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence. 28. This court will now proceed to determine whether the Claimant and the Respondent proved their respective cases to the required standards. 29. Whereas the Claimant prayed for a declaration that the Respondent owed her AED 40,000/=, the Excel Sheet Car Repayment Schedule (Cexh.1) she relied on to support her claim shows that the car loan advanced to the Respondent was AED 41,500/=. 30. During the hearing of this matter, the Claimant stated that the Respondent owed her AED 48,000/= inclusive of interest. The Claimant did not place before this court to support the claim for interest. 31. The evidence on record (Cexh.1) only proved that the Claimant advanced to the Respondent the sum of AED 41,500/=. A perusal of Cexh.1 shows that as of May 2023, the loan balance was AED 36,400/ =. That translates to Kshs. 1,359,540/= as per the exchange rates then. 32. There was no evidence placed before this court to show that the Respondent paid any amount to the Claimant between May and September 2024 towards the repayment of the outstanding loan of AED 36,400/=. 33. Whereas the Respondent set out a tabulation of the amount owing to the Claimant in their written submissions, it is trite law that submissions are not evidence. Further, there is no evidence that those https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/62/eng@2025-07-10 3

page 3 of 5

written submissions were served upon the Claimant for the Claimant to also submit on the tabulations. That being the case, relying on those tabulations will prejudice the Claimant. Therefore, this court cannot rely on the tabulations in the Respondent’s written submissions to determine the amount the Respondent owes the Claimant. 34. The foregoing shows that the Claimant proved to the required standards that as at September 2024, when this claim was filed, the Respondent owed the her AED 36,400/= equivalent to Kshs. 1,277,640/ = per the exchange rates in September 2024. 35. It is noteworthy that the Claimant waived her claim to any amount above Kshs. 1,000,000. 36. In the circumstances, this court holds and finds that as at the time of filing this claim, the Respondent owed Claimant Kshs. 1,000,000/=. 37. Turning to the Respondent’s set ofi, the Respondent placed before this court documents outlining the expenses incurred in selling the motor vehicle herein. It was the Respondent’s case that the Claimant was to meet the costs of selling the motor vehicle herein. 38. However, during cross-examination, the Respondent conceded that he did not agree with the Claimant on the Claimant meeting the costs of selling the motor vehicle herein. The Respondent instead alleged that he agreed with the Claimant’s agent that the Claimant was to meet the costs of selling the motor vehicle herein. 39. The Respondent neither named the alleged Claimant’s agent nor prayed for summons against the alleged Claimant’s agent for that alleged agent to come and corroborate the Respondent’s assertions on who was to meet the cost of selling the motor vehicle herein. 40. It is against this backdrop that this court holds and finds that the Respondent’s Set Ofi is bereft of merit. Disposition 41. For the reasons above, the following orders commend to this court: a. Judgment is entered against the Respondent for the sum of Kshs. 1,000,000/= less any amount of money paid by the Respondent to the Claimant from the date of filing this claim b. The sum of money in (a) above will earn interest at court rate from the date of filing this claim till payment in full c. The Respondent’s Set Ofi is dismissed for want of proof d. Considering the relationship between the parties herein, and in a bid not to antagonize the parties herein further, each party to bear their costs of the claim and set ofi. 42. Decree to issue forthwith upon payment of the requisite court fees, if any. 43. Judgment accordingly. 44. File closed. READ, SIGNED AND DELIVERED IN OPEN COURT AT BUNGOMA THIS 10TH DAY OF JULY OF 2025 T. O. OMONO ADJUDICATOR https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/62/eng@2025-07-10 4

page 4 of 5

In the presence of: Kiprotich for the Claimant Maina for the Respondent C/A: Albert https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/62/eng@2025-07-10 5

page 5 of 5

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.