Zenka Digital Limited v Litali (Commercial Case E97182 of 2025) [2025] SCC 57 (KLR) (16 October 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] SCC 57 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE MILIMANI SMALL CLAIMS COURT COMMERCIAL CASE E97182 OF 2025 TO OMONO, ADJ OCTOBER 16, 2025 BETWEEN ZENKA DIGITAL LIMITED .................................................................... CLAIMANT AND NANCY LITALI ................................................................................... RESPONDENT JUDGMENT 1. The Claimant moved this court vide a Statement of Claim dated 26th June 2025, praying for judgment against the Respondent for: a. Judgment in the sum of Kshs. 104,000/= b. Costs of the claim c. Interest at court’s rate from when the breach arose 2. The Claimant pleaded that on 31st October 2024 the Respondent borrowed a loan of Kshs. 36,000/= through the Claimant’s mobile loan application platform that was to be repaid within one month at an interest rate of 39.00%. The Respondent reportedly defaulted in repaying the loan as agreed leading the outstanding loan to rise to Kshs. 50,040/=. 3. It was also pleaded by the Claimant that on diverse dates in October 2024, the Respondent requested for top up loans from the Claimant causing the principal loan amount to rise to Kshs. 76,040/=. 4. The Respondent allegedly defaulted in repaying the loan hence the outstanding loan rose to Kshs. 104,000/= as at the time of filing this claim. 5. The Respondent neither entered appearance nor filed a Response to the Claim despite having been duly served. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/57/eng@2025-10-16 1
page 1 of 4
6. Consequently, this claim proceeded as an undefended claim. Whereas this claim was a claim for a liquidated claim, the matter proceeded to formal proof in view of the nature of the claim and the interest rates claimed for this court to determine whether the interest rates were unconscionable or not. The summary of the evidence adduced by the Claimant is set out below. Claimant’s Case 7. CW1 Anne Nkatha Muriuki adopted her witness statement dated 26th June 2025 as her evidence in chief. That statement is by and large a regurgitation of the contents of the averments in the Claimant’s Statement of Defence. 8. She produced the documents in the Claimant’s list of documents and supplementary list of documents herein as exhibits. Analysis & Determination 9. This court has duly considered all the pleadings and all the evidence placed before it. 10. This court has stated earlier on in this judgment that this matter proceeded by way of formal proof. 11. Be that as it may, the Claimant, even in the absence of evidence to the contrary by the Respondent, is duty-bound to prove their case on a balance of probabilities. 12. It is trite that the legal burden of proof lies with the person who alleges. Section 107 (1) of the Evidence Act, Cap 80 Laws of Kenya provides that: “ Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependant on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.’’ 13. In Anne Wambui Ndiritu –vs- Joseph Kiprono Ropkoi & Another [2005] 1 EA 334, the Court of Appeal held that: “ As a general proposition under Section 107 (1) of the Evidence Act, Cap 80, the legal burden of proof lies upon the party who invokes the aid of the law and substantially asserts the afirmative of the issue. There is however the evidential burden that is case upon any party the burden of proving any particular fact which he desires the court to believe in its existence which is captured in Sections 109 and 112 of the Act.” 14. In Daniel Toroitich Arap Moi –vs- Mwangi Stephen Muriithi & Another [2014] eKLR the Court of Appeal held that: “ It is a firmly settled procedure that even where a defendant has not denied the claim by filing a defence or an afidavit or even where the defendant did not appear, formal proof proceedings are conducted. The claimant lays on the table evidence of facts contended against the defendant. And the trial court has a duty to examine that evidence to satisfy itself that indeed the claim has been proved. If the evidence falls short of the required standard of proof, the claim is and must be dismissed. The standard of proof in a civil case, on a balance of probabilities, does not change even in the absence of rebuttal by the other side.” 15. Guided by the authorities above, it follows that the only issue that commend to this court for determination is whether the Claimant proved this claim to the required standards. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/57/eng@2025-10-16 2
page 2 of 4
16. The Claimant relied on a copy of the loan agreement dated 31st October 2024, a Demand Letter dated 13th May 2025, Mpesa transactions messages screenshots for 31st October 2024 and 05th November 2024, and messages screenshots to prove this claim. 17. A reading of the Mpesa transaction messages screenshots placed before this court by the Claimant show that the Respondent reportedly received Kshs. 14,100/=, Kshs. 1,900/=, and Kshs. 36,000/= through phone number 0710702766 on diverse dates between 31st October 2024 and 05th November 2024. Interestingly, those Mpesa transactions messages screenshots do not disclose the identity of whoever was sending the money to the Respondent’s phone number 0710702766. 18. It is also noteworthy that the loan agreement dated 31st October 2024 placed before this court by the Claimant shows that the terms therein were applicable to the loan of Kshs. 36,000/= reportedly advanced to the Respondent on 31st October 2024. The terms of the other alleged top up loans remain unknown. 19. The Claimant also relied on messages extracts showing that the Respondent reportedly requested for a loan of Kshs. 1,900/= and Kshs. 14,100/= from the Claimant. The said messages extracts do not show when the alleged loan requests were made. Further, the origin of those messages extracts are unknown. 20. Be that as it may, this court notes that the Mpesa messages extracts and the messages extracts on record do not meet the test of admissibility of electronic evidence under section 106B of the Evidence Act. The Court of Appeal in County Assembly of Kisumu & 2 others v Kisumu County Assembly Service Board & 6 others [2015] eKLR stated that, despite the introduction of the blanket declaration of admissibility under the provisions of section 78A, the requirement of a certificate as described in section 106B is a mandatory one which cannot be obviated by constitutional prohibitions against undue regard to procedural technicalities 21. Whereas section 32 (2) of the Small Claims Court Act provides that the Court may admit as evidence in any proceedings before it, any oral or written testimony, record or other 22. material that the Court considers credible or trustworthy even though the testimony, 23. record or other material is not admissible as evidence in any other Court under the 24. law of evidence, this court takes judicial notice of the risk associated with manipulation of electronic evidence in this modern age. 25. Therefore, this court takes the view that electronic evidence adduced before the Small Claims Court, more so in instances where a party is represented by an advocate well versed in the rules of evidence, can only pass the test of credibility and trustworthy if the said evidence is adduced per section 106 B of the Evidence Act. 26. It is against this backdrop that this court finds and holds that the Mpesa transactions messages screenshots and the messages extracts adduced by the Claimant in support of their case in contravention of section 106B of the Evidence Act are of no evidential value. 27. In any event, clause 2 of the agreement herein defines a request as a request or instruction received by Zenka from you or purportedly from you through the system and upon which Zenka is authorised to act on. No such request was placed before this court by the Claimant to prove on a balance of probabilities that the Respondent requested for loans from them. 28. In the absence of proof of the requests for loans by the Respondent to the Claimant, there is no proof that the Respondent requested for the alleged loans from the Claimant. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/57/eng@2025-10-16 3
page 3 of 4
29. Clause 9 of the loan agreement on record contemplates the existence of a loan statement. Clause 9.5 is explicit that a Statement of the Respondent’s loan account shall be conclusive evidence of the transactions carried out on the Respondent’s account during a given period. That shows that only a statement of account/loan statement could prove on a balance of probabilities that the Respondent borrowed loan(s) from the Claimant, defaulted in repaying the loan (s), and the extent of the Respondent’s indebtedness to the Claimant. 30. The Claimant did not place before this court the loan statement(s) relating to the claim herein. 31. In the absence of the the requests for loan (s) from the Respondent to the Claimant and the loan(s) statements, this court cannot tell if the Respondent requested for the alleged loans from the Claimant, and whether the Respondent defaulted in repaying the alleged loans, and the extent of the Respondent’s alleged indebtedness to the Claimant. 32. It is worth restating that the failure by a party to respond to a demand letter demanding the repayment of an alleged debt is not an admission of indebtedness by the alleged debtor to the alleged creditor in that demand letter. 33. It is against this background that this court finds and holds that the Claimant failed to prove this claim to the required standards. Disposition 34. The upshot of the foregoing is that this claim is struck out with no order as to costs. Judgment accordingly. File closed. READ, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED IN OPEN COURT AT BUNGOMA THIS 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2025 T.O. OMONO ADJUDICATOR In the presence of: Ms. Nakhanu for the Claimant C/A: Mr. Rioba https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/scc/2025/57/eng@2025-10-16 4
page 4 of 4