REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE CHIEF MAGISTRATES COURT AT BUNGOMA CIVIL CASE NO. E517 OF 2024 FRED NYONGESA WAMAYUYI………………….……………….PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT VERSUS THE CHAIRMAN, KNUT BUNGOMA BRANCH,BUNGOMA SOUTH TEACHERS BURIAL AND BENEVOLENT SCHEME & 2 OTHERS…………...DEFENDANT/APPLICANT JUDGMENT 1. The Plaintiff moved this court through a Plaint dated 04th December 2024 seeking judgment against the Defendants jointly and severally for: a) An order that the Defendants jointly and severally be compelled to immediately process and release the Plaintiff’s Burial and Benevolent Fund contribution of Kshs. 136,900/= as enshrined under Article III (9)(i) of the Defendants’ constitution b) The costs of this suit c) Interest on (a) and (b) at court rates d) Any other or further relief this honourable court may deem fit 2. The Plaintiff pleaded that he was a bona fide member of the KNUT Bungoma Branch Bungoma South Teachers’ Burial and Benevolent Scheme (“the Scheme”) until his retirement on 30th June 2024. 3. He further pleaded that the scheme’s by laws that he was entitled to his benefits under the scheme upon retirement, but the Defendants had refused to release to him his benefits of Kshs. 136,900/= despite several demands and notice of intention to sue thus necessitating the filing of this suit. 4. The Defendants filed a Statement of Defence admitting the Plaintiff’s membership of the scheme. However, they took the position that the
page 1 of 8
scheme’s bylaws had been amended through an Annual General Meeting held on 07th April 2018, where it was resolved that there would not be refunds for retirees, and that the retirees would become life members of the scheme. 5. In the circumstances, the Defendants urged this court to dismiss this suit with costs. 6. It is against this backdrop that this matter was set down for hearing for the parties herein to prove the averments in their respective pleadings on a balance of probabilities. EVIDENCE Plaintiff’s Case 7. PW1 Fred Nyongesa Wamayuyi adopted his witness statement dated 04th December 2024 as his evidence in chief. He also produced all the documents in his list of documents herein as exhibits. 8. His testimony was largely a reiteration of the averments in his Plaint. 9. He stated in cross-examination that he was not aware of any resolution passed by the scheme on 07th April 2018 on life membership of the scheme for retirees. He denied the existence of such a resolution. 10. He added that the scheme has always been making contributions’ refunds to retirees. Defendants’ Case 11. DW1 Titus Busuru Chebori is the scheme’s chairperson. He adopted his witness statement dated 22nd October 2025 as his evidence in chief. He produced the minutes of the scheme’s Annual General meeting held on 07 th April 2018 as an exhibit. 12. The crux of his testimony was that the scheme passed a resolution on th 07 April 2018 during the scheme’s Annual General Meeting to the effect that retirees were to retain their scheme’s membership upon retirement. He added that the scheme’s membership also resolved that retirees were not to be refunded their contributions.
page 2 of 8
13. He admitted in cross-examination that the Plaintiff was a member of the scheme. He conceded that the scheme’s minutes, which he had produced, were incomplete. 14. He also conceded that the minutes he had produced did not disclose the mover or the proposer of the resolution that retirees were not to be refunded their contributions upon retirement. He further admitted that he was aware of instances where retirees had been refunded their contributions made during their membership of the scheme. 15. When this court, in exercise of its power to seek clarity from any witness as provided for under Order 18 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules, asked him if the scheme’s membership was voluntary, he informed this court that the scheme’s membership was voluntary. He added that contributions made by a member were refundable, less administrative fees, upon a member’s retirement. ANALYSIS & DETERMINATION 16. There is no dispute that the Plaintiff was a member of the scheme until 30th June 2024 when he retired. It is common ground that the Plaintiff made contributions of Kshs. 136,900/= during his active membership of the scheme. 17. The foregoing inclines this court to find and hold that the only issue for determination is whether the Defendants should be compelled to refund the Plaintiff his scheme’s contributions of Kshs. 136,900/=. 18. The Plaintiff placed before this court the scheme’s bylaws amended in August 2003, showing that Article III (9)(i) of the bylaws expressly provided that upon retirement of a member, the member’s total contribution was to be paid to the member, less 10% towards office operational costs and what the scheme had supported the member. 19. The said scheme’s bylaws, placed before this court by the Plaintiff, shifted the evidential burden to the Defendants to prove on a
page 3 of 8
balance of probabilities that there were other scheme’s bylaws that did not permit the refund of contributions to retirees. 20. The Defendants distanced themselves from the bylaws placed before this court by the Plaintiff by stating that the scheme had passed a resolution during an Annual General Meeting held on 07 th April 2018, disallowing refund of contributions to retirees. The Defendants’ evidence was that the Plaintiff became the scheme’s life member upon retirement, hence he could not claim a refund of his contributions. 21. The Defendants placed reliance on a copy of minutes of the scheme’s alleged Annual General Meeting held on 07 th April 2018 and the alleged resolution amending the scheme’s bylaws in support of their case that the Plaintiff was not entitled to a refund of his contributions since he became the scheme’s life member upon retirement. 22. Interestingly, DW1 conceded that the minutes he had produced before this court were incomplete to the extent that the mover or the proposer of the said resolution could not be known. DW1 also admitted that the scheme’s membership was voluntary, and that upon retirement, a retiree was entitled to a refund of his contributions less administrative fees. 23. It is also not lost to this court that any association’s Annual General Meeting is preceded by a notice convening the meeting. Further, a meeting can only be deemed to have been held by an association or scheme where the association/scheme’s members' signed attendance list is attached to the minutes of any meeting. Further, this court notes that the Defendants did not produce the scheme’s bylaws, which were reportedly amended after the passing of the alleged resolution. 24. The Defendants just placed before this court incomplete minutes of the alleged scheme’s general meeting.
page 4 of 8
25. This court is of the humble view that the question of whether the scheme’s members held an Annual General Meeting and passed a resolution making retirees the scheme’s life members not entitled to a refund of their contributions as alleged by the Defendants could only be settled by the Defendants placing before this court a notice convening the alleged Annual General Meeting, complete minutes of the alleged Annual General Meeting, a signed scheme’s Annual General Meeting members attendance list, and the scheme’s amended bylaws. 26. In the absence of the documents above, the authenticity and credibility of the minutes placed before this court by the Defendants in support of their case are questionable. 27. The Defendants did not give any explanation why they never placed before this court the documents alluded to above. This means that the Defendants deliberately chose not to lead evidence within their knowledge or control in support of their case. 28. In Kenya Akiba Micro Financing Limited v Ezekiel Chebii & 14 others [2012] eKLR, the court stated as follows regarding the consequence of a party failing to adduce evidence within their knowledge or control: “ Section 112 of the Evidence Act Chapter 80 of the laws of Kenya provides: ‘In civil proceedings, when any fact is especially within the knowledge of any party to those proceedings, the burden of proving of disproving that fact is upon him.’ Where a party has custody or is in control of evidence which that party fails or refuses to tender or produce, the court is entitled to make adverse inference that if such evidence was produced, it would be adverse to such a party. In the case of Kimotho v KCB
page 5 of 8
[2003] 1 EA 108 the court held that adverse inference should be drawn upon a party who fails to call evidence in his possession.” 29. In the circumstances and guided by the authority above, it follows that the failure by the Defendants to place before this court the documents above leads to the inevitable conclusion that had the Defendants placed before this court the said documents, the evidence contained in those documents would have been adverse to their case. 30. Be that as it may, Article III (9) (i) of the scheme’s bylaws, placed before this court by the Plaintiff, is explicit that the Plaintiff was entitled to a refund of his contributions of Kshs. 136,900/= upon retirement, less 10% towards office operation costs, and what the scheme supported him with during his membership. 31. In the absence of the scheme’s alleged bylaws making the Plaintiff the scheme’s life member, this court finds no reason to doubt the contents and the authenticity of the scheme’s bylaws produced by the Plaintiff. 32. In any event, even if this court were to believe that the scheme’s members passed the alleged resolution making the Plaintiff the scheme’s life member, this court doubts if such a resolution could pass the constitutionality test when read together with Article 36 (2) of the Constitution, which expressly provides that no person shall be compelled to join an association of any kind. 33. This court finds support from Kenya Medical Practitioners, Pharmacists and Dentists Union (KMPDU) v Kenya Medical Association & 2 others [2019] eKLR, where the High Court held that freedom of association includes the freedom not to associate. The Court further stated in that case that compelling membership in any body without consent is unconstitutional, save for very narrow exceptions expressly allowed by the Constitution.
page 6 of 8
34. In addition to the above, a person’s right to join and leave any association can also be gleaned from guideline 8 of the Guidelines on Freedom of Association and Assembly in Africa developed in accordance with the relevant provisions of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (African Charter) during the African Commission’s 60th Ordinary Session. The guideline provides as follows: “The right to freedom of association is a right enjoyed both by individuals and by groups. The choice to exercise the right to freedom of association shall always be voluntary; individuals shall not be compelled to join associations, and shall always be free to leave them.” 35. It is abundantly clear from the authorities above that the Plaintiff’s right to leave the scheme could not be curtailed in any way whatsoever without his consent. 36. Therefore, the demand letters issued by the Plaintiff to the scheme upon retirement were an exercise of the Plaintiff’s freedom of association protected under Article 36 of the Constitution. The Defendants were obligated to respect the Plaintiff’s freedom of association by refunding him his contributions less any deductions permissible under the scheme’s bylaws. 37. It is against this backdrop that this court finds and holds that the Plaintiff proved his case on a balance of probabilities. DETERMINATION 38. Accordingly, for the reasons set out above, this court makes the following orders: a) The Defendants are jointly and severally compelled to immediately process and release the Plaintiff’s Burial and Benevolent Fund contribution of Kshs. 136,900/= less any deductions permissible under the scheme’s bylaws
page 7 of 8
b) The amount in (a) to earn interest at court rate from the date of this judgment till payment in full c) The Plaintiff will have the costs of this suit 39. It is so ordered. Read, signed, and delivered in open court at Bungoma, this 26th day of March 2026 T.O. OMONO SENIOR RESIDENT MAGISTRATE In the presence of: Mr. Juma Waswa h/b for Gatimu for the Plaintiff/Respondent Mr. Angima for the Defendant/Applicant C/A: Rioba
page 8 of 8