Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

In re AW AND AW(2) (Minors) (Children's Case E018 of 2025) [2026] KEMC 611 (KLR)

In re AW AND AW(2) (Minors) (Children's Case E018 of 2025) [2026] KEMC 611 (KLR) (10 March 2026) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2026] KEMC 611 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE BUNGOMA LAW COURTS CHILDREN'S CASE E018 OF 2025 TO OMONO, SRM MARCH 10, 2026 IN THE MATTER OF AW AND AW(2) (MINORS) BETWEEN PNM (SUING AS NEXT FRIEND AND GUARDIAN AD-LITEM FOR AW & AW(2) - MINORS) ...................................................................................... PLAINTIFF AND TW ............................................................................................................ DEFENDANT RULING 1. The Defendant/Applicant moved this court through a Notice of Motion dated 05th February 2026 seeking the following orders: a. That the custody of the minors AW (18) years and AW(2) (15) years be granted to the Applicant b. Any other orders this Honourable Court deems is (sic) fit for the welfare of the children 2. The instant Application was premised on the grounds on the face of it, which grounds were further reiterated in the Supporting Afidavit sworn by the Defendant/Applicant on 05th February 2026. 3. The Defendant/Applicant averred that the Plaintifi/Respondent was cohabiting with another man in a small rented house in Bungoma, where she was also staying with the children herein. He added that the Plaintifi/Respondent had taken away the children to his exclusion and other family members. 4. It was also averred by the Defendant/Applicant that whenever he calls the children, the children sound distressed, and that the children had expressed a desire to stay with him since they were old enough to stay in their father’s home. 5. He further stated that he had a stable income and suitable living arrangements, thus if the children’s custody is granted to him, the minor’s schooling and social life would not be disrupted. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2026/611/eng@2026-03-10 1

page 1 of 4

6. It is against this backdrop that the Defendant/Applicant took the position that it was in the interest of justice and the welfare of the children that he be granted the children’s custody. 7. The Plaintifi/Respondent opposed the instant Application through a Replying Afidavit sworn on 06th March 2026. She characterized the instant Application as frivolous, vexatious, and lacking any substance. 8. The Plaintifi/Respondent averred that the parties herein had settled the issue regarding the children’s custody through a Parental Responsibility Agreement dated 30th October 2025, which they executed at the Bungoma South Children Oficer’s ofice. 9. She also deponed that the Defendant/Applicant had not stated the children’s correct age, and that the Defendant/Applicant had not demonstrated that she was unfit to have the children’s physical custody. 10. In the circumstances, the Plaintifi/Respondent urged this court to jettison the instant Application summarily for lack of merit. Analysis & Determination 11. This court has given due regard to the pleadings and the evidence on record. This court takes the humble view that the only issue for determination is whether the instant Application is merited. 12. From the onset, this court notes that the parties herein executed a Joint Parental Responsibility Agreement dated 30th October 2025 (“the PRA”) per section 33 of the Children Act (“the Act”), vesting the children’s physical custody in the Plaintifi/Respondent. 13. The PRA was adopted by this court on 09th December 2025 as an order/judgment of this court. 14. The foregoing shows that this matter was settled by consent of the parties herein. 15. It thus follows that the instant Application seeks to set aside or vary the terms of the PRA and the consent order herein. 16. Section 33 (3) of the Act grants this court the power to revoke or terminate a PRA upon being moved by a person who has parental responsibility over the child, or a child, with the leave of the Court. This, by implication, means that the court can vary the terms of a PRA upon being moved by a person who has parental responsibility over the child, or a child, with the leave of the Court. 17. There is no doubt that the Defendant/Applicant, being the children’s father, has parental responsibility over the children. Therefore, the Defendant/Applicant had the legal standing to move this court to revoke, terminate, or vary the PRA herein. 18. However, this court notes that the Act does not set out the grounds for setting aside or varying a PRA. 19. Be that as it may, given that a PRA is akin to a consent, it follows that such an agreement can be varied, revoked, or set aside if the conditions for setting aside a consent are established. 20. The principles to guide courts in considering an application to review a consent order were well articulated in the Jamaican case of Windsor Commercial Land Company Ltd & others v Century National Merchant Bank Trust Ltd SCCA 114/2005, where the court stated; “ The court will not interfere or disturb a consent order between the parties other than on those grounds in which it would interfere with any other contract. These would include mistake, misrepresentation, duress, and undue infiuence.” https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2026/611/eng@2026-03-10 2

page 2 of 4

21. In Duncan Onyango Odera v Mary Adhiambo Wasonga & Eliud Otieno Odingo (Suing as Legal Representatives of the Estate of Benard Ooko Otieno alias Benard Otieno Odero [Deceased] [2021] eKLR Aburili J observed as follows on the conditions of setting aside a consent order: “ [30] ..a consent order will only be set aside if it can be demonstrated that it was procured through fraud, non- disclosure of material facts or mistake or for a reason which would enable the Court to set it aside." 22. The common thread running through the authorities above is that for a consent order or a PRA to be set aside or varied, the Defendant/Applicant must demonstrate the existence of exceptional circumstances which include fraud, mistake, coercion, change of circumstances from the date the consent was adopted, or any other suficient cause. 23. In the circumstances, this court will proceed to determine whether the Defendant/Applicant has proved on a balance of probabilities the existence of the circumstances requiring the setting aside or the variation of the parental responsibility agreement or the consent order herein. 24. The crux of the Defendant/Applicant’s application is that the children are staying with their mother, who is reportedly cohabiting with another man in a small rented house within Bungoma town. He also alleged that the Plaintifi/Respondent had kept the children away from him and other family members. 25. He further alleged that the children are being held by the Plaintifi/Respondent against their will, given that they reportedly sound distressed when speaking to him. He added that the children were old enough to stay in their father’s home. 26. The Plaintifi/Respondent disputed the averments made by the Defendant/Applicant in support of the instant Application. 27. There is no doubt that the evidence in support and against the instant Application is largely the Defendant/Applicant’s word against the Plaintifi/Respondent’s word. 28. This court takes the view that such evidence is barely adequate for this court to determine if there are factors, a change of circumstances, or exceptional circumstances to warrant the varying of the PRA or the consent order on record. 29. In any event, even if one of the children is 18 years old, this court cannot dictate to an adult with whom such an adult should stay. Such an adult is at liberty to decide on which parent he desires to stay with. 30. On the alleged Plaintifi/Respondent’s action of keeping away the children from the Defendant/ Applicant and other family members, this court can only direct that the Plaintifi/Respondent to comply with clause 4 of the parental responsibility agreement herein, requiring the minors to visit the Defendant/Applicant during school holidays. 31. The long and short of it all is that the Defendant/Applicant has not proved on a balance of probabilities that there exist factors, reasons, exceptional circumstances, or a change of circumstances, for this court to set aside the PRA or the consent order herein. Determination 32. From the foregoing, it is hereby ordered: - a. That the Defendant/Applicant’s Application dated 05th February 2026 is dismissed for want of merit https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2026/611/eng@2026-03-10 3

page 3 of 4

b. That the parties herein are ordered to comply with the terms of the parental responsibility agreement herein, in breach, this court may order that legal action be taken against the ofiending party per section 33 (5) of the Act c. That this being a children's matter, each party shall bear their costs of this Application. READ, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED IN OPEN COURT AT BUNGOMA THIS 10TH DAY OF MARCH 2026 T.O. OMONO SENIOR RESIDENT MAGISTRATE In the presence of: Plaintifi/Respondent Defendant/Applicant C/A: Mr. Rioba https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2026/611/eng@2026-03-10 4

page 4 of 4

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.