REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE CHIEF MAGISTRATES COURT AT BUNGOMA CIVIL CASE NO. E043 OF 2025 NICHOLAS RAHAYO OMONDI……………...……………......…. ………………………………………...PLAINTIFF VERSUS YUNNAN INTERNATIONAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED……..DEFENDANT JUDGMENT 1. The Plaintiff moved this court through a Plaint dated 21 st November 2024 seeking judgment against the Defendants jointly and severally for: i. General damages ii. Special damages Kshs. 6,550/= iii. Costs of the suit iv. Interest on (i) and (ii) above 2. The Plaintiff averred that on 26 th October 2024, while riding a motorcycle along Bungoma – Webuye road at Ndengelwa area, the motorcycle rammed into the 2nd Defendant’s motor vehicle registration number KCR 036 M, which had been negligently parked on the road, thereby obstructing his way leading to the occurrence of the accident.
page 1 of 11
3. The Plaintiff further averred that the accident caused him severe bodily injuries set out in paragraph 6 of the Plaint hence this suit. 4. The Plaintiff blamed the accident on negligence by the motor vehicle’s driver as enumerated in paragraph 5 of the Plaint. 5. The Plaintiff also averred that the Defendants were vicariously liable for the negligent acts and omissions of the motor vehicle driver. 6. The Defendants entered appearance and filed an Amended Statement of Defence denying being the registered owners and beneficial owners of the motor vehicle. 7. The Defendants admitted that the accident herein occurred on 27 th October 2024 involving the 2nd Defendant’s motor vehicle registration number KCR 036 M and a motorcycle registration number KMGF 393 E with a rider and two pillion passengers. 8. However, the Defendants took the position that the accident was caused by the Plaintiff’s negligence as particularized in paragraph 6A of the amended Defence. 9. The Defendants prayed that this case be dismissed with costs. 10. The Plaintiff replied to the Defendant’s amended Defence through a Reply to the Amended Statement of Defence dated 17 th September 2025, reiterating the contents of her Plaint. EVIDENCE Plaintiff’s Case
page 2 of 11
11. PW1 Ambrose Simiyu Wekesa adopted his witness statement dated 21st November 2024 as his evidence in chief. 12. He testified that on the date of the accident, he hit the motor vehicle from behind since the said motor vehicle had been parked in the middle of the road without any warning signs. 13. In cross-examination, he added that he was carrying two pillion passengers and that he was not wearing a helmet at the time of the accident. He also stated that his motorcycle’s headlight was on at the time of the accident, which helped him to see the stationary white lorry. He further stated that he did not apply the brakes before hitting the lorry from behind. Defendants’ Case 14. The Defendants did not call any witnesses to substantiate the allegations pleaded in their Statement of Defence. 15. However, on 03rd February 2026, the parties herein recorded a consent permitting the Defendants to produce the Plaintiff’s second medical examination report dated 26th November 2025 by Dr. Oketch Protas Were as an exhibit. ANALYSIS & DETERMINATION 16. This court has given due regard to the pleadings filed herein, the evidence on record, the written submissions filed, as well as the authorities relied upon by the parties.
page 3 of 11
17. It is common ground that the accident herein occurred. It is also not disputed that the Plaintiff was injured as a result of the accident herein. Further, the parties herein are in agreement that the 1 st Defendant was the motor vehicle’s driver at the time of the accident, while the 2nd Defendant was the said motor vehicle’s registered owner. 18. Given the foregoing, the only issues for determination is liability and quantum. Liability 19. It goes without saying that the motor vehicles which were involved in the accident owed the Plaintiff a duty of care to ensure that the Plaintiff reached her destination safely. That duty of care was breached when the Plaintiff was involved in an accident before reaching her destination. 20. The liability of a passenger in an accident is well settled in this jurisdiction. In Wilter Chemutai Torongei Vs. W.E. Tilley Muthaiga & Another (2017) eKLR, the court held; 21. The only time a passenger maybe held to be liable in my view, is when for instance it is shown that he did not fasten his seat belt or was trying to jump out of the vehicle when it has not stopped. That way, some contributory negligence could be attached to him. 22. The authority above shows that in the absence of evidence to prove negligence on the part of a passenger, a passenger cannot be held liable for the causation of an accident. (See also Rosemary
page 4 of 11
Wanjiku Kungu –Vs- Francis Mutua Mbuvi & Another (2014) eKLR and Viviane Anyango Onyango –Vs- Charity Wanjiku (2017) eKLR). 23. There is no evidence on record to suggest that the Plaintiff acted negligently, leading to the occurrence of the accident. 24. Accidents do not just occur, they are caused either by acts of God, human error, or mechanical failure. There is nothing on record to suggest that the accident herein was caused by an act of God. This accident must have been caused by acts or omissions by the drivers of the two motor vehicles involved in the accident. 25. The Plaintiff had the option of suing either of the drivers or suing them jointly. She chose to sue the Defendant’s driver. Nothing suggests that the Defendant’s driver was on their own frolic at the time of the accident. Therefore, the Defendant must be held vicariously liable for her driver’s acts or omissions. 26. It is against this backdrop that this court finds and holds the Defendant 100% liable for the occurrence of the accident. 27. The Plaintiff’s evidence on the circumstances under which the accident occurred remained unshaken even after cross-examination. That evidence was not controverted by the Defendants. When confronted with such a situation, the Court of Appeal in Edward Muuga V Nathaniel D. Schuller (C.A. No 23 of 1997 (UR), the Court of Appeal also observed that where a defendant does not adduce evidence, the plaintiffs’ evidence is to be believed. This reasoning was
page 5 of 11
also adopted by Aburili J in Otieno & another v Odhiambo (Civil Appeal E027 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 7688 (KLR). 28. Police officer……the accident occurred…..involving the matatu and the shovel….passengers……involving the children…..desirable those of age to testify….doctrine of res ipsa loquitor…..shovel and matatu owed them a duty of care….. 29. Defendant blaming the matatu driver….ought to have taken out a third party notice……..in any event did not lead any evidence to prove the averments in their Statement of Defence….. 30. Defendant 100% liable……passengers Quantum (a) 31. General Damages for Pain and Suffering The Plaintiff pleaded in paragraph 6 of her Plaint that the accident caused him to sustain a cut wound on the right forehead, blunt injuries to the right eye, periorbital region, neck, chest, and both knees. 32. The Plaintiff’s medical evidence on record and the Plaintiff’s second medical report dated 26th November 2025 by Dr. Were corroborated the Plaintiff’s averments in the Plaint on the injuries she sustained as a result of the accident. 33. It is against this backdrop that this court finds and holds that the Plaintiff proved on a balance of probabilities that the accident herein
page 6 of 11
caused him to sustain a cut wound on the right forehead, blunt injuries to the right eye, periorbital region, neck, chest, and both knees. 34. The law in this jurisdiction on the award of damages for accident injuries is that, in awarding damages, is that comparable injuries should, as far as possible, be compensated by comparable awards. The Court of Appeal in Stanley Maore vs Geoffrey Mwenda (2004) eKLR, held: “...we must consider the award of damages in the light of the injuries sustained. It has been stated now and again that in assessment of damages, the general approach should be that comparable injuries should, as far as possible, be compensated by comparable awards, keeping in mind the correct level of awards in similar cases.” 35. This court has given due regard to the written submissions on record on quantum. 36. The injuries sustained by the Plaintiff herein are almost similar to the injuries sustained by the Plaintiff in Surian Enterprises Ltd v Mary Bahati Peter (Civil Appeal No. E199 of 2021) [2023] KEHC 20426 (KLR), where the court made an award of Kshs. 150,000/= for multiple soft tissue injuries, including a deep cut on the forehead, and blunt injury to the right knee.
page 7 of 11
37. In Oloo v Arika & another (Civil Appeal E080 of 2024) [2026] KEHC 2889 (KLR), the court made an award of Kshs. 150,000/= for a head injury, left and right leg injury, superficial bruises to both knees, face, and scalp, chest injury, soft tissue injuries on the fingers, bruises, and lacerations on various parts of the body. 38. In the circumstances, this court makes an award of Kshs. 150,000/= under this head. (b) 39. Special Damages The Plaintiff pleaded for Special Damages of Kshs. 6,550/=. The receipts produced by the Plaintiff proved the pleaded Special Damages. 40. It is against this backdrop that this court makes an award of Kshs. 6,550/= under this head. CC E042 OF 2025 WILSON OBURU OMONDI….born 2016….9 years at the time of the accident….no eye witnesses…res ipso loquitor….passengers Head injury with loss of consciousness….not in the initial treatment notes….Dr. Sokobe and Adoka conceded…just suffered multiple soft tissue injuries….agree with Dr. Kahuthu….suffered multiple soft tissue injuries GD Kshs. 150,000/= SD Kshs. 7,250/=
page 8 of 11
CC E043 OF 2025 Nicholas Rahayo Omondi a) GD Kshs. 150,000/= b) SD Kshs. 6,550/= CC E044 OF 2025 Michael Jamia Omondi William Omondi Owuor father testified, did not witness the accident, the police officer…police abstract only confirmed that the accident occurred….no circumstances…a parent/guardian only power is to institute the suit….born on 09th May 2014 per birth certificate….2024 was 10 years old…..at the time of testifying in 2015 was 11 years old….desirable the child testifies….competent witnesss….the father who was not present, heresay…….no evidence on record on how the accident occurred…..047 lead file accident occurred…..100% a) GD Kshs. 150,000/= b) SD Kshs. 6,550/= CC E045 OF 2025 Constantine Wanjala Sifuna a) GD Kshs. 150,000/= b) SD Kshs. 6,550/= CC E048 OF 2025 Twapnicol Natasha Omondi a) GD Kshs. 150,000/= b) SD Kshs. 7,000/=
page 9 of 11
DETERMINATION 41. The upshot of the foregoing is that judgment is entered against the Defendants jointly and severally in the following terms: a) Liability………………………………………70%:30% in favour of the Plaintiff b) General Damages…………………...………Kshs. 150,000/= c) Special Damages……………………...…….Kshs. 6,550/= Grand Award……………………… Kshs. 156,550/= Less 30% Net Award………………………………………Kshs. 109,585/= 42. The General Damages will accrue interest at court rate from the date of this judgment till payment in full while the Special Damages will accrue interest at court rate from the date of filing this suit till payment in full. 43. The Plaintiff will have the costs of this suit subject to the ratio of liability herein. 44. Judgment accordingly. Read, signed, and delivered in open Court at Bungoma this 10th day of March 2026
page 10 of 11
T.O. OMONO SENIOR RESIDENT MAGISTRATE In the presence of: Mr. Shikhu for the Plaintiff Mr. Odongo for the Defendants C/A: Mr. Rioba
page 11 of 11