Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Simamile v Mumalasi (Civil Case E547 of 2024) [2025] KEMC 448 (KLR)

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE CHIEF MAGISTRATES COURT AT BUNGOMA CIVIL CASE NO. E547 OF 2024 CONSTATINE KACHILA SIMAMILE……....…. …………………………………………….PLAINTIFF VERSUS JANET NAFULA MUMALASI………………………………………………………………………...1ST DEFENDANT JUDGMENT The Plaintiff herein sued the Defendant herein through a Plaint dated 17 th December 2024 for judgment for Kshs. 400,000/=, interest, and cost of this suit. The Plaintiff pleaded that on 26th January 2023 he entered into a sale of land agreement with the Defendant for the sale of land parcel number East Bukusu/East Sang’alo measuring 30m by 67m (in this judgment referred to as ‘the suit property’) at a consideration of Kshs. 400,000/=. He added that he paid the consideration in full and thereafter build a house on the suit property in March 2023 only for the Plaintiff to allegedly demolish that house and chase away the Plaintiff hence this suit. The Defendant entered appearance and filed a Statement of Defence dated 03rd January 2025. It was the Defendant’s case that she sold a portion of the suit property to the Plaintiff after that said portion had been awarded to her by her father and the clan. She added that she gave the Plaintiff vacant possession of the suit property and that the Plaintiff had been using the suit property to date. The Defendant denied demolishing the Plaintiff’s house. She attributed the demolition of the Plaintiff’s house to three people namely Wales Wefwafwa, Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 1 of 10 Judgment

page 1 of 10

Jared Mutelwa, Festus Wanjuisi, and Joyce Namalwa that the Plaintiff had reported to Mechimeru Police Post for the demolition of his house. Further, the Defendant pleaded that she did not have capacity to be sued since the suit property belonged to Mutongonyi Siara who died on 10 th September 1975. Plaintiff’s Case PW1 Constatine Simamile Kachila the Plaintiff herein adopted his witness statement herein as his evidence in chief. His witness statements reiterated the contents of his Plaint. He also produced the documents in his list of documents herein as exhibits (Pexh.1 & 2). In cross-examination he stated that at the time of purchasing the suit property, the suit property was registered in Mutongoi Siara’s name and that land succession had not been conducted. He conceded that the Plaintiff did not demolish his house but the house had been demolished by the Defendant’s husband one Robert Barasa and other people. He added that the Defendant wronged him since she sold to him land that did not belong to him. Defendant’s case DW1 Janet Nafula Mumalasi adopted her witness statement dated 23 rd February 2025 as her evidence in chief. She reiterated the contents of her Statement of Defence. She added that the Plaintiff was at liberty with utilization of the suit property since she had not chased him away. She produced the documents in her list of documents dated….as exhibits. In cross-examination, she conceded that she had sold the suit property to the Plaintiff before commencement of succession proceedings with respect to Mutongoyi Siara’s estate. Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 2 of 10 Judgment

page 2 of 10

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION This court has duly considered the respective parties’ pleadings, evidence, written submissions and authorities placed before this court. The issues that arise for determination by this court are:a) Whether the Defendant had the capacity to be sued by the Plaintiff b) Whether the sale of land transaction herein was void c) What are the orders that commend to this court Whether the Defendant had the capacity to be sued by the Plaintiff The Defendant pleaded in paragraph 8 of her Statement of Defence herein that she lacked the capacity to be sue as the suit property belonged to Mutongoyi Siara. It is common ground that the suit property was registered in Mutongoyi Siara’s name at the time of execution of the Sale of Land Agreement dated 26th January 2023 between the parties herein. It is also not disputed that the said Mutongoyi died on 10th September 1975 and that succession proceedings with respect to Mutongoyi’s estate had not been concluded as at 26th January 2023. A reading of that agreement shows that the Plaintiff did not enter into the sale of land agreement with the estate of the late Mutongoyi Siara or a personal representative of the estate of Mutongoyi Siara. The Plaintiff contracted with the Defendant. The Plaintiff paid Kshs. 400,000/= for the suit property to the Defendant. The Plaintiff herein is seeking amongst other orders an order for a refund of Kshs. 400,000/= that she paid to the Defendant. the Plaintiff is not seeking occupation of the suit property. Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 3 of 10 Judgment

page 3 of 10

It would have been necessary for the Plaintiff to sue the personal representative of Mutongoyi Siara’s estate if at all the Plaintiff was seeking occupation of the suit property. That is not the case in this matter. It is against this backdrop that this court finds and holds that the Defendant was properly sued by the Plaintiff. Whether the sale of land transaction herein was void The Plaintiff did not plead for a declaration that the sale of land transaction herein be declared void. Neither party led evidence on this point of law. The closest the Plaintiff came to raising this point of law was during his testimony when the stated that the Defendant wronged him by selling to him the suit property that was not registered in her name. The general rule is that parties are bound by their pleadings and that a court cannot take a journey of wandering beyond the parties’ pleadings. Be that as it may, every general rule has exceptions. The law in this jurisdiction is that a court is at liberty to raise a point of law suo moto and then proceed to determine the same. The position taken by this court is fortified by the Aburili J’s finding in Kenya Agricultural and Livestock Research Organization v Okoko & another (Civil Appeal 36 A of 2021) [2022] KEHC 3302 (KLR) (29 June 2022) (Judgment), where the learned judge rendered herself thus: ‘A matter of law is not a matter that must be pleaded and a court of law can on its own motion determine such issue of law even where parties have not pleaded it. This is so because the court is deemed to know the law. In Pancras T Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited [2014] eKLR the Court of Appeal stated: “23.The High Court is presumed to know the law. That is why the Constitution has conferred on the High Court in Article 165(3)(a) Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 4 of 10 Judgment

page 4 of 10

unlimited original jurisdiction in Civil and Criminal matters and in Article 20 (3)(a) jurisdiction to develop the law and in Article 20 (3) (b) the mandate to interpret the Bill of Rights. It was expected that counsel, in getting up on the brief would come up with the law and authorities including the Treaty and the case-law. But he failed to do so. It was the duty of the Court to have before it the relevant law and to apply it correctly…” It is therefore my finding that the trial court did not err in entertaining the issue of the plaintiff/appellant herein not having filed authority for institution of suit.’ The foregoing shows that it is within the province of this court to raise and determine the point of law on whether the sale of land agreement herein was void. The parties were in agreement that at the time of execution of the sale of land agreement dated 26th January 2023, the suit property was registered in Mutongoyi Siara’s name and that the said Mutongoyi died on 10 th September 1975. It is also common ground that at the time of execution of the sale of land agreement herein, succession proceedings with respect to Mutongoyi’s estate had neither been commenced nor concluded. Section 45 of the Law of Succession Act provides that:Except so far as expressly authorized by this Act, or by any other written law, or by a grant of representation under this Act, no person shall, for any purpose, take possession or dispose of, or otherwise intermeddle with, any free property of a deceased person. Musyoka, J had the occasion to determine the import of section 45 of the Law of Succession Act in Veronica Njoki Wakagoto (Deceased) [2013] eKLR where he stated: Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 5 of 10 Judgment

page 5 of 10

“The effect of [Section 45]…is that the property of a dead person cannot be lawfully dealt with by anybody unless such a person is authorised to do so by the Law. Such authority emanates from a grant of representation and any person who handles estate property without authority is guilty of intermeddling. The law takes a very serious view of intermeddling and makes it a criminal offence.” In Re Estate of Paul M’Maria (Deceased) [2017] eKLR, the court held that; “The restriction provided by law that no immovable property shall be sold or distributed before confirmation of grant is not merely directory or an embellishment. It is a statutory command with fatal consequences on any transaction done in contravention of the said law. Accordingly, acquisition of immovable property of the estate in contravention of the Law of Succession Act is tinctured with killer poison; and is unlawful acquisition; thus, property so acquired does not enjoy the protection of property rights under article 40(6) of the Constitution. See the claw-back provision of the Constitution that:40(6) The rights under this Article do not extend to any property that has been found to have been unlawfully acquired. Therefore, applying the law and the Constitution, the sale of Plot 18A Mitunguu Market on July 12, 2004 was in contravention of the Law of Succession Act and therefore vitiated by that illegality. It is thus invalid, null and void transaction. Such contract is ex facie illegal and is unenforceable; no person can maintain an action based on or recover on the basis of a contract which is prohibited by statute” The authorities above leave no doubt in the mind of this court that the Defendant lacked the capacity to transfer the suit property to the Plaintiff at the time of execution of the sale of land agreement dated 26th January 2023. Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 6 of 10 Judgment

page 6 of 10

At the time of executing the said sale of land agreement, the Defendant lacked a good title that she could transfer to the Defendant. To quote the nemodat principle embodied in section 23 of the Sale of Goods Act, the Defendant could not give the Plaintiff what she did not have. For the reasons above, this court holds and finds that the sale of land agreement dated 26th January 2023 between the parties herein is void. What orders commend to this court The Defendant pleaded in her Statement of Defence that the Plaintiff was at liberty to occupy the suit property. Having found that the agreement herein was void, the Defendant cannot purport to invite the Plaintiff to continue performing an illegality. In any event the Defendant cannot purport to give what she does not have. The parties herein participated in an illegality. It has been held times without number in this jurisdiction that no person can maintain an action based on or recover on the basis of a contract which is prohibited by statute (see Re Estate of Paul M’Maria (Deceased) case (supra)). On the face of it, it would appear that the Plaintiff would not be entitled to a refund of Kshs. 400,000/= paid under the void agreement herein. That begs the question of whether it would be proper in the circumstances for the Defendant to retain the land and Kshs. 400,000/= that she unlawfully received from the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff lost Kshs. 400,000/= and was thereafter chased from the suit property. Clearly, the Plaintiff, despite having actively participated in an illegality, suffered a wrong. In the circumstances, should the Plaintiff be left without a remedy? This question was answered by the Court of Appeal in Macharia Mwangi Maina and 87 others v Davidson Mwangi Kagiri (2014) eKLR, the court restated the dicta in the Chase International case and held that;- Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 7 of 10 Judgment

page 7 of 10

“This court is a court of law and a court of equity; Equity shall suffer no wrong without a remedy; no man shall benefit from his own wrongdoing; and equity detest unjust enrichment. This court is bound to deliver substantive rather than technical and procedural justice. The relief, orders and directions given in this judgment are aimed at delivery of substantive justice to all parties having legal and equitable interest in the suit property.” (Emphasis added) This court is of the considered view that this is a proper case where the principles of equity must be invoked to ameliorate the harshness of the rule that an action for recovery of money based on an illegal contract cannot be sustained. Allowing the Defendant to retain the suit property and Kshs. 400,000/= will be a mockery of justice. This court is minded that post 2010, the principles of equity became constitutuinal principles and values that this court must apply in delivering its constitutional mandate. This position was restated by Kemei J in Njoroge & 3 others v Maina (Environment and Land Appeal 16 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 4799 (KLR) (15 September 2022) (Judgment), where the court stated thus:‘It is important to note that trust is an equitable remedy which is recognized at Article 10 (2) (b) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 . This court is bound by the national values and principles of governance under the said Article as can be seen below. Equity having been elevated to a constitutional edict, and in the circumstances of this case, allowing Mburu and his sons to keep the land and the money amounts to unjust enrichment. Equity detests injustice.’ (Emphasis added) Having considered the authorities above, this court will not countenance unjust enrichment. Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 8 of 10 Judgment

page 8 of 10

The appropriate order in the circumstances of this case is the order for refund of the Kshs. 400,000/= paid to the Defendant as was ordered in Benedict Nzioka vs Agnes Waita (2020) eKLR where the court awarded the Plaintiff a refund of the purchase price since the beneficiaries had no capacity to sell a portion of the land before letters of grant of administration had been confirmed. DISPOSITION The upshot of the foregoing is that judgment is entered against the Defendant for the sum of Kshs. 400,000/=. The sum of Kshs. 400,000/= due to the Plaintiff will earn interest from the date of filing this suit till payment in full. Given that the parties herein engaged in an illegality leading to this suit, each party to bear their costs of this suit Judgment accordingly. File closed. Read, signed, and delivered in open Court at Bungoma this 10 th day of July 2025 T.O. OMONO MAGISTRATE In the presence Plaintiff Defendant C/A: Albert Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 9 of 10 Judgment

page 9 of 10

Kitale CMC CC. No. 26 of 2023 Page 10 of 10 Judgment

page 10 of 10

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.