REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE CHIEF MAGISTRATES COURT AT BUNGOMA CIVIL CASE NO. E036 OF 2025 FRANCIS WAFULA KHISA….……………………………………..PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT VERSUS CHRISANTUS MAYIENDE MANG’OLI... ………………………......................DEFENDANT RULING Before this court for determination is the Defendant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion Application dated 25th June 2025 under Certificate of Urgency expressed to be brought under Sections 1A, 1B, and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 10 rule 11, and Order 51 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules (2010), and all other enabling provisions of the law, seeking the following orders: a) Spent b) This honourable court be pleased to review, vary, discharge and/or set aside the exparte judgment delivered on 27th day of May 2025 c) The Defendant be granted leave to file Memorandum of Appearance and Statement of Defence in order to defend the suit d) Costs of this Application be provided for The Application was predicated on the grounds on the face of the said Application and the Supporting Affidavit of Chrisantus Mayende Mangoli sworn on 25th June 2025. The instant Application is largely grounded on the ground that the Defendant was never served with the Summons to Enter Appearance and pleadings in
page 1 of 6
this case hence his failure to enter appearance, file a Statement of Defence, and to participate in the hearing and determination of this matter. His position was that the Affidavit of Service sworn on 01 st February 2025 by Paul Wamalwa Kundu contained false hoods regarding the location of the Applicant’s home, and that his house had green ironsheets, not blue iron sheets as averred by Paul Wamalwa in the impugned Affidavit of service. The Applicant also disputed the occurrence of the accident herein by stating that the injuries sustained by the Respondent were linked to an assault case that was reported at Nalondo Police Station vide OB. No. 18/25/10/2024. He added that given that the injuries sustained by the Respondent were allegedly as a result of assault not a road traffic accident, the Applicant had a good defence against the Respondent’s case. The Respondent on the other hand filed Grounds of Opposition terming the Applicant’s Application as an abuse of the court process, frivolous, and vexatious meant to defeat the course of justice. The Respondent reiterated that the Applicant was duly served with the Summons to Enter Appearance, all the relevant notices, and pleadings, as evidence by the Affidavits of service on record. Application was canvassed by way of written submissions where both parties largely reiterated the contents of their respective pleadings. Issue(s) for determination The Law governing an application to set aside an exparte judgment Where judgment in default of appearance or defence or for failure to serve has been entered under the various provisions of Order 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 (the Rules), rule 11 of that Order gives the court a wide discretion to set aside or vary such judgment and any consequential decree or order “upon such terms as are just”.
page 2 of 6
In James Kanyita Nderitu v Maries Philotas Ghika & Another [2016] eKLR, the Court stated that: In a regular default judgment, the defendant will have been duly served with summons to enter appearance, but for one reason or another, he had failed to enter appearances or to file defence, resulting in default judgment. Such a defendant is entitled, under Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules, to move the court to set aside the default judgment and to grant him leave to defend the suit. In such a scenario, the court has unfettered discretion in determining whether or not to set aside the default judgment, and will take into account such as the reason for the failure of the defendant to file his Memorandum of appearance or defence, as the case may be, the length of time that has elapsed since the default judgment was entered; whether the intended defence raises triable issues; the respective prejudice such party is likely to suffer. The court then stated regarding an irregular judgment that: Judgment will have been entered against a defendant who has not been served or properly served with summons to enter appearance. In such a situation, the default judgment is set aside ex debito justitiae, as a matter of right. The court does not even have to be moved by a party once it comes to its notice that the judgment is irregular, it can set aside the default judgment on its own motion. In addition, the court will not venture into considerations of whether the intended defence raises triable issue. Or whether there has been inordinate delay in applying to set aside the irregular judgment. The reason why such judgment is set aside as of right, and not as a matter of discretion, is because the party against whom it is entered has been condemned without notice of the allegations against him or an opportunity to be heard in response to those allegations. The right to be heard before an
page 3 of 6
adverse decision is taken against a person is fundamental and permeates our entire justice system. A reading of the authority above shows that in a regular judgment, a defendant will have been properly served, but for some reason, he failed to enter appearance or file a defence. In such a situation, has wide discretion to set aside the judgment on terms that are just. 34. On the other hand an irregular judgment will have been obtained without service or proper service on the defendant. Such a judgment will be set aside as a matter of right and the defendant granted unconditional leave to defend. Guided by the authorities above and having considered the pleadings, the submissions, and the authorities relied on by the parties herein, the issues that commend to this court for determination are: a) Whether the exparte judgment was regularly entered b) Whether the applicant has a defence on the merits that raises triable issues c) Whether the instant Application has been filed without undue delay d) Whether any prejudice will be occasioned to the Plaintiff if the orders sought are not granted Whether the exparte judgment was regularly entered The Applicant contented that the Plaint, the Summons to Enter Appearance, and the Notice of Entry of Judgment on 25 th June 2025, the Applicant giving a description of the location of his home. He also attached a photo to his supporting affidavit (CMM-2) disputing the averment in the Affidavit Sworn
page 4 of 6
by Pius Wamalwa Kundu on 01st February 2025 on the colour of his house’s ironsheets. The Respondent did not controvert the Applicant’s averments on the location and description of his home. In the circumstances, this court is inclined to find that the Applicant proved on a balance of probabilities that he was not served with the Plaint and Summons to Enter Appearance as averred in the Affidavit of Service sworn by Pius Wamalwa Kundu on 01st February 2025. That being the case, it follows that the ex parte judgment herein is irregular and the same must be set aside of right. Having found that the exparte judgment herein is irregular, a determination of the other issues will be an academic exercise that this court declines to engage in. Determination Accordingly, for the reasons set out above, this Court makes the following orders: 1. The ex parte judgment entered herein on 27 th May 2025 and all consequential orders thereby arising are hereby set aside. 2. The Applicant is granted leave to file its defense out of time and serve the same within fourteen (14) days from the date hereof. 3. Costs of this application be in the cause. It is so ordered. Read, signed, and delivered in open Court at Bungoma this 02 nd day of September 2025 T.O. OMONO
page 5 of 6
RESIDENT MAGISTRATE
page 6 of 6