REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE CHIEF MAGISTRATE’S COURT AT BUNGOMA CIVIL SUIT NO. E165 OF 2025 ZEPHANIA AMENYA AREBA T/A REMMA AUCTIONEERS……... ………............………….PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT VERSUS MOSES ANYANJE & ANOTHER….…………DEFENDANTS/APPLICANTS RULING This ruling determines the Defendants/Applicants’ Preliminary Objection raised in paragraph 11 of the Defendants/Applicants’ Statement of Defence dated 26th May 2025. The Defendants/Applicants pleaded that this court lacked the jurisdiction to heat and determine this suit. On 16th September 2025, this court directed that the instant Preliminary Objection be canvassed by way of written submissions. Whereas the Defendants/Applicants filed their written submissions, the Plaintiff/Respondent did not. Be that as it may, the mere fact that the Plaintiff/Respondent did not oppose the instant Preliminary Objection does not mean that the said Preliminary Objection ought to be allowed. Taking that approach will be akin to this court abdicating its duty of determining the merits or otherwise of any matters brought before it. This court will thus proceed to determine whether the instant Preliminary Objection is merited. ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION Kitale SCC Claim No. E173 of 2024 Page 1 of 4 Ruling
page 1 of 4
This court has duly considered the substance of the Respondent/Applicant’s Preliminary Objection. The only issue for determination is whether the instant Preliminary Objection is merited. Before determining the instant Application, this court must satisfy itself that the Preliminary Objection meets the thresh-hold espoused in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd V. West End Distributors Ltd., (1969) EA 696. Where Law J made the following observations; “…..a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded or which arise by clear implication out of the pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit…..” The Defendants/Applicants question this court’s jurisdiction to hear and determine this matter. Jurisdiction is a point of law. In the event this court finds that it does not have the jurisdiction to hear and determine this matter, it will down its tools with the consequence that this suit will be disposed off summarily. It thus follows that the instant Preliminary Objection meets the threshold of a Preliminary Objection set out in the Mukisa case (supra). The instant Preliminary Objection was grounded on section 34 of the Civil Procedure Act. The provisions of Section 34 of the Civil Procedure Code read as follows; “34.(1) All questions arising between the parties to the suit in which the decree was passed, or their representatives, and relating to the execution, discharge of satisfaction of the decree, shall be determined by the court executing the decree and not by a separate suit. (2) The court may, subject to any objection as to limitation or jurisdiction, treat the Kitale SCC Claim No. E173 of 2024 Page 2 of 4 Ruling
page 2 of 4
proceeding, and may, if necessary, order payment of any additional court fees. (3)………….. The Defendants/Applicants submitted that since the dispute between the parties herein arose from the execution undertaken in the primary suit Bungoma CMCC E263 of 2024. this suit ought to have been filed in the primary suit per section 34 of the Civil Procedure Act. This court disagrees with the Defendants/Applicants on this issue. The matter before this court is not a dispute arising from execution in the primary suit in the strict sense. In this case, the Plaintiff/Respondent seeks the adoption of the Certificate of Costs dated 13th March 2025 that he obtained in Civil Miscellaneous Application No. E105 of 2025 as a judgment of the court for execution given that a Certificate of Costs is not an executable document. This court relies on Rubo Kimngetich Arap Cheruiyot v Peter Kiprop Rotich [2006] KEHC 413 (KLR) where Ibrahim J (as he then was) stated thus:It is my view that a Decree duly approved and signed had to be on record for any execution to take place, whether for the eviction, costs or otherwise. As far as the parties in a suit are concerned, a certificate of costs is not an executable legal instrument. A certificate of costs is not capable of being “executed”. Warrants of attachment and sale cannot in law be issued on the basis of a certificate of costs. There must be a decree first. It is true that the Decree may not be necessarily or always contain the ascertained costs. Costs can be determined before a decree is issued or subsequently, after the Decree has been drawn. However for one to recover costs, there must be a decree. Any money awarded by court Kitale SCC Claim No. E173 of 2024 Page 3 of 4 Ruling
page 3 of 4
including costs is only payable under a decree particularly, if it is through enforcement (see Order XXI, Rule 1). The authority above shows that the approach taken by the Plaintiff/Respondent to have his Certificate of Costs adopted as a judgment of the court for execution is the correct procedure in law. The foregoing shows that the provisions of section 34 of the Civil Procedure Act that the instant Preliminary Objection was grounded on is not applicable in this case. Therefore, this suit could not be filed in the primary suit as submitted by the Defendants/Applicants. DETERMINATION The upshot of the foregoing is that the Defendants/Applicants Preliminary Objection is bereft of merit, hence the same suffers the fate of dismissal with no order as to costs. It is so ordered. READ, SIGNED and DELIVERED in open court at Bungoma this 16th day of October 2025 T. O. OMONO SENIOR RESIDENT MAGISTRATE In the presence of: C/A: Mr. Rioba Kitale SCC Claim No. E173 of 2024 Page 4 of 4 Ruling
page 4 of 4