Mwananchi Credit Ltd v Muhongo (Civil Case E001 of 2025) [2025] KEMC 364 (KLR) (11 November 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] KEMC 364 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE MACHAKOS LAW COURTS CIVIL CASE E001 OF 2025 CC OLUOCH, CM NOVEMBER 11, 2025 BETWEEN MWANANCHI CREDIT LTD .................................................................. PLAINTIFF AND JESCAH KHANALI MUHONGO ......................................................... DEFENDANT JUDGMENT Introduction 1. This matter was initiated by way of an Originating Summons dated 7th January 2025, filed by the Plaintifi, seeking leave from this court to exercise its statutory power of sale over the property known as Title Number Donyo Sabuk/Komarock Block I/31521, hereinafter referred to as the suit property. The basis of the application is the alleged creation of an informal charge over the suit property to secure a loan facility advanced to the Defendant. The application is based on the assertion that the Defendant defaulted on the repayment terms of the loan facility, thereby enabling the chargee’s remedies under the Land Act, 2012. The Application 2. The Originating Summons primarily seeks the following orders: i. A declaration that the Defendant created an informal charge in favour of the Plaintifi by depositing the original certificate of title for property Donyo Sabuk/Komarock Block I/31521 as security for a loan facility of Kshs. 2,000,000.00 advanced on 6th July 2017. ii. An order granting leave to the Plaintifi to sell the suit property to recover the outstanding loan balance of Kshs. 4,152,294.87 due as of 3rd September 2022. iii. An order for vacant possession over the suit property to facilitate the exercise of the statutory power of sale. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/364/eng@2025-11-11 1
page 1 of 5
iv. Costs of the application. 3. The application is supported by the afidavit of Saleh Jackline, the Legal Administrator and Analyst of the Plaintifi, sworn on 7th January 2025, and a further afidavit sworn on 23rd September 2025. The Plaintifi averred that the Defendant was advanced a top-up loan of Kshs. 2,000,000 on 6th July 2017, as a restructuring of an old loan. The security provided was the original certificate of title for Donyo Sabuk/Komarock Block I/31521. The Plaintifi averred that the deposit of the title deed, coupled with the execution of the loan agreement, created a valid informal charge under Section 79 of the Land Act, 2012. 4. Regarding disbursement, the Plaintifi stated that from the Kshs. 2,000,000 facility, Kshs. Kshs. 731,001 was used to liquidate the prior loan. Kshs. 268,999.00 covered costs, and the balance of Kshs. 1,000,000 was disbursed to the Defendant in cash via In-House Voucher No. 012026685, the receipt of which the Defendant acknowledged by signing the voucher. This is corroborated by the Plaintifi''s bank statement, which shows the corresponding cash withdrawal. 5. The Plaintifi contends that the Defendant defaulted on repayment, making only irregular payments, the last of which was on 24th December 2018. The Defendant is now indebted to the tune of Kshs. 4,152,294.87 due to accrued interest and penalties. The Plaintifi also annexed emails showing that the Defendant acknowledged the debt and sought more time to settle the matter out of court. The Plaintifi averred, via its certificate of incorporation, that it is a non-deposit-taking micro- credit company, not subject to the Central Bank of Kenya prudential regulations for deposit-takers at the material time. Defendant’s Case 6. The Defendant opposed the application by way of her replying afidavit, sworn on 1st September 2025. The Defendant denied owing the debt and challenged the transaction''s legality. She denied receiving the purported loan of Kshs. 2,000,000 or the disbursement of Kshs. 1,000,000, arguing that the cheques/vouchers were never paid into her account. She alleged that the Plaintifi’s employees engaged in a “deceitful racket,” denying her the opportunity to read and retain copies of the executed documents. She challenged the Plaintifi''s capacity as a financial institution, demanding proof of the Central Bank of Kenya''s authority and compliance with the alleged bank rates. The Defendant further denied the creation of any formal or informal charge over the land, stating that it cannot be created before actual disbursement into her account. She asserted that the Plaintifi has failed to demonstrate clean hands and urged the court to dismiss the Originating Summons. Submissions 7. Only the Plaintifi filed written submissions. Counsel submitted that the claim arises from the Defendant’s persistent default on a loan restructure agreement dated 6th July 2017. Pursuant to this agreement, the Plaintifi advanced Kshs. 2,000,000, which was secured by an informal charge over the property known as Donyo Sabuk/Komarock Block I/31521. It was submitted that the Defendant agreed to repay Kshs. 2,200,000 in a single instalment, but made irregular payments amounting to only Kshs. 663,004 The last payment was made on 24th December 2018. Due to accrued interest and penalties, the outstanding debt has escalated to Kshs. 4,152,294.87. 8. The sole issue put forward by counsel for determination is whether the Plaintifi is entitled to exercise its statutory power of sale over the suit property, as sought in the Originating Summons. Counsel argued that the security arrangement constitutes a valid informal charge under Section 79 of the Land Act. This provision allows the creation of an informal charge by depositing a certificate of title as security. Counsel relied on Jamii Bora Bank Ltd v Wapak Developers [2018] eKLR and Kingdom Bank Ltd v https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/364/eng@2025-11-11 2
page 2 of 5
Okotsi [2022] eKLR, where the courts afirmed that the deposit of a title deed together with a clear intention to secure a loan constitutes an informal charge under Section 79(6)(b)(i). The Plaintifi''s counsel asserted that the Defendant''s act of depositing the original title and countersigning every page of the loan documents under the rubric “Read, Filled and Signed” constitutes afirmative evidence of assent to the security arrangement, satisfying Section 79(6)(b)(i). 9. Counsel countered the Defendant''s denial of receiving funds by citing contemporaneous records, specifically In-House Voucher No. 012026685 for Kshs. 1,000,000, supported by the Plaintifi’s bank statement extract, which proves cash disbursement on 06/07/2017. It was explained that the facility was a restructure (top-up) of an Old Loan (CCIN001157-15000-001). Of the total Kshs. 2,000,000 facility, Kshs. 731,001.00 cleared the old balance, Kshs. 268,999 covered fees, and the remaining Kshs. 1,000,000 was paid to the Defendant in cash. 10. On the Plaintifi’s regulatory status, counsel submitted that as a non-deposit-taking micro-credit company operating in compliance with the Microfinance Act, 2006, and not subject to Central Bank prudential supervision. 11. On default and the right to sell, Counsel contended that the Defendant’s account has been in arrears since inception, unheeded statutory notices were issued, and the statutory power of sale has therefore crystallised under Section 90(3) of the Land Act, which is triggered by continued default under Section 90(1). Counsel cited Kingdom Bank Ltd v Okotsi [2022] eKLR. To counter the Defendant’s allegations, the Plaintifi invoked the principle of sanctity of contract from National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & Another [2001] eKLR, emphasising that: “ A court of law cannot re-write a contract between the parties... unless coercion, fraud or undue infiuence are pleaded and proved." 12. Finally, regarding the dispute over the quantum, counsel relied on Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] eKLR, which states that: “ The mortgagee will not be restrained from exercising his power of sale because the amount due is in dispute... He will be restrained, however, if the mortgagor pays the amount claimed into court...". Analysis and Determination 13. I have considered the application, the supporting afidavits and further afidavit, the replying afidavit, and the written submissions by the Plaintifi. The sole issue for determination is whether the Plaintifi has demonstrated the existence of a valid informal charge over the suit property and whether its statutory power of sale has accrued under the law. 14. On the creation of an informal charge, Section 2 of the Land Act defines a charge to include: “ (a) an informal charge, which is a written and witnessed undertaking, the clear intention (my emphasis) of which is to charge the chargor’s land with the repayment of money or money’s worth obtained from the chargee;” Section 79 of the Act provides for informal charges as follows: “ (1) An owner of private land or a lessee, by an instrument in the prescribed form, may charge the interest in the land or a part thereof for any purpose including but https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/364/eng@2025-11-11 3
page 3 of 5
not limited to securing the payment of an existing or a future or a contingent debt or other money or money’s worth or the fulfilment of a condition. (2) The power conferred by subsection (1) shall include the power to create second and subsequent charges… 6. An informal charge may be created where— 7. 15. a. a chargee accepts a written and witnessed undertaking from a chargor, the clear intention of which is to charge the chargor’s land or interest in land, with the repayment of money or money’s worth, obtained from the chargee plus interest as agreed by the chargor and the chargee; b. the chargor deposits any of the following — (i)a certificate of title to the land; ii. a document of lease of land; ii. any other document which it is agreed evidences ownership of land or a right to interest in land. A chargee holding an informal charge may only take possession of or sell the land which is the subject of an informal charge, on obtaining an order of the court to that efiect.” In Lincoln Kivuti Njeru v Insurance Company of East Africa [2017] KEHC 3062 (KLR), the court held that: “ It is also evident from the applicable provisions of law that informal charges must be by way of an instrument and therefore evidenced in writing, and the Defendant must therefore enter into further charges or agreements in the event that they want security provided for any other monies that may be found to be owed by the Plaintifi.” 16. In Commercial International Bank (CIB) Kenya Ltd v Azofco General Merchants Limited [2025] KEHC 640 (KLR) the court held that: “ Section 79 of the Land Act creates prerequisites for the creation of both formal and informal charges. For informal charges what is required is writing to disclose clear intent to ofier the title out laid or an interest in land to secure the payment of a debt whether existing, contingent or future, which instrument is then accepted by the chargee as a written commitment and the deposit of any document agreed to evidence the ownership of the land by the chargor.” https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/364/eng@2025-11-11 4
page 4 of 5
In dismissing the application by the lending institution, the Court held that: “ Nonetheless, the Plaintifi has merely mentioned that it has been unable to realise the statutory power of sale over the charged property. It is not clear what challenges it has faced. Now the Plaintifi wishes to realise another security ofiered by the Defendant. It is not discernible from the evidence presented how the Plaintifi came to be in possession of the title for the second property. It is not clear whether the second property was ofiered as security for the same loan or a difierent loan. Has the Plaintifi attempted to realise any of the other securities provided in the Letter of Ofier? On this issue, I find that the Plaintifi has not proved its case to the required standard. Instead, the Plaintifi has left many gaping holes, expecting the Court to play guessing games in order to fill in the blanks.” 17. The consistent theme in the above provisions of law and case law is that simply depositing a title document as collateral for a loan without a written instrument does not constitute an informal charge. In this case, the Plaintifi submitted a chattel mortgage dated 25th April 2016. Land has been added to the schedule attached to the document. Additionally, the chattel mortgage was signed in relation to an earlier loan, and not the top-up of Kshs. 2,000,000 on 6th July 2017. Even if an informal charge had been properly executed for the initial facility, which I believe it was not, a separate written instrument for the top-up should have been executed. 18. The legal position is that a written document must evidence the disposition of land, or the contract for its disposition. The document must clearly express the parties'' intention to create a charge over the land, granting the lender the right to exercise a statutory power of sale over that specific asset upon default. Although this case concerns an informal or equitable charge, the instrument establishing that equity must still meet the minimum statutory standards set out in Sections 2 and 79 of the Land Act. The Land Registration (General) Regulations (Legal Notice 278 of 2017), Rule 67(a), and Schedule 6 specify the format for an informal charge. It cannot take the form of, or be incorporated into, a chattel mortgage. There must be an explicit intention on the part of the borrower to create an informal charge over the collateral, based on a properly executed document. Disposition 19. Consequently, the claim by the Plaintifi for a declaration that it holds a valid and enforceable informal charge over the land, and the subsequent relief of sale of the said land, must therefore fail. The Plaintifi is, however, at liberty to institute a liquidated claim for recovery of the amount due. I accordingly dismiss the suit and direct that each party bear its costs. DELIVERED ELECTRONICALLY, SIGNED AND DATED THIS 11TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2025. HON. C.C. OLUOCH-CHIEF MAGISTRATE In the presence of: Court Assistant- Catherine Signed by: HON. CHARITY OLUOCH https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/364/eng@2025-11-11 5
page 5 of 5