Monica v Machakos County Government & another (Environment and Land Case E146 of 2024) [2025] KEMC 361 (KLR) (31 October 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] KEMC 361 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE MACHAKOS LAW COURTS ENVIRONMENT AND LAND CASE E146 OF 2024 CC OLUOCH, CM OCTOBER 31, 2025 BETWEEN MONICA ...................................................................................................... PLAINTIFF AND MACHAKOS COUNTY GOVERNMENT .................................... 1ST DEFENDANT JOSEPH MUNYAO .......................................................................... 2ND DEFENDANT JUDGMENT Introduction 1. 2. The Plaintifi filed this suit seeking mandatory and permanent injunctions against the Defendants for obstructing a public access road leading to her property, Land Parcel No. Machakos/Kiandani/644. She seeks the following orders: a. A mandatory injunction compelling the Defendants, by themselves, servants, agents, employees, proxies or any other person acting on their behalf, to forthwith open the public access road passing between land parcels 642 and 643, to give access to the Plaintifi’s Parcel Number Machakos/Kiandani/644 by removing all the structures erected on the road. b. A permanent injunction restraining the 1st Defendant by himself, its servants, agents, employees, proxies or any other person acting on its behalf, from blocking the public access road passing said parcels. c. Costs of the suit plus interest. The record confirms that the Defendants were duly served with the summons to enter appearance and the plaint. Despite such service, they failed to enter an appearance or file their respective defences within the stipulated time. Consequently, this matter was set down for an ex parte hearing of the Plaintifi’s case. 2. The Plaintifi’s Case https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/361/eng@2025-10-31 1
page 1 of 3
3. PW1 Monica Nthenya Nzwili, the Plaintifi’s evidence was that she is the legal administrator of the Estate of Duncan Ngei Kisalu, the owner of Land Parcel No. Machakos/Kiandani/644, which adjoins Parcels 643, 642, and 633. The Plaintifi established that an existing public access road runs between Land Parcels 642 and 643 to provide access to her parcel, No. 644. The essence of the dispute is the allegation that the 1st Defendant unlawfully blocked public access to this road by destroying beacons and erecting permanent house structures, thereby rendering the Plaintifi''s property landlocked. The Plaintifi also states that the 2nd Defendant abdicated its responsibility to maintain and rehabilitate this public road. The Plaintifi presented a copy of the Registry Index Map (RIM) Sheet 13, which clearly demarcates the road reserve. There was also photographic evidence showing the permanent structures erected by the 1st Defendant on the road reserve. 4. PW2 Lawrence Muundu Munyao, the Senior Assistant Chief of Kiandani Sub-location, confirmed the Plaintifi’s ownership claim and stated that she reported the dispute to him. The area chief had written to the land registry, and a surveyor had visited the suit land to open up the road. According to him, the surveyor carried out the exercise on the land. The 1st Defendant asked for time to consult his family, as he had constructed a house on the access road. To date, the 1st Defendant has taken no further action. 5. PW2 Douglas Sibota, a land surveyor from Machakos County, testified that he surveyed the suit land on 15th July 2021, in the presence of PW2. He established that Parcel Number 638 borders the Plaintifi’s on the right side. The left side has 643, and the upper side has 642. He determined the location of the road that leads to parcel number 644, which was marked on the RIM. He stated that the owners of 643 have made some development of permanent structures that encroach on the road. The width of the road is 6 metres, 5 metres and 4 metres at some point. There is a permanent structure along the entire length of the road. Clearing the road would therefore require demolishing the whole structure. Analysis and Determination 6. I have carefully reviewed the Plaintifi’s evidence regarding the existence of the public access road and its obstruction by the 1st Defendant, which remains entirely uncontested. The Surveyor’s Report verifies the factual basis of the obstruction along a clearly defined boundary. The 1st Defendant’s action of erecting permanent structures on a public road reserve constitutes a trespass and a nuisance, infringing on the Plaintifi’s right to a quiet possession of the property. 7. The Plaintifi having proved, on a balance of probabilities, that she has a clear legal right to access her land via the public road and that this right has been violated by the unlawful actions of the 1st Defendant, and that the 2nd Defendant has failed to exercise its statutory mandate, the injunctive reliefs sought are merited. Disposition 8. For the foregoing reasons, judgment is hereby entered in favour of the Plaintifi against the 1st Defendant in the following terms 1. A mandatory injunction is hereby granted, compelling the 1st Defendant, by himself, servants, agents, employees, proxies, or any other person acting on his behalf, to forthwith open the public access road passing between land parcels Machakos/Kiandani/642 and 643 to give access to the Plaintifi’s parcel No. Machakos/Kiandani/644, by removing all the structures, permanent or otherwise, erected on the said road reserve within sixty (60) days from the date of this Judgment. In default, the Plaintifi shall be at liberty to carry out a demolition of the structures. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/361/eng@2025-10-31 2
page 2 of 3
2. A permanent be and is hereby granted, restraining the 1st Defendant, by himself, his servants, agents, employees, proxies, or any other person acting on his behalf, from blocking, encroaching upon, or in any way interfering with the said public access road. 3. The Plaintifi shall bear her costs of the suit. DELIVERED ELECTRONICALLY, SIGNED AND DATED THIS 31ST DAY OF OCTOBER 2025 HON. C. C. OLUOCH CHIEF MAGISTRATE https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2025/361/eng@2025-10-31 3
page 3 of 3