Republic v Kariuki (Criminal Case 1105 of 2013) [2014] KEMC 10 (KLR) (16 September 2014) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2014] KEMC 10 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE NYAHURURU LAW COURTS CRIMINAL CASE 1105 OF 2013 PA NDEGE, AG. PM SEPTEMBER 16, 2014 BETWEEN REPUBLIC ............................................................................................ PROSECUTOR AND WILLIAM THIONG'O KARIUKI ....................................................... DEFENDANT RULING 1. The Defendant herein, William Thiong'o Kariuki, was on 15/07/2013 charged with the ofience of Illegal Grazing contrary to section 8 as read section 11 of Stock and Farm Produce Act cap 356 Laws of Kenya. He denied that on 19/06/2013 at Gichigirira village, Ndemi location in Nyandarua county, he illegally grazed his sheep on planted cabbages valued at Kshs. 55,000/=, the property of Joseph Ndungu Kamau. 2. The prosecution were only able to call only one witness herein before controversially closing their case on 10/06/2014. The controversy was mainly because of scant instructions from the Investigating oficer herein on how the complaints herein were to be handled. There were also some serious allegations by the defence counsel on the conduct of the investigating oficer herein. 3. On the evidence adduced, the only witness herein, PW1, Joseph Ndungu Kamau, stated that at all material times herein, had planted cabbages on three acres of land that had been leased to him by one Mark Gachau. That on the material day at around 11.00 am., he found more than 30 sheep that he knew belonged to the defendant herein, while grazing on the land and consuming his cabbages. He called his assistant chief who advised him to call someone to witness the same. He therefore decided to call Mama John who is a sister to the land lord. Mama Gachau responded and found when the sheep were still grazing on the cabbages. They removed the sheep from the farm and detained them so as to await the chief. That it did not take long for the defendant herein to emerge. That he greeted them and then proceeded to drive the sheep away in spite of their protests. He later made the report to Ol Kalau https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2014/10/eng@2014-09-16 1
page 1 of 3
Police Station. An Agricultural Oficer later went to the farm and assessed the crop damage therein to be worth Kshs. 55,000/=. 4. He confirmed in cross-examination that the sheep were grazing in the farm on their own. 5. There were submissions from the learned counsel for the defendant, Mr. Sigilai, at the close of the prosecution's case. 6. He mainly submitted on the legal technicalities surrounding the charges herein; and also on the evidence herein that no one saw the defendant while grazing the sheep herein in the farm as alleged in the charge herein. 7. I will begin with the evidence herein on whether the prosecution has been able to prove to the required standard at this stage that the defendant herein illegally grazed his sheep on the complainant's planted cabbages as charged herein. 8. The complainant confirmed that he did not find anyone herding the sheep in his farm. He just found the sheep while grazing in his farm on their own. It cannot therefore be said with a degree of certainty that it is the defendant herein who took them there. It cannot also be said with the requisite certainty required in criminal trial that the defendant herein was aware that the sheep were in the complainant's farm. We were not told how far the defendant's home was from the farm herein. The sheep could have gone into the farm on their own, given that the complainant confirmed in his evidence in court that it was not the first time for the sheep to get into the farm. 9. The prosecution may be imputing negligence on the part of the defendant herein. Unless expressly stated in the statutes creating the ofience, negligence do not necessarily give rise to criminal responsibility. 10. For this reason, i do find no prima facie case disclosed against the defendant herein to require me to call upon him to defend himself and possible prove that he was or was not aware that his sheep were grazing on the complainant's cabbages as alleged in the charge herein. Doing so, will be going against the law that provides that the burden of proof in criminal trials generally do not shift to the defence except in rare circumstances which I do not find to exist herein. 11. The charges herein were also based on a wrong or non-existent provision of the law. The defendant, his counsel and the court were however aware that it was being alleged herein that he illegally grazed his sheep on the complainant's cabbages as clearly stated in the particulars of the charge and the complainant's evidence. I see no prejudice in the same. We are in a new Constitutional dispensation where under Article 159 (2) we are mandated to be guided by the principle that justice shall be administered without undue regard to technicalities. 12. I have however found no prima facie case disclosed herein, and I do consequently dismiss the charge herein under the provisions of section 210 of the Criminal Procedure Code and do hereby acquit the defendant. DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NYAHURURU IN OPEN COURT THIS _16TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER , 2014 ALOYCE-PETER-NDEGE AG. PRINCIPAL MAGISTRATE In the presence of; Court interpreter: Milka https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2014/10/eng@2014-09-16 2
page 2 of 3
Prosecutions: Faith Defence: Sigilai Defendant: Present https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2014/10/eng@2014-09-16 3
page 3 of 3