Republic v Gatoto (Criminal Case 1361 of 2014) [2014] KEMC 9 (KLR) (21 October 2014) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2014] KEMC 9 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE NYAHURURU LAW COURTS CRIMINAL CASE 1361 OF 2014 PA NDEGE, AG. PM OCTOBER 21, 2014 BETWEEN REPUBLIC ............................................................................................ PROSECUTOR AND SAMUEL MUTHEE GATOTO .............................................................. DEFENDANT RULING 1. On 28/05/2014, the defendant herein, Samuel Muthee Gatoto, was charged with the ofience of Felling and Removing Forest Produce ( Barakiba Tree Log) without permit contrary to section 52(1)(a) as read with section 52(2) of the Forest Act . It was alleged that on 27.05.2014 at Ol-Arabal Forest, Mochongoi Division in Marigat District within Baringo County, he was found felling and Removing one Barakira Tree Log valued at Kshs. 1,000 without a permit. 2. The main witnesses herein are PW1, Michael Lesengei and PW2, Richard Konga, both forest rangers attached to Ol-Arabel Forest. They both confirmed that they were on their normal patrol duties within the said forest when they found the defendant herein while preparing some trees for charcoal burning. That the defendant tried to escape upon seeing them. They however managed to arrest him and recovered two logs of Barakiba tree, panga and axe. They took him to the Mochongoi police station together with the items. 3. At the police station, they were received by PW3, NO. 48821 PC Simon Njuguna. He performed the role of an investigating oficer herein. He produced a piece of the log as PEXH. No 1, and axe as PEXH. NO. 2, a panga as PEXH. No. 3 and another log as PEXH. No. 4. He then charged the defendant herein. 4. The prosecution charged the defendant with felling and removing the forest produce in the same charge herein. For the charge to be proved, then the prosecution had to prove to the required standard that the defendant did actually fall and remove the forest produce as charged. The evidence of the 2 https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2014/9/eng@2014-10-21 1
page 1 of 2
forest rangers however sought to prove that the defendant was found while preparing forest produce for charcoal while inside the forest. There is no evidence that he was removing or had removed the forest produce from the said forest as charged. 5. It cannot therefore be said that the charge of felling and removing forest produce has been proved or constituted to the required standard. 6. No prima facie case has therefore been constituted as required. No evidence that the defendant removed the forest produce as charged. No conviction will follow if he opts to remain silent in his defence. 7. I do therefore dismiss the charge herein pursuant to the provisions of section 210 CPC and consequently do hereby acquit the defendant herein of the charge of Felling and Removing Forest Produce c/s 52(1)(a) a read with section 52(2) of the Forest Act as charged herein. Any cash bail deposited by him herein be refunded forthwith. DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NYAHURURU IN OPEN COURT THIS 21 at DAY OF October, 2014 ALOYCE-PETER-NDEGE AG. PRINCIPAL MAGISTRATE In the presence of; Court interpreter: Milka Prosecutor: IP Mugambi Defendant: Present https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2014/9/eng@2014-10-21 2
page 2 of 2