Republic v Retirement Benefits Appeals Tribunal & another; Board of Trustees, Teleposta Pension Scheme and Provident Fund & another (Interested Parties); Ngugi & 553 others (Ex parte Applicants) (All Suing as Former Members of Telposta Pension Scheme and Provident Fund) (Judicial Review Application E359 of 2025) [2025] KEHC 17613 (KLR) (Judicial Review) (24 November 2025) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2025] KEHC 17613 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE HIGH COURT AT NAIROBI (MILIMANI LAW COURTS) JUDICIAL REVIEW JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION E359 OF 2025 RE ABURILI, J NOVEMBER 24, 2025 IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION BY THE APPLICANTS FOR LEAVE TO APPLY FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW ORDERS OF CERTIORARI AND MANDAMUS AND IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 47 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION ACT, 2015 AND IN THE MATTER OF SECTIONS 8 AND 9 OF THE LAW REFORM ACT AND IN THE MATTER OF THE RETIREMENT BENEFITS ACT, CAP 197 LAWS OF KENYA BETWEEN REPUBLIC ................................................................................................. APPLICANT AND RETIREMENT BENEFITS APPEALS TRIBUNAL ................... 1ST RESPONDENT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL ..................................................... 2ND RESPONDENT AND THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TELEPOSTA PENSION SCHEME AND PROVIDENT FUND ............................................................... INTERESTED PARTY https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 1
page 1 of 19
RETIREMENT BENEFITS AUTHORITY ........................... INTERESTED PARTY AND BEATRICE NJERI NGUGI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY MURUGI KANYI .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SALLY JEPKEMOI KIMAIYO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ADAM ISILIU MUTINDA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ADEB ABDI BULLE ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT AFSA BTEBTA ZAHIR ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT AGNES WANJIRU MUNGAU ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT AGNESS K MANGERA ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT AGNESS WANJIRU NGUGI ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ALFANUS OBUNA ORURU .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ALI HASSAN BOYA ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ALICE CHEPKEMOI NGASURA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ALICE MARY AKUMU ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ALICE WAMBUI NGINYA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ALICE WANGUI KARUGA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ALICE WANGUI MBUGUA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ALLAN MWANGI KIHAGI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ALOISE OMONDI ODHIAMBO ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT AMBROSE OFAFA WANBIYA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT AMSTRONG LAWRENCE MUISYO ................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ANDEREW NYAPARA ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ANDERSON N. MOJAROKI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ANDREW BONFACE KIPROTICH ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ANDREW CHESIR KRELKUTT ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ANDREW ODHIAMBO OLENDO ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ANDREW YEGON .............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ANN MAPENZI NJUGUNA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ANNAH LANKENYA NKIPIDAI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ANNE KAKAI JUMA .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ANNE NJOKI MATHAI ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ANNIEL MIGUONGO IRERI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ANTHONY GACHOKA ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 2
page 2 of 19
ANTONY WACHIRA ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT APELLES ATIENO KAGONJO .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ASBAEI JALONKIPTOO SAMBU ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ASMA JUMA KALEMA ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ASNA MORAA MARACK ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT BARABARA NYAMUSI MBIRU ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BARASA LEONARD ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BEATRICE MWANISA MWUGUSI .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT BEATRICE WANJIRU KINGORI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BEATRICE WANJIRU NGAMAU ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BELITA WAKI MUIA .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BENARD ANEMBA OMBELE ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BENARD KIPKIRUI KORIR ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT BENARDETTE WANYANGA ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT BENEDICT KALOKI MANG'OO ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BENJAMIN KIYEGON RUGUT ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT BENJAMIN ODHIAMBO ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BENJAMIN W. MUNYASIA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BENSON AKOYI OSIMBO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT BENSON KIMEMA GICHUKI .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BENTA ACHIENG ODHIAMBO ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BERNARD KIPCHUMBA CHEPTOO ............................. EX PARTE APPLICANT BERNARD KIPKIRUI KOROS ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BETTY CHEMUTAI ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT BONIFACE MARIGA .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT BONIFACE MBOYA MUTUA ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT BROOKER OWINO SAOLA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT CAROLINE NGANYI .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CATHERINE ANYANO MAINDI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CATHERINE KOSKEI ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT CATHERINE NJAMBI THAGICHU ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT CATHERINE WANJA NJIRU ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES A NYANGORO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES A. NYOTURU ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 3
page 3 of 19
CHARLES ANYASI ANDANI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES GATOTO MURAGURI ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES K. MIBEI ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES KANYI KAMAU ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES KIPROTICH KOECH ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES MOKORI MYANGENA ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES ODHIAMBO OKWACH .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES ONDIKO MUTEKA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES ONGERA OYAOGA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES OTARO GICHANA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARLES SIMIYU MUNYASIA ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT CHARTY MUTHONI ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHEBUKTO RICHARD KIBII ARAP .............................. EX PARTE APPLICANT CHRISTINE KANITHI MBITI ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHRISTOPHER KIMUTAI KAMOING .......................... EX PARTE APPLICANT CHRISTOPHER MWAURA MUNGAI ............................. EX PARTE APPLICANT DANIEL K. KENDUIWO ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DANIEL KIPYEGON RUTTOH ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT DANIEL NJOGU MURIGI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID FELIX MUCHUIRI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID FESTUS KASUKU OJENGE .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID IHUTHIA KINUTHIA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID KIPKURUI TOO .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID LUBANGA MUKUIYA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID MAKABE ONTWEKA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID MEPUKORI MOLLEL ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID NAJERU MUNGAI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID NGENO ................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DAVID NJUGUNA GITAU ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT DELPHINE KEMUNO NYAMBERO ................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT DICKSON CHERUIYOT MUNAI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DICKSON MUNYUA MWAURA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DOROTHY AWINO NYABUWALLA ............................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DUKE OMBAGI MASESE ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 4
page 4 of 19
DUNCAN BENARD NGINYA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EBILISIBAH CHERONO SIONGOK ................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWARD JOHN MAKORI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWARD MULALA JARED .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWARD NDUNG'U MATHEA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWARD OGENDI ANDAL .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWIN KIPNGETICH TANUI ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWIN KIPNYANGO KIPTUNGE .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT EDWIN OMURWA OKIOMA ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ELENA NYAMBURA KARANJA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELIJAH KIMAIYO KIPKOECH ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELIJAH LETUNGA CHERUIYOT ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELIJAH O. AYIEKO ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ELIZABETH CHEBIAMA OMARI .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELIZABETH MUTINDI MWITHI .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELIZABETH W. MUNENE ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ELJAH NDIRANGU WACHIRA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELLY NYABUTO ODABU .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ELSIE TSADSA GANDANI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ELZABETH WANJIKU MUNENE ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ELZABETH WAYEKO LUMBASI ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EMILY CHEPKORIR .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EMMILY JEROTICH KIPROP ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ENOCK ANDALA MUSIDIA ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ENOS DAWA OMBOK ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ERICK AMMO AMUKO .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ERICK KIPTOO KIMETO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ERNEST MURUNGA NGONDO ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ESHAS NYAMAN WAMALABE ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTER NJAMBI MUNGA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTHER BOCHERE ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTHER CHELANGAT KIPSANG ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTHER JELAGAT KIPSANG ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTHER JEPKEMBOI SITIENEI ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 5
page 5 of 19
ESTHER NJERI CHEGE ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTHER ROSEMARY GANDA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ESTHER WANJIKU NJENGA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EUNICE CHERUTO LANGAT .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EUNICE WANJIRU KAMARU .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EUNICE WANJIRU KIMARU ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EVALINE OYULA MAENDE .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT EVANS JEGUGU KOYI ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT EVANS ONWONGA NYAMATO ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT EVELYN WAMBUI KAHIGA ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT FANNY KERUBO OMWENA ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT FATUMA NJERI JAFFAR ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FLEMON MWACHIA KOFIA ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT FLORENCE AOL ATIENO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT FLORENCE KIKWAI CHEPKIRUI .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT FLORENCE KIPRONO ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FLORENCE WAMBUI MUIRURU ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIKA MANYIEKA WANZA ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS B.K TONUI ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS KIPCHIRCHIR ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS KIPROTICH KORIR ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS KIPYEGON MARITIM .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS KIZITO ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS MUTHEE KORIR ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANCIS NJOROGE CHEGE ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT FRANSISCA AWUOR AWUOR ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT FRED OSINO OYOO ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FREDRICK KIPKEMBOI KOECH ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FREDRICK MASINDE ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT FREDRICK OTIENO EZEKIEL ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GABRIEL KIRUT ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GEOFFREY ODHIAMBO OBURU .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GEORGE ERICK OLOO ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GEORGE HAMNINGTON OUMA ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 6
page 6 of 19
GEORGE M. OTARO .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GEORGE MWANGI GITOGO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GEORGE NJOROGE KAHUGU ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GEORGE OTIENO RANGALLA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GIDEON KIPKIRUI LANGAT .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GILBERT KAMAU NDIRANGU ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GLADYS CHEMUTAI ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GLADYS KWAMBOKA KINTU ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GODFREY KABOGORO GACARA .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE AKINYI AWINO ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE CHERONO ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE MUTIO MASAKU ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE OBENYO ORINA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE W. KIARIE ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE WAFULA ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE WAITHIRA MBUTHI .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE WANGECHI KAIRU ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT GRACE WANJIRU NGURE ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HABIL OKELLO OMUSINDE ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HANIEL KIBICHO NJERU ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT HANNAH NUNA MAINA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT HARISON NYOBENGO ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HARRIS WASONGA OCHIENG ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HARRISON OGINGA OKUMU ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT HARRON M. MBARAK ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HARRY KIHIMA BWOSI ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HELLEN BWOSI .................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT HELLEN C. CHEPKWONYI .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT HELLEN J. EMOJO .............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT HELLEN MOGITI MOSOTA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT HELLEN NYABOKE MAGUTO ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HELLEN OMWENA ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT HENRY JOHN CHAKA ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT HENRY OMBONGI KERAMA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 7
page 7 of 19
HERINA ATIENO LUMUMBA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT IBRAHIM WALID ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT IRENE CHEROTICH KOSGEI .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ISAAC CHARLES OTIENO ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ISMAEL OTIENO ACHIENG ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT J.M NYANGENA .................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JACINTA P. OMANYI ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JACINTA PILISI OMANYI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKLINE KWABOKA OPENDA .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKSON M MUKABANA ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKSON MUHINYA MURAYA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKSON MUNYANYA MUKABANA ............................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKSON MUTUKU WAMBUA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKSON ODENY OYOO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JACKTON OUMA ONDIYO .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JACQUELINE ACHIENG KUBAI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JAMES GASICHO OKOKO ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JAMES KIDI MAKIBA ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JAMES MACHUKI NYAKONU ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JAMES ORONGO MBOYA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JAMES OTIENO OMBONGI .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JAMES WAINAINA KIMANI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE ALUOCH OKELLO .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE ALUOCH OTIENO ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE CHEPNG'ENO TANUI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE CHERONO SAMBU ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE JEPKOSGEI KIPLAGAT ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE JEPTUM KIPKELUM ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE MOMANYI ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE MORAA OMORO ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE MWEROO KIBURI .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE SAMBU ....................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE WAIRIMU MBIRIRI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JANE WAITHIRA NGUGI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 8
page 8 of 19
JANET C. BETT ................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANET CHEROTICH MARITIM ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JANETH CHEPNGETICH KITUR ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JAPHET KIMUTAI KORIR ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JARED OWINO OCHOLA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JECINTA PILISI OMANYI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JENIFFER JEBICHI KOMEN ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JENIFFER MOSINYA MURAGE ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JENIFFER WANJIRU MARIGA ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JENNIFER J. KIPKETER .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JENNIFER MUTUMI ISHINDU ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JENNIFER NGINA .............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JEREMIAH ASHITUBI KUTSWA ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JEREMIAH KIMANI THIRU ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JESEPH ALEX ONG'OLA ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOAKIM NDISHU ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOANCHEPKEMOI KILEL ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL ARAP TOWETT ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL K GITUMA ................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL KARUMBA NGATTA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL KIGEN BARSAMBU ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL KIPRONO LANGAT ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL KIPYEGON MUTAI .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOEL MUGANDA ONDUSO .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN CHACHA MOROA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN CHOLE MUGOYIA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN ETEMESI AKHANYINYA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN KIDONDO OMWA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN KIPKOECH CHEPKWONY ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN KIPRONO MATINYKWONY ............................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN MAGOMA OMAYIO ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN MWITA NYASOKO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN NGUGI GATURU .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN NJOROGE KIRIMA ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 9
page 9 of 19
JOHN NJUGUNA NJOROGE ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN OCHIENG HAWANGA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN OCHIENG KAWAGA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN ODAWA OWANGO .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN OTIRIGOYA OROO ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHN OYOLA OCHOLA .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOHNSTONE KIPKOECH ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JONATHAN KIPCHUMBA KOECH ................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JONATHAN WAFULA ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEAH KIPKIRUI CHERUIYOT .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH DAVIDSON ESTABO ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH DAVISON ESTABO .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH K. CHERUIYOT ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH KAMAU MWANGI .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH KANGIRI KAROBIA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH KIMUTAI CHIRCHIR ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH KIPNGETICH BETT ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH MASIGA WAFULA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH MUNYAO MUTHUSI .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH N. ONYISI ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH NDUNGU KAGUAGA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH NYAMWINARA MARUA ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH OTIENO OMOKE ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPH RAGANG ONDENG ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSEPHAT MUTYOTA KIILU .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSHEPH ONYISI ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSHINE CHEPKEMOI CHUMA ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSHINE MAGHUWA GIBSON ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSIAH KIPKIRUI BII ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOSTONE KIGADA MALESI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE AKINYI ODHIAMBO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE C. CHEPKWONY ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE CHEPCHIRCHIR TANUI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE CHEPKEMOI .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 10
page 10 of 19
JOYCE CHEPKIRUI RONO ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE CHEPKORIER BARCHOR ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE IMBULANA KIHADA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE IRENE ACHIENG MALELE .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE IRINE ACHIENG ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE WANGU KIHENJA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JOYCE WANJIRU NZIMBI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JUDITH CHELAGAT SANG .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JUDITH CHERONO MOSONIK ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JULIE C. TANUI .................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT JULIUS KIMANI MACHAKA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JULIUS KIOKO KYOVE ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT JULIUS OMINGO ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT JUSTUS M. MULI ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT KADIJA ADOW ABDI ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT KADUMALA RAJAB .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KASSIM MOHAMED UMEYA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KAYUS NYAKWENYANYA NYARIKA ........................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KEFAATANGA ISANDA ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KELLEN KARIMI MBAE ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KENNEDY ASAVA MWUGUSI .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KENNEDY OMBUNA OYUGI ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KENNETH OCHIENG JOSEPH ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT KIMANI NGANGA K. WAINAINA .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT KIPNGENO CHEBUSIT ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT KIPROTICH KANGOGO WILSON ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT LEAH W. MUKUNO ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LEONARD J. BARASA WALELA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LEONARD JOSIAH AMBUNYA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LEONARD M'BORI SOGHONA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LESAH JEPKONGA CHEBII .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT LILIAN WAMUCII WANJOHI .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LINNER CHEROTICH BIEGON ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LIVINGSTONE NEDIA MASINDE ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 11
page 11 of 19
LIVINGSTONE KOECH ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LUCY ACHIENG ................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT LUCY CHERONO MARISIM ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT LUCY MARION ................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LUCY MUTHONI MWANGI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT LUCY MUTHONI NJENGA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LUCY WANJIKU MAINA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT LUKA KORIR KIPKIRUI .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT LYDIA MASONGOLE ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LYDIAH JEBET KETER ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT LYDIAH ZIMANGI MUDASIA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MABEL TSISIGA MUKITI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MAGURU GITONGA ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MANASH OKOTH OKANJA ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARCELLA CHELAGAT KURGAT ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARGARET ANYANGO OCHIENG ............................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARGARET CHEPKOECH KIRUI ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARGARET MWANGI MORIMBA ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARGARET MWENDA YAA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARGARET NJERI MBUGUA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARGARET ONYANGO NYALWAL ............................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARIA ATIENO LWANDE ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARK MUKWE MUKWANA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARSELLAH CHEBET RONO ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARTHA OYARO OBWOUI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARTIN MURAGE ............................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY A. RICHARD .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY ACHIENG RICHARD ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY AKINYI ODHIAMBO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY ANYANGO OYUNGU ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY CHEPKURUI MIBEI .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY GORETTY MUHUNYA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY JELAGAT TANAU ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY JEMTAI ELISHA ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 12
page 12 of 19
MARY LITAL ........................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY MUKABANE WAIGANJO ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY NJERI KINYANJUI ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY NYAGITHII NGULI ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY REPHER AYUMA ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY W. IGUNZA ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY WACHIRA KARIUKI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MARY WANGARI WAINAINA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MATU WAHOME ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MAURICE OGOLA OBIERO ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MEKENYI WAMBUA .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MESES KIPSOO RONO ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MICHAEL GITONGA GIKONYO ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MICHAEL KARIUKI WACHIRA ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MILKA CHEPKEMBOI MALLOI ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MILKA WANJIRU ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT DOROTHY AWINO NYABUWALLA ............................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ABIGAEL JEPTANUI KIMUTA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ISAAC ODHIAMBO ASIYO ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ISSA ABDI MASUD ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MIRANDA W. THIGA ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MIRIAM DIBO ..................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MOFFAT ONCHAGA NYAKUNGU ................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MOHAMED ADAM ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MOHAMMED ADDI SHEIKH ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MOHAMMED ASSAM ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MONICA AKINYI OUKO .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MONICA WANJIRU NJOGU ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT MORRIS OIRO OWITI ...................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MOSES K. CHEBII ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT MOSES KIMKUNG NAIBEI ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT NAJMA ALI HASSAN ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT NANCY JERUTO SIGILAT ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT NANCY MUTHONI MURIUKI ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 13
page 13 of 19
NANCY RUGUT .................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT NANCY WAMBUI NJOROGE ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT NANCY WANJIKU MAINA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT NATHAN OYASI WANGA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT NELLIE ADHIAMBO ISUMBA .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT NELLY KACHE ASUVILA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT NEWTON KIBYEGON MARITIM ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT NICHOLAS N. OELE ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ONESMUS MUTUA KIMEU .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PAMELA AUMA AKOKO ................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PATRICK KIMOSE NGUHI ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PATRICK KINUTHIA MBURU ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT PATRICK NGARACHU KAHUGI .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PATRICK NZIOKA KIMINDU ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PATRICK OCHOLA NYAWARA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PAUL G. KIBUGI ................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PAUL KIPYEGON CHERUIYOT ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PAULINA CHELAGAT KIRUAI ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT PAULINE CHEROTICH KIMETO .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PAULS KAMATU KAMAU ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT PENINAH KEMUNTO ONDARI ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PERIS CHEMUTAI BII ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PERIS JEBET KRELKUTT ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PERIS MORAA MUSETI .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER ANTONY MWANGI MBUGUA ........................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER KASOMA MUTISYA ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER M KANZI ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER MAINA NGUGI ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER MUIRU GICHUKI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER NAHASHON MAGWAWI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER NASHON MAGAWI .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER NGARI GITHINJI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER NJOROGE MBUGUA ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER OKECH OGOLLA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 14
page 14 of 19
PETER ONDIMI OMAYIO ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER ONYANGO OWIDA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER OPIYO NYENDE .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER OPIYO SIRA ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETER WEYA AWIRO ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PETERSON KIBII KANYORO .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PHARES ONYANGO OTIENO .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PHELOMENA NJERI MWANG ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PHILIP MWANGI KINGORI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PHILIP ODHIAMBO MUHUNYA .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PHILIS WANJIRU KIBE ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT PRISCILLA C. CHESIMET ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT PROTUS SIMIYU KARAMI WASILWA ........................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RAHAB WAMBUI MUMO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT RAMADHAN YAHYA ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT RAPHAEL MACHARIA IRUNGU ................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RAPHAEL ONYANGO NYAKOYO .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT RASHID SULEIMAN JUMA .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT REDEMPTOR NDINDA MWANGA ................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD DANNY KATIECHI ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD G. WAHOME .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD K. CHERONGA ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD KIPNGENO NGENY ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD KIPNGETICH SIELE ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD KIPRITICH RONOH ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD NGENY ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT RICHARD ONYANI ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RISPER MATORO ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSE CHEMUTAI BIEGON .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSE CHEPKORIR MASESE ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSE JEPKOECH LANGA ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSE MUNAI CHELAGAT ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSE MUTHONI MURIUKI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSELINE KIMONYAKWA TOWETT ............................ EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 15
page 15 of 19
ROSELINE KIMONYAKWA TOWETT ............................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSELINE NAFULA M. NYAKUNDIPARAGRAPH 478. .... EX PARTE APPLICANT ROSILINE NYAKESA ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RUNGU WAIGANJO .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RUTH ANYANGO OTIENO .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT RUTH C. KOSKEY .............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT RUTH CHEPKEMOI CHEMEJO ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RUTH CHEPKOECH TUWEI ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT RUTH J. CHEBOI ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT RUTH WANJA KIMANI .................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SALIM TSUMA NYAWA ..................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SALIMA J. SAID ................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SALINA JEPKOSGEI KORIR ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SALINA CHERONO SUGE ................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SALINA JEPKOSGEI KORIR ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SALINA SANG KENDAGORPARAGRAPH 492. ........... EX PARTE APPLICANT SALLY J. CHEBII .................................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMMY CLEMENT WARUI .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMMY DAVIS KIMUTAI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMSON NYAKAAKGA NGOKO .................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL A. NYAMAR ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL CHERUIYOT RONO ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL KIMANI GICHUHI ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL KIPLAGAT KIRUI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL KIPLAGAT KORIR ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL NYAMWERI WAMWADO ................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL OKONGO OGORO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL SOSSIO NGENO ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMUEL WANYEKI WAICHIGO ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SAMWEL MWASHA MWANGI ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SARAH MUMBI MATHENGE ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SARAH MUTHONI KAHIGA ........................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SATNLEY GITAU GITHANGA ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 16
page 16 of 19
SEBASTIAN MAKORI NDEGE ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SHADRACK KIPROP SERONEY ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SILAS KIPKOSGEI CHESIRE ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SIMON CHERUIYOT ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SIMON K.A ROTICH ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SOLOMON OPANY ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT STANLEY KIPKORIR LANGAT ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT STANLEY KIPKORIR RUTOH ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT STANLEY KIPYEGON LANGAT ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT STANLEY MBURU MWENGWA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT STELLA CHERAISI KORIRPARAGRAPH 520. ............. EX PARTE APPLICANT STEPHEN KANDIE ............................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT STEPHEN MUTURI MWAURAPARAGRAPH 522. ...... EX PARTE APPLICANT STEPHEN NGETICH .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SUSAN CHELAGAT BIEGON ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT SUSAN MUKUHI WANJOHI ............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT SYMON NDIRANGU MUCHIRI ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT SYMON TUITOEK KIPLAGAT ......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT TECLA CHERUYOT ........................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT TERRY KADENYI ANALO ............................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT TERRY KAROBIA ............................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT THOMAS M. OBARE .......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT THOMAS MUKABANA MUNYANYA ............................. EX PARTE APPLICANT THOMAS OCHIENG ODIPO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT THOMAS OWINO NGOJE ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT TIMOTHY WANJALA WANYAMA .................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT TOBIAS NAM OGADI ........................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT VERONICAH CHEPKWAMBOK ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT VINCENT K. KOECH ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT VIRGINIA WAMUYU KABURU ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT WILFRED NGUNJIRI ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT WILLIAM K. SERGON ....................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT WILLIAM KIPTANUI LANGAT ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT WILLIAM OBONYO OKELLO .......................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 17
page 17 of 19
WILSON MWANGI MUGWERU ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT WILSON RONO MOSONIK .............................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT WINNIE J KEMEI ................................................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT WYCLIFFE ANYANZWA AURA ....................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT WYCLIFFE MURUMBA SIFUNA ...................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT YUNIAH KWAMBOKA OMBATI ..................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ZEBED MAINA MWANGI ................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ZEBEDEE O. KENYANYA .................................................. EX PARTE APPLICANT ZEDY C. YOSEI .................................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ZIBORAH J. RONOH ......................................................... EX PARTE APPLICANT ZURAH RAMADHAN JUMAH ........................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT CONSOLATA ADHIAMBO OBONYO ............................. EX PARTE APPLICANT MERCY WANJIKU KIONGO ............................................ EX PARTE APPLICANT ALL SUING AS FORMER MEMBERS OF TELPOSTA PENSION SCHEME AND PROVIDENT FUND RULING Ruling on an Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review Orders 1. The Chamber Summons dated 15th November 2025 seeks leave of this court to allow the 555 Applicants, all suing as former members of Telposta Pension Scheme and Provident Fund, to apply for Judicial Review orders challenging the decision of the 1st Respondent made on 2/10/2025 in RBAT Appeal No.7/2011 – Boniface Mariga & 948 Others vs Retirement Benefits Authority & Another. 2. The application is predicated on several grounds on the face of the chamber summons supported by a statutory statement and the verifying affidavit sworn by Boniface Mariga, the 58th Applicant. The applicants also annexed several documents in support of the chamber summons. 3. The applicants are aggrieved by the decision of the RBAT dated 2/10/2025 dismissing their appeal and upholding the 1st Respondent’s decision/directions dated 3/10/2012. A perusal of the application reveals that the intended motion is not frivolous or hopeless. The applicants raise issues which this court is being called upon to inquire into at the substantive stage, which issues affect their rights as former employees of Telkom (K) Ltd and members of a Pension Scheme and Provident Fund administered by the 1st Interested Party. 4. Without delving into the merits of the intended application, I am satisfied that the application as intended is arguable. Being arguable does not mean that it will succeed but that the applicants should be accorded an opportunity to ventilate their grievances in accordance with Article 50(1) of the Constitution. 5. Accordingly, I grant leave to the 555 applicants herein to apply for the Judicial Review orders sought in their chamber summons dated 16/11/2025. The substantive Notice of Motion to be filed and served upon all the Respondents and Interested Parties within 21 days of today. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 18
page 18 of 19
6. The substantive motion shall be filed in a fresh Judicial Review file. The applicant is not expected to reproduce the statutory statement and verifying affidavit or annextures. Order 53 Rules 3 and 4 contemplate a Notice of Motion and the applicant once granted leave, will file and serve upon the adverse parties the Notice of Motion and all documents filed in support of the chamber summons for leave, which the Court will also rely on in the substantive motion. 7. Costs if any shall be in the substantive motion. 8. This file is closed. DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 24TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2025 R.E. ABURILI JUDGE https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2025/17613/eng@2025-11-24 19
page 19 of 19