In re Estate of Gikonyo Thumbi (Deceased) (Succession Cause 1234 of 2018) [2024] KEHC 13007 (KLR) (Civ) (18 October 2024) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2024] KEHC 13007 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE HIGH COURT AT NAIROBI (MILIMANI LAW COURTS) CIVIL SUCCESSION CAUSE 1234 OF 2018 PM NYAUNDI, J OCTOBER 18, 2024 RULING 1. Vide Summons for confirmation dated 11th December 2024, the 1st Administrator Rosemary Wambui Nyagenye seeks the following orders 1. Spent 2. That the grant of letters of Administration made to Rosemary Wambui Nyangenye & Mercy Wangari Kariuki on the 8th December 2023 be confirmed. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/13007/eng@2024-10-18 1
page 1 of 4
DESCRIPTION PROPERTIES OF NAMES SHARES OF HEIRS Lr No. 474 Makongeni Settlement Scheme Mercy Wangari Kariuki Absolutely Lr No. 919 Makongeni Settlement Scheme Mercy Wangari Kariuki (Holding in trust for Wiclifi(sic) Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga Plot No. Ndemi/ 3413 Nyandarau Mercy Wangari Kariuki Absolutely PLot No. Kayole Riverside Mercy Wangari Kariuki (holding In Trust For Wiclifi (sic) Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga Kantafu Plot No. 1488 Rosemary Wambui Nyegenye ( Life interest) (Holding in Trust for Wiclifi (sic) Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga That costs of this application be in the cause. Paragraph 4. The Application is supported by her affidavit sworn on even date in which she proposes that the properties be distributed as per schedule below2. The 2nd Administrator has filed affidavit of protest and proposes that the Estate of the deceased be distributed as hereunder DESCRIPTION PROPERTIES OF NAMES SHARES OF HEIRS Lr No. 496 Makongeni Settlement Scheme Mercy Wangari Kariuki Absolutely Lr No. 919 Makongeni Settlement Scheme Mercy Wangari Kariuki (Holding in trust for Wiclifi(sic) Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga Plot No. Nyandarau Ndemi/ 3413 Mercy Wangari Kariuki Absolutely Kantafu Plot No. 1488 Rosemary Wambui Nyegenye ( Life interest) ( Holding in Trust for Wiclifi (sic) Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/13007/eng@2024-10-18 2
page 2 of 4
3. The protestor contends that Property known as Kayole Riverside South Plot No. K4 does not comprise part of the estate of the deceased as the property was previously registered in their joint names and upon his death it was vested in her solely by operation of law. 4. Both parties filed their respective submissions in which they recited the averments in their respective affidavits. 5. The relevant provisions are Sections 34 to 42 of the Law of Succession Act. The first issue for determination is who the beneficiaries of the estate. It is not in dispute that it is both the Administrators and the two children of the 2nd Administrator, one of whom is a minor. 6. The next issue is what are the assets of the estate of the deceased. The 2nd Administrator submits that Kayole Riverside South Plot No. K4 does not comprise the estate of the deceased as the same was registered in their joint names and devolved to her by operation of law upon the death of the deceased. This is not challenged by the 1st Administrator. Accordingly, I find that the asset is not part of the estate of the deceased. 7. The 2nd Administrator submits that Kantafu Plot No. 1488 comprises part of the estate and has submitted a letter confirming the same. The 1st Administrator has not controverted this. 8. The two proposals are somewhat aligned to the extent that provision is made for each of the identified beneficiaries. This has eased the work of the Court. In an estate such as this the Court is concerned to ensure that the surviving widows are not at risk of being rendered destitute and the estate is preserved for the benefit of the Children. With this in mind I make the following order as regards the distribution of the estate. DESCRIPTION PROPERTIES OF NAMES SHARES OF HEIRS Lr No. 496 Makongeni Settlement Scheme Mercy Wangari Kariuki And Wyclifi Thumbi Hold in Trust for Wyclifi Thumbi and Lucy Wachinga in equal shares Lr No. 919 Makongeni Settlement Scheme Mercy Wangari Kariuki And Wyclifi Thumbi (Holding in trust for Wyclifi Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga In Equal Shares Plot No. Nyandarau Ndemi/ 3413 Mercy Wangari Kariuki And Rosemary Wambui Nyegenye ( Life Interest) (Holding in trust for Wyclifi Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga To Hold Jointly Kantafu Plot No. 1488 Rosemary Wambui Nyegenye And Mercy Wangari Kariuki ( Life interest) (Holding in Trust for Wyclifi Thumbi & Lucy Wachinga in equal shares 9. The grant issued on 8th December 2023 is confirmed, the mode of Distribution shall be as per schedule in paragraph 8 above. The Administrators shall finalize transmission of the estate within 60 days. Mention on 27th November 2024 to confirm compliance. 10. This being a family matter there shall be no order as to costs. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/13007/eng@2024-10-18 3
page 3 of 4
It is so ordered SIGNED DATED AND DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT THIS 18TH OF OCTOBER, 2024. P. NYAUNDI JUDGE In presence of: Fardosa Court Assistant https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/13007/eng@2024-10-18 4
page 4 of 4