REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS DIVISION PETITION NUMBER E425 OF 2020 AS CONSOLIDATED WITH PETITION NO. E014 OF 2021 BETWEEN HON. MIKE SONKO MBUVI GEDION KIOKO................................................ 1 ST PETITIONER OKIYA OMTATAH OKOITI.................................................................................. 2 ND PETITIONER VERSUS THE CLERK, NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ASSEMBLY......................................1 ST RESPONDENT THE SPEAKER, NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ASSEMBLY................................ 2 ND RESPONDENT THE NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ASSEMBLY......................................................3 RD RESPONDENT THE CLERK OF THE SENATE............................................................................4 TH RESPONDENT THE SPEAKER OF THE SENATE OF KENYA..................................................5 TH RESPODNENT THE SENATE OF KENYA......................................................................................6 TH RESPONDENT HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL...............................................................................7 TH RESPONDENT THE INDEPENDENT ELECTORAL AND BOUNDARIES COMMISSION....8TH RESPONDENT THE ASSUMPTION OF THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY, GOVERNOR, COMMITTEE, NAIROBI CITY COUNTY........................................................................................ 9 TH RESPONDENT THE AG. GOVERNOR, NAIROBI CITY COUNTY.............................................10 TH RESPONDENT RULING On 18th March, 2021, this court gave very clear directions and timelines regarding the filing of pleadings and submissions by the parties herein. According to the said directions, the Respondents were granted 14 days to file their respective responses on or before 2 nd April, 2021. The Petitioners were granted 7 days to file and serve written submission and any supplementary affidavits and that was to be done on or before 10th April, 2021. The Respondents were to file and serve their submissions on or before 19 th April, 2021, the court listed the case for hearing today, 4th may, 2021, for the highlighting of submission.
page 1 of 2
We are, however, appalled and perplexed that today, being the hearing date, the parties have indicated that the submissions have either not been filed or were filed too late in the day thus precipitating requests for adjournment by the respondents to enable them file their submissions. We have gone through the record and noted that the amended petition was filed on 21 st December, 2020 clearly therefore, the contention by the Respondents that they were served with the amended petition last month cannot be correct. Even assuming that the Petitioners had on 18 th March, 2021 indicated that they had already filed and served their submissions, they had a duty to inform the Respondents, at least as at 10 th April, 2021 that they did not intend to file any additional submissions or affidavits. The failure by the Petitioners to communicate their position to the Respondents created the confusion that the parties now find themselves in. Moreover, as regards the 2 nd Petitioner, it is apparent that he filed his submissions on 25 th April, 2021 which was clearly outside the timelines set by the court. For the above reasons, we find that it will only be just and fair to grant the Respondent’s an adjournment to enable them file their submissions. Consequently, we allow the Respondents application for adjournment and direct that 1 st Petitioner to serve Mr. Kokebe for the 2 nd Respondent, with their submissions before close of business today. The Respondents to file their submission on or before 12 th May, 2021. The Petitioners will have 3 days to make their rejoinder, if need be, which rejoinder shall be filed and served before 11 a.m. on 17 th May, 2021. Hearing on 18th May, 2021 at 10 a.m. Turning to the issue of contempt of court orders that was raised by Dr. Khaminwa, we find that there is no substantive application before this court to that effect. Moreover, Mr. Nyamu, the lead counsel for the 1 st Petitioner indicated that the Petitioner would wish to proceed with the main petition. We, therefore, need not say more about the issue of contempt. S J CHITEMBWE JUDGE 4/5/2021 W KORIR W OKWANY JUDGE JUDGE 4/5/2021 4/5/2021 Mr. Kinyanjui: We pray for a copy of the order. This enable us serve each party. Mr. Kokebe: We do appreciate the timelines given by the court. Mr. Nyamudi: there are to issues I wish to raise. The Petitioner to serve original and further submissions on all matters. Secondly, on 18 th, I will be holding the impeachment of Wajir Governor before the Senate. Mr. Nyamu: There is no notice from the Senate shown. S J CHITEMBWE JUDGE 4/5/2021 Court: By further orders, the Petitioner to serve all the Respondents with hard copies of the original submissions and any further submissions by 4.30 p.m. today. Mr. Nyamu to serve list of authorities today and the hard copies of authorities by Thursday, 6 th and 7th Midday. The Petitioners and Respondents to provide the court with three sets of hard copies of their respective submissions and the same to be with the registry by 17th May, 2021. S J CHITEMBWE JUDGE 4/5/2021
page 2 of 2