Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Caselaw
Original judgment

Emily Wanja Murugu v Andrew Kimathi Murugu

Read the case summaryDownload PDF

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA SUCCESSION CAUSE NO. 273 OF 2013 In the Matter of the Estate of Solomon KunganiaMurugu (deceased) EMILY WANJA MURUGU.........................PETITIONER VERSUS ANDREW KIMATHI MURUGU.................PROTESTOR JUDGMENT Protest and confirmation of grant [1] Before me is a Summons for Confirmation of Grant dated 9 th February, 2018 brought under section 71 of the Law of Succession Act. The summons seeks confirmation of grant issued herein. [2] The application is premised upon grounds set out in the summons, and the affidavit of Fredah Eddy Kananu, holder of power of attorney from the Petitioner. According to the summons, the dependants of the deceased are:a. Emily Wanja Murugu b. Kathleen Nkatha Murugu c. Fredah Kinanu Murugu d. Andrew Kimathi Murugu e. Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu f. Juliette Makandi Murugu g. Jane Ann Kagwiria Murugu h. June Carolyn Gacheri Murugu i. Yvonne Kathambi Murugu j. Filbert Kendi k. Wilson Mugambi [3] The estate comprises of:a. NAIROBI BLOCK 32/528- 0.06 Ha b. LR. NO NTIMA/IGOKI/391- 2.40 Ha c. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1751- 0.07 Ha

page 1 of 7

d. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1756- 0.07 Ha e. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1758- 0.07 Ha f. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1759- 0.07 Ha g. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1760- 0.07 Ha h. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1761- 0.07 Ha i. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1762- 0.07 Ha j. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1763- 0.28 Ha k. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1764- 1.16 Ha l. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1765- 0.52 Ha m. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1766- 1.23 Ha n. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1768- 1.53 Ha o. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3123- 0.82 Ha p. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3124- 0.93 Ha q. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3313- 0.04 Ha r. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/408- 8.08 Ha s. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/716 t. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/717 u. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/944- 2.5 Ha [4] The Petitioner proposes the estate to be distributed as follows:a. NAIROBI BLOCK 32/528- 0.06 Hato go to Emily Wanja Murugu b. LR. NO NTIMA/IGOKI/391- 2.40 Hato go to Emily Wanja Murugu c. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1751- 0.07 Ha to go to Mercy Kathira to hold in trust for Filbert Kendi and Wilson Mugambi d. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1756- 0.07 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu e. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1758- 0.07 Ha to go to Katheleen Nkatha Murugu f. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1759- 0.07 Ha to go to Yvonne Kathambi Murugu g. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1760- 0.07 Ha to go to June Corolyne Gacheri Murugu h. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1761- 0.07 Ha to go to Jane Ann KagwiriaMurugu i. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1762- 0.07 Ha to go to Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu j. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1763- 0.28 Ha to go to Katheleen Nkatha Murugu k. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1764- 1.16 Ha – to go to Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu l. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1765- 0.52 Ha to go to Fredah Kananu Murugu m. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1766- 1.90 Ha to go to Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu – 1.23 HA and Katheleen Nkatha Murugu – 0.67 Ha

page 2 of 7

n. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1768- 1.53 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu o. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3123- 0.82 Ha to go to Juliette Makandi Murugu p. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3124- 0.93 Ha to go to Fredah Kinanu Murugu q. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3313- 0.04 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu r. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/408- 8.08 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu s. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/716–5.0 Ha to go to (a) June Carolyne Gacheri Murugu – 2.39 ha. (b) Yvonne Kathambi Murugu – 2.39 Ha (c) Kathleen Nkatha Murugu - 0.22 Ha t. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/717 – 6.23 Ha (a) Fredah Kinanu Murugu 1.01 Ha (b) Juliette Makandi Murugu – 1.64 Ha (c) Jane Ann Kagwiria Murugu – 2.39 Ha (d) Kathleen Nkatha Murugu - 1.19 Ha u. LR Kiirua/Naari/944 - 2.5 Ha – to be held by Mercy Kithira in trust for Filbert Kendi Murugu and Wilson Mugambi Murugu. v. Motor Vehicle Registration No. KAA 627Z to go to Emily Wanja Murugu. w. Shares with cooperative Bank, Safari com and KCB to go to Emily Wanja Murugu. x. Bank Account in Standard Chartered Bank to go to Emily Wanja Murugu [5] The Protestor in her affidavit of protest proposed the estate of the deceased to be distributed as follows:(a) L.R Kiirua/Naari/408 I. Andrew KimathiMurugu - shall get portion with his home only and an access road. II. Emily WanjaMurugu III. Kathleen NkathaMurugu IV. FredahKinanu Murugu Share V. Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu the VI. Julietta Makandi Murugu VII. Jane Ann Kagwiria Murugu balance Equally VIII. June Carolyne Gacheri Murugu IX. Yvonne Kathambi Murugu (b) KIIRUA/Naari/716 Kiirua/Naari /717 Kiirua/Naari 1763

page 3 of 7

Kiirua/Naari/1764 Kiirua/Naari 1765 Kiirua/Naari/1766 Kiirua/Naari/3123 Kiirua/Nari/3124 Kiirua/Naari/1762 Kiirua/Naari 1768 – all to Andrew Kimathi Murugu. (c) Kiirua/Naari/1751 Kiirua /Naari/1758 Kiiru /Naari/1759 Kiirua/ Naari/ 1760 Kiirua/Naari/1761 – Shall be shared among all the daughters. (d) Kiirua/Naari/944 – Mercy Kithira to hold in trust for her children namely Filbert Kendi Murugu (daughter and Wilson Mugambi Murugu (son). (e) Nairobi Block 32/528 - To sell and proceeds shared among i. Cathleen Nkatha Murugu ii. Andrew Kimathi Murugu iii. Fredah Kinanu Murugu, iv. Edith Kaimuri Murugu v. Juliet Makandi Murugu, vi. Jane Ann Kagwiria Murugu vii. June Caroline Gacheri Murugu viii. Yvonne Kathambi Murugu (f) NTIMA/IGOKI/391 – 240 Ha i. Andrew Kimathi Murugu to be owned ii. EmilyWanjaMurugu jointly (g) Motor Vehicles i. Registration KAA627Z- Mitsubishi Pajero - Emily WanjaMurugu ii. Registration KAJ 881f Toyota Hilux - Andrew KimathiMurugu. (h) Shares i. Co-operative Bank ii. KCB Shares Andrew KimathiMurugu

page 4 of 7

iii. Safaricom shares and Emily WanjaMurugu I. Standard Chartered Bank Account- Andrew Kimathi Murugu and Emily Wanja Murugu ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION Mercy’s children provided for [6] Mercy Kithira had applied through application dated 7 th December 2015 for provision in the estate of her two children, FILBER KENDI MURUGU and WILSON MUGAMBI MURUGU. It seems agreed to make the provision for the two children in numb4er 944. She stated that she and her children reside in No 944. Accordingly, I find the provision to be adequate. Therefore, I direct that (a) Kiirua/Naari/944 – Shall be registered to Mercy Kithira to hold in trust for her children namely Filbert Kendi Murugu (daughter and Wilson Mugambi Murugu (son). Gift inter vivos [7] Another matter which I should determine in limine; alleged gift inter vivos to Andrew Kimathi. Fredah Kananu stated in her affidavit that the deceased bequeathed to Andrew the following properties: a. LR. NO. KIIRUA/NKANDO/506 approx. 30 acre b. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1754 approx. 0.07 Ha c. LR. NO.KIIRUA/NAARI/1769 approx. 1 acre [8] The facts as presented were not denied by Andrew. Of pointed relevance also, these lands appears in the same catalogue as the estate property; and Andrew stated that he came back to help his father in the administration of his properties. These facts suggest that the properties above were gifts inter vivos. Such bequests are taken into account when determining the ultimate entitlement of the donee beneficiary under section 42 0f the Law of Succession Act which provides as follows:42. Previous benefits to be brought into account Where (a) an intestate has, during his lifetime or by will, paid, given or settled any property to or for the benefit of a child, grandchild or house; or (b) property has been appointed or awarded to any child or grandchild under the provisions of section 26 or section 35, that property shall be taken into account in determining the share of the net intestate estate finally accruing to the child, grandchild or house [9] I will therefore take that fact into consideration as provided for under section 28 of the Law of Succession Act when making final orders on distribution. Pend that for a while. [10] I have looked at the proposal by Andrew; it is just too selfish for he has allocated to himself substantial portion of the estate. From the tone set in the affidavit by Andrew it seems he has been influenced by three things: (1) the odour of patriarchy- he is a son and the other beneficiaries are daughters; (2) unfounded fears that the daughters intend to sell the shares they are asking for; and (3) contempt of the surviving widow, who has right over the property of her marriage as well as in the estate of her late spouse. The law is clear now that all children of the deceased are entitled to equal sharing of the estate unless otherwise provided for in a will or permitted in law. Again, once you receive a share of the estate it becomes yours absolutely unless there is a trust thereto, and you may in respect thereto, do what an owner can lawfully do with the property. The widow is also entitled to a distinct share. And, Fredah has provided for the widow. For those reasons, I reject the proposal by Andrew. The proposal by Fredah seems fair as it takes into account the bequests except it requires some few adjustments which I shall spell out specifically. I note that Andrew has over 33 acres already of land through gift inter vivos. I have said before that Section 42 of the Law of Succession Act acts as a stabilizer of equity in distribution of the estate. Therefore, after taking into account what Andrew already has, the estate of the deceased shall be shared as follows:a. NAIROBI BLOCK 32/528- 0.06 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu b. LR. NO NTIMA/IGOKI/391- 2.40 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu c. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1751- 0.07 Ha to go to Mercy Kathira to hold in trust for Filbert Kendi and Wilson Mugambi d. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1756- 0.07 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu e. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1758- 0.07 Ha to go to Katheleen Nkatha Murugu

page 5 of 7

f. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1759- 0.07 Ha to go to Yvonne Kathambi Murugu g. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1760- 0.07 Ha to go to June Corolyne Gacheri Murugu h. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1761- 0.07 Ha to go to Jane Ann Kagwiria Murugu i. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1762- 0.07 Ha to go to Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu j. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1763- 0.28 Ha to go to Katheleen Nkatha Murugu k. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1764- 1.16 Ha – to go to Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu l. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1765- 0.52 Ha to go to Fredah Kananu Murugu m. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1766- 1.90 Ha to go to Fredah Eddy Kananu Murugu – 1.23 HA and Katheleen Nkatha Murugu – 0.67 Ha n. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/1768- 1.53 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu o. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3123- 0.82 Ha to go to Juliette Makandi Murugu p. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3124- 0.93 Ha to go to Fredah Kinanu Murugu q. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/3313- 0.04 Ha to go to Emily Wanja Murugu r. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/408- 8.08 Ha to remain as family homestead to be registered to Emily Wanja Murugu to hold it on her own behalf and that of all the children of the deceased. Andrew’s house shall remain on the land as is. s. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/716–5.0 Ha to go to (a) June Carolyne Gacheri Murugu – 2.39 ha. (b) Yvonne Kathambi Murugu – 2.39 Ha (c) Kathleen Nkatha Murugu - 0.22 Ha t. LR. NO KIIRUA/NAARI/717 – 6.23 Ha (a) Fredah Kinanu Murugu 1.01 Ha (b) Juliette Makandi Murugu – 1.64 Ha (c) Jane Ann Kagwiria Murugu – 2.39 Ha (d) Kathleen Nkatha Murugu - 1.19 Ha u. LR Kiirua/Naari/944 - 2.5 Ha – to be held by Mercy Kithira in trust for Filbert Kendi Murugu and Wilson Mugambi Murugu. v. Motor Vehicle Registration No. KAA 627Z to go to Emily Wanja Murugu. w. Motor Vehicle Registration No. KAJ 881F to go to Andrew Kimathi Murugu x. Shares with cooperative Bank, Safari com and KCB to go to Emily Wanja Murugu. y. Bank Account in Standard Chartered Bank to go to Emily Wanja Murugu [11] The grant herein is now confirmed upon the foregoing terms. Dated, signed and delivered in open court at Meru this 3rd day of December 2018 F. GIKONYO

page 6 of 7

JUDGE In presence of Kithinji for protestor Gikunda Anampiu for petitioner – absent F. GIKONYO JUDGE

page 7 of 7

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.