Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Mudonyi & 68 others v Toner Holdings Limited (Cause 1153 of 2016) [2022] KEELRC 1658 (KLR)

Mudonyi & 68 others v Toner Holdings Limited (Cause 1153 of 2016) [2022] KEELRC 1658 (KLR) (26 May 2022) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2022] KEELRC 1658 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI CAUSE 1153 OF 2016 L NDOLO, J MAY 26, 2022 BETWEEN EZEKIEL MUGERA MUDONYI ....................................................... 1ST CLAIMANT GEOFFREY AMOI .............................................................................. 2ND CLAIMANT REUBEN MWANIKI .......................................................................... 3RD CLAIMANT DOUGLAS CHUMA ........................................................................... 4TH CLAIMANT CLEMENT SHIKOLI .......................................................................... 5TH CLAIMANT OLIVER AFANDA .............................................................................. 6TH CLAIMANT PETER RURAYA ................................................................................ 7TH CLAIMANT NZENGE MUTHUI ............................................................................ 8TH CLAIMANT SHADRACK SHIKOLI ....................................................................... 9TH CLAIMANT JOHN MULONZA ............................................................................ 10TH CLAIMANT CHARLES MALALA ........................................................................ 11TH CLAIMANT ZABLON MUKOSELO ..................................................................... 12TH CLAIMANT DANIEL OWICH .............................................................................. 13TH CLAIMANT PATRICK KARERE ......................................................................... 14TH CLAIMANT KATHULI MUTEMI ........................................................................ 15TH CLAIMANT PETER MUTEMI .............................................................................. 16TH CLAIMANT DUNSTONE LIKABO ...................................................................... 17TH CLAIMANT PETER KIMWELE ............................................................................ 18TH CLAIMANT JOSHUA MUEMA ............................................................................. 19TH CLAIMANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1658/eng@2022-05-26 1

page 1 of 6

JUSTUS MUSEE ................................................................................ 20TH CLAIMANT NICHOLAS MUSEMBI ..................................................................... 21ST CLAIMANT KAMAU MUCHIRI ......................................................................... 22ND CLAIMANT SIMON MUTURI ............................................................................. 23RD CLAIMANT JARED JUMA .................................................................................... 24TH CLAIMANT JOHN MUTINDA ............................................................................. 25TH CLAIMANT ANTHONY MULANDI ................................................................... 26TH CLAIMANT JARED MOSE .................................................................................... 27TH CLAIMANT SAMUEL OKOYO ............................................................................. 28TH CLAIMANT EVANSON GITHOGE ...................................................................... 29TH CLAIMANT DUNCAN KIMAILI ......................................................................... 30TH CLAIMANT DOUGLAS LUNYASI ........................................................................ 31ST CLAIMANT RICHARD OWIRE .......................................................................... 32ND CLAIMANT ESAU MADEGWA ............................................................................. 33RD CLAIMANT OTIENO SAMUEL ............................................................................ 34TH CLAIMANT PATRICK ASENGI ........................................................................... 35TH CLAIMANT EVANS OTENI .................................................................................. 36TH CLAIMANT GODFREY MULAMA ...................................................................... 37TH CLAIMANT JOSIAH MWATII .............................................................................. 38TH CLAIMANT SHADRACK MUSILI ....................................................................... 39TH CLAIMANT NELSON ONCHIRI ......................................................................... 40TH CLAIMANT EDISON ONYAMBU ......................................................................... 41ST CLAIMANT AGGREY IROE ................................................................................. 42ND CLAIMANT MUENDO KIILU .............................................................................. 43RD CLAIMANT ABEDNEGO KYALO ........................................................................ 44TH CLAIMANT JONATHAN MUTUA ...................................................................... 45TH CLAIMANT VINCENT KADEMI ......................................................................... 46TH CLAIMANT CHARLES KORIR ............................................................................ 47TH CLAIMANT DANIEL MWANGANGI .................................................................. 48TH CLAIMANT DAVID MAINA ................................................................................. 49TH CLAIMANT ERASTUS KIOKO ............................................................................ 50TH CLAIMANT GEOFFREY WERE ............................................................................ 51ST CLAIMANT https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1658/eng@2022-05-26 2

page 2 of 6

SIMON MACHARIA ....................................................................... 52ND CLAIMANT SAMUEL INGANGA ........................................................................ 53RD CLAIMANT KELVIN MUITA ............................................................................... 54TH CLAIMANT DOUGLAS BABU .............................................................................. 55TH CLAIMANT HUDSON SHIZIBA .......................................................................... 56TH CLAIMANT CHARLES ODANGA ....................................................................... 57TH CLAIMANT JACKSON NZOMO .......................................................................... 58TH CLAIMANT EVANS NYAMBANE ........................................................................ 59TH CLAIMANT STEVEN WAWERU .......................................................................... 60TH CLAIMANT DAVID KIMANI ................................................................................ 61ST CLAIMANT DENIS NYABERA ............................................................................ 62ND CLAIMANT RICHARD GITHAIGA .................................................................... 63RD CLAIMANT JOSEPH OGOLLA ............................................................................. 64TH CLAIMANT STEPHEN WAMBUA ....................................................................... 65TH CLAIMANT JOHN MAINA MWANGI ................................................................ 66TH CLAIMANT ALLAN KISALA ............................................................................... 67TH CLAIMANT DENIS MAKAU ................................................................................ 68TH CLAIMANT SAMUEL MOMANYI ....................................................................... 69TH CLAIMANT AND TONER HOLDINGS LIMITED ......................................................... RESPONDENT JUDGMENT 1. By their memorandum of claim as amended on September 23, 2021, the claimants sued the respondent for unlawful termination of employment. The respondent’s defence to the claimants’ claim is by way of a statement of response dated July 22, 2016 and filed in court on July 25, 2016. 2. The respondent did not attend the trial, in spite of due service. The matter therefore proceeded ex parte, with the 1st claimant, Ezekiel Mugera Mudonyi testifying on his own behalf and on behalf of his co-claimants. The claimants also filed written submissions. In reaching its decision, the court has taken into account the respondent’s statement of response on record. The Claimants’ Case 3. The claimants state that they were employed by the respondent as unskilled labourers, on various dates between 2010 and 2013. 4. They claim that on August 26, 2015, they went to collect their salaries but noticed that an amount Kshs 1,000 had been deducted from each of them. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1658/eng@2022-05-26 3

page 3 of 6

5. The claimants add that on August 27, 2015, they found a notice at the respondent’s premises indicating that all workers’ wages had been deducted to cater for National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) and National Social Security Fund (NSSF) contributions. The claimants state that they had no accounts with the two statutory bodies. 6. The claimants went to complain to the site manager, Ramesh Halai who informed them that the company had made a decision to efiect the deductions and anyone who was dissatisfied was free to leave the respondent’s employment. 7. The claimants aver that they were dissatisfied with Halai’s explanation, and therefore went back for another meeting on August 28, 2015. They claim that Halai refused to negotiate with them and instead called the police to lock them out of the premises. 8. The claimants further aver that on August 29, 2015, they went to work only to find the premises locked by security guards. 9. The claimants state that on August 31, 2015, three (3) notices signed by the site manager, were placed on the site gate, stating that all workers who did not agree with the deductions would be summarily dismissed. 10. The claimants reported the matter to the labour ofice on September 2, 2015 and a labour oficer by the name Robert Ngugi wrote to the respondent asking for computation of the claimants’ dues. 11. The labour oficer convened a meeting between the respondent’s site manager & project manager and five (5) representatives of the claimants. 12. On September 10, 2015, the claimants were paid for leave days for the term served only. 13. The claimants now seek compensation for unlawful and unfair termination of employment as well as terminal dues being notice pay, leave pay and severance pay. The Respondent’s Case 14. In its statement of response dated July 22, 2016 and filed in court on July 25, 2016, the respondent states that the claimants’ employment was lawfully terminated. 15. The respondent adds that the claimants were paid all their terminal dues. 16. the respondent therefore denies the claimants’ entire claim. Findings and Determination 17. There are two (2) issues for determination in this case: a. Whether the termination of the claimants’ employment was lawful and fair; b. Whether the claimants are entitled to the remedies sought. The Termination 18. From the parties’ pleadings, the fact that the claimants’ employment was terminated is not a contested issue. What is in dispute is the legality of the termination. On their part, the claimants claim that they were locked out of the work place after registering their grievance regarding deduction of their salaries on account of NHIF and NSSF. 19. Section 45 of the Employment Act provides as follows: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1658/eng@2022-05-26 4

page 4 of 6

45. (1) No (2) employer shall a. terminate b. the employment of an employee unfairly. 20. A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to provethat the reason for the termination is valid; that the reason for the termination is a fair reason i. related to the employee’s conduct, capacity or compatibility; or ii. based on the operational requirements of the employer; and iii. that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure. In the final submissions filed on behalf of the claimants, reference was made to the decision in Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] eKLR where this court stated the following: “ For a termination of employment to pass the fairness test, there must be both substantive justification and procedural fairness. Substantive justification has to do with establishment of a valid reason for the termination while procedural fairness addresses the procedure adopted by the employer in efiecting the termination.” 21. The respondent did not bother to explain to the court the circumstances under which the claimants’ employment was terminated. Indeed, all the respondent states in its statement of response, is that the claimants’ employment was lawfully terminated. 22. I therefore find and hold that the respondent has failed to establish a valid reason for terminating the claimants’ employment as required under section 43 of the Employment Act. Further, there was no evidence that the respondent complied with the procedural fairness dictates set by section 41 of the Act. 23. For the foregoing reason, the inescapable conclusion is that the termination of the claimants’ employment was substantively and procedurally unfair and the claimants are entitled to compensation. Remedies 24. In light of these findings, I award each claimant three (3) months’ salary in compensation. In arriving at this award, I have taken into account, the claimants’ length of service as well as the respondent’s unlawful conduct in executing the termination. 25. I further award each claimant one (1) month’s salary in lieu of notice. 26. No basis was laid for the claim for severance pay which therefore fails and is dismissed. 27. The 1st claimant, Ezekiel Mugera Mudonyi testified that the claimants were paid for days worked and leave days. These claims are therefore also without basis and are disallowed. 28. In the end, I enter judgment in favour of each claimant in the equivalent of three (3) months’ pay plus one (1) month’s pay in lieu of notice, both based on the applicable pay at the time of termination. The Nairobi County Labour Oficer is directed to tabulate the specific sums payable to each claimant and file a report in this court within the next sixty (60) days from the date of this judgment. 29. I award the costs of this case to the claimants. 30. Orders accordingly. DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 26TH DAY OF MAY 2022 https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1658/eng@2022-05-26 5

page 5 of 6

LINNET NDOLO JUDGE Appearance: Mr. Onyango h/b for Miss Ng’etich for the claimants No appearance for the Respondent https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1658/eng@2022-05-26 6

page 6 of 6

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.