Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Kenya Medical Practitioners, Pharmacists & Dentists Union & 61 others v County Government of Laikipia & another; Public Service Commission (Interested Party) [2020] KEELRC 1887 (KLR)

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT OF KENYA AT NYERI JUDICIAL REVIEW MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. 9 OF 2019 IN THE MATTER OF: AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO COMMENCE JUDICIAL REVIEW PROCEEDINGS AND IN THE MATTER OF: AN APPLICATION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW FOR ORDERS OF CERTIORARI, PROHIBITION AND MANDAMUS AND IN THE MATTER OF: SECTION D.20, D.28 & D.29 OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF KENYA; COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE HUMAN RESOURCE MANUAL AND IN THE MATTER OF: ARTICLE 41 & 47 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010, THE FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS ACT, 2015 AND IN THE MATTER OF: SECTION 74 OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION ACT, 2017 AND IN THE MATTER OF: SECTION 3(5) OF THE INTERPRETATION AND GENERAL PROVISIONS ACT AND SECTION 3(1) (A)(I) OF THE KENYA INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATIONS (POSTAL AND COURIER SERVICES) REGULATIONS, 2010 BETWEEN 1. KENYA MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS, PHARMACISTS & DENTISTS UNION 2. DR. AYUB GITAKA 3. DR. BONIFACE MIRINGU 4. DR. FRANK BUYA 5. DR. MARGARET MUKUHI 6. DR. SAMUEL WANJOHI 7. DR. SETH JOMO 8. DR. SOLOMON KIRUGO 9. DR. SOLOMON TYAA

page 1 of 4

10. DR. ABDISALAM MUTAJ 11. DR. ALEX GITAU 12. DR. ALICE WANGARI GITAU 13. DR. ANDREW MUTUA 14. DR. ANTHONY MUTURI 15. DR. ANTHONY NDEI 16. DR. APPOLO KINGA 17. DR. BERNARD ODHIAMBO 18. DR. BETTE ADHIAMBO 19. DR. BRIAN IMBOVA 20. DR. CAESAR MAKARA KANYANGO 21. DR. CATHERINE NYAMBURA 22. DR. CHARLES COLLINS 23. DR. CYNTHIA RUWA 24. DR. CYRUS NG'ANG'A NJOROGE 25. DR. DENNIS NG'ANG'A 26. DR. DIANA MARION 27. DR. EDWIN MAINA MWANGI 28. DR. EDWIN ONDICHO 29. DR. ELIZABETH MUTHONI 30. DR. ELIZABETH WAMBUI 31. DR. EMILY MUTHONI 32. DR. ERIC GACHATHI 33. DR. ESBON WAMBUGU 34. DR. ESTHER WAIRIMU 35. DR. EUNICE NYAMBURA 36. DR. JAMES WAGURA 37. DR. JOHN OMENDO 38. DR. JORAM MWANGI MUCHIRI 39. DR. JOSEPH ASERE 40. DR. JOSEPH SIMEL 41. DR. JOSEPH TABALYA MUSAMIA

page 2 of 4

42. DR. JULIA THEURI 43. DR. JUSTUS WAMBUGU 44. DR. KENNETH KINGORI 45. DR. KILONZO SAMM 46. DR. LYDIA KAVOCHI ILADIVA 47. DR. MARTIN WANJOHI 48. DR. MARY KHASIALA MUHALIA 49. DR. MARYANNE NJERI 50. DR. MERCY KINYA 51. DR. NANCY NKATHA 52. DR. OSANO NYANGA 53. DR. PATIENCE NANDWA 54. DR. PATRICK NJUGUNA 55. DR. PAUL GASCOIGNE 56. DR. SHEILA WANJIRA 57. DR. STEPHEN CHARAGU 58. DR. TOBI WAMAI 59. DR. TONY JUMA 60. DR. VINCENT GILBERT 61. DR. VINCENT WAMBUGU 62. DR. WINNIE WANJIRU.................................................EX – PARTE APPLICANTS VERSUS THE COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF LAIKIPIA.............................1 ST RESPONDENT LAIKIPIA COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARD.........................2ND RESPONDENT AND PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION..............................................INTERESTED PARTY RULING 1. The 1st Ex parte Applicant, in the main, seeks in its application dated 31 st August 2020 that the Interested Party’s ruling of 12 th August 2020 be deemed as filed and adopted as an order of the Honourable Court. Upon adoption of the Interested Party’s ruling of 12 th August 2020 as an order of this Court, summons be issued to Karanja Njora, the County Secretary of the County Government of Laikipia, Dr. Donald Mogoi, the Acting County Chief Officer Medical Services and Public Health, County Government of Laikipia and Paul Njenga Waweru, the Acting County Chief Officer, Finance, County Government of Laikipia, to show cause why he should not be committed to civil jail for blatant disobedience of the Interested Party’s ruling of 12 th August 2020 as adopted as an order of this Honourable Court. Additionally, it sought that the Respondents and the said Karanja Njora, Dr. Donald Mogoi and Paul Njenga Waweru be and are hereby denied further audience by this Honourable Court save for showing cause why they should jointly and/or severally not be committed to civil jail for such term as the Court may deem just for the blatant disobedience of the Interested Party’s ruling of 12 th August 2020 as adopted as an order of this Court. The application was premised on grounds upon its face and is supported by the affidavit of Dr. Davji Bhimji Atella.

page 3 of 4

2. The Respondents were opposed and filed a replying affidavit sworn by Karanja Njora, the County Secretary Laikipia County Government. In brief he stated that the application is a non-starter as the orders sought cannot be granted. He deponed that the consent was reached on mutual agreement by all parties that this suit was wrongfully instituted in the first place and there was need to regularize. He stated that this suit was defective, void ab initio because for the Ex parte Applicants, the Interested Party was the first port of call. He deponed that it is not possible to seek additional orders within this suit as it is flawed and fatally defective ab initio. The Respondents assert that the enforcement orders can only be through an application in a fresh suit. The Respondents additionally argued that they were not accorded a fair hearing by the Interested Party thus impairing the decision it arrived at. 3. Pursuant to the Consent Order made on 15 th October 2019, the 1st Ex Parte Applicant the Kenya Medial, Pharmacists & Dentists Practitioners Union on or about 25 th October 2019, for and on behalf of the 61 Ex Parte Applicants herein, submitted to the Interested Party for Appeal the entire decision by the Respondents of the 21 st June 2019 to summarily dismiss 34 of the 1 st Ex Parte Applicant’s members. The Public Service Commission (PSC) on 12 th August 2020 issued its final ruling to the 1 st Ex Parte Applicant’s Appeal. It directed as follows:1) The decision of the Respondents to summarily dismiss the doctors listed in the appeal dated 25 th October 2019, from the Laikipia County Service, is hereby set aside. 2) The doctors listed in the appeal dated 25 th October 2019 are hereby reinstated to the positions that they held in the Laikipia County Public Service prior to the decision of the Respondents to summarily dismiss them on 21 st June 2019. 3) The doctors listed in the appeal dated 25 th October 2019 are not entitled to any remuneration and benefits between the period 3 rd June and 20th June 2019 when they participated in a strike that was declared by court to be unlawful and unprotected. 4) The doctors listed in the appeal dated 25 th October 2019 are entitled to all their remuneration and benefits, save as otherwise stated in this decision, in the same manner as other members of the appellant who were not terminated. 5) The respondents do pay the doctors listed in the appeal dated 25 th October 2019 all and any withheld remuneration and benefits, save as ordered in this decision, up to and including the date that the Respondents shall reinstate them back to the County Public Service. 6) Upon reinstatement, the Respondents do continue to pay the doctors listed in the appeal dated 25 th October 2019 in accordance with their terms and conditions of service. 4. The attack against the ex parte Applicant’s prayer for the adoption of the decision of the Public Service Commission decision of 12 th August 2020 is this – the proceedings here are impugned on the basis that the procedure invoked was unlawful since the ex parte Applicant had moved the Court before first exhausting the remedy under the law which was what it did in the appeal to PSC. It is indeed true that the proceedings in this judicial review were attacked as being premature and in a swift about turn, the Ex parte Applicants sought to have the appeal against the decision of the Respondents at the Public Service Commission be heard and determined within 30 days effective 16 th October 2019. This is the decision that ultimately was issued on 12 th August 2020. 5. In my considered view, the Court not having determined that the proceedings were impaired, can the Court now adopt for action or as a court order the decision that was obtained after the ex parte Applicant sought the relief in the correct forum? I think so. The proceedings though challenged by the preliminary objection filed, a determination thereon was not made as the preliminary objection was compromised by way of a consent. The consent of the parties made no mention of the illegality of the proceedings before me or the alleged defect in the suit. It is clear the best course is to have the 1 st Ex parte Applicant to make an application seeking enforcement by way of mandamus. In the premises as the orders sought in the first substantive prayer of the motion are in the nature of mandamus, I grant the motion by the 1st Ex parte Applicant in part to the extent that the Interested Party’s ruling of 12 th August 2020 be and is hereby deemed as duly filed and adopted as an order of the Honourable Court. I accordingly direct and compel the Respondents by way of mandamus to commence implementation of the Ruling of the Public Service Commission dated 12 th August 2020 bearing in mind the provisions of Section 89 of the Public Service Commission Act. There shall be no order as to costs. It is so ordered. Dated and delivered at Nyeri this 19th day of October 2020 Nzioki wa Makau JUDGE

page 4 of 4

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.