REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI CAUSE NO. 1936 OF 2015 MARTIN WAMAE WANGU AND 294 OTHERS VERSUS BIDCO AFRICA LIMITED JUDGMENT ON QUANTUM In the judgment delivered on 13th July 2018, the court (Aboudha J.) awarded the claimants the following– “In the circumstances, the court would not make a finding on the issue of unfair termination of service. The court will in the circumstances order that each of the claimants be compensated as follows: a. One month’s salary in lieu of notice on termination of service. b. One month’s salary in lieu of leave for each complete year of service from 2009 to 2013 for those in service during this period. c. Counsel for the parties liase with their respective clients for computation of orders (a) and (b) are return to Court on 11th October 2018 for recording of final orders. d. Costs of the suit. The parties have disagreed on the computation of the award. They have each submitted their computations to court in order for the court to determine which of the two is the correct computation. The court has considered the submissions and tabulation by the parties. The following has been noted – 1. That the respondent has recovered PAYE on the lump sum from the sums due to the claimants; 2. That the respondent has used 21 days’ pay for leave instead of one month’s salary as per judgment; 3. That the respondent has recovered ex-gratia paid to the employees from the payments due to the employees contrary to the award in the judgment; 4. That the respondent has not stated the number of years worked by each employee in its tabulation or the last salary earned by each employee; 5. That the respondent has prepared two separate lists “A” and “B” of employees yet the judgment applied to all the claimants uniformly. In arriving at its tabulation, the court has considered the following – 1. Computation is based on the actual salary earned by each employee and not the statutory minimum wage. 2. Payment is based on the last gross salary. 3. No deduction for NSSF or NHIF should be made from the sums payable to the claimants as they are no longer in employment of the respondent.
page 1 of 19
4. The number of days worked is calculated at 30 days based on Section 37(2) of the Employment Act, to the effect that employees are entitled to payment for rest days where they work in excess of one month. 5. PAYE to be recovered based on the gross monthly pay and not on the lump sum. The quantum of the award of the court pursuant to Judgment of the court delivered on 13 th July 2018 is as per attached Table. The amount in the Table constitutes the final award of the judgment herein dated 13 th July 2018. NO NAME LAST GROSS SALARY (483 x 30) NO OF YEARS WORKED NOTICE PAY (ONE MONTH'S SALARY PAY IN LIEU OF LEAVE (ONE MONTH'S TOTAL SALARY X AWARD YEARS WORKED) 1 MARTIN WAMAE WANGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 2 FRANCIS AZERE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 3 RATIFU OMWANGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 4 ALBERT LUKOYE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 5 WILBERFORCE OKUKU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 6 JOSEPH ONDIEKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 7 JOSEPH MAINGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 8 ANTONY KITHANDA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 9 JAMIN OVAMBA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 10 JACKSON AMBASA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 11 JOAB NDEGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 GEOFFREY MOMANYI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 13 KENNEDY 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 12 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 2 of 19
OWINO 86,940 14 PETER MUTUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 15 DANIEL KYULI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 16 GEORGE MUTUNDA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 17 FREDRICK JUMA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 18 JAMES MBUGUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 19 DANIEL KIREKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 20 DICKSON MACHISU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 21 FRANCIS MBINDU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 22 HUMPHREY CHONELWA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 23 SHADRACK MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 24 STEPHEN NDOLO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 25 BENSON MATHEKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 26 DOUGLAS OMIMI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 27 BENSFORD KIMANI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 28 VICTOR ABUOR 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 29 COSMAS MBITHI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 30 DENNIS 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 3 of 19
MANENO 86,940 JAMES NYAKUNDI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 32 SAMUEL YAA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 33 JOHN NDUNGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 34 SYLVANUS MOGERE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 35 GABRIEL SIMASI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 36 ALFRED OBONYO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 37 PETER MBUVI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 38 GEORGE NGUGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 39 ROBERT KIVAA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 40 JULIUS MOSE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 41 JAMES WACIRA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 42 PETER MUNYAKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 43 PATRICK NDIRANGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 44 ANTONY KAMAU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 45 JAMES MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 REUBEN MACHUKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 47 JOHN WANJALA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 31 46 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 4 of 19
86,940 48 JAMES MWOSYA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 49 JUSTUS ISAIAH 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 50 DUNCAN OYARE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 51 KINYOSI NDEGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 52 SYMON NZAMBU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 53 RAHAB WANJERI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 54 JOHN GITHINJI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 55 LAWRENCE MUSAKALE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 56 PETER MWANZIA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 57 DANIEL MUTISYA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 58 NICHOLAS ORWA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 59 NAFTALI K. MASINDE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 60 PATRICK JOSECK 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 61 TIMOTHY OSALE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 62 PAUL MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 MUOKI NDAMBUKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 64 LEONARD 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 63 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 5 of 19
ABUKI 86,940 SHADRACK W MAINGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 66 MALUKI KAVUO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 67 DAUD VILU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 68 JAMES NYAWADE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 69 JAMES ONYANGO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 70 PATRICK MUTUNGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 71 JAVEL WAMBUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 72 WILLIS WATA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 73 BONFACE MUTUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 74 KENNETHY NGUGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 75 FEDILIS OUKO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 MWENDWA MUTUNGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 77 PAUL NGIGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 78 GEORGE NGANGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 79 NICHOLAS SAMBA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 80 EVAN NYACHAE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 81 BENSON 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 65 76 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 6 of 19
NJUGUNA 86,940 82 SAMUEL KIVAYA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 83 CLEOPHAS ODONGO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 84 JOYCE KIHONGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 85 ANDREW NJOROGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 86 MICHAEL MBINDU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 87 DAVID MUINDI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 88 BERNARD MATHEKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 89 SAMSOM MUKALA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 90 BENSON ODHIAMBO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 91 EDWARD MUSITSA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 92 GEOFFREY MACHOKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 93 DENNIS MOFFAT 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 94 ALEX KAMONDE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 95 JOHN MBILA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 ROGDERS MULEMA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 97 FRANCIS MBUVI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 98 IRERI KARIUKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 96 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 7 of 19
86,940 99 DOUGLAS NYABOGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 100 NELSON NYONGESA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 101 PAUL KATWEI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 FRANCIS MWENDIA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 103 PETER SAMBA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 104 JAMES NJOROGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 105 MICHAEL EGADWA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 106 DAVID NYAMAI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 107 JULIUS MOKAYA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 108 MUTINDA MUTHOKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 109 JOSEPH MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 110 STANLEY NGATIA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 111 KYALO NZUKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 112 KIZITO WITABA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 STEPHEN MASILA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 114 DANIEL KIOKO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 115 ROBERT KIREKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 102 113 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 8 of 19
86,940 116 PETER MULEI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 117 CHARLES MUGENDI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 118 BENARD MWENZE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 119 ANTONY MAINA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 120 FRANCIS KARANJA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 121 CHARLES KYALO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 122 FRANCIS KIMANI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 123 JOSEPH OGUTU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 124 JOSEPH MWANGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 125 MUTISYA NYAMAI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 126 MULI MUTINDA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 127 PETER RUTEERE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 128 JOSHUA ODINGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 129 JOSEPH NGANGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 130 JOHN KIARI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 JEREMIAH OKUMU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 132 JOHN OKOTH 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 131 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 9 of 19
86,940 133 DANIEL NAMAGWA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 134 GRACE MWENDE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 135 MARY NDUNGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 136 PATRICK MOTURI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 137 NICHOLAS AMAYUKU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 138 PETER MUNGUTI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 139 JOSHUA OMARE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 140 ROBERT MUNGAI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 141 RAPHAEL WAMBUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 142 BERNARD KILONZO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 143 KITHOME ANNAH 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 144 PETER MAKABILA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 145 FRANCIS KISINGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 146 STEPHEN KIMULI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 147 MICHAEL OWINO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 148 KAVIVU MWAKAVI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 149 JULIUS 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 10 of 19
IMBWAKA 86,940 150 GEORGE OKATCH 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 151 VINCENT MUGUSU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 152 JOSEPH MAANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 153 PETER IRUNGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 STANLEY MBURU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 155 HASSAN AUSI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 156 PETER KAMANDE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 157 BENARD MAUMO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 158 HENRY NGANGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 159 STEPHEN MUGAMBI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 160 JOHN KIMANI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 161 JAMES NGUMBI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 STEPHEN KIAMA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 163 MICHAEL OOKO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 164 JOHN WANJIKU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 TIMOTHY ORONGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 166 JAMES MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 154 162 165 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 11 of 19
86,940 167 JOHN M MUTUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 168 STEPHEN MOSOMI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 169 STANLEY KIAMA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 170 PETER WANYOIKE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 171 JULIUS OUMA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 ALIPHONCE MUTUKU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 173 JOSEPH CHEGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 172 174 MARTIN RIUNGU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 175 BONIFACE MUINDUNKO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 176 JOHN KAMAU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 177 THOMAS OMAMO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 178 AMOS MATHEKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 179 RUTH NJERI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 180 PETER MUTUKU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 181 EPHANTUS MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 182 MICHAEL MUTUKU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 183 PETER KIMEU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 12 of 19
86,940 184 PETER MIHIU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 JARED GATEMBE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 186 HEZRON NDEGE 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 187 JOSEPH GITHUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 188 STEPHEN NDERI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 EDWARD MUCHENI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 190 BENJAMIN MUIA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 191 MUSILI MUTISO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 CHARLES KARANJA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 193 ALPHAYO TIFO 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 194 BONFACE MBILA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 195 WILLIAM OKOTH 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 196 FIDELIS MULI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 197 JOHN NGANGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 198 MOSES KABIRU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 185 189 192 199 BENSON MUGUSU 200 JAMES WEKESA 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940
page 13 of 19
86,940 201 NICHOLAS WAMBUA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 202 JOSHUA MUSYOKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 203 MUSEMBI KAMULA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 204 KEVIN NYARIKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 205 JOHN O. ODEGA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 206 DOUGLAS MECHA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 207 GIBSON MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 208 SOLOMON MWANGI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 209 CHARLES NGURU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 210 FRANCIS KIILU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 211 MICHAEL NGURU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 212 PATRICK KITHUKA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 213 SAMUEL KARIUKI 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 214 GEORGE WAWERU 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 215 JOSEPH KULUMBA 14,490 5 14,490 72,450 216 PATRICK NZULU 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 217 DANVAS 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 86,940 72,450
page 14 of 19
MOMANYI 72,450 218 EDWIN MURIITHI 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 219 FRANCIS OMBURA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 220 GEOFFREY SIMIYU 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 221 WALLACE MULI 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 222 JOSEPH KIOKO 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 223 BENARD G.WANJIRU 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 224 DANIEL GACHOKA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 225 ZACHEUS NYAKWEBA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 226 KAYO INGATIA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 227 FREDRICK ODUOR 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 228 ROBINSON MAINA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 229 SIMON MUTUNGA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 230 ROBERT MOSETI 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 231 HEBERT KOMENI 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 232 DANIEL MUTUA 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 FRANCIS KILONZO 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 234 BENARD 14,490 4 14,490 57,960 233 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450 72,450
page 15 of 19
KIYONDI 72,450 235 ABINAH NDEGE 14,490 3 14,490 43,470 236 RUSSEL KIBET 14,490 3 14,490 43,470 GEORGE ANYANZWA 14,490 3 14,490 43,470 238 JOHN WAWERU 14,490 3 14,490 43,470 239 KENNEDY BARONGO 14,490 3 14,490 43,470 240 STEPHEN IRUNGU 14,490 3 14,490 43,470 241 COSMOS MOSE 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 242 RAPHAEL OCHIENG 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 243 VINCENT MOMANYI 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 244 MICHAH MAINGI 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 245 ERICK OGOT 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 MAURICE OLANG 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 247 ERICK NDEMO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 248 VINCENT KIOKO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 237 246 249 STEPHEN LUVEMBE 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 250 ERKANA GWARO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 251 BENSON KYALO 57,960 57,960 57,960 57,960 57,960 57,960 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470
page 16 of 19
43,470 252 JOHN KINUTHIA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 253 DAVID MWAKIO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 KENNEDY ODHIAMBO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 255 NDOO MWIZI 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 256 FRANCIS W. WAWERU 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 257 KENNEDY KASORO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 258 VINCENT MABIRIA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 259 WILSON WAMBUA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 260 JAMES OBIERO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 261 MUIMI KYEVA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 262 DOMINIC MATIVO 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 263 JOSEPHAT NJENGA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 264 MICHAEL THUKU 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 265 FRANCIS NJUGUNA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 266 CHARLES ODUOR 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 267 BONIFACE MUASYA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 268 FREDRICK 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 254 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470 43,470
page 17 of 19
KURIA 43,470 MESHACK MUOKI 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 270 JACTON GUMBA 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 271 JOSEPH MWANGANGI 14,490 2 14,490 28,980 272 ERICK MUGAMBI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 273 SAMUEL KARANJA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 274 NATHAN GIKUNDI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 275 JOHN MUTINDA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 BENARD WAWERU 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 277 EVANS WACIRA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 278 CASPAH KUTEYI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 279 JOHNSTONE ODANGA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 280 STEPHEN OMONDI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 281 ERICK NYARIKI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 282 POLO WASHINGTON 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 283 GEOFFREY KAMAU 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 284 STEPHEN ODEKA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 269 276 285 DANIEL 43,470 43,470 43,470 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980
page 18 of 19
MOCHAMA 28,980 286 EVANS TROON 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 OLIVER MUTSOTSO 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 288 JACK ATOLI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 289 SAMUEL MWAURA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 290 CHARLES TSUMA 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 291 CALEB ORARO 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 292 ALLAN OMONDI 14,490 1 14,490 14,490 293 PHILIP KURIA 14,490 0.08 14,490 1,208 294 NICK KUKUBO 14,490 0.08 14,490 1,208 ONESMUS MUTUKU 14,490 0.08 14,490 1,208 287 295 TOTAL AWARD The claimants are awarded costs of the suit as per the award made by the court on 13th July 2018. DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI ON THIS 7TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2019 MAUREEN ONYANGO JUDGE 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 28,980 15,698 15,698 15,698 22,419,653
page 19 of 19