REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MOMBASA CAUSE NO. 781 OF 2015 MCDONALD CHARO & 36 OTHERS …………....CLAIMANTS VERSUS BOFA MAWENI LIMITED …………………........RESPONDENT JUDGMENT INTRODUCTION 1. This is a claim for terminal benefits plus compensation for unfair termination of the claimants’ contract of employment by the respondent on 2013 and 1/11/2014. The respondent has not filed any defence despite service with summons and as such the suit proceeded exparte. Mr. Mcdonald Charo Mbogo (29th claimant) and Mwalimu Amani Ngonyo (1st claimant) testified on behalf of all the claimants as Cw1 and Cw2 respectively. Thereafter the claimants filed written submissions. CLAIMANTS’ CASE 2. CW1 was employed by the respondent as a supervisor on 5/10/2010 earning ksh.650 per day which translated to ksh.19500 per month. He was working from 6pm to 6 am during his night shift and 6 am to 6pm during his day shift. He knew all the other claimants because they were continuously working together for the respondent. He produced payment vouchers and attendance register to prove that they were indeed employed by the respondent. 3. On 11/1/2014, the respondents’ manager Mr. Raymond Gitau brought strangers to the workplace and showed them stores and replaced the padlocks. Thereafter the manager called all the staff to a meeting and told them that the strangers were the new managers of the site. He further advised the staff to go home until further notice. CW1 told the court that the claimants were never called back and when they went to check the respondent’s premises, they found the company operating under other workers. 4. CW1 contended that their termination was unfair and unlawful because they were not served with any prior notice and that they were not paid their terminal benefits. He therefore prayed for, and on behalf of all the claimants, salary in lieu of notice plus compensation for the unfair termination. He also prayed for service pay. 5. CW2 testified that he was employed as a casual worker by the respondent from 4/4/2009 earning ksh.500 per day equaling to ksh.15000 per month. The payment was however done weekly. He was working from 6am to 6pm and did so continuously until 11/1/2014 when one of the respondents’ directors
page 1 of 9
Mr. Raymond Gitau brought strangers to the site and after inspecting the facilities, they fitted new padlocks and installed their own watchman to guard. Thereafter they were introduced to the new manager Mr. Edward Wangamati who told them to go home and return after 2 weeks to enable them service the machine. 6. CW1 contended that they were never allowed back to work again since 11/1/2014 and they were never paid their terminal dues. He therefore prayed for the dues sought in the suit. ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION 7. After considering the evidence and the submissions presented to the court and which was not controverted by the respondent, it is clear that all the claimants were employed by the respondent. There is also no dispute that the claimants were terminated following the change in the management of the site where the claimants were employed. The issues for determination are: a. Whether the termination was unfair and unlawful. b. Whether the claimants are entitled to the reliefs sought. UNFAIR TERMINATION 8. Under Section 45 of the Employment Act, termination of employment by an employer is unfair if he fails to prove that it was grounded on a valid and fair reason and that it was done after following a fair procedure. In this case the claimants have contended that they were laid off following a change of management of the site where the claimants were employed and that no prior notice was served on them. 9. The respondent has not tendered any evidence to prove or justify the reason for terminating the employment contract of the claimants. She has also not attempted to prove that the termination was done after following a fair procedure. Under Section 40 of the Act, the employer is barred from terminating the employment of employee on account of redundancy without first serving a written notice of at least one month on both the employee and the labour officer and paying them their terminal dues and severance pay. 10. In this case the employees had continuously worked on casual basis for a long period and had under Section 37 of the act converted to regular terms contract employees. They had therefore qualified for the protection of the law from unfair redundancy. Considering the undisputed evidence that the claimants were laid off without following the mandatory procedure provided under Section 40 of the Act, I find and hold that the termination of the claimants’ employment contracts were unfair within the meaning of Section 45 of the Act. RELIEFS 11. Under Section 49 of the Act, I award each claimant one month salary in lieu of notice plus three months salary as compensation for unfair termination. In awarding the said compensation, I have considered the fact that they were not guilty of any misconduct. I however dismiss the claim for leave allowance for lack of evidence to prove that they were entitled to the same under their contracts of employment. I also dismiss the claim for off days and public holidays worked for lack of particulars and evidence. I further dismiss the claim for house allowance because the claimants were paid a daily wage which under the Wage order includes house allowance. I however award each claimant service pay for their respective years of service. 12. The award for each claimant is summarized as follows. MWALIMU AMANI NGONYO [1ST CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………....15000
page 2 of 9
Compensation……………………………….....45000 Service pay 4 years ………………………....…30000 90000 SAID FOLENI SULEIMAN [2ND CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………....18000 Compensation……………………………..........54000 Service pay (2years)……………………….........18000 90000 SAID SALIM MOHAMMED [3RD CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………........….18000 Compensation ………………………………..…54000 Service pay (7 years)……………………….........36000 108000 SUMA SAID NYIRO [4TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………….......…18000 Compensation……………………………......…..54000 Service pay (3years)………………………….…..27000 90000 BAHATI ELIUD MANDA [5TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………………...........19500 Compensation…………………………………....58500 Service pay (2 years)…………….....…………....19500 97500 SAFARI NGONYO MAINGE [6TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………….18000 Compensation…………………………….…….54000 Service pay (2 years) ………………….....……..18000 90000
page 3 of 9
MWARO BAYA MANGI [7TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………..............12000 Compensation…………………………........…...36000 Service pay (4 years) ………………….........…...24000 72000 RASHID MSENA FUNDI [8TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………..….........21000 Compensation…………………………...…….…63000 Service pay (2 years) ……………………...……..21000 105000 MWERI KAZUNGU MURE [9TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………………....…...11250 Compensation……………………………....……33750 Service pay (4 years) …………….....……………22500 67500 CHARO BAMBANYA CHAI [10TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………...………….11250 Compensation ………………………....…………33750 Service pay ……………………....………………...11250 56250 AMOS CHAI MUNGA [11TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………….........…..15000 Compensation………………………………..…..45000 Service pay …………………………………...…...45000 105000 MICHAEL KAHINDI YAA [12TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………........…..19500 Compensation………………………..………….58500
page 4 of 9
Service pay (4 years) ……………….......……….39000 117000 SAMUEL BIRYA MASHA [13TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………..………18000 Compensation ………………………....………..54000 Service pay (2 years) ………….......………….…18000 90000 FRANCIS MWATUA NDORE [14TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………….…….…….11250 Compensation………………………….…....…...33750 Service pay (3 years)………………........………..16875 61875 WILSON NYUNDO MRAMBA [15TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………..………………..11250 Compensation……………………....…...………..33750 Service ……………………………...…...…………22500 67500 SAMUEL KATANA KARISA [16TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………....……..…….18000 Compensation……………………………....……54000 Service pay (3 years) ………………........……….27000 99000 KAHINDI KITSAO MAKAZI [17TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………....…18000 Compensation………………………….....………54000 Service pay (3 years) …………….........………….27000 99000 NGUMBAO KAZUNGU (18TH CLAIMANT)
page 5 of 9
Notice ………………………………………..…….11250 Compensation…………………………......……..33750 Service pay (2 years) ………………........……….11250 56250 BAO MWAFUMBA [19TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………….18000 Compensation …………………………....……..54000 Service pay (3 years)……………….......………..27000 99000 KELVIN CHARO KAZUNGU [20TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………….....……………...11250 Compensation ……………………......…………..33750 Service pay (2 years)…………….........…………..11250 56250 JUMA RATIB KHAMIS [21ST CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………....……….11250 Compensation ………………………….....………33750 Service pay [1 year] ………………….........………...5625 50625 SAFARI MWARINGA [22ND CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………...…..18000 Compensation………………………………....…..54000 Service pay (2 years) ………………….......………18000 90000 JAMES FONDO [23RD CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………….........………….18000 Compensation…………………………..........…….54000 Service pay (3 years) ………………..............……..27000
page 6 of 9
99000 SAFARI KARISA MKARE[24TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………...........……13500 Compensation………………………..............……..40500 Service pay (3 years)………….................………….20250 74250 STEPHEN KITI KOMBE [25TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………..............……….19500 Compensation……………………................………58500 Service pay ……………………….................……….39000 117000 JUMA ABDHALLAH MUSENA [26TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………........……………18000 Compensation…………………...........……………..54000 Service pay (2years)………………...............……….18000 90000 ANDREW AGOSO AMUNGA [27TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………….........………………21000 Compensation…………………...........……………...63000 Service pay (3 years)………………..............………..31500 115500 KHAMIS TSUMA UNDA [28TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………….......…………………..19500 Compensation ………………........………………….58500 Service pay (4 years)………............………………...39000 117000 MCDONALD CHARO [29TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………….......……..19500
page 7 of 9
Compensation……………………………….……….58500 Service pay (3 years) …………………….....………..29250 107250 MURAMBA KIRINGI [30TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………....…………….18000 Compensation………………………......……………..54000 Service pay (4 years)……………………..........………36000 108000 JOSPHAT CHARO NDURYA [31ST CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………………....…………11250 Compensation ……………………………..…………. 33750 Service pay (2 years)…………………......…………….11250 56250 KAHINDI CHARO NDURYA [32ND CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………………………..…..11250 Compensation …………………………………....……33750 Service pay ………………………………….....………..11250 56250 ABDALLAH SALIM OMAR [33RD CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………………........….18000 Compensation ……………………………………….…54000 Service pay (3 years) ……………………………......….27000 99000 ESHWA EMANKWALE [34TH CLAIMANT] Notice …………………………………………....………..11250 Compensation ………………………………..…………33750 Service pay [2 years] …………………….......…………..11250 56250
page 8 of 9
WYCLIFF YAA BAYA [35TH CLAIMANT] Notice ……………………………………………………..11250 Compensation………………………………….………..33750 Service pay (3 years) …………………………....………16975 61875 JUMA SALIM MOHAMMED[36TH CLAIMANT] Notice ………………………………………….....………..12000 Compensation…………………………………........…….36000 Service pay (4 years) ……………………............………..24000 72000 DISPOSITION 13. For the reasons that the termination of the claimants employment contracts was unfair, I enter judgment for them in the aggregate sum of ksh.3,096,375 plus costs and interest. They will also be issued with certificates of service. Dated signed and delivered this 19th May 2017 O. N. Makau Judge
page 9 of 9