Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Sarah Manani Tumbo & Another v Phylis Ogake Ratemo & 3 Others

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT KISII ELC L A NO. E029 OF 2024 SARAH MANANI TUMBO .................................................. 1ST APPELLANT FRANCIS KAYAGO ONDICHO ......................................... 2ND APPELLANT -VERSUSPHYLIS OGAKE RATEMO .............................................. 1ST RESPONDENT FELIX OMBOKI RATEMO .............................................. 2ND RESPONDENT MARY KEMUMA RATEMO ............................................ 3RD RESPONDENT LAND REGISTRAR, KISII ............................................... 4TH RESPONDENT RULING 1. For determination is the 2nd and 3rd Respondents’ application dated 19th May 2026 and brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A, and 95 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap. 21, Rules 77(2) and 84(1) of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2022, and Order 42(6), Order 50(6), and Order 51(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010. The Applicants are seeking the following orders: a. THAT upon inter partes hearing, there be a stay of execution of the judgement and decree and all consequential orders arising thereunder of the Honourable Justice Munyao Sila in Kisii ELC No. E029 of 2024: Sarah Manani Tumbo & Another -versus- Phylis 1

page 1 of 8

Ogake Ratemo & 3 Others pending the hearing and determination of the appeal. b. Spent c. THAT the Appellants be restrained from filing, prosecuting, taxing or enforcing any bills of costs arising from the judgment pending determination of the appeal. d. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to make such further and/or other orders as it may deem just, fair, reasonable and appropriate in the circumstances in order for the ends of justice to be met. e. 2. THAT the cost of the application be provided for. The application is supported by the grounds on the face of the Notice of Motion and the affidavit in support sworn on 18th May 2026 by Felix Omboki Ratemo. 3. In this Court’s judgment delivered on 18th February 2026, Justice Munyao Sila (as he then was) found in favour of the Appellants that the Suit Land, parcel NYARIBARI CHACHE/B/B/BOBURIA/14270, belonged to the 1st Appellant. Aggrieved by that decision, the Applicants filed the present application seeking several orders that can broadly be summarized as: (i) leave to institute an appeal out of time and (ii) stay of execution pending appeal. 2

page 2 of 8

4. During the hearing on 7th July 2026, the application was partially allowed to the extent that time was extended for the Applicants to lodge their appeal before the Court of Appeal within ten (10) days thereof. It is the second issue -stay of execution pending appeal- that is awaiting determination. What is outstanding for determination is whether the Applicants merit the orders of stay of execution. 5. Felix Omboki Ratemo deposed that the Appellants have already obtained a decree in the matter and have initiated the transfer of the Suit Land to themselves. He states that the intended appeal shall be rendered nugatory if the transfer is finalised. He further states that unless the sought stay of execution is granted, the family of the late Francis Ratemo shall lose the Suit Land, which is their source of livelihood. He described such loss as substantial and irreparable. 6. The 2nd Appellant opposed the application through his Replying Affidavit sworn on 5th June 2026. He deposes that the application is duplicative and an abuse of the process of the Court. He further states that the Applicants have failed to demonstrate the substantial loss that they will suffer if a stay of execution is not granted. 7. Submissions on behalf of the Applicantss are dated 10th June 2026 filed by the firm of E. Onono Advocates. On the issue of stay of execution pending appeal, reliance is placed on Butt v Rent Restriction Tribunal [1979] eKLR, to the effect that a stay should be granted where refusal would 3

page 3 of 8

render the appeal nugatory. They submitted that the Appellants have commenced the process of transfer of the Suit Property to themselves. If effected, this transfer shall disinherit the Applicants and cause them to lose their source of income, because the Suit Property may be leased, mortgaged, or sold to third parties. 8. On his part, Mr. Mainga, learned Counsel, vide submissions dated 18th June 2026 on behalf of the Respondents, states that an applicant for stay of execution pending appeal needs to demonstrate (i) that substantial loss may result unless the order for stay is made, (ii) that the application has been made without unreasonable delay, and (iii) provide such security as the Court may order for the due performance of the decree. 9. Placing reliance on the case of James Wangalwa & Another v Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR, Counsel submits that the Applicants have not demonstrated that execution shall create a state of affairs that will irreparably negate the very core of the Applicants as the successful parties in the appeal. He further submits that the Applicants have unreasonably delayed filing the present application and did not offer or undertake to provide security for the due performance of the decree. On this basis, he submits that Applicants’ prayer for stay of execution pending appeal is incompetent. ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION: 4

page 4 of 8

10. Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 sets out grounds to be considered in an application for stay thus; “(2) No order for stay of execution shall be made under subrule (1) unless— (a) the court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and (b) such security as the court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the applicant.” 11. Just as identified by Mr. Mainga, learned Counsel, there are three key conditions that an applicant for a stay of execution needs to satisfy to be successful. The applicant must show the substantial loss that they may suffer if the order of stay sought is not granted; they must prove that the application for stay was made without unreasonable delay; and furnish such security as the Court may order for the due performance of the decree as may ultimately be binding upon them. On Substantial Loss 12. “He who alleges must prove” thus, the burden is squarely upon the Applicants to clearly show the substantial loss they may suffer should stay sought fail to be granted. Felix Ratemo deposes that the Appellants are in 5

page 5 of 8

the process of transferring the Suit Land to themselves. Once this process is complete, the beneficiaries of the estate of the late Francis Ratemo will lose the Suit Land, which has, over the years, been their source of livelihood. The Respondents confirm that they have already set in motion the requisite steps to transfer the Suit title to themselves. 13. On substantial loss, the Court of Appeal in Mukuma v Abuoga [1988] KECA 107 (KLR) stated at paragraph 5 as follows: “Granting a stay in the High Court is governed by Order XLI rule 4(2), the questions to be decided being – (a) whether substantial loss may result unless the stay is granted and the application is made without delay; and (b) the applicant has given security. The discretion under rule 5(2)(b) is at large, but as was pointed out in the Kenya Shell case substantial loss is the cornerstone of both jurisdictions. That is what has to be prevented, because such loss would render the appeal nugatory. Therefore it is necessary to preserve the status quo.” 14. It is the occurrence of an event that will render the appeal nugatory or useless that is to be prevented through an order of stay of execution pending appeal. The Applicants state that they shall be disinherited if the Suit Land is transferred to the Appellants, but this is the natural consequence of the Court’s judgement. It is my considered opinion that the change of name in title perse cannot deemed to occasion substantial loss. 6

page 6 of 8

In the event the Applicants are successful in their appeal, the title can always revert to their name. 15. Although the Applicants argue that they shall lose their source of livelihood if the Suit title is transferred to the Appellants, they did not state the nature of activities they (Applicants) have been conducting on the Suit Land through which they have been deriving an income. Similarly, the application provided no evidence of any such activities. 16. The only real loss that is anticipatory, which may render the appeal nugatory, is the potential transfer of the Suit Land by the Respondents to third parties. This loss exists only as a possibility and can be prevented by injuncting the Appellants from transferring the Suit Land to third parties, but not by granting an order that stops the transfer of title into the Respondents’ names. Whether the Application was Made without Unreasonable Delay 17. The Applicants explained the reasons for the delay in filing their notice of appeal on time and, after due consideration, the Court extended the time within which they were to lodge the appeal. An application for stay could not be made before leave to appeal out of time was granted as a stay of execution cannot be ordered on the basis of a non-existent appeal. On this basis, the Court finds that there was no unreasonable delay in making the application for stay of execution pending appeal. 7

page 7 of 8

Provision of Such Security as the Court May Order 18. Mr Mainga, learned Counsel, faults the Applicants for not offering or undertaking to provide security for the due performance of the decree. However, security is only offered where it is practical to do so. In this instance, the Court has allowed the Respondents in the application to proceed with transferring the title in their names hence there is no need to order for provision of security. 19. In the end, I hold that the application partially succeeds and it is granted in the following terms; a. The Applicants are granted leave to lodge an appeal to the Court of Appeal out of time. b. The Appellants are at liberty to execute the decree by transferring the suit title into their names. Thereafter, the Appellants are injuncted from transferring, charging and/or in any way parting with possession of the Suit Land to any third party pending the determination of the appeal before the Court of Appeal. c. Costs of the application to the Respondents (in the application). Dated, signed and delivered at Kisii this 24th day of September, 2026. A. OMOLLO JUDGE 8

page 8 of 8

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.