Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Esther Nyabate Ngare v Arnold Rasugu Ogamba

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NYAMIRA ELCC No. E001 OF 2022 ESTHER NYABATE NGARE ………...........................………... …... PLAINTIFF VERSUS ARNOLD RASUGU OGAMBA ................................................. DEFENDANT RULING 1. By Notice of Motion dated 29th April 2026, the Plaintiff is seeking the following orders: 1) [Spent] 2) [Spent] 3) That this Honourable court be pleased to review and/or set aside the judgment and decree of this court dated 15th February 2024 and 20th February 2024 and all consequential orders and the plaintiff's suit be fixed for hearing denovo (sic). 4) That subsequently the registration of title LR. No. Matutu Settlement Scheme/702 out of the suitland (sic) be ordered cancelled and/or revoked. 5) Costs of the application be provided for. ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 1 of 19

page 1 of 19

2. The application is based on the grounds listed on its face and is supported by an affidavit sworn by the Plaintiff/Applicant. She deposed that she had since discovered the existence of a very important and material evidence which “with all due diligence “was not available at the time of hearing relating to the disputed land parcel LR. No. Matutu Settlement Scheme/641. She annexed a copy of the register and added that at the time of hearing, a search was done which reflected that the original title was intact and not interfered with at all. 3. She annexed a copy of the certificate of search and further deposed that she had relied on the certificate of search and other documents at trial and that the documents had been taken from the land registry before the inception of this case. 4. The Plaintiff also deposed that she had also discovered that on 21st December 2016, the Land Registrar made an entry in the register discharging a charge despite non-payment of loan and that subsequently, the Land Registrar issued a new title LR. No Matutu Settlement Scheme/702 in the name of the Defendant. That despite the Defendant being aware of the above title created out of LR. No Matutu Settlement Scheme /641, there was no disclosure from him of those developments. He further deposed that there was no pending appeal in the Court of Appeal and that what was there had been dealt with. 5. She added that she had been advised by her advocate on record that two separate registers may have been opened at ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 2 of 19

page 2 of 19

the land registry where the Defendant had access to one with a title and the other in the name of the late Stephen Ngare Ogamba, a situation that was irregular. That in essence the respondent obtained registration of title LR. No. Matutu Settlement/Scheme/702 illegally and without disclosure to the Court, hence there was need for drastic measures, review of the judgment and a fresh hearing to ensure justice. 6. The Defendant opposed the application through a replying affidavit in which he deposed that the application was a representation of the superfluous lengths the Plaintiff, who is the Judgement Debtor, was ready to go to abuse and make a mockery of the Court process. That the application was an afterthought since the Applicant had elected to pursue an appeal and had failed to disclose that there was another application for review on the same grounds which was dismissed on 9th October 2024 thus rendering the matter res judicata. 7. He further deposed that the documents that the Applicant was referring to as new evidence were dated the year 2017 and earlier and that they would have been obtained with reasonable due diligence before the filing of this suit in 2022. That the titles were not a novelty since they were referred to in the judgment and that although the Applicant’s appeal to the Court of Appeal had been struck out, there were still active proceedings in the said Court since the Applicant had filed an ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 3 of 19

page 3 of 19

application dated 12th May 2026, seeking to reinstate the appeal. 8. The Plaintiff/Applicant filed a supplementary affidavit in which she deposed that the pending application in the Court of Appeal seeking to file an appeal did not amount to an actual appeal. She added that although the documents constituting the new evidence date back to 2017, they were not in her knowledge during trial. 9. The application was canvassed though written submissions. The Applicant filed submissions dated 3 rd August 2026 while the Defendant filed submissions dated 10th August 2026. 10.I have carefully considered the application, the affidavits and the submissions. The issues that emerge for determination are whether the application is res judicata and whether the review should be granted. 11.In a ruling which I delivered in this matter on 15 th October 2025, I found it necessary to summarize the history of this matter. I still find it necessary to restate that background. 12.Proceedings commenced in this matter on 4 th April 2022, when the Plaintiff filed Plaint dated 1st April 2022. The Defendant filed Defence and Counterclaim dated 13th June 2022. Upon hearing the matter, the Court, differently constituted, delivered judgment on 15th February 2024 as follows: ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 4 of 19

page 4 of 19

1.The Plaintiff’s suit and prayers engraved in the Plaint dated 1/4/2022 is hereby and wholly dismissed with costs to the Defendant. 2.The Defendant’s Counter-claim dated 13/6/2022 is hereby allowed in terms of prayers number (b) and prayer number (a) the latter being restricted to the 8 Acres he has been occupying. 3.The Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited is hereby ordered to discharge the entire parcel of land Matutu Settlement Scheme/641, to facilitate the same to be sub-divided into two in the ratio of 2:1 between the Deceased Stephan Ngare Ogamba and the Defendant Arnold Rasugu Ogamba respectively. 4.Immediately after the aforesaid sub-division the two portions shall be registered with the Defendant being registered the absolute owner of 8 Acres thereof which shall be where he has built a mud house and the Deceased being the proprietor of the 16 Acres on the other side which has the permanent house. 5.The Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited shall be at liberty to charge the Plaintiff’s (Deceased’s) portion and if not enough then she ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 5 of 19

page 5 of 19

will look for other collaterals belonging to the Deceased. 6.For the avoidance of doubt, the Defendant shall have the costs of the suit and that of the Counter-claim. These are the orders of the court. 13.Following delivery of the judgment, the Plaintiff filed Notice of Motion dated 11th March 2024, through which she sought stay of execution pending appeal. The application was determined by the Court, still differently constituted, through a ruling delivered on 27th May 2024 as follows: This being the scenario, if an unconditional stay of execution is granted in this case, and the Judgment Debtor decides, as she and her late husband have done in the last 10 years, not to service the loan, then the Bank would dispose of the property by way of exercise of her statutory power of sale and both parties would lose the property and this will be the surest way of rendering exercise the and intended thus appeal making the an academic fears of the Applicant a reality. In addition to the order that the Title Deed in respect of L.R. No. Matutu Settlement Scheme/641 be deposited in court ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 6 of 19

page 6 of 19

within the next 15 Days from the date of this Ruling, I will also give another condition to the stay. The Judgment Debtor will have to either: a. Deposit in this court the sum of Kshs. 4,007,572.01 as security for the outstanding loan, or in the alternative, b. Furnish this court with proof that she has cleared the said loan with the Co-operative Bank of Kenya and has had the property discharged, or further in the alternative, c. Deposit a sum of money to be agreed with the Co-operative Bank of Kenya with an undertaking and commitment on how to liquidate the balance of the outstanding loan by monthly instalments until payment in full. In the last option, in case of any default in payment of any one instalment on its due date, execution to issue. Should any of the above 3 conditions be satisfied within the next days hereof, there shall be a stay of execution only limited to the sub-division of the parcel of the land known as L.R. No. Matutu Settlement Scheme/641. However, the Decree Holder shall remain in possession and occupation ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 7 of 19

page 7 of 19

of the designated 8 Acres of the suit property as was his share and as is set apart on the ground until the Hearing and determination of the intended Appeal. 14.Later, Co-Operative Bank of Kenya Ltd filed Notice of Motion dated 12th June 2024 through which it sought to join the suit as an Interested Party and leave to file a statement of defence and counterclaim. The application was determined through a ruling delivered on 9th October 2024. The Court (differently constituted) held thus: This is a discretionally prayer and equity aids the vigilant and not the indolent. And besides, the Court has already taken the interests of the Applicant into consideration. Nowhere has the Applicant suggested to the Court that the wind of opportunity given to her would not be successful. In any case, what is the interest of the Applicant rather than recovering the monies advanced to the Judgment Debtor’s Estate which as observed above, she has had no interest pursuing. This leads to only one conclusion. The Applicant is acting at the behest of the Judgment Debtor which was very clear in the proceedings in that even though the loan was not serviced at all, the Applicant took no action. This of course explains ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 8 of 19

page 8 of 19

why the Judgment Debtor is not opposed to the Motion. In fact the last correspondence from the Applicant to the chargor is dated 28/12/2006 demanding that the chargor do make payments. This was produced in Court by the Applicant’s own Business Manager. Now that the court has condemned the Judgment Debtor to have the Decree Holder’s parcel of land released from the entire charged parcel and the Decree Holder has demanded the discharge Applicant has rushed to of the Court same, the to have the process halted instead of pursuing the large portion which the Court has ordered that it be charged. The Judgment is very clear. If the same were to be sub-divided and/or transferred to 3rd Parties, it would only be because the Applicant has allowed it to happen. The Applicant has therefore not come to court with clean hands nor in good faith and I strongly believe that her Application dated 12/6/2024 belongs to the archives. The same is hereby dismissed with costs to the Defendant/Decree Holder. 15.Thereafter, the matter remained dormant in this Court until the Defendant filed Notice of Motion dated 6 th May 2025, seeking orders that the Deputy Registrar executes discharge ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 9 of 19

page 9 of 19

documents on behalf of the chargor and chargee, and all conveyancing documents in respect of Matutu Settlement Scheme/641 to give effect to the judgement and that the Land Registrar effects and registers the discharge, subdivision, transfer as well as issues a certificate of title in respect of the 8 acres belonging to the Defendant. 16.The Court heard and determined Notice of Motion dated 6 th May 2025 through the aforesaid ruling which I delivered on 15th October 2025. I dismissed the application with costs to the Plaintiff. 17.I now consider whether Notice of Motion dated 29 th April 2026 is res judicata. 18.Although a doctrine of general application, res judicata has statutory expression in Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act. To successfully raise an objection based on res judicata, it must be he shown that there was a previous suit in which the matter was in issue; the parties in both matters were the same or litigating under the same title; the previous matter was heard and determined by a competent Court and the issue is raised once again in the new suit. See John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another v Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure & 3 others [2015] eKLR. ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 10 of 19

page 10 of 19

19.The objectives of the doctrine was stated by the Supreme Court in Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v Muiri Cofee Estate Limited & another [2016] eKLR as being preventing the litigant, or persons claiming under the same title, from returning to Court to claim further reliefs not claimed in the earlier action or submitting to Court issues that have been heard and determined by a competent Court. The doctrine prevents a multiplicity of suits and ensures that litigation ends. 20.The Defendant has contended that the present application is res judicata because there was another application for review on the same grounds which was dismissed on 9 th October 2024. As is manifest from the background that I gave above, the ruling of 9th October 2024 was on Notice of Motion dated 12th June 2024 through which Co-Operative Bank of Kenya Ltd sought to join the suit as an Interested Party and leave to file a statement of defence and counterclaim. The Court did not deal with the question of review. I find that the present application is not res judicata. 21.The application is brought inter alia under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procure Rules. Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act provides as follows: Any person who considers himself aggrieved – ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 11 of 19

page 11 of 19

(a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed by this Act, but from which no appeal has been preferred; or (b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed by this Act, may apply for a review of judgment to the court which passed the decree or made the order, and the court may make such order thereon as it thinks fit. 22.On the other hand, Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procure Rules provides thus: Any person considering himself aggrieved— (a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred; or (b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is hereby allowed, and who from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree was passed or the order made, or on account of some mistake or ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 12 of 19

page 12 of 19

error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree or order, may apply for a review of judgment to the court which passed the decree or made the order without unreasonable delay. 23.The Defendant has opposed the application on the basis that the Applicant filed an appeal against the judgment and that although the was struck out, the Applicant had filed an application dated 12th May 2026, seeking to reinstate the appeal, which application is pending determination. 24.It is trite that review is not available where an appeal has been preferred against the decree or order sought to be reviewed. An appeal and an application for review in respect of the same decree or order cannot co-exist. Where an appeal exists, the matter sought to be remedied by review must merge in the appeal. See Otieno, Ragot & Company Advocates v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2020] eKLR and William Karani & 47 others v Wamalwa Kijana & 2 others [1987] eKLR. 25.There is no dispute that the appeal which the Applicant filed is Civil Appeal No. E281 of 2024 and that the said appeal was struck out on 20th April 2026, pursuant to an application by the Defendant. Following the striking out, the Applicant filed Civil Application No. E088 of 2026, seeking leave to file Notice of ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 13 of 19

page 13 of 19

Appeal and Record of Appeal out of time. The application is pending determination in the Court of Appeal at Kisumu. 26.The application pending determination in the Court of Appeal may or may not be allowed. If it is allowed, the Applicant will have a chance to appeal against the decree. If not, there will be no appeal. In those circumstances, it cannot be said that there is an appeal against the decree at the moment. I see no valid reason to bar the application for review, on the ground of an as yet non-existent appeal. 27.The Plaintiff has given discovery of new and important evidence as her ground for seeking review. Does that ground pass muster in the circumstances? I am not persuaded that it does. 28.Great caution is required when dealing with such an application since, as the Nigerian Supreme Court stated in the case of Citec International Estate Ltd. & Others v. Francis & Others (2014) LPELR-22314 (SC), an application for review is not meant to afford the losing party an opportunity to re-litigate or re-open a matter merely because such party is unhappy with the outcome. 29.The Court of Appeal expressed similar caution in D. J. Lowe & Company Limited vs Banque Indosuez [1998] eKLR where it stated: ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 14 of 19

page 14 of 19

Where such a review application is based on fact of the discovery of fresh evidence the court must exercise greatest of care as it is easy for a party who has lost, to see the weak part of his case and the temptation to lay and procure evidence which will strengthen that weak part and put a different complexion. In such event, to succeed, the party must show that there was no remissness on his part in adducing all possible evidence at the hearing. 30.The “new and important evidence” that the Applicant is referring to is that on 21st December 2016, the Land Registrar made an entry in the register discharging a charge and that subsequently issued a new title LR. No Matutu Settlement Scheme/702 to the Defendant. She claims that the Defendant obtained registration of title LR. No. Matutu Settlement/Scheme/702 illegally and without disclosure to the Court. 31.A perusal of the record however reveals that there is nothing new in those claims. The said material was on record and was discussed in the judgment. Therein, Mr. Martin Osano, Land Registrar is Nyamira recorded as having testified that “… Matutu Settlement Scheme/641 was …. never closed yet there are Green Cards for 701 and 702, resultant therefore which are suspect … No one was issued with Title for Matutu ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 15 of 19

page 15 of 19

Settlement Scheme/701 – 701 measures 6.53 Hectares while Matutu Settlement Scheme/702 measures 3.23 Hectares, 8 Acres. These were issued before the Mutation was registered and to date the same has never been registered. The same could not have been registered due to the caution and the charge. Maybe the documents were backdated after Stephen had died …”. 32.In its analysis, the trial Court stated as follows in the judgment: In the meantime, disagreements had started occurring and with advise from close family members, the two brothers decided to rescind their earlier contract of exchanges and get back to their original portions. There were Mutation forms prepared Scheme/641 was and Matutu sub-divided Settlement into Matutu Settlement Scheme/701 measuring 6.53 Hectares to be retained by the Deceased and Matutu Settlement Scheme/702 – 3.23 Hectares which was allegedly transferred in the name of the Defendant and a Title Deed allegedly issued. This was not possible since the Mutation had not been registered and the land had a caution registered against it. 33.It is thus manifest that there nothing new in the evidence. Further, a reading of the Applicant’s submissions in respect of ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 16 of 19

page 16 of 19

the present application reveals that the Applicant is simply dissatisfied with how the trial Court handled or interpreted the evidence. 34.The Applicant argued in his submissions thus: “The applicant has also discovered that the judgment of the court did not consider the evidence adduced by the Land Registrar one Martin Osano. He gave his evidence on 25/10/2023 as shown on page 32, 33, and 34 of the judgment. This evidence is new though on record but was not considered. The trial judge also did not consider that he was transferring the title to a deceased person 16 acres .The deceased was not a party to benefit out of this suit.” 35.The Applicant went on to argue that “The applicant has provided new and compelling evidence that was not in her possession as at the time of drafting and hearing of the case. The new evidence was unveiled by the land registrar which the court did not consider thereby arriving at the wrong decision. As per the evidence adduced by the Land Registrar which evidence was not considered by the trial court the disputed parcel was charged with Co-operative Bank somewhere in 2004 later discharged on 21/12/2016 and new title certificate issued on 25/1/2017 to Arnold Rasugu Ogamba. This contradicts the judgment of the court delivered on 15/2/2024. The land registrar denied in his evidence that there is no discharge as per the records attached.” ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 17 of 19

page 17 of 19

36.The foregoing arguments manifest a litigant who believes that the judgment has a mistake of law or fact or an erroneous finding. As the Court of Appeal held in National Bank of Kenya Ltd v. Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR, it cannot be a ground for review that the Court proceeded on an incorrect exposition, reached an erroneous conclusion or that that another Judge could have taken a different view of the matter. The Applicant must await the fate of her application for leave to file Notice of Appeal and Record of Appeal out of time and then test those arguments in an appeal against the judgment. 37.It is a requirement of Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procure Rules that an application for review be made without unreasonable delay. The present application was filed on 29 th April 2026 while the judgment sought to be reviewed was delivered on 15th February 2024, some 26 months earlier. A delay of over two years is both unreasonable and inordinate. It matters not that the Applicant had an appeal in the Court of Appeal since the decision to appeal or review is one that a party makes from the onset. Appeal and review are mutually exclusive. A litigant must decide at once which way to go. She cannot test the appellate process and once her appeal is struck out she seeks review without reckoning the time that passed while the appeal was pending. ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 18 of 19

page 18 of 19

38.In view of the foregoing discourse, I find no merit in Notice of Motion dated 29th April 2026. I dismiss it with costs to the Defendant. Dated, signed, and delivered at Nyamira, this 23 rd day of September 2026. D. O. OHUNGO JUDGE Delivered in the presence of: Mr Anyona for the Plaintiff Mr Bonuke for the Defendant Court Assistant: B Kerubo ELCC No. E001 of 2022 (Nyamira) Page 19 of 19

page 19 of 19

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.