Kangerwe v Munene & another (Environment and Land Appeal E009 of 2024) [2025] KEELC 8525 (KLR) (26 November 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] KEELC 8525 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT EMBU ENVIRONMENT AND LAND APPEAL E009 OF 2024 AK BOR, J NOVEMBER 26, 2025 BETWEEN MUNENE KANGERWE .......................................................................... APPELLANT AND SICILY KARIMI MUNENE .......................................................... 1ST RESPONDENT THE LAND REGISTRAR EMBU ............................................... 2ND RESPONDENT JUDGMENT 1. This appeal arises from the judgment of Hon J.W Gichimu (SPM) delivered on 14/3/2024 in Runyenjes ELC Case no. E035 of 2022, which the 1st Respondent, Sicily Munene instituted seeking a declaration that the transfer and registration of the land known as Kagaari/Kanja/10325 (the suit land) to the sole name of the Appellant without her consent and participation, and the issuance of the title deed to the Appellant solely on 4/8/2017 was fraudulent, null and void. She sought cancellation of the registration of the Appellant as the sole owner and reversion of title over the suit land to their joint names as well as costs of the suit. 2. The 1st Respondent’s claim was that she was legally married to the Respondent and that on 8/9/2016, they were registered as absolute joint owners of the suit land measuring 0.52 hectares and that a joint title was issued to them on 11/10/2016. She averred that on 20/7/2017, the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent conspired and fraudulently cancelled her registration as joint owner of the suit land and registered the land in the sole name of the Appellant and issued him with a title deed on 4/8/2017. 3. She set out the particulars of fraud as fraudulently conspiring to have her name removed from the land register of the suit land without her consent and participation and registering the land in the name of the Appellant; fraudulently cancelling her registration as a joint owner of the suit land and fraudulently having a new title deed issued in the name of the Appellant without her consent, knowledge and participation. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/8525/eng@2025-11-26 1
page 1 of 6
4. The Appellant filed a defence and counterclaim and sought to have the 1st Respondent’s suit dismissed. He averred that he was the registered owner and absolute proprietor of the suit land and sought an order for the Land Registrar, Embu to lift the restriction registered against the suit land as well as costs of the counterclaim. 5. In his defence, the Appellant denied the particulars of fraud attributed to him and averred that the 1st Respondent had fraudulently caused the suit land to be registered jointly in both their names without his knowledge and consent as the owner of the land. The Appellant claimed that the 1st Respondent had without any colour of right registered a restriction against his land which was curtailing him from enjoying his rights as proprietor. 6. He stated that he learnt that the 1st Respondent was in the process of selling the suit land and complained to the Land Registrar. That the Land Registrar summoned the 1st Respondent to his ofice before revoking their joint registration which he alleged occurred through fraud and forgery of documents purported to be signed by him. The Appellant stated that he was no longer married to the 1st Respondent as their marriage was dissolved on 23/7/2020 and that there was no basis to have her name reinstated as a joint proprietor of the suit land which belongs to him. 7. The 2nd Respondent filed a defence and denied the 1st Respondents claims of fraud. He asserted that if indeed the Appellant was registered as the sole proprietor of the suit land, it was done lawfully and in accordance with the law and upon presentation of the relevant legal documents. 8. During the hearing, the 1st Respondent testified that the suit land was originally part of Kagaari/ Kanja/805 registered in the name of the Appellant. That they later subdivided the land into 5 portions, with the suit land herein as one of the resultant portions which was registered in their joint names. She stated that on 22/6/2017, she received a call and was informed that the Appellant had gone to the Land Registrar and terminated their joint proprietorship of the suit land. She maintained that she neither agreed to have her name removed from the register nor did she sign any document to sever the joint proprietorship. 9. On cross examination, she stated that she was living in a rented plot in Karurumo while the Appellant lived on the suit land. She testified that she planted tea bushes on the suit land in 2020. She denied that she attempted to sell the suit land. She also denied being divorced from the Appellant and stated that they were separated in 2017 when the Appellant chased her away. She stated that she had children with the Appellant and that the Appellant gave her son Kagaari/Kanja/10324 measuring 1/2 acre which the son had sold. The 1st Respondent relied on the certificate of marriage, a copy of the green card for Kagaari/Kanja/10325 and a notice of intention to sue issued to the Ofice of the Attorney General in support of her case. 10. The Appellant, Munene Kangerwe in his testimony maintained that the 1st Respondent caused the suit land to be registered jointly in their names without his knowledge. He stated that the 1st Respondent sold her son’s land and that he suspected she would sell the suit land as well. He testified that he was now living on the land and denied that the 1st Respondent had planted tea bushes there. 11. He asked the Land Registrar to sever the joint proprietorship as he did not allow the plaintifi to be jointly registered with him. He maintained that he neither signed any documents for the joint proprietorship of the land nor did he attend any land control board to efiect the joint proprietorship. The Appellant relied on the decree dissolving his marriage with the 1st Respondent and the green card over the suit land in support of his case. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/8525/eng@2025-11-26 2
page 2 of 6
12. The 2nd Respondent, Caroline Kitaru, the Land Registrar Embu testified that she was not the Registrar in 2017 when the actions complained of took place. She stated that she could not able tell how entry no. 4, being the joint proprietorship was efiected. She contended that the Land Registrar had power under Section 79(2) of the Land Registration Act to revoke an unlawful registration and that it does not require a court order to revoke such registration. She told the court that she did not know the circumstances under which the registration of the suit land was changed from joint to sole proprietorship. 13. The trial court in its judgment framed the issue for determination as whether the Land Registrar had the authority to revoke the 1st Respondent’s registration as a joint owner of the suit land. Upon examining Section 79 of the Land Registration Act, the court held that the Land Registrar’s powers were limited to rectification of errors, mistakes, or omissions that do not materially afiect the interest of a registered proprietor. The court found that such rectification could not include cancellation of a title of a registered proprietor and in the instant case; it could not include the removal of the 1st Respondent’s name from the register as joint owner of the suit land. 14. The court held that the Land Registrar acted beyond her powers when she removed the 1st Respondent’s name as a joint owner of the suit land. The court noted that Caroline Kitaru, the Land Registrar did not give any reason or indicate why the name of the 1st Respondent was removed from the register. 15. The court relied on the decisions in Republic v Chief Land Registrar and Another, Ex parte Yosabia Kerubo Manyura [2018] eKLR and Republic v District Land Registrar Meru North & Another, Ex parte Kennedy Kimathi M’Itabari M’Muriki [2021] eKLR, which afirmed that the Land Registrar lacks jurisdiction to cancel a registered proprietor’s title and that under Section 80(1) of the Land Registration Act, it is the court that has power to direct the cancellation of registration. Consequently, the trial court found that the 1st Respondent had proved her case on a balance of probabilities and allowed her suit and dismissed the Appellant’s counterclaim. 16. The Appellant raised six grounds of appeal in the memorandum of appeal. He mainly faulted the trial court for finding that the Registrar did not have powers to cancel a registration under Section 79 of the Land Registration Act and for failing to make a finding that the entry of joint proprietorship was made fraudulently. He also faulted the court for failing to find that the restriction registered by the 1st Respondent on the suit land was illegal, and for dismissing his counterclaim. He argued that the trial court erred by generally disregarding his defence. He asked the court to set aside the trial court’s judgment and for the 1st Respondent’s suit to be dismissed with costs. He also prayed for the counterclaim to be allowed with costs. In addition, he sought the costs of the appeal and those for the trial court. 17. The court directed the parties to file and exchange written submissions which it has considered. The Appellant submitted that the learned magistrate erred in law and fact by misconstruing the powers granted to the Land Registrar under Section 79 of the Land Registration Act, by holding that rectification does not include cancellation of a title. He contended that Section 79(2) allows the Registrar to rectify the register where there is a mistake or omission, and that the inclusion of the 1st Respondent’s name as joint proprietor of the suit land was erroneous or fraudulent, made without any transfer instrument, gift, court order, or succession process. That the Land Registrar was therefore within her mandate in removing the Respondent’s name from the register. 18. The Appellant argued that the trial court failed to interrogate the validity of the entry of 8/9/2016 that listed the 1st Respondent as a joint proprietor, despite the absence of any evidence to show how she https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/8525/eng@2025-11-26 3
page 3 of 6
became entitled to registration. Citing Sections 24 and 26 of the Land Registration Act and relevant authorities, the Appellant maintained that fraud vitiates any title, and that courts have a duty to prevent the register from being used to uphold unlawful acquisitions. He argued that the trial court erred in adopting a narrow interpretation of “rectification” as used under Section 79 of the Land Registration Act and that cancellation of the 1st Respondent’s void entry in the register was well within the meaning and intention of rectification. The Appellant further submitted that the restriction lodged by the 1st Respondent after her removal as joint owner was illegal under Section 76 of the Land Registration Act, as she had no court order or justifiable legal claim. Ultimately the court was urged to allow the appeal. 19. The 1st Respondent in her submissions gave a brief background to the case. She supported the trial court’s findings and urged this court to uphold those findings. 20. The 2nd Respondent submitted that Section 79(2) of the Land Registration Act grants the Land Registrar the power to amend or correct the register in cases of error, omission, or fraudulent entries, even without a court order, provided the rights of a registered proprietor in possession are not prejudiced. The 2nd Respondent contended that the inclusion of the 1st Respondent’s name as joint proprietor of the suit land was done without any valid proof of a transfer instrument or court order, and was therefore fraudulent. That the Land Registrar was only carrying out an administrative mandate under Section 79 in rectifying the register and removing the 1st Respondent’s name, who was never a bona fide purchaser or transferee for value and therefore not in the exclusive possession of the land. 21. Further, that the Land Registrar followed the legal procedure for rectification of title. Relying on Section 26 of the Land Registration Act, they argued that title can only be challenged on grounds of fraud, misrepresentation, illegality, or procedural impropriety, and that the Land Registrar confirmed all the documents and processed the rectification as required by law. The 2nd Respondent urged that a copy of the green card showing how the transactions took place was filed in court for guidance. It was submitted that the 1st Respondent did not produce suficient proof that there was any fraudulent transaction carried out by the Appellant and the Land Registrar. The court was urged to allow the appeal. 22. The court has considered the pleadings, evidence, and submissions before the trial court, as well as the rival submissions before this court on appeal. From the memorandum of appeal and the record, the issues that arise for determination are whether the Land Registrar acted within the powers conferred by Section 79 of the Land Registration Act when removing the 1st Respondent’s name from the register as a joint proprietor of the suit land; whether the restriction lodged by the 1st Respondent was lawful; whether the trial court erred in dismissing the Appellant’s counterclaim; and lastly, who should meet the costs of the appeal. 23. The 1st Respondent submitted that she was the estranged wife of the Appellant. The copy of the marriage certificate tendered in evidence shows that the two got married on 14/10/2016. The Appellant was a widower aged 89 years while the 1st Respondent was a spinster aged 40 years. 24. Section 79 of the Land Registration Act stipulates that the Registrar may rectify the register or any instrument presented for registration in the following cases:a. in formal matters and in case of errors, mistakes or omissions not materially afiecting the interests of any proprietor; b. in any case and at any time with the consent of all afiected parties; https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/8525/eng@2025-11-26 4
page 4 of 6
c. if upon resurvey, a dimension or area shown in the register is found to be incorrect, in such case the Registrar shall first give notice in writing to all persons with an interest in the rectification of the parcel; d. for purposes of updating the register; or e. for purposes of correcting the name, address or other particulars of the proprietor upon the written application by the proprietor in a prescribed form. 25. Section 79 (2) states that no alteration afiecting the title of the proprietor may be made pursuant to sub-section (1) without the proprietor' s consent unless the proprietor has by fraud or lack of proper care caused or substantially contributed to the error, mistake or omission; or it would for any other reason be unjust for the alteration not to be made. A written notice of ninety days should be given to the proprietor of such intention to make the alteration. 26. The trial court found that the Land Registrar lacked jurisdiction to cancel a registered proprietor’s title, being that of the 1st Respondent. The Appellant, however, argued that the removal of the 1st Respondent’s name did not amount to cancellation of title but was a lawful rectification under Section 79 of the Land Registration Act to correct a fraudulent or erroneous entry. 27. The copy of the register for Kagaari/Kanja/10325 shows that it was opened on 30/8/2016 and that this parcel resulted from the subdivision of 805. The Appellant was registered as the proprietor of the suit land on 30/8/2016. There is no entry to show when the title deed was issued to him, if at all it was issued. Entry no. 2 dated 8/9/2016, has the names of the 1st Respondent and the Appellant registered as joint proprietors of the land. A title deed was issued on 11/10/2016, and is refiected as entry no. 3. The register shows that that was done for a consideration of Kshs. 750,000/=. 28. During the hearing, the 1st Respondent explained that that value was paid for valuation without giving any further explanation. Entry no. 4 shows that on 20/7/2017, the Appellant was registered as the sole proprietor of the land and a title deed issued to him on 4/8/2017, which is entry no. 5. Entry no. 6 is a restriction on dealings with the land placed by the 1st Respondent. 29. The Appellant argued that the trial court failed to interrogate the validity of the entry made on 8/9/2016 that listed the 1st Respondent as a joint proprietor, despite the absence of evidence on how she got to be registered as a joint proprietor. It was his contention in the defence and the counterclaim that the 1st Respondent fraudulently got her name registered as a joint proprietor of the suit land. 30. According to the marriage certificate, the two got married on 14/10/2016 but the suit land was registered in their joint names prior to this on 8/9/2016. In this court’s view, the burden to prove that she was lawfully registered as a joint owner of the suit land on 8/9/2016 fell on the 1st Respondent and she failed to discharge that burden. The 1st Respondent wishes the court to overlook this critical aspect while looking up to Section 79 of the Land Registration Act to afiord her protection as a joint proprietor. 31. How the 1st Respondent came to be registered as a joint proprietor of the suit land is as important as to how the 2nd Respondent removed her name from the register in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 79 of the Land Registration Act. The 2nd Respondent as custodian of land records did not tender any evidence to show how the 1st Respondent was registered as a joint owner of the suit land. That registration was undertaken without the Appellant’s consent and was therefore unlawful. 32. The appeal succeeds. The Appellant is awarded the costs of the appeal. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/8525/eng@2025-11-26 5
page 5 of 6
DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT EMBU THIS 26TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2025. K. BOR JUDGE In the presence of: Diana Kemboi-Court Assistant No appearance for the parties https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/8525/eng@2025-11-26 6
page 6 of 6