Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

keelc-2025-07563

Ikengo v Bothemi & 7 others (Environment and Land Case 16 of 2019 & Enviromental and Land Originating Summons 43 (Kisii) of 2015 (Consolidated)) [2025] KEELC 7563 (KLR) (31 October 2025) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2025] KEELC 7563 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MIGORI ENVIRONMENT AND LAND CASE 16 OF 2019 & ENVIROMENTAL AND LAND ORIGINATING SUMMONS 43 (KISII) OF 2015 (CONSOLIDATED) MN KULLOW, J OCTOBER 31, 2025 BETWEEN IKENGO MURIMI IKENGO .................................................................... PLAINTIFF AND PASKALIA MUGOSI BOTHEMI .................................................... 1ST DEFENDANT KENNEDY CHACHA BOTEBI ...................................................... 2ND DEFENDANT MOHABE JOSEPH BOTEBI CHACHA ........................................ 3RD DEFENDANT MONANKA LUCAS BOTEBI ........................................................ 4TH DEFENDANT JOSEPH BOTEBI CHACHA ........................................................... 5TH DEFENDANT NAFTALI MAYABA OTONDO ...................................................... 6TH DEFENDANT PETER TUGUCHA ......................................................................... 7TH DEFENDANT DAVID TATIRO ............................................................................... 8TH DEFENDANT JUDGMENT A. Introduction and Background 1. The Plaintifi, Ikengo Murimi Ikengo, instituted this suit by way of a plaint dated 28th February 2019 against the Defendants seeking, inter alia, a permanent injunction restraining the Defendants, their servants and/or agents from trespassing upon or interfering with Land Parcel No. Bukira/ Buhirimonono/933 measuring approximately 2.4 hectares, an order for eviction and vacant possession against the Defendants and any persons claiming under them, and costs of the suit with interest thereon. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 1

page 1 of 8

2. The Plaintifi’s case as pleaded is that he is the registered and lawful owner of the suit property, having acquired it through purchase from one Chacha Chacha Monanka on 14th June 1991, and that he has been in exclusive use, occupation, and possession thereof since that date until around December 2014 and early 2015, when the Defendants allegedly forcefully entered the land, constructed structures, cultivated, and began selling portions thereof to third parties without his consent. 3. The Plaintifi avers that the Defendants’ actions amounted to illegal invasion and trespass, prompting him to file the present suit. He denies ever granting the Defendants permission, licence, or consent to occupy or utilize the suit land in any manner, contending that their entry was violent, unlawful, and recent, hence incapable of ripening into any lawful claim such as adverse possession. 4. He further states that the Defendants’ assertion of ownership through Kisii ELC (O.S.) No. 43 of 2015 was misconceived and without legal foundation, since the statutory period required for adverse possession had not elapsed by the time the claim was instituted. 5. In their response, the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th Defendants, who are sons of the late Joseph Botebi Chacha and grandsons of Chacha Monanka, filed their statement of defence and counterclaim (originally through O.S. 43 of 2015), contending that the entire land parcel Bukira/Buhirimonono/933 was originally part of Bukira/Buhirimonono/293, the family land of their grandfather, Chacha Monanka, who passed away in 1989. 6. The Defendants pleaded that following the patriarch’s death, the family land was subdivided among his sons in accordance with Kuria customary law and that the portion now known as parcel No. 933 fell to the family of Botebi Chacha, their father. They claim to have been in actual possession, use, and occupation of the suit land for well over 30 to 40 years, long before the Plaintifi’s alleged purchase and registration, and that such occupation has been open, continuous, peaceful, and as of right. 7. The Defendants further allege that the Plaintifi’s registration as proprietor of the suit land in 1991 was fraudulent, irregular, and unlawful, having been efiected without their knowledge, consent, or family resolution, and contrary to the rights of the beneficiaries of the estate of Chacha Monanka. Consequently, they aver that the Plaintifi holds title to the land in trust for them as the rightful family beneficiaries. 8. The Defendants thus assert that the Plaintifi’s title, if any, has been extinguished by operation of law under sections 7, 13, and 17 of the Limitation of Actions Act, and that they have since acquired title by adverse possession. They pray that the Plaintifi’s suit be dismissed with costs and that they be declared the lawful owners of the suit land. 9. The Plaintifi filed a reply to defence and defence to counterclaim, reiterating his ownership and denying the alleged long occupation or any customary entitlement by the Defendants. He maintains that the land was lawfully transferred and registered, that the Defendants have their own parcels, and that their alleged occupation commenced only in 2014/2015 through unlawful encroachment. 10. Owing to the competing claims, the court, on 26th March 2019, ordered the consolidation of this suit with Kisii ELC (O.S.) No. 43 of 2015, the present file being the lead file, and directed that the matter proceed to hearing on a priority basis. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 2

page 2 of 8

B. Hearing a. Plaintifi case 11. The hearing of the consolidated suit commenced before Hon. G. Ongondo, J, on 8th April 2021, with the plaintifi, Ikengo Murimi Ikengo, testifying as PW1. He adopted his witness statements dated 28th February 2019 and 7th April 2021, together with his replying afidavit sworn on 9th December 2016. He testified that he is the registered proprietor of LR No. Bukira/Buhirimonono/933 (the suit land), which he purchased from Chacha Minanga. 12. He stated that he had been in peaceful occupation and use of the suit land since 1991 until the year 2015 when the defendants allegedly entered the land without his consent, constructed structures, and began cultivation. He produced six documents marked P Exhibits 1–6 in support of his case and prayed for the reliefs sought in the plaint. In cross-examination, he maintained that the defendants invaded the land by force in 2015, denied that they had any legal right to occupy it, and stated that he had reported the trespass to the police, though he did not produce an OB number. 13. The plaintifi called one additional witness, PW2, Julius Rioba Machugu, who testified on 21st September 2022 before me. He adopted his witness statement dated 4th April 2021 as his evidence-inchief. PW2 confirmed that he was familiar with the plaintifi and the suit land and that the plaintifi had been utilizing the land prior to the dispute with the defendants. He corroborated the plaintifi’s account that the defendants entered the suit land around 2015 and began using it without the plaintifi’s consent. His evidence supported the plaintifi’s position that the land rightfully belonged to the plaintifi. Upon conclusion of PW2’s testimony, the plaintifi closed his case. b. Defence case 14. On the part of the defence, DW1, Joseph Botedi Chacha, testified on behalf of the 2nd to 5th defendants. He adopted his statement dated 26th July 2023 together with defence documents marked as Exhibits 1–8. He stated that the suit land originally belonged to his grandfather, Chacha Monanka, and that the plaintifi was aware of this. He confirmed that the land was initially parcel number 293, later subdivided into four portions, one of which parcel 933 was transferred to the plaintifi. 15. He further testified that he currently resides on the suit land and that other defendants also occupy portions of it. On cross-examination, he admitted that the plaintifi’s name appears on the green card as the registered owner since 1991 but insisted that the land was ancestral and no succession had been done. Upon re-examination, he reiterated that his family had merely been shown where to live and that his father was never formally registered as owner. The defence then closed its case. C. Submissions by Each Party a. Plaintifi ’s Submissions 16. Counsel for the plaintifi submitted that the suit concerns land parcel LR No. Bukira/ Buhirimonono/933, measuring 2.4 hectares and registered in the plaintifi’s name since 14th June 1991. The plaintifi contends that the defendants unlawfully invaded the suit land in December 2014 and early 2015, erected illegal structures, and began cultivation. It was argued that the plaintifi’s registration was lawfully derived from Chacha Chacha Monanka, who had obtained the land from the family patriarch Chacha Monanka following the subdivision of the original parcel No. 293. The plaintifi maintained that his title is protected under sections 24, 25, and 26 of the Land Registration Act, 2012, and that the defendants’ entry onto the land was trespass and without consent. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 3

page 3 of 8

17. It was further submitted that the defendants’ claim of long occupation and adverse possession is not supported by credible evidence. Counsel referred to Samwel Kihamba v Mary Mbaisi (2015) eKLR, emphasizing that for adverse possession to succeed, occupation must be open, peaceful, and without permission or force (nec vi, nec clam, nec precario). The plaintifi argued that the defendants’ alleged occupation began only in 2014–2015, far short of the statutory twelve years required under sections 7, 13, 17, and 38 of the Limitation of Actions Act, and that their possession has been characterized by confiict and resistance, thereby failing to meet the test of adverse possession. 18. The plaintifi submitted that the defendants’ reliance on family ancestry is misplaced, since the patriarch’s subdivision of the original parcel allocated distinct shares to each son, and parcel 933 was validly transferred to the plaintifi. It was contended that the defendants’ photographs purporting to show occupation were unsupported by survey evidence, and only one defendant testified without clarifying each occupant’s portion. The plaintifi therefore urged the court to find that his title has not been extinguished, that the defendants’ entry was unlawful, and to grant the reliefs sought in the plaint while dismissing the defendants’ originating summons in Kisii ELC No. 43 of 2015. b. Defendants’ Submissions 19. Counsel for the 2nd to 5th defendants submitted that they are the sons of the late Joseph Botebi Chacha, who was himself a son of Chacha Monanka, the original owner of the entire ancestral land, including the suit parcel. They argued that the plaintifi’s registration as proprietor of parcel No. Bukira/ Buhirimonono/933 was irregular and did not confer good title, as the plaintifi’s predecessor had acquired it unlawfully. The defendants contended that they and their family have been in continuous, open, and uninterrupted possession of the suit land for over thirty years, and that the plaintifi’s title has been extinguished by operation of law. 20. It was their submission that this suit is statute-barred under sections 7, 9, 13(1), and 17 of the Limitation of Actions Act, as the defendants have occupied the land as of right and adversely to the plaintifi’s proprietorship. They urged the court to find that by reason of prolonged occupation, the plaintifi holds the title in trust for them, and consequently, the plaintifi’s claim should be dismissed with costs. D. Issues for Determination 21. Having carefully considered the pleadings, the oral and documentary evidence adduced by both parties, together with their respective written submissions and the authorities cited, the Court is of the view that the following issues arise for determination: a. Whether the Plaintifi is the lawful proprietor of the suit land or whether the Defendants have acquired title by adverse possession. b. Whether the Defendants’ occupation and sale of portions of the suit land constituted trespass or created any lawful interest in favour of the 6th-8th Defendants. c. What reliefs, if any, should the court grant. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 4

page 4 of 8

E. Analysis and Determination Issue 1: Whether the Plaintifi is the lawful proprietor of the suit land or whether the Defendants have acquired title by adverse possession 22. The Plaintifi, produced documentary evidence showing that he is the registered proprietor of Land Parcel No. Bukira/Buhirimonono/933, measuring approximately 2.4 hectares, having been registered as such on 14th June 1991.He tendered a certified copy of the register, a title deed, and a certificate of oficial search in proof thereof (PExh.1–3). 23. The Plaintifi testified that he lawfully purchased the land from one Chacha Chacha Monanka, who had obtained it from his father, the patriarch Chacha Monanka, following a subdivision of the original parcel No. Bukira/Buhirimonono/293 into four portions among the patriarch’s sons. He stated that he took possession in 1991 and used the land for cultivation and grazing until December 2014 or early 2015, when the Defendants forcefully invaded and began constructing structures thereon. 24. It is not in dispute that the Defendants are descendants of the late Botebi Chacha, a brother to Chacha Chacha Monanka, and that they occupy land adjacent to the suit property, known as parcel No. 932.Their case, however, is that they have been in occupation of parcel 933 the suit land openly and continuously for over 30 years, and that the Plaintifi’s registration is therefore extinguished by adverse possession. 25. The Defendants did not produce any documentary evidence showing allocation, transfer, or registration in their favour. Their case rests entirely on the alleged long occupation. They relied on the afidavit of the late Paskalia Mugosi filed in Kisii ELC (O.S) No. 43 of 2015, wherein she claimed that the family had occupied the land for over 40 years, and that the Plaintifi’s registration was fraudulent. 26. The court observes, however, that in paragraph 6 of the said afidavit, the late Paskalia deponed that in 1989, the patriarch Chacha Monanka subdivided his land (No. 293) into four portions among his sons. That admission is significant: it indicates that the subdivision took place only in 1989 not forty years earlier and that each son took his distinct portion.Botebi, was allocated his own share (separate from parcel 933), while Chacha Monanka received the land that was later sold to the Plaintifi. The Defendants’ patriarch, 27. From the foregoing, the court finds that the Plaintifi’s registration as proprietor of parcel 933 on 14th June 1991 was based on a lawful transfer from Chacha Monanka, who held good title following the family subdivision. Under sections 24, 25, and 26 of the Land Registration Act, 2012, the registration of a person as proprietor vests in him absolute ownership together with all rights and privileges appurtenant thereto, subject only to encumbrances, restrictions, or overriding interests noted in the register. No evidence was adduced to suggest fraud, illegality, or procedural impropriety in the Plaintifi’s acquisition. 28. Section 38(1) of the Limitation of Actions Act allows a person to move the Court for an order that he be registered as proprietor in place of the registered owner, where he has been in adverse possession for at least twelve years. In Kasuve v Mwaani Investments Ltd & Others [2004] 1 KLR 184, the Court of Appeal held that: “In order to be entitled to land by adverse possession, the claimant must prove that he has been in exclusive possession of the land openly and as of right and without interruption for a period of twelve years either after dispossessing the owner or by discontinuation of possession by the owner on his own volition.” https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 5

page 5 of 8

29. It is now settled that the combined efiect of sections 6, 13, and 17 of the Limitation of Actions Act is to extinguish the title of the registered proprietor in favour of an adverse possessor after twelve years of continuous adverse possession. In Kimani Ruchine & Another v Swift Rutherford & Co. Ltd [1980] KLR 10, the Court stated that occupation must not be by force, secrecy, or permission—nec vi, nec clam, nec precario—and must be open, peaceful, continuous, and uninterrupted. 30. The doctrine was further clarified in Mtana Lewa v Kahindi Ngala Mwagandi, Civil Appeal No. 56 of 2014 [2015 eKLR], where the Court of Appeal described adverse possession as: “A situation where a person takes possession of land and asserts rights over it, and the person having title omits or neglects to take action against such person in assertion of his title for a certain period. In Kenya, it is twelve (12) years. The essential pre-requisites being that the possession is neither by force, stealth, nor under licence of the owner; it must be adequate in continuity, in publicity and in extent to show that possession is adverse to the title owner.” 31. Applying these principles, the Defendants’ claim must be examined against the undisputed date of invasion of December 2014 to early 2015, as stated by the Plaintifi and not efiectively rebutted in crossexamination. Even assuming occupation commenced then, by the time Kisii ELC (O.S.) No. 43 of 2015 was filed and later consolidated with this suit in 2019, less than twelve years had elapsed. 32. The Defendants did not demonstrate when their possession became adverse to the Plaintifi’s title. Their own witness, Muhare Joseph admitted in cross-examination that the Plaintifi has consistently asserted ownership and even involved the area chief in resolving the dispute. Such consistent protestation and litigation negate the element of peaceful, uninterrupted possession. Accordingly, the court finds that the Defendants’ occupation of the suit land, having commenced in or about 2014 to 2015, has not ripened into ownership by adverse possession and cannot extinguish the Plaintifi’s registered title. 33. Accordingly, the Court finds that the Defendants’ occupation of the suit land, having commenced in or about 2014 to 2015, has not ripened into ownership by adverse possession and cannot extinguish the Plaintifi’s registered title. 34. I therefore find and hold that the Plaintifi remains the lawful proprietor of LR No. Bukira/ Buhirimonono/933, and that his title has not been extinguished or defeated by the Defendants’ claim. Issue 2: Whether the Defendants’ occupation and sale of portions of the suit land constituted trespass or created any lawful interest in favour of the 6th–8th Defendants 35. Having found that the Plaintifi is the lawful proprietor of Land Parcel No. Bukira/ Buhirimonono/933, it follows that any occupation, use, or interference with the said land by the Defendants can only be lawful if authorized by the Plaintifi, or if it falls within a legally recognized exception such as a registered lease, easement, or other overriding interest. 36. The Plaintifi testified that the Defendants forcefully entered the land in December 2014 and early 2015, built semi-permanent structures, and began cultivating portions of the land without his consent. He stated further that he made reports to the local administration and even sought interim injunctive orders to restrain the Defendants’ continued interference. 37. The Defendants, in response, maintained that they have lived on the land “peacefully and continuously” for over thirty years and have even sold portions thereof to third parties the 6th, 7th and 8th Defendants who are alleged to be bona fide purchasers. However, they did not produce any sale agreements, receipts, or consent to transfer from the Land Control Board to substantiate those transactions. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 6

page 6 of 8

38. The law is clear that only the registered proprietor of agricultural land may lawfully transfer or convey an interest in it, and any transaction in contravention of section 6(1) of the Land Control Act (Cap. 302) is void for all purposes. In the instant case, the 2nd to 5th Defendants were not registered owners and thus lacked capacity to transfer any valid title or interest to the alleged purchasers. 39. The maxim nemo dat quod non habet no one can give what he does not have applies squarely. The 6th to 8th Defendants, being purported purchasers from persons without title, acquired no better interest than their vendors possessed. (See David Peterson Kiengo & 2 Others v Kariuki Thuo [2012] eKLR.) Moreover, there is no evidence that the Plaintifi ever gave consent or permission to the Defendants to occupy, build on, or dispose of portions of the land. His unchallenged testimony is that he has consistently resisted their entry and sought legal redress promptly after the invasion. 40. For a claim of peaceful occupation or equitable interest to stand, the defendants must show that the owner acquiesced or granted an implied licence. In this case, the Plaintifi’s persistent objection negates such inference. The Defendants’ entry was therefore without right or colour of title. Trespass to land is any unjustifiable intrusion by one person upon land in the possession of another. (See Clerk & Lindsell on Torts, 19th Edn, para 18-01.) Once ownership has been established, any unauthorized entry amounts to trespass regardless of motive or duration. 41. The photographs and oral evidence adduced by the Defendants do not establish that their structures are on parcel 933 as opposed to their adjoining family land. No surveyor’s report or expert evidence was produced to verify that the impugned developments lie within the boundaries of the suit property. Even if they did, the occupation remains unlawful and constitutes continuing trespass. 42. The court therefore finds that: the Defendants’ occupation of the Plaintifi’s land since 2014–2015 amounts to trespass; and the purported sale of portions thereof to the 6th–8th Defendants is null and void and confers no legal or equitable interest upon them. 43. Consequently, the continued possession and sale activities by the Defendants are illegal, unjustified, and an infringement of the Plaintifi’s proprietary rights under Article 40 of the Constitution of Kenya and Sections 24 and 25 of the Land Registration Act. Issue 3: What reliefs, if any, should the court grant 44. The Plaintifi, in his Plaint, sought substantive reliefs against the Defendants. He prayed for a permanent injunction restraining the Defendants, their servants and/or agents from trespassing upon Land Parcel No. Bukira/Buhirimonono/933. He further sought an order of eviction against the Defendants and any persons claiming under them, together with costs of the suit and interest thereon. 45. Having found under Issue 1 that the Plaintifi is the lawful registered proprietor of the suit land, and under Issue 2 that the Defendants’ occupation amounts to trespass and that the 6th to 8th Defendants have acquired no lawful or equitable interest therein, the Plaintifi is entitled to the protection of his proprietary rights as envisaged under Sections 24, 25 and 26 of the Land Registration Act. Consequently, the Court finds that the reliefs sought are merited. The Defendants, having no lawful claim to the land, must vacate and deliver vacant possession to the Plaintifi forthwith. The Plaintifi shall also have the costs of this suit and interest thereon as provided by law. F. Final Orders 46. In view of the findings made under Issues 1, 2 and 3, and based on the reliefs sought in the Plaint, the Court hereby makes the following final orders: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 7

page 7 of 8

a. A permanent injunction is hereby issued restraining the Defendants, their servants and/or agents from trespassing upon, cultivating, constructing on, or in any manner interfering with the Plaintifi’s quiet possession and use of Land Parcel No. Bukira/Buhirimonono/933. b. The Defendants and any persons claiming under them shall vacate the suit land within ninety (90) days from the date of this judgment, failing which an order of eviction shall issue without further reference to the Court. c. The Plaintifi shall have the costs of this suit and interest thereon at court rates. DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 31st day of October, 2025. MOHAMMED N. KULLOW JUDGE Judgement delivered in the presence of: N/A for the Applicant N/A for the Respondent Philomena W. Court Assistant https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/7563/eng@2025-10-31 8

page 8 of 8

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.