Ahmed v Luhar & another (Enviromental and Land Originating Summons E1054 of 2013) [2025] KEELC 6361 (KLR) (26 June 2025) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2025] KEELC 6361 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI ENVIROMENTAL AND LAND ORIGINATING SUMMONS E1054 OF 2013 J OMANGE, J JUNE 26, 2025 BETWEEN NURU ABDULLA AHMED .................................................................... APPLICANT AND ARSHAD BEGUM LUHAR .......................................................... 1ST RESPONDENT SANAU KOILAPA ......................................................................... 2ND RESPONDENT RULING 1. 2. On the 18th May 2023, this court on application of the 1st Respondent set aside a Judgement that had declared the Applicant herein the owner of LR 36/11/347 (hereinafter referred to as the suit property) The court in the Ruling issued further directions as follows; a. The Judgement entered against the Plaintifi/Applicant on the 29th April, 2021 herein and all consequential orders arising there from are hereby set aside and the originating summons herein is to be heard and determined afresh subject to clause (b) and (c) below. b. That the matter is to be listed for a case management conference on a priority basis during which a time table for the hearing of the case is to be set which the Applicant/Respondent will be required to strictly adhere to. c. The Applicant/Respondent is pay the Respondent/Applicant thrown away costs of Kshs.100,000 as costs for the application and proceedings which have been set aside. d. In default of compliance with order given in (b) and (c) then the order setting aside the judgement shall automatically lapse without further reference to the Court. The matter subsequently came up for hearing in court on two occasions but could not proceed on account of the Applicants illness. The court was subsequently informed that the Applicants had passed https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/6361/eng@2025-06-26 1
page 1 of 4
away. In the present application dated 11th October,2024, the Applicant has sought for the following orders; a. Spent b. That the Applicant herein Nuru Abdulla Ahmed deceased be substituted with Mohamed Nurow Abdalla who is the Administrator ad litem of the estate of the deceased Applicant. c. That the Honourable Court do issue a conservatory order stopping the 1st Respondent whether by themselves, their servants, employees, agents, any other person and/or body claiming ownership of the suit property under them, any and/or all alleged purchasers of the suit property from all and any further dealings over the suit property including selling, leasing, renting, trespass, alienating, entering, constructing, excavating, fencing, and/or erecting any structures or building thereon pending the hearing and determination of this Application. d. That the Honourable Court do issue a conservatory order stopping the 1st Respondent whether by themselves, their servants, employees, agents, any other person and/or body claiming ownership of the suit property under them, any and/or all alleged purchasers of the suit property from all and any further dealings over the suit property including selling, leasing, renting, trespass, alienating, entering, constructing, excavating, fencing, and/or erecting any structures or building thereon pending the hearing and determination of this suit. e. That the status quo ante be restored over the suit property LR No 36/11/347, 8th Street, Eastleigh, Nairobi County at the time of filing this suit pending the hearing and determination of this suit. f. That the Court do issue an order cancelling the registration entered in the Land Register on 06/06/2023 and issue an inhibition order to prohibit any further entry in respect to LR 36/11/347, situate in Eastleigh, Nairobi County by the Land Registrar until the determination of the main suit herein. g. That the Oficer Commanding Pangani Police Station (O.C.S), Nairobi County be ordered to ensure compliance of the orders herein 3. The application is premised on the grounds that while the court is yet to determine the Applicants claim of adverse possession, the 1st Respondent has in utter disregard of the doctrine of lis pendens transferred the suit property to a third party and that there are ongoing developments on the suit property. The application also seeks to have the deceased applicant substituted with the administrator. 4. The 1st Respondent has filed grounds of opposition dated 7th February 2025 arguing that conservatory, status quo ante and cancellation of title amount to final orders which the court cannot grant at an interlocutory stage. The 1st Respondent also delves into factual matters in the grounds of opposition by stating that she has letters of administration to the estate of the late Hurbai Hussein and hence is entitled to deal with the property. 5. Both parties filed submissions in support of their respective positions. Counsel for the Applicant in the submissions dated 17th February 2025 abandoned the prayers for conservatory orders and instead urged the court to grant the status quo ante orders. Counsel submitted that the applicant had satisfied the ingredients for grant of an injunction to preserve the substratum of the suit. 6. Counsel for the 1st Respondent submitted that the Applicant had failed to satisfy the threshold for grant of a conservatory order. Counsel further argued that there is an appeal against the decision of the court issued on 18th May, 2023 as such the court cannot issue status quo ante. Counsel took issue https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/6361/eng@2025-06-26 2
page 2 of 4
with the orders sought for cancellation of title as they would amount to issuing final orders at an interlocutory stage. 7. Having considered the application, the afidavits filed herein and the submissions the court notes that the Applicant withdrew the prayers for conservatory orders hence the court will not consider the same. The application for substitution is not contested hence is allowed. The only issues then left for the courts determination are;Whether to grant a status quo ante ordersWhether to issue an order cancelling the entry made in the register on 6/6/2023 and whether to issue an inhibition order prohibiting any further entries in respect of the suit property 8. The issue of substitution is straightforward and is not challenged. Order 24 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules states that; “ 1. Where one of two or more plaintifis dies and the cause of action does not survive or continue to the surviving plaintifi or plaintifis alone, or a sole plaintifi or sole surviving plaintifi dies and the cause of action survives or continues, the court, on an application made in that behalf, shall cause the legal representative of the deceased plaintifi to be made a party and shall proceed with the suit. 2. Where within one year no application is made under sub rule (1), the suit shall abate so far as the deceased plaintifi is concerned, and, on the application of the defendant, the court may award to him the costs which he may have incurred in defending the suit to be recovered from the estate of the deceased plaintifi:" 9. The applicant was granted letters of administration ad litem on the 25th September 2024, and this application was made on 11th October 2024, 6 months after the death of the plaintifi hence falls within the 1-year timeline. The prayer for substitution is thus merited and is allowed. 10. The guiding principles for the grant of orders of temporary injunction are well settled and are set out in the judicial decision of Giella v Cassman Brown (1973) EA. This position has been reiterated in numerous decisions from Kenyan courts and more particularly in the case of Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 others CA No.77 of 2012 (2014) eKLR where the Court of Appeal held that; “ in an interlocutory injunction application the Applicant has to satisfy the triple requirements to 11. (a) establishes his case only at a prima facie level, (b) demonstrates irreparable injury if a temporary injunction is not granted and (c) ally any doubts as to b, by showing that the balance of convenience is in his favour. These are the three pillars on which rest the foundation of any order of injunction interlocutory or permanent. It is established that all the above three conditions and states are to be applied as separate distinct and logical hurdles which the applicant is expected to surmount sequentially” Consequently, the applicant ought to, first, establish a prima facie case. The Applicant submitted that he has established a prima facie case and relied on the judicial decision of Mrao Ltd v First American https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/6361/eng@2025-06-26 3
page 3 of 4
Bank of Kenya Ltd (2003) eKLR in which the Court of Appeal gave a determination on a prima facie case. The court stated that: “ In civil cases, it is a case in which, on the material presented to the court a tribunal properly directing itself will conclude that there exists a legal right which has apparently been infringed by the opposite party as to call for an explanation or rebuttal from the latter.” 12. It is my humble view that given that a Judgement had been entered in favour of the Applicant and which was only set aside to allow the Respondents to be heard, is on its own proof of a prima facie case. The Respondent will during the hearing present for consideration the evidence in support of his case. Until this evidence is produced before the court and a determination rendered, the 1st Respondent cannot proceed with the matter as if there is no pending case. There is also an appeal pending in the Court of Appeal against this courts decision to set aside the Judgement. There is real likelihood of harm being meted upon innocent third parties who may purchase the suit property while there is contention over ownership. If successful either in the Court of Appeal or in this court, the Applicant would also sufier irreparable harm if the property will have been disposed of or construction undertaken. 13. In the case of Amir Suleiman v Amboseli Resort Limited [2004] eKLR , the court explained “balance of convenience” thus “ The court in responding to prayers for interlocutory injunctive reliefs should always opt for the lower rather than the higher risk of injustice.” 14. The lower risk in this instance would be that the court take action to secure the suit property while the matter is heard. Consequently the court issues the following orders; a. The Applicant herein Nuru Abdulla Ahmed deceased be substituted with Mohamed Nurow Abdalla who is the Administrator ad litem of the estate of the deceased Applicant. b. The status quo relating in respect of the suit property is to be maintained as it stands today 3rd July, 2025. This means that there should be no transfer of the suit property to any party and neither should there be any construction carried out on the suit property by any of the parties or their agents. c. Costs shall abide the outcome of the main suit RULING SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS ON 26TH OF JUNE, 2025 JUDY OMANGE JUDGE In the presence of:Court Assistant Catherine Ms Swara for Plaintifi Mr. Nchogu for Defendant https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/6361/eng@2025-06-26 4
page 4 of 4