Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

keelc-2025-05987

Ireri & 8 others v Munyi & 50 others (Environment and Land Case E028 of 2022) [2025] KEELC 5987 (KLR) (11 September 2025) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2025] KEELC 5987 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT EMBU ENVIRONMENT AND LAND CASE E028 OF 2022 AK BOR, J SEPTEMBER 11, 2025 BETWEEN JOB IRERI & 8 OTHERS & 8 OTHERS & 8 OTHERS ......................... PLAINTIFF AND MWANIKI MUNYI & 50 OTHERS & 50 OTHERS & 50 OTHERS DEFENDANT RULING 1. There are two applications pending before this court for determination. The first application dated 20/5/2024 was brought by the Plaintifis and seeks orders of inhibition to be registered against the parcels of land known as Mbeti/Gachuriri/2690, 2704, 2674, 3576, 3578, 3577, 3582, 3580, 3579, 3581, 3583, 3784, 3585, 3586, 3587, 3588, 3589, 3590, 3591, 4437, 4438, 4439, 3936, 3935, 3791, 3790, 3789, 5794, 5795, 3784, 3785 and 3786 pending the hearing and determination of the main suit. The Plaintifis also seek leave to amend the plaint dated 2/8/2022 in terms of the attached draft amended plaint and for the draft amended plaint to be deemed as duly filed and properly on record upon payment of the requisite fees. They also seek that the costs of the application be borne by the Defendants. 2. The application was made on the grounds that the court allowed the Plaintifi’s application dated 24/1/2023 seeking orders of inhibition and a court order was issued on 26/1/2024 which order was paid for and registered at the lands ofice on 7/2/2024. They averred that during the pendency of the application, some of the Defendants had adversely dealt with some of the parcels of land comprising the suit land and subdivided some of the portions, transferred the new subdivisions to third parties who are not parties to this suit in a bid to defeat justice, frustrate the Plaintifis’ case and hurriedly make financial gain. They gave the example of Mbeti/Gachuriri/2704, which they claimed that the 1st Defendant transferred to Joseph Mwangi Nthiga on 21/8/2023 while the application was pending. It was the Plaintifis’ contention that when they attempted to register the court order issued on 26/1/2024, the https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/5987/eng@2025-09-11 1

page 1 of 4

order could not be registered against some parcels of land because the court order did not mention the resultant subdivisions. 3. The Plaintifis urged that the new sub-divisions should be inhibited to prevent any further dealings to expedite this matter. They added that the new sub-divisions are registered in the names of proprietors who are not parties to this suit and that it Is necessary that they be made parties to the suit by amendment of plaint. They expressed apprehension that this suit may not be brought to a successful determination if alienation pendete lite prevails as this would not only defeat their case but the matter may not be concluded. They urged that the Land Registration Act empowers this court to inhibit dealings with the suit land and it is imperative that they be granted leave to amend the plaint to include the current registered proprietors of the suit land. 4. The Plaintifis averred that no party will be prejudiced if the application is allowed. Job Ireri, swore the afidavit in support of the application and attached copies of the order issued on 26/1/2024, green cards showing the registration of the orders of inhibition issued on 26/1/2024, the register for parcel 2704, oficial searches for the other parcels of land and a copy of the draft amended plaint. 5. The Defendants opposed the application vide the replying afidavits sworn by John Mwaniki Munyi, the 1st Defendant and the one sworn by the 32nd Defendant, John Winfred Njue Kioi. They deponed that the application is an abuse of the court’s process and a waste of judicial time as the Plaintifis are not keen on the expeditious disposition of this dispute. They averred that the Plaintifis admitted that some parcels of land mentioned were not part of the suit and therefore they were not subject to the orders issued on 26/1/2024, which casts doubt as to the Plaintifis’ claim. John Mwaniki Munyi denied dealing adversely with the land parcels that were the subject of the order of inhibition issued by the court after the order was issued. 6. They contended that the Plaintifis are seeking orders against individuals who are strangers and have not been joined to this suit and who cannot defend themselves against the allegations made against them in the application or any potential orders that may issue against their proprietary interests over the parcels of land in question. They also contended that it would be against the rules of natural justice for the court to issue any orders or entertain an application that afiects persons who were not parties to the suit. That the court already ruled on similar issues on 26/1/2024, and as such, the Plaintifis should not be allowed to prosecute their grievances piecemeal. 7. The second application dated 25/9/2024 was filed by the Defendants seeking to have the court strike out the Plaintifis’ suit. The application was made on the grounds that the Plaintifis misled the court by falsely claiming to be landless and that they had been disinherited by the Chairman of Mbandi Clan, as a result of which the court issued restraining orders against rightful landowners. The Defendants averred that the Plaintifis were closely related, the 1st Plaintifi is the son of the 2nd Plaintifi, and the 3rd to 8th Plaintifis are their cousins. Further, that the 2nd Plaintifi was the chairman of the Mbandi Clan and had been involved as an elder in the land adjudication process within the Mbeere South Adjudication Section and had amassed hundreds of acres of land a fact that he concealed from the court. It was urged that the Plaintifis were direct beneficiaries of the land that the 2nd Plaintifi acquired and each of them is entitled to a portion either collectively or by proxy. 8. Further, the Defendants urged that the Plaintifis have approached this court with unclean hands and that the suit is frivolous, vexatious, and an abuse of the court process. It was also contended that allowing it to proceed will only waste judicial time and will aid the Plaintifis to use the court to frustrate innocent litigants. The court was urged to strike out the plaint. John Winfred Njue Kioi, the 32nd Defendant swore the afidavit in support of the application and attached a bundle of green cards and searches for the various parcels of land said to belong to the 2nd Plaintifi. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/5987/eng@2025-09-11 2

page 2 of 4

9. The 1st, 2nd and 5th Plaintifis on behalf of the 6th, 9th, 4th, 3rd and 8th Plaintifis responded to the application vide a replying afidavit in which they averred that the application is an abuse of the court process and a waste of judicial time as the parcels of land alleged to have been acquired by the 2nd Plaintifi are not the subject of this suit. They aver that the advocate on record for the 32nd and 64th Defendants herein represented the 5th Plaintifi in Embu CMCC 278 of 2015 and is guilty of professional misconduct for using confidential advocate client information in that case to ask for the dismissal of this suit. They stated that the application seeks to summarily dismiss their suit on allegations that have to be heard and determined in the main suit upon interrogating witnesses at the hearing. They contend that the grounds advanced for the dismissal of this suit are baseless, asserting that their case is not frivolous and does in fact disclose a reasonable cause of action. They further explain that the amendment of the plaint was solely intended to join additional parties who have become necessary to the suit as a result of the actions of the original Defendants. They urge the court not to act in darkness by dismissing their suit summarily without the full facts of the case before it. They urged that the Defendant’s application should be dismissed and annexed several documents to support their position. 10. Parties filed and exchanged written submissions, which the court has considered. The Plaintifis submitted that Order 8 rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that the court may at any stage of proceedings allow any party to amend their pleadings on the courts terms as to costs or as the court may direct. They contend that the emended plaint has included the registered owners of the suit lands that form part of the subject matter of the suit and evidence has been adduced that the 1st Defendant did adversely deal with some of the suit lands. That the amendment is sought before the matter proceeds for pretrial and the purpose of the amendment is to allow the court to determine the real issues in controversy between the parties. 11. They further submitted that, on the issue of seeking prohibitory orders, they rely on the lis pendens principle in that it would be impossible that this suit could be brought to a successful determination if alienation pendente lite were permitted to prevail. They contend that the 1st Defendant has already violated the principle as per the green card of land parcel 2704 which indicates that on 21/8/2023, the 1st Defendant transferred the land to Joseph Mwangi Nthiga who is the proposed 53rd Defendant. 12. On the Defendant’s application, they submitted that striking out a suit is a draconian act and a court of law must exercise its discretion as provided for in Order 2 Rule 15(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. They urged that the application requires evidence to substantiate the claim that their suit discloses no reasonable cause of action which they had not established. They urged that the application should be dismissed. 13. The 1st, 3rd and 33rd to 51st Defendants on their part submitted that an order of inhibition is more or less an interlocutory injunction and therefore a party is bound to demonstrate that they have satisfied the conditions set out in Giella v Cassman Brown which the Plaintifis had not met. The court was invited to dismiss the application. 14. On the issue that the Plaintifi’s suit discloses no reasonable cause of action, it was submitted that their claim is premised on the misconception that the Plaintifis are clan members who were unfairly excluded from the distribution of community property. They averred that this notion however, had been dispelled by the fact that the Plaintifis are already in possession of over 100 acres of land, a fact which they deliberately failed to disclose to the court. In those circumstances, it was contended that the suit lacks merit and is not worthy of consideration and the court was accordingly urged to strike it out. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/5987/eng@2025-09-11 3

page 3 of 4

15. The issues for determination are whether the Plaintifis should be granted leave to amend the plaint and whether orders of inhibition ought to be issued, or whether the Defendants’ application to strike out the suit should succeed. 16. On the question of amendment, the court notes that the Plaintifis seek to join parties who are registered as proprietors of some of the parcels created from the subdivision of some of the disputed parcels of land. The amendment is necessary to enable the court to efiectively and conclusively determine the real issues in controversy between the parties. The proposed amendment is also sought at a stage before the matter has proceeded for pretrial, the Defendants have not demonstrated any prejudice they stand to sufier if the amendment is allowed. The prayer for amendment is merited. 17. It is evident from the material placed before the court that certain dealings with the suit properties have taken place during the pendency of this suit. Unless restrained, such actions are likely to prolong the disposal of the suit. It is necessary to preserve the substratum of the suit pending its determination. 18. Regarding the Defendants’ application to strike out the plaint, the court is not persuaded that the Plaintifis’ claim does not disclose a reasonable cause of action. The grounds raised by the Defendants touch on substantive issues of fact which can only be determined at the hearing of the suit. 19. The Plaintifis’ application dated 20/5/2024 is allowed. Leave is granted to amend the plaint, and the draft amended plaint will be deemed as duly filed upon payment of the requisite court fees. 20. An order of inhibition is issued over the suit parcels as set out in the application pending the hearing and determination of this suit. The Defendants’ application dated 25/9/2024 is dismissed. 21. The costs of both applications shall abide the outcome of the main suit. DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 11TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2025. K. BOR JUDGE In the presence of: Mr. I. Kiplimo holding brief for Mr. J. Kiongo for the 2nd Defendant Mr. Paul Bulowa for all the Defendants except the 2nd and 32nd Defendants Mr. Dennis Mungai for the 32nd Defendant No appearance for the Plaintifi https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2025/5987/eng@2025-09-11 4

page 4 of 4

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.

keelc-2025-05987 — Original judgment | Caselaw