Olango v Agoro & another (Environment & Land Case 40 of 2019) [2023] KEELC 21279 (KLR) (7 November 2023) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2023] KEELC 21279 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT BUSIA ENVIRONMENT & LAND CASE 40 OF 2019 BN OLAO, J NOVEMBER 7, 2023 BETWEEN STEPHEN OUMA OLANGO .................................................................... PLAINTIFF AND ELIZABETH S. AGORO ................................................................... 1ST DEFENDANT NATHAN MWEMA ........................................................................ 2ND DEFENDANT JUDGMENT 1. Stephen Ouma Olango (the plainti) approached this court vide his plaint dated May 21, 2019 and led herein on May 29, 2019 seeking against Elizabeth S. Agoro and Nathan Mwema (the 1st and 2nd defendants respectively), judgment against them jointly and severally in the following terms; 1. An order of eviction. 2. An order of rectication of the plainti’s boundary with the defendants. 3. Cost. 2. The basis of the plainti’s case is that he is the owner of the land parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/3101 (the suit land) measuring 0.12 hectares while the 1st defendant who is the wife to the 2nd defendant is the owner of the land parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/6297 measuring 0.15 hectares. The plainti claims that the defendants have jointly, unlawfully and illegally encroached onto the plainti’s land thus necessitating this suit. 3. Together with the plaint the plainti led his statement and lists of documents in support of his case. 4. In his statement dated May 21, 2019, he conrms that he is the registered proprietor of the suit land having purchased it in 2003 from one Joseph Wanyama Okaya and has occupied it since 2015. That in 2009, the 2nd defendant up-rooted the boundary hedge which had been planted by the surveyor and https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/21279/eng@2023-11-07 1
page 1 of 5
that the 1st defendant’s Land Parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/6297 does not even appear on the map. The incident was reported to the area Assistant Chief but when summoned, the 1st defendant did not turn up. Instead, in 2014 and 2019, the 2nd defendant again interfered with the boundary thereby restricting the plainti’s access. In 2018, the plainti reported the matter to the Land Registrar who visited the site and ruled that boundary should remain as they were despite noting that defendant’s boundary was un-clear. 5. The plainti led the following documents as per the list dated May 21, 2019: 1. Copy of Certicate of Search for the Land Parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/3101. 2. Copy of Certicate of Search for the Land Parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/6297. 3. Copy of mutation form for the Land Parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/2228. 4. Copy of minutes of Boundary dispute hearing by the Land Registrar in respect to the land parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/3101 and 6207 dated February 1, 2018. 5. Copy a Report by Geomap Surveying Consultants dated January 11, 2019. 6. Map. 6. The plainti led two other lists of documents dated August 28, 2020 and July 7, 2022. 7. In the list dated August 28, 2020, the plainti annexed the following documents: 8. 1. Mutation Form for land parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/1573. 2. Demand letter by Obwoge Onsongo & Company Advocates dated November 11, 2014. In the list dated July 7, 2022, the plainti annexed the following documents: 1. Surveyor’s report for the Land Parcels No Bukhayo/Bugengi/3101, 6297, 2878 and 1512 dated July 13, 2022. 2. Mutation Form for Land Parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/1512 registered on August 2, 1998. 3. Map. 9. The defendants led separates defences. 10. In her defences dated October 18, 2019 and led on October 22, 2019, the 1st defendant denied that the 2nd defendants is her husband. She conrmed however that she is the owner of the land parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/6297. She denied having trespassed onto the suit land and put the plainti to strict proof thereof adding that she occupies a distinct portion of her land and has never encroached onto the suit land. She added further that she has been in possession of her land long before the plainti bought the suit land and that she established the boundaries thereof as per the survey which was conducted during the purchase and which is still in existence to-date and at no time has she trespassed onto the suit land. She asked this court to dismiss the plainti’s suit with costs. 11. In her witness statement dated September 2, 2020, she stated that she bought two adjacent parcels of land from Seferio Mose Eromoto and Vincent Ochebo Emoroto between 1997 and 1999. That the plainti also purchased the suit land from the same family but much later than her. 12. The 1st defendant states that since the two parcels of land she bought were adjacent, she combined them. There was no dispute over boundaries until the plainti suddenly brought up the issue with the https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/21279/eng@2023-11-07 2
page 2 of 5
chief. The Chief made a decision and also invited the Land Registrar and Surveyor who conrmed the decision to the eect that the boundary was intact and did not need adjustments. 13. The 1st defendant led a list of documents dated May 30, 2022 to which was annexed the following: 1. Copy of the Boundary dispute hearing report in respect of the land parcel NoBukhayo/ Bugengi/3101 and 6297 dated February 1, 2018. 14. The 2nd defendant led his defence dated August 5, 2019 in which he denied all the averments levelled against him in the plaint adding that they do not disclose any cause of action against him and the suit oends the mandatory provisions of Order 3 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Preliminary Objection would be raised. He further questioned the jurisdiction on this court to determine this dispute adding that it is a boundary dispute which ought to be entertained by the Land Registrar in accordance with the provisions of Sections 16(1), 18(2) and 79(1) of the Land Registration Act. 15. In his statement dated August 19, 2020, he conrmed that between 1997 and 1999, he was a witness when the 1st defendant purchased various parcels of land from Seferio Mose Eromoto and Vincent Ochebo Emoroto which parcels were subsequently combined. That the 1st defendant also bought land from the same family but much earlier than the plainti. That there was no dispute over boundary until later on when the plainti raised the issue of boundaries which was resolved by the chief and Local Administration. The plainti was not satised by the decision of the chief and invited the Land Registrar and surveyor who adopted the chief’s decision. 16. The hearing of the case commenced before Omollo J on November 29, 2021 when the plainti testied. 17. I took over the trial on October 12, 2022 and heard the plaintis witness Daniel Betteshazzar Songwa (PW2) and subsequently the case for the 1st defendant. The 2nd defendant did not testify. 18. Both the parties adopted as their evidence the contents of their respective statements and produced the documents led herein. 19. In support of the plainti’s case Daniel Betteshazzar Songwa (PW2) who described himself as a Surveyor working with the rm of Kapanga Land Surveys & Consultants recalled how he had received instructions to carry out a survey on the suit land. He told the court that the suit land, as per his report dated June 13, 2022 and which he produced as part of the plainti’s documentary evidence, has been encroached upon. 20. Submission were thereafter led by Mr J V Juma instructed by the rm of J V Juma & Company Advocates for the plainti and by Mr Okeyo instructed by the rm of Okeyo & Company Advocates for the defendants. I wish to place it on record, however, that although Mr Okeyoled his submission on behalf of both defendants, he is on record only for the 1st defendant. The rm of D K Nabulindo & Company Advocates are on record for the 2nd defendant. Indeed on September 18, 2023, Mr Okeyo told the court that he was holding brief for Ms Nabulindo for the 1st defendant. 21. I have considered the evidence by the parties as well as the submission by the counsel for the plainti and the 1st defendant. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/21279/eng@2023-11-07 3
page 3 of 5
22. The plainti’s claim is that the defendants have jointly trespassed on to the suit land. The Trespass Act provides in Section 3 (1) that: “ Any person who without reasonable excuse enters, is or remains upon, or erects any structure on, or cultivates or tills, or grazes stock or permits stock to be on, private land without the consent of the occupier thereof shall be guilty of an oence.” In Black’s Law Dictionary 10Th Edition, it is dened as: “ An unlawful act committed against the person or property of another; especially wrongful entry on another’s real property.” In Clark & Lindsell on Tort 18Th Edition, it is dened thus: “ Any unjustiable intrusion by one person upon the land in possession of another.” Before I delve into the gist of the plainti’s claim, an issue of jurisdiction was raised by the 2nd defendant in paragraph 7 of his defence as follows: “ In further reply to paragraph 6 of the plaint, the 2nd defendant will raise a Preliminary Objection on a point of law that his Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the claim herein as this is a boundary dispute which ought to be entertained by the Land Registrar as provided for under Section 16(1), Section 18(2) and Section 79(1) of the Land Registration Act Cap 300 Laws of Kenya and Plainti is put on notice.” It is true that Section 18(2) of the Land Registration Act divests this Court of the jurisdiction to determine a boundary dispute involving registered land. That is the mandate of the Land Registrar. I have however read the report of the Land Registrar Busia Mr Tom M. Chepkwesi dated February 1, 2018 and which is led as the 1st defendant’s documentary evidence. The relevant portion of that report reads: “ The lower part of the dispute relates to the boundary between the complainant’s parcel with another number allegedly arising from the sub-division of Bukhayo/Bugengi/2878 and according to testimonies, was formally owned by the late Vincent Ochebo ... As to this boundary, it is clear that the boundary currently in place is authentic safe (sic) for the lower portion which is unclear owing to the circumstances noted above. Order: Boundaries will be retained as currently established.” Emphasis mine. It is clear from the above that if there is any boundary dispute involving the suit land, then it only involves the parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/2878 which is not a subject of these proceedings. And we cannot marry into these proceedings land parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/2878 because the proprietor is not a party herein. 23. During the proceeding before the Land Registrar, the plainti’s complaint against the defendant was trespass into the suit land. This is captured in his own words thus: “ The accused had fenced her land using cedar poles but I was of view that the boundary was not correctly established .... https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/21279/eng@2023-11-07 4
page 4 of 5
I pray that a re-survey is done and to conrm and correct the boundary. That is all.” It is clear from the plainti’s own complaint, and the ndings of the Land Registrar as captured above, that the boundary between the suit land and the 1st defendant’s land is in place and is “authentic”. Indeed, the plainti was requesting a “re-survey”. The Land Registrar having conrmed that there is an “authentic” boundary, and that being the mandate of the Land Registrar, it follows that this is not a boundary dispute. This becomes a case of trespass and this Court is therefore seized of the requisite jurisdiction. 24. The onus was therefore on the plainti, as provided for under Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evident Act, to prove that indeed the defendants had trespassed onto the suit land. He called as his star witness DanielBetteshazzar Songwa (PW2) who started by introducing himself as a surveyor working with the rm of Kapanga Land Surveys & Consultants. The witness produced as part of the plainti’s documentary evidence, a report dated June 13, 2022 in which it is stated in the last paragraph as follows: “ I therefore conclude that parcel No Bukhayo/Bugengi/3101 has been encroached upon.” However, when he was cross-examined by Mr Okeyo on October 12, 2022, he said: “ I am not licensed but I am attached to a surveyor. I do not have a license myself.” It turned out that even the report did not have the name of the person who prepared it. Clearly therefore, even if the witness had signed the report, it is not of any probative value to the plainti’s case having been prepared by an unqualied person. 25. Most signicantly, when the plainti was cross-examined by Mr Okeyo on November 29, 2021, he said: “ My pleadings does not state extent of encroachment ... The report doesn’t indicate that 6297 has encroached on my land. Part of my complaint is that the 1st defendant has planted kayabas which grow and extend to my path.” 26. Trespass is a fact to be observed on the land. One would have expected the plainti to at least produce photographs of the “kayaba which grow and extend to my path”. He did not do so. In any event, his path and the land parcel No Bukhayo/Bungengi/6297 cannot mean one and the same thing. 27. The totality of the plainti’s evidence, taken together with the report by the Land Registrar dated February 1, 2018 shows clearly that he has failed to discharge the burden of proving his case. 28. The up-shot of all the above is that the plainti’s suit is dismissed with costs to the defendants. JUDGMENT DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED ON THIS 7TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2023 BY WAY OF ELECTRONIC MAIL. Right of Appeal BOAZ N. OLAO JUDGE https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/21279/eng@2023-11-07 5
page 5 of 5