Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Mai Mahiu Kijabe Longonot Co Ltd v Kariuki & 6 others

Mai Mahiu Kijabe Longonot Co Ltd v Kariuki & 6 others (Environment & Land Case 36 of 2017) [2023] KEELC 17979 (KLR) (7 June 2023) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2023] KEELC 17979 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAKURU ENVIRONMENT & LAND CASE 36 OF 2017 FM NJOROGE, J JUNE 7, 2023 BETWEEN MAI MAHIU KIJABE LONGONOT CO LTD ........................................ PLAINTIFF AND WINFRED MUTHONI KARIUKI ................................................. 1ST DEFENDANT BENSON IRUNGU KARIUKI ....................................................... 2ND DEFENDANT ALICE WANGUI KARIUKI ........................................................... 3RD DEFENDANT JOSEPH KIMANI KABAIKU ......................................................... 4TH DEFENDANT SAMMY MWICIGI .......................................................................... 5TH DEFENDANT HANNAH NJERI ............................................................................. 6TH DEFENDANT GATERE KARIUKI ......................................................................... 7TH DEFENDANT RULING 1. This ruling is in respect of the defendants Notice of Motion application dated February 27, 2023 expressed to be brought under order 40 rule 1, order 42 rule 6(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules and Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act which sought the following orders: a. Spent b. Spent c. That there be a stay of execution of the judgement of Justice Mwangi Njoroge delivered on 9th February 2023 pending hearing and determination of the applicant’s intended appeal against the whole of the judgement. d. That costs of this application be provided for. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17979/eng@2023-06-07 1

page 1 of 5

2. The application is supported by the adavit of Mary Muthoni Kariuki sworn on February 27, 2023. The grounds on the face of the application and the supporting adavit are that the defendants had led an originating summons seeking to be declared the owners of LR No 1144/17/XXIV through adverse possession; that the plainti on the other hand led a claim against the defendants seeking that they be evicted from the suit property; that the matters were consolidated, heard and judgement delivered on February 9, 2023; that the court in its judgement dismissed the defendants originating summons, allowed the respondent’s suit and issued orders of eviction against them; that the defendants were dissatised with the judgement of the court and lodged a Notice of Appeal and also requested for typed proceedings; that the defendants are intent on appealing the said judgement and should the plainti execute the judgement, their appeal will be rendered nugatory; that the defendants stand to suer great nancial loss as they have made nancial inputs in order to maintain the building located on the suit property; that the intended appeal is arguable and will be rendered nugatory if the orders sought are not granted; that the plainti will not suer prejudice if the orders sought are granted and that it is fair and just that the application be allowed. 3. In response to the said application, the plainti led grounds of opposition dated 7/03/2023 and a replying adavit sworn by Patrick Ndungu Kuria on the same date. Both the grounds of opposition and the replying adavit were led on 9/03/2023. 4. The grounds of opposition are as follows: 5. a. That the applicants have not either in the application or in the adavit shown that they will suer a substantial loss unless the order of stay is granted. b. That no decree has been extracted and none was attached to the application. c. That the ultimate decree requires the applicants to vacate the suit property on the basis that they are trespassers and in the event that they succeed in the appeal, the land shall still be available. In other words, the appeal shall not be rendered nugatory. d. That the second part of the ultimate decree is payment of Kshs 1,000,000/= and costs to the respondent. It has not been demonstrated that the respondent shall not be able to refund the said sum in the event that the applicants succeed in the intended appeal. e. That the applicants have not oered any security in terms of costs and the judgement sum to the respondent. f. That it has not been demonstrated that the applicants have any arguable appeal. No memorandum of appeal was attached and mere statement that there is an arguable appeal is not sucient. g. That the justice of the case demands that the respondent should reap the fruits of its judgement and should not be denied from doing so without demonstrable and congent reasons. In the replying adavit led by the respondent, Patrick Ndung’u Kuria reiterated the grounds in the grounds of opposition and averred that the orders intended to be appealed from relate to LR No 1144/17/XXIV; that the defendants had testied that they do not live on the suit property; that the suit premises on the suit property is rented out; that no substantial loss can arise from a business premises as they can be compensated if they succeed in the intended appeal; that the defendants have not oered any security for costs and since they have not annexed their Memorandum of Appeal they have not demonstrated that they have an arguable appeal. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17979/eng@2023-06-07 2

page 2 of 5

Submissions 6. The defendants led their submissions dated 4/04/2023 and led on April 11, 2023 while the plainti led its submissions dated April 20, 2023 on the same date. 7. The defendants in their submissions set out the background and submitted on whether stay of execution should be granted pending the hearing and determination of their intended appeal. The defendants relied on Order 46 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules and submitted that they need only demonstrate that their application has been made without unreasonable delay, whether they will suer substantial loss unless the stay order is made and readiness to deposit security for the due performance of the decree of the court in order to succeed in their application. 8. The defendants relied on the cases of Peter Ondande T/A Spreawett Chemis vs Josephine Wangari Karanja [2006] eKLR, Kisiang’ani Tulienge and 2 others vs Paul Wafula and 2 others [1998] eKLR and submitted that their application was led without unreasonable delay as judgement in the matter was delivered on February 9, 2023 and they led their application on February 28, 2023. On whether they are likely to suer substantial loss if the stay orders are not granted, the defendants submitted that they are likely to be evicted from the suit property which would render their appeal nugatory. They relied on the cases of Ann Wanjiru Waigwa & Another vs Joseph Kiragu Kibarua [2009] eKLR, James Wangalwa and another vs Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR in support of their arguments. 9. On the issue of security, the defendants submitted that they are ready and willing to comply with any conditions that this court may set in issuance of orders of stay of execution orders. In response to the plainti’s grounds of opposition and replying adavit, the defendants submitted that Article 159(2) (d) of the Constitution of Kenya mandates the court to ensure that justice is administered without undue regard to technicalities and this was in response to the contention that their application is bad in law for failure to attach a copy of the extracted decree. They concluded their submissions by seeking that their application be allowed as prayed. 10. The plainti in its submissions relied on Order 42 Rule 1(1) and (2) of the Civil Procedure Rules and submitted that the defendants have not demonstrated that they will suer substantial loss if the orders sought are not granted. The Plainti also relied on the case of Kenya Shell Limited versus Benjamin Karuga Kibiru, Ruth Wairimu Karuga Nairobi Court of Appeal Civil Application No 97 of 1986 reiterated that the defendants have not attached a draft Memorandum of Appeal to enable the court determine if they have an arguable appeal even though it is not a requirement under Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. The plainti then sought that the defendant’s application be dismissed with costs. Analysis and determination 11. After considering the application, the responses thereto and the submissions, the only issue that arises for determination is whether the court should grant orders of stay of execution pending appeal. 12. Order 42 Rule 6 (1) and (2) of the Civil Procedure Rules provides as follows: (1) No appeal or second appeal shall operate as a stay of execution or proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except in so far as the court appealed from may order but, the court appealed from may for sucient cause order stay of execution of such decree or order, and whether the application for such stay shall have been granted or refused by the court appealed from, the court to which such appeal is preferred shall be at liberty, on application being made, to consider such application and to make such order thereon as may to it seem just, and any https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17979/eng@2023-06-07 3

page 3 of 5

person aggrieved by an order of stay made by the court from whose decision the appeal is preferred may apply to the appellate court to have such order set aside. 13. (2) No order for stay of execution shall be made under subrule (1) unless— (a) the court is satised that substantial loss may result to the applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and (b) such security as the court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the applicant. The court in the case of Civil Appeal No107 of 2015, Masisi Mwita v Damaris Wanjiku Njeri (2016) eKLR held as follows: “ The application must meet a criteria set out in precedents and the criteria is best captured in the case of Halal & another v Thornton & Turpin Ltd, where the Court of Appeal (Gicheru JA, Chesoni and Cockar Ag JA) held that:“The High Court’s discretion to order stay of execution of its Order or Decree is fettered by three conditions, namely; - Sucient Cause, substantial loss would ensue from a refusal to grant stay, the Applicant must furnish security, the application must be made without unreasonable delay.” In addition, the Applicant must demonstrate that the intended Appeal will be rendered nugatory if stay is not granted as was held in Hassan Guyo Wakalo v Straman EA Ltd (2013) as follows:“ In addition, the Applicant must prove that if the orders sought are not granted and his Appeal eventually succeeds, then the same shall have been rendered nugatory.” These twin principles go hand in hand and failure to prove one dislodges the other.” 14. On whether the application was led without unreasonable delay, the plainti led the present application on February 28, 2023 while judgement was delivered on February 9, 2023. There is a Notice of Appeal annexed to the defendant’s application dated February 14, 2023 and lodged on the same day. It is therefore my view that that for the purposes of this application, there is an appeal in place and the application was led without unreasonable delay. 15. On whether the defendants will stand to suer substantial loss, the defendants argued that the court in its judgement issued orders for eviction and that since they have spent money in maintaining the building that is standing on the suit property, they stand to suer great nancial loss if their application is not granted. The plainti on the other hand argued that during the hearing of the case, the defendants testied that they did not live on the suit property as the building on the land is rented out and therefore they cannot suer any substantial loss that cannot be compensated if their intended appeal succeeded. 16. The court in the case of Elishaphan Omollo Nyasita v Gradus Atieno Othim & another [2019] eKLR held as follows: “ 11. It is trite law that it is not merely sucient for the applicant to state that he or rather she is likely to suer substantial loss if the application for stay of execution sought is not allowed. The applicant has not shown the damage or loss that he is likely to suer if the order sought in the application is not granted. Moreover, to grant the order aforesaid would https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17979/eng@2023-06-07 4

page 4 of 5

deny a successful litigant (respondent) the fruits of his judgment as held in Kenya Shell Ltd case (supra).” 17. It is my view that the defendants in this matter have not demonstrated the substantial loss that they are likely to suer if the orders sought are not granted. Consequently, their application dated February 27, 2023 lacks merit and it is hereby dismissed with costs. DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAKURU VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL ON THIS 7TH DAY OF JUNE, 2023. MWANGI NJOROGE JUDGE, ELC, NAKURU https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17979/eng@2023-06-07 5

page 5 of 5

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.