Seventh Day Adventist Church (E.A) v Saina & 7 others (Environment & Land Case 120 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 4871 (KLR) (20 September 2022) (Ruling) Neutral citation: [2022] KEELC 4871 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT KAPSABET ENVIRONMENT & LAND CASE 120 OF 2021 MN MWANYALE, J SEPTEMBER 20, 2022 BETWEEN SEVENTH DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH (E.A .................................... APPLICANT AND CHRISTOPHER K. SAINA .......................................................... 1ST RESPONDENT JOSEPH KOGO .............................................................................. 2ND RESPONDENT JULIA BIRIR .................................................................................. 3RD RESPONDENT MOSES OCHOLA .......................................................................... 4TH RESPONDENT NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION ............................................ 5TH RESPONDENT LAND REGISTRAR, NANDI COUNTY ................................... 6TH RESPONDENT COUNTY GOVERNMENT .......................................................... 7TH RESPONDENT ATTORNEY GENERAL ............................................................... 8TH RESPONDENT RULING 1. This ruling is in respect of the Notice of Motion application dated 30th May 2022 seeking that the Applicant be granted leave to further amend its plaint by replacing the 3rd Defendant Julia Birir with Priscillah Jepkemboi; and a further prayer that the annexed draft further amended plaint be deemed as properly led and served subject to payment of requisite Court ling fees. 2. The grounds in support of the application is that the person who ought to have been sued as 3rd Defendant is Priscillah Jepkemboi as opposed to the current 3rd Defendant Julia Birir. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/4871/eng@2022-09-20 1
page 1 of 2
3. The Application is further supported by the annexed Supporting Adavit of the Advocate Ms. Isiaho Sawe; who reiterates the grounds in support of the application and specically depones that the amendment is meant to determine the real issues in controversy. 4. Ms. Odeyo Counsel for 5th, 6th and 8th Defendants/Respondents as well as Ms. Kogo for the 7th Defendant are not opposed to the application however Mr. Ngigi Mbugua for the 1st and 2nd Defendants/Respondent opposed the Application. 5. A replying adavit by the 1st Defendant was led. In the said adavit; the 1st Defendant in opposition to the application states the time for substitution has lapsed, since the certicate of lease was issued on July 2002. 6. Parties led written submissions in respect of the application. I have considered the application before Court, the response to the application, the submissions and the law relation to substitution. 7. The suit herein was led in Eldoret ELC in 2017 and transferred to Kapsabet ELC in 2021. The suit has not yet been heard although it is ready for hearing. The assertion by the Respondent that it has taken 20 years to bring in an application for substitution is therefore misleading. 8. An Amendment can be made at any stage of the suit before Judgment, so as to bring the real issued in dispute to the light. 9. I have also perused the draft amended plaint, and other than the substitution, no new cause of action against the 3rd Defendant has been pleaded. 10. The proposed 3rd Defendant shall have any opportunity to le a defence and plead Limitation of Actions, if need be, and it’s not for the 1st and 2nd Defendants to plead that on her behalf. 11. Accordingly in order to bring the real issue in controversy to light. The Application for substitution is hereby allowed and the draft amended plaint is deemed as duly led upon payment of Court fees. 12. The amended plaint to be served on the 3rd Defendant within 7 days from date hereof, the Defendant to enter appearance in line with the Civil Procedure Rules. 13. Orders accordingly. DATED AT KAPSABET THIS 20TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2022. HON. M. N. MWANYALE, JUDGE In the presence of; Mr. Ngigi Mbugua for the 1st and 2nd Defendant/Respondents Mr. Siboe holding brief for Ms. Isiaho Sawe for Plainti/applicant https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/4871/eng@2022-09-20 2
page 2 of 2