Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Ngaruiya & another v Kajiado & 2 others (Environment & Land Case 69 of 2018) [2022] KEELC 3490 (KLR)

Ngaruiya & another v Kajiado & 2 others (Environment & Land Case 69 of 2018) [2022] KEELC 3490 (KLR) (19 May 2022) (Judgment) Neutral citation: [2022] KEELC 3490 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT KAJIADO ENVIRONMENT & LAND CASE 69 OF 2018 MN GICHERU, J MAY 19, 2022 BETWEEN MUNGAI NGARUIYA ......................................................................... 1ST PLAINTIFF ELIZABETH WANJIKU NGARUIYA ............................................... 2ND PLAINTIFF AND LAND REGISTRAR, KAJIADO ..................................................... 1ST DEFENDANT ATTORNEY GENERAL ................................................................. 2ND DEFENDANT BENJAMIN GACHAGUA NYAGA ................................................ 3RD DEFENDANT JUDGMENT 1. 2. Mungai Ngaruiya and Elizabeth Ngaruiya, the plaintifis, seek the following reliefs against the Land Registrar Kajiado, the Attorney General and Benjamin Gachagua Nyaga, the first, second and third defendants respectively; a. A declaration that the plaintifis are the legal owners of LR Kajiado/Kitengela/4130, suit land. b. An order compelling the District Land Registrar Kajiado to rectify and amend the green card to the suit land and restore the plaintifis as the legal owners of the suit land. c. An order revoking any title deed issued to the third defendant. d. Costs of the suit. e. Any other relief that the court may deem just to grant. The plaintifis case is as follows; they are the registered owners of the suit land which they purchased at an auction. The land had been charged with Kenya Commercial Bank by one Reuben Ole Nakuo. The plaintifis paid Kshs 2.5 million. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/3490/eng@2022-05-19 1

page 1 of 3

They obtained the necessary consent from the relevant Land Control Board and took possession of the land from May 26, 2005. They have never lost possession. They were also issued with a title deed. They also put up concrete pillars on the land. During a routine search, the plaintifis found out that the green card had the name of Benjamin Gachagua Nyagah. This person was unknown to the plaintifis. They had not sold their land to the third defendant or any other person. They still had possession of the land and the original title deed thereto. They made a report to the first defendant who did not take any action to rectify the anomaly. They also made a report to Criminal Investigations Department at Kajiado and the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission in Nairobi. Finally, the plaintifis filed this action seeking the above reliefs. 3. 4. In support of their case, the plaintifis filed the following evidence; a. First plaintifis witness statement dated 20/2/2020. b. Copy of letter to the Attorney General dated 2/7/2015. c. Copies of letters to the Land Registrar Kajiado. d. Copy of Title Deed for the suit land dated 26/5/2005. e. Copy of the green card dated 6/9/2013. f. Copy of certificate of oficial search dated 8/2/2012 showing the plaintifis as the registered proprietors of the suit land. g. Copy of letter by the Attorney General to the Principal Secretary Ministry of Lands dated 14/7/2015. h. Copy of transfer by chargee to the plaintifis dated May 2, 2005. i. Copy of letter of consent dated 11/5/2005 from the Land Control Board authorizing the transfer of the suit to the plaintifis. j. Copy of cheque dated 30/3/2005 for stamp duty amounting to Kshs 50,000/=. The first and second defendants filed a written statement of defence dated June 14, 2016 in which they denied the averments in the plaintifis plaint. Vide paragraph 5, they aver that the transfer, if any, was done in good faith and upon representation of the plaintifi. They also stated that the suit ofiends the mandatory provisions of section 13A of the Government Proceedings Act. No witness statement or document was filed by the defendants. The third defendant did not file anything in this case. There was no memorandum of appearance or a defence by this defendant. 5. At the trial on October 28, 2020 the first plaintifi testified and produced five (5) of his exhibits. Then on 11/3/2021, Mr Tanui the Land Registrar, Kajiado, testified and said that the entry of the third defendant’s name on the green card of the suit land was suspicious. The Land Registrar requested the Criminal Investigation Department to investigate. The third defendant did not appear to produce his title deed at the Land Registry. He also confirmed that no stamps duty was paid by the third defendant. 6. The plaintifis’ counsel filed written submission on 28/5/202 while the counsel for the first and second defendants filed hers on June 7, 2021. https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/3490/eng@2022-05-19 2

page 2 of 3

In the defendants’ submissions, it is said that no fraud has been proved by the plaintifi and since he is in possession, he has not sufiered any loss to warrant the award of costs. On the other hand, the plaintifis’ counsel urges that the plaintifis’ suit has been proved on a balance of probabilities and they are entitled to all the orders sought. 7. I have carefully considered all the evidence adduced in this case by both sides including the witness statements, the documents and the oral testimony at the trial. I have also considered the submissions by learned counsel for the parties and the issues raised therein. I make the following findings; Firstly, the plaintifis have proved that they purchased the suit land in a lawful transaction and that they followed all the necessary procedures in acquiring the title to the suit land. The oral evidence by the first plaintifi is credible, consistent, backed by documentary evidence and uncontroverted by any evidence from any of the defendants. Secondly, the third defendant though appearing in the register of the suit land at entry number 7, such entry dated 15/9/2010 has been proved to be fraudulent both by the evidence of the first plaintifi and that of the Land Registrar, Mr Tonui. Such entry is not supported by mandatory documents like evidence of payment of stamp duty, consent of the Land Control Board, transfer instrument, agreement for sale and land etcetera. Without these documents, the entry is fraudulent. Thirdly, such fraud was perpetrated by oficials of the Land Registry and no efiort was made by the Land Registry to explain which of its oficers countersigned the fraudulent entry. For the above reasons, I enter judgment for the plaintifis against the defendants jointly and severally as prayed for in the amended plaint dated November 1, 2019. Order accordingly. DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT KAJIADO THIS 19TH DAY OF MAY, 2022. M.N. GICHERU JUDGE https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/3490/eng@2022-05-19 3

page 3 of 3

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.