Mwangi & 16 others v Nyemukia Developers Company Limited (Enviromental and Land Originating Summons 209 of 2016) [2020] KEELC 3987 (KLR) (16 September 2020) (Judgment) Jamlick Mwangi & 16 others v Nyemukia Developers Company Ltd [2020] eKLR Neutral citation: [2020] KEELC 3987 (KLR) REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI ENVIROMENTAL AND LAND ORIGINATING SUMMONS 209 OF 2016 AK BOR, J SEPTEMBER 16, 2020 BETWEEN JAMLICK MWANGI ............................................................................ 1ST PLAINTIFF ERICK KANGETHE ........................................................................... 2ND PLAINTIFF MARY WAMAITHA ............................................................................ 3RD PLAINTIFF GEOFFREY MUCHENE (SUING AS CHAIRMAN KAMUINGI SELF HELP GROUP) ................................................................................................. 4TH PLAINTIFF MWANGI MBUTHIA .......................................................................... 5TH PLAINTIFF MARY NDIRIMA ................................................................................ 6TH PLAINTIFF LYDIA NYAMBUA KIMEMIA ........................................................... 7TH PLAINTIFF ELIZABETH ATEKA ........................................................................... 8TH PLAINTIFF DAVID KINYANJUI MUNGAI .......................................................... 9TH PLAINTIFF PETER NJUGUNA KAMAU ............................................................ 10TH PLAINTIFF MARY WAMBUI KINYANJUI ......................................................... 11TH PLAINTIFF CAROLINE MUGURE KIRAGU .................................................... 12TH PLAINTIFF RUTH WAIRIMU NJOROGE .......................................................... 13TH PLAINTIFF PETER MARURI NGOCHE ............................................................ 14TH PLAINTIFF FRANCIS KAMAU NJUGUNA ....................................................... 15TH PLAINTIFF HEZEKIEL MBIRA KIMENDE ....................................................... 16TH PLAINTIFF SIMON PETER MWANGI ................................................................ 17TH PLAINTIFF https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/3987/eng@2020-09-16 1
page 1 of 3
AND NYEMUKIA DEVELOPERS COMPANY LIMITED .......................... DEFENDANT JUDGMENT 1. The Plaintifis filed suit on 4/3/2016 claiming they were members of the Defendant from whom they acquired portions of land, which they contended that the Defendant was selling to unsuspecting members of the public to the detriment of the Plaintifis. They claimed that they had paid all the requisite fees to the Defendant and sought an order to compel the Defendant to release the Plaintifis’ letters of allotment for the parcels of land, deed plans and duly executed transfer forms. They sought vacant possession of the land and a permanent injunction to stop the Defendant or its agent from developing or interfering with the suit parcels in the manner that it would prejudice the interests of the Plaintifis. 2. The Defendant did not file a defence and the hearing of this case proceeded on 2/7/2020 when the 2nd Plaintifi testified and produced various documents. These included the list said to be that of members of the Defendant’s company; some occupational certificates issued by the Defendant to some of the Plaintifis; copies of receipts showing the payments made for the plots and various correspondence. 3. Looking at the documents produced by the Plaintifis, the list of shareholders did not give any land reference number and only referred to plot numbers and identified the type of plots as either residential, commercial, church, nursery, social hall or church with some refiected as gift plot and s/share plot. The occupational certificates and receipts issued by the Defendant to the Plaintifis only referred to plot numbers without giving the land reference number. 4. The 2nd Plaintifi referred to L.R. No. 7340/157 and 7340/173 Mavoko in his witness statement and only produced a copy of the first page of the certificate of title over L.R. No. 7340/173 measuring 2.538 hectares issued to the Defendant on 9/5/1995. No evidence was led to show whether L.R. No. 7340/173 was ever subdivided by the Defendant. The plaint was filed on 4/3/2016. 5. A recent search done on the suit land would have confirmed whether any transactions were carried out against the land after the certificate of title was issued in 1995, for that is a very long time during which the status of the suit land may have changed. The Mavoko Municiapl Council issued a rates clearance certificate to the Defendant on 13/10/2010 in respect of plots 7340/157 and 7340/173. It is not clear whether the Defendant subdivided these two parcels of land and transferred the resultant parcels to third parties who should have been made parties to this suit. 6. The court declines to grant the orders sought in the plaint because no land reference number was given in respect of which the court could have granted the orders sought. Since the matter was not defended the Plaintifis will bear their own costs. DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 16TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2020 K.BOR JUDGE In the presence of:Mr. Stanley Kinyanjui for the Plaintifis Mr. V. Owuor- Court Assistant https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/3987/eng@2020-09-16 2
page 2 of 3
No appearance for the Defendant https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/3987/eng@2020-09-16 3
page 3 of 3