Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

Shokat Ebrahim Ali Mohho Omar v Integrar Auctioneers (K) Co & 3 others [2020] KEELC 1645 (KLR)

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MOMBASA ELC.NO. 289 OF 2018 SHOKAT EBRAHIM ALI MOHHO OMAR......................................PLAINTIFF VERSUS INTEGRAR AUCTIONEERS (K)CO KENYA FINANCE BANK (IL) THE LAND REGISTRAR MOMBASA THE HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL..............................................DEFENDANTS RULING 1. Before me for determination is the preliminary objection dated 31 st January, 2019 raised by the 2nd defendant on the sustainability of the suit herein on the following grounds: 1. That the suit herein is incompetent for failure to comply with mandatory statutory provisions as to the filing of civil proceedings against an institution under liquidation . 2. That no leave of court was obtained prior to the filing of this suit as against the 2 nd defendant/respondent and thus the proceedings are a nullity. 3. That the plaintiff has no legal capacity to sue on behalf of the estate of the late Sakinabhai Ali Mohamed. 4. That the filing of suits against institutions under liquidation is a matter regulated by law and relevant rules of procedure and this suit offends the same. 5. That the plaintiff’s suit is incompetent, misconceived, bad in law, in bad faith, frivolous and vexatious. 2. In the course of these proceedings the notice of motion dated 10 th December, 2018 by the plaintiff was withdrawn with costs to the 2 nd defendant. On 16th October, 2019, directions were taken that the preliminary objection be disposed of by way of written submissions. The 2nd defendant filed their written submissions on 21st November, 2019 while the plaintiff and the other defendants did not file any submissions within the time granted or at all. 3. In their submissions, the 2nd defendant stated that the plaintiff’s suit is primarily pegged on alleged misdeed of the 2 nd defendant. The 2nd defendant stated that it was placed under liquidation by the Central Bank of Kenya vide Gazette Notice No. 6269 of 8 th November, 1996 under Section 35 (1)of the Banking Act. It is the 2 nd defendant’s contention that the plaintiff had failed to obtain leave before filing the suit and because of that failure, the suit should be struck out with costs. The 2 nd defendant’s counsel relied on the case of Donald Smith Earle – v- Central Bank of Kenya & Another, Imperial Bank Limited (Interested Party) (2019)eKLR; Kuza Farms and Allied Limited –vDubai Bank of Kenya Limited (in liquidation) Kitale ELC No. 116 of 2017; and David WabwenI Wafula –v- Peter Wafula Khaemba & 2 Others (2018)eKLR. 4. The 2nd defendant further submitted that the suit is frivolous, vexatious, bad in law, in bad faith, misconceived and failed to disclose that the deceased had another suit pending against the 2 nd defendant, namely HCCC No. 667 of 1994. That having brought the suit on behalf of the estate of the deceased, the plaintiff was under duty to disclose to the court the existence of the prior suit and that the suit herein is sub

page 1 of 2

judice. It is the 2nd defendant’s contention that the multiplicity of suits against the 2 nd defendant is vexatious and thus is in bad faith and is tantamount to abuse of court process. The 2 nd defendant’s counsel relied on the case of Trust Bank Limited –v – Amin Company Ltd & Another (2000)KLR 164 (cited in Kivanga Estates Limited –v- National Bank of Kenya Limited (2017)eKLR.) The 2nd defendant urged the court to uphold the preliminary objection and dismiss the suit with costs. 5. I have considered the submissions in respect to the preliminary objection under considerations. The main issue to determine is whether the plaintiff ought to have obtained leave of the court before instituting this suit against the 2 nd defendant. It is not in dispute that the 2 nd defendant is in liquidation with the Kenya Deposit Insurance Corporation being the liquidator. Section 56 (2) of the Kenya Deposit Insurance Act 2012 requires that leave of the court be sought and obtained before commencing civil proceedings against an institution under receivership, liquidation or winding up. It states as follows: “No injunction may be brought or any other action or civil proceedings may be commenced or continued against an institution or in respect of iTs assets without the sanction of the court”. 6. The wording of the above Section is couched in mandatory terms. Institution in Section 1 of the Act is defined as bank, financial institution or mortgage finance company. In this case, institution is the 2 nd defendant. Indeed, in the plaint, the plaintiff describes the 2 nd defendant as “in liquidation”. It is clear from the above provision of the law that sanction of the court was necessary before suit was filed or presented. I note that the plaintiff has not filed my submissions in opposition of the preliminary objection herein. I must also add that the plaintiff has in the instant case, failed to show that leave of the court was sought and obtained before the suit herein was commenced. 7. As a consequent of the aforesaid, I find that the suit herein is incompetent. Having found that the suit is incompetent, the same is therefore not sustainable. I therefore allow the preliminary objection and strike out the suit against the defendants with costs DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED at MOMBASA this 20th day of July 2020 C.K. YANO JUDGE IN THE PRESENCE OF: Yumna Court Assistant C.K. YANO JUDGE

page 2 of 2

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.