Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
Original judgment

keelc-2018-00860

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI ELC PETITION NO. 614 OF 2013 FALCON KENYA LIMITED.......................................................APPLICANT VERSUS CHIEF LANDS REGISTRAR..........................................1ST RESPONDENT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.........................................2 ND RESPONDENT ABDULLAHI MUIRURI MUIGAI.....................1ST INTERESTED PARTY RAYMOND MWANGI WAWERU.....................2ND INTERESTED PARTY KARIUKI NJOROGE.........................................3RD INTERESTED PARTY PETER KARUMBI KEINGATI........................4TH INTERESTED PARTY JOSEPH NDUATI NGENDO............................5TH INTERESTED PARTY KIAMBU DANDORA FARMERS CO. LIMITED.....................................................6 TH INTERESTED PARTY RULING The Petitioner filed this Petition on 14th May, 2013 against the Respondents seeking: (1) An order of mandamus directing the Respondents to release to the Petitioner forthwith all documents of title relating to L.R No. 13379/3 submitted to them by the Petitioner for purposes of discharge of charge. (2) An order that the Respondents do unconditionally register the discharge of charge on the title of the property within such time frame as may be deemed appropriate by the court. (3) That the court do make, issue and give further and/or such further consequential orders, directions and/or findings as it may find fair and just to grant for the purposes of restoring the dignity and integrity of the Respondents’ offices and further for the purposes of enforcing or securing the enforcement of the mandatory provisions of the law as envisaged in the Constitutional of Kenya and the orders of the court. (4) An award of aggravated, exemplary and/or general damages together with mesne profits for the loss of user of the land. (5) Costs and interest. In its petition dated 9th May, 2013, the Petitioner averred that L.R No. 11379/3 (hereinafter “the suit property”) was transferred to it by Dandora Housing Schemes Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “Dandora Housing”) in 1981. The Petitioner averred that sometimes in 1998, it charged the suit property and on 9 th January, 2011, it presented its title together with a discharge of charge to the 1 st Respondent for registration. The Petitioner averred that its title to the suit property together with the discharge of charge were confiscated by the 1 st Respondent without any explanation and the same had not been returned. The Petitioner averred that the decision by the 1 st Respondent not to return the said title documents without giving reason amounted to a violation of its right to a fair administrative action guaranteed under

page 1 of 3

Article 47(2) of the Constitution. The Petitioner averred that from the time it lodged the said title document and discharge of charge for registration, the 1st Respondent had not communicated to it as to what had happened to the documents which is a violation of its right under Article 47(1) of the Constitution to expeditious, efficient, lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair administrative action. The Petitioner averred that the aim of the Respondents was to dispossess it of the suit property in violation of Article 40 of the Constitution. The Petitioner averred that it had absolute rights over the suit property and was entitled to be given back its title. The Respondents have not responded to the Petitioner’s Petition. On 23rd July, 2015 the Interested Parties were added to the petition as parties. The Interested Parties responded to the petition through a replying affidavit sworn by the 6th Interested Party’s director Joseph Mwangi Karanja on 15 th October, 2015. In their affidavit, the Interested Parties contended that the suit property was owned solely by the 6 th Interested Party and that its title is held on behalf of the 6 th Interested Party by its trustees. The Interested Parties contended that the original title for the suit property was in their possession and that they had produced the same in court for inspection. The Interested Parties averred that the said original title was neither lost nor had it been kept by the 1st Respondent, the Commissioner of Lands or any other authority. The Interested Parties contended that the allegations contained in the Petitioner’s Petition were all false and amounted to perjury. The Interested Parties termed the Petitioner’s director, Cornelius Peterson Waithaka “a fraudulent character” who had been engaged in fraud and forgery involving the suit property that belonged to the 6 th Interested Party. The Interested Parties averred that the dispute over the ownership of the suit property as between the Interested Parties, Cornelius Peterson Waithaka (“Waithaka”) and the Petitioner was heard and conclusively determined in Nairobi HCCC No. 1348 of 1972 and Nairobi HCCC No. 1088 of 2000 in which the 6th Interested Party’s title to the suit property was upheld. The Interested Parties averred that Waithaka forged a Provisional Certificate of title for the suit property and made entries therein transferring the suit property to Dandara Housing Schemes Ltd. on 16 th December, 1997 and thereafter to the Petitioner on 11 th December, 1998 before charging the property to a company known as Simply Perfect Development Company Limited on the same day. The Interested Parties averred that the acquisition of the said Provisional title and the entries made on the title thereafter were fraudulent and that Waithaka was arrested on account thereof and charged at Makadara Senior Principal Magistrate’s Court in Criminal Case No. 516 of 1999. The Interested Parties averred that the title for the suit property was not lost and that the purported Gazette Notice that was issued by the 1 st Respondent about the loss of the said title and its intention to issue a Provisional Certificate of title to the Petitioner was a further act of fraud on the part of Waithaka for which he should be arrested. The interested Parties contended that the issues raised in the Petition herein are res judicata since the same were fully and finally determined in Nairobi HCCC No. 1348 of 1972. What is now before me is the Interested Parties’ Notice of Motion application dated 20 th August, 2015 seeking to strike out the Petitioner’s Petition with costs as an abuse of the process of the Court. The application which is supported by the affidavit of the 6 th Interested Party’s director Joseph Mwangi Karanja was brought on the same grounds set out in the Interested Parties’ replying affidavit the contents of which I have highlighted at length above. The Interested Parties have contended that the Petitioner has sought an order of mandamus directed at the 1st Respondent to release to it the title relating to the suit property. The interested parties have contended that the Petition is based on falsehood and lies in that the title for the suit property is in the possession of the Interested Parties and that the same is not lost neither has it been surrendered to the 1st Respondent. The Interested Parties have averred that on 23 rd July, 2015 the court had directed them to produce the original title for the suit property in court for inspection and they complied. The Interested Parties have contended that the Petitioner is taking the court for a ride and that the Petition has become moot after the production of the original title in court. The application was opposed by the Petitioner who relied on several affidavits sworn by Cornelius Peterson Waithaka (Waithaka). In its response to the application, the Petitioner reiterated that the suit property was transferred to Dandora Housing pursuant to a court order that was made in Nairobi HCCC No. 1348 of 1972 and that Dandora Housing thereafter transferred the property to the Petitioner. The Petitioner has contended that the certificate of title held by the Interested Parties which they produced in court is a forgery and the entries made therein are false. The Petitioner has averred that the 1 st Respondent who had custody of the certificate of title has never come to court to state the whereabouts of the same even after being ordered by the court to do so. The Petitioner has admitted that the issues raised in the Petition were determined in a previous suit but has contended that the same were determined in its favour. The Petitioner has accused the Interested Parties of engaging in fraud by producing false documents with the aim of subverting the cause of justice. The Interested Parties’ application was heard by way of written submissions. The Petitioner filed its submissions on 24 th January, 2018. The Interested Parties filed their submissions on 15 th November, 2017 and further submissions on 12 th February, 2018. I have considered the Interested Parties’ application together with the affidavit filed in support thereof. I am in agreement with the Petitioner that this is not an appropriate case for summary determination. I have at the beginning of this ruling summarised each party’s case. What is in contention in the petition before the court is the ownership of the suit property and the whereabouts of the valid certificate of title for the property. The Interested Parties have contended that they are the bona fide owners of the suit property and that they have in their custody the Original Certificate of title in respect thereof. The Petitioner has also contended that it is the lawful proprietor of the suit property and that its certificate of title for the suit property is in the custody of the 1 st Respondent who has declined to release the same. The Petitioner has termed the alleged original certificate of title held by the Interested Parties as fraudulent. The Interested Parties have likewise accused the Petitioner of holding a fraudulent title over the suit property. Both the Petitioner and the Interested Parties have admitted that they have been involved in several suits in which the issue of the ownership of the suit property has been determined. They are however not in agreement as to the decisions that were made on the issue in the said suits. The Petitioner has contended that the court in Nairobi HCCC No. 1348 of 1972 determined the issue of ownership of the suit property in its favour. The Interested Parties have contended to the contrary. The 1 st and 2nd Respondents who are the custodians of land records have kept mum. I am unable to determine the issue of the ownership of the suit property and the whereabouts of its valid certificate of title on the conflicting affidavit evidence before me. I have looked at the copy of the Certificate of title that was produced by the Interested Parties in court on 23 rd July, 2015. The title has the Interested Parties as the owners of the suit property. According to the title, the suit property has never been transferred to any other party since 8 th April, 1970 when the title was issued. There is no doubt that this is not the same title the subject of the Petitioner’s complaint before this court. The title which the Petitioner claims to have given to the 1st Respondent was in its name and had a charge registered on it. It is clear that the Petitioner and the Interested Parties are talking of different certificates of titles albeit for the same property. It will take a plenary hearing to determine the ownership of the suit property and the holder of a valid title as between the Petitioner and the Interested Parties. This court cannot determine the issues of fraud and forgery raised by both parties on affidavit evidence.

page 2 of 3

The up short of the foregoing is that the Interested Parties Notice of Motion dated 20 th August, 2015 wrongly dated 20th August, 2014 has no merit. The application is dismissed with costs to the Petitioner. Delivered and Dated at Nairobi this 12th day of November, 2018 S. OKONG’O JUDGE Ruling read in open court in the presence of: Ms. Wangari h/b for Mr. Kihara for the Petitioner No appearance for the 1st Respondent No appearance for the 2nd Respondent No appearance for the Interested Parties Catherine - Court Assistant

page 3 of 3

A note on accuracy. These pages are generated automatically from our AI-written case briefs and have not been checked by a lawyer. Case titles and citations come from Kenya Law; the counts, topics, propositions and “treatment” labels are derived from the briefs and can be incomplete or wrong. Use them as a research aid and always read the original judgment before relying on anything here. This is not legal advice.