Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
MagistrateDismissedConsolidated Election Petitions (unspecified in judgment)· [2018] KEMC 82 (KLR)

Shiyenji Silas Muyeyia & another v Benson Manuni Mulinya & 2 others [2018] KEMC 82 (KLR)

Chief Magistrate's Court (Election Court)
12 January 2018
2,968 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kakamega election court refused a vote recount because a signed results form and a two-vote margin alone weren't enough to justify one.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This ruling by E. Malesi, S.R.M. in the Kakamega election court resolves the 1st Petitioner's application dated 6/12/2017, made after the close of hearing in consolidated petitions challenging the election of Benson Manuni Mulinya as Member of County Assembly for Idakho East Ward on 8/8/2017. The application sought a recount of votes in four polling stations (Kasavayi, Ivole, Shitoli and Lwenya Primary Schools) and the production of election materials including polling day diaries and ballot boxes. The 2nd and 3rd Respondents objected in limine, contending that section 82 of the Elections Act covers only scrutiny and not recount, and that Rule 29 of the 2017 Petition Rules was wrongly invoked. The court rejected both objections, holding that election courts have jurisdiction over both recount and scrutiny and that Rule 29 was the correct provision. On the merits, applying the Supreme Court's Munya principles and the Wambua decision, the court found: the Kasavayi agent's signed Form 36A vouched for the results absent deceit or undue influence; ODM's interests at Ivole were protected by another agent who signed Form 36A without reservation; the alleged stray presidential vote at Shitoli was outside the court's jurisdiction and could not benefit any MCA candidate; and the Lwenya allegation rested on untested, hearsay evidence. The two-vote margin between the winner (2,155) and the 1st Petitioner (2,153) was held not per se to justify a recount absent allegations of counting and tallying errors. The application was dismissed in its entirety, with costs to abide the outcome of the main petition.

Key legal issues

#
01

Jurisdiction to order recount

Holding

The court has jurisdiction to entertain applications for both recount and scrutiny under the Elections Act and the 2017 Petition Rules

Reasoning

The 2nd and 3rd Respondents argued in limine that section 82 of the Elections Act covers only scrutiny, not recount, and that Rule 29 was wrongly cited. The court reviewed a 'plethora of decisions' holding that election courts have jurisdiction over both recount and scrutiny, and found Rule 29 (not Rule 32) to be the relevant provision, so it proceeded to consider the application on merit.

p. 4
02

Effect of an agent's signature on Form 36A

Holding

A voluntary signature on Form 36A's declaration vouches for the announced results

Reasoning

At Kasavayi, the agent alleged the Presiding Officer announced 47 votes while Form 36A recorded 46, yet he signed the form under protest. The court held the declaration binds the signatory unless signing was procured by deceit or undue influence, and found no sufficient basis for a recount there.

p. 5
03

Hearsay and untested evidence

Holding

An affidavit of an agent not availed as a witness for cross-examination carries no probative value

Reasoning

The allegation of discrepancy in Form 36A at Lwenya was deposed to by the Petitioner on information from his agent, who was not produced as a witness. The court held such evidence to be hearsay and inadmissible in support of a recount at that station.

p. 6
04

Effect of narrow margin of victory

Holding

A narrow margin alone does not justify a recount; it matters only where counting or tallying errors are alleged

Reasoning

The margin between the winner (2,155 votes) and the 1st Petitioner (2,153 votes) was two votes. Applying the Munya principles, the court found the allegations were of 'anomalies and irregularities' rather than counting and tallying errors, so the narrow margin did not establish a basis for recount.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • An election court is clothed with jurisdiction to entertain applications both for recount and scrutiny
  • A recount is limited to establishing the number of votes garnered by the candidates and the tallying of such votes
  • An agent who voluntarily signs Form 36A cannot turn back to dispute the results unless the signature was obtained by deceit or undue influence

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The application dated 6/12/2017 is dismissed in its entirety
  2. 2.Costs shall abide the outcome of the main petition

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Elections Act, 2011section 82
  • Elections Act, 2011section 80(4)
  • Elections Act, 2011section 30(1) and (2)
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petitions Rules, 2017Rules 28 and 29
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petitions Rules 2013Rule 33 (as referenced in Munya principles)
  • Elections (General) Regulations, 2012Regulation 62(1) and (2)

Cases cited (6)

  • Gatirau Peter Munya v Dickson Mwenda Kithinji & 2 Others
    [2014] eKLR
  • William Maina Kamanda v Margaret Wanjiru & 2 Others
    [2008] eKLR
  • Joho v Nyange & Anor
    [2008] 3KLR (EP) 500
  • Justus Gesito Mugali M'maya v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 2 Others
    [2013] eKLR
  • Gedion Mwangangi Wambua & Another v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 2 Others
    [2013] eKLR
  • Bwana Mohamed Bwana v Silvano Buko Bonaya & 2 Others
    [2013] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Election petition under the Elections Act, 2011 (ss. 80(4), 82) and the Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petitions Rules, 2017 (Rules 28 and 29)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Shiyenji Silas Muyeyia & another v Benson Manuni Mulinya & 2 others [2018] KEMC 82 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). Consolidated Election Petitions (unspecified in judgment). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2018/82/eng@2018-01-12

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.