Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
MagistrateStruck OutElection Petition No 1 of 2017· [2018] KEMC 69 (KLR)

Regina Chepkemboi Chumba v Jubilee Party & 16 others [2018] KEMC 69 (KLR)

High Court of Kenya (Election Court, Magistrate's Court level)
26 January 2018
3,173 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~13 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan election petition was struck out because the petitioner failed to pay a mandatory Kshs.100,000 security deposit and served the petition nearly a month late.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This ruling by Hon. C. Obulutsa, CM, dealt with three intertwined applications in an election petition challenging the election of a Member of County Assembly. The Petitioner, a person living with disability, sought waiver of the statutory deposit of Kshs.100,000/- security, while the 2nd Respondent and the Interested Parties sought striking out/dismissal of the petition on the grounds of non-deposit of security and late service. The court found it not in dispute that the Petitioner never deposited the security required by Section 78 of the Elections Act within the 10 days allowed by Rule 11(1). Relying on superior-court authority including Morris Mutisa v Naomi Shaban and Ibrahim Ahmed v IEBC, the court held the deposit requirement mandatory and substantive, going to the root of the petition, with no statutory provision empowering the court to waive it; Article 159(2) was held not a panacea for substantive omissions. On service, the court found the petition filed on 5.9.17 was served only on 4.10.17 and 5.10.17, far outside the 15 days prescribed by Section 76(1)(a), with no explanation offered, and reiterated that electoral timelines are strictly enforced and are not mere technicalities. The court also noted uncertainty over whether the Petitioner sued personally or representatively. The Petitioner's application for waiver was dismissed with costs; the 2nd Respondent's and Interested Parties' applications were allowed; the petition was struck out with costs, capped at Kshs.500,000/- (250,000/- each to the 2nd Respondent and the Interested Parties), to be taxed by the Executive Officer.

Key legal issues

#
01

Failure to deposit security of 100,000/- under Section 78 of the Elections Act

Holding

Failure to deposit security is a breach of a mandatory statutory provision that goes to the root of the petition; the court has no discretion to waive it.

Reasoning

Section 78(2)(c) requires a petitioner against an MCA to deposit 100,000/- within 10 days under Rule 11(1). Authorities (Kamau J in the Voi case; Kimaru J in Ibrahim Ahmed; Morris Mutisa v Naomi Shaban) hold the requirement substantive and imperative, aimed at compensating successful respondents and deterring frivolous petitions. Parliament made no provision for waiver; Article 159(2) cannot cure substantive omissions.

p. 6
02

Service of the petition outside the 15-day period prescribed by Section 76(1)(a) of the Elections Act

Holding

The petition was served almost a month late, contrary to the law; late service is a substantive defect going to the root of the petition.

Reasoning

The petition filed on 5.9.17 ought to have been served by 20.9.17 but was served on 4.10.17 (Interested Parties) and 5.10.17 (Respondents). The petitioner gave no explanation, filing only grounds of opposition. Following the Bench Book authorities and Peter Gatira Munya v Dickson Githinji, electoral timelines are strictly enforced as fundamental to timely resolution of electoral disputes.

p. 5
03

Capacity of the Petitioner - personal or representative suit

Holding

The court found it unclear whether the petitioner sued personally or on behalf of persons living with disability; she was not a party to the Political Parties Disputes Tribunal judgment she relied on.

Reasoning

The respondents argued unnamed persons could not be represented. The court observed the petition did not indicate a representative capacity, nor that the petitioner had offered herself for nomination, and that she did not appear as a party in the PPDT judgment. Reference was made to Jane Njeri Kamande v Anthony Njomo Maina on voter petitions.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • Deposit of security under Section 78 of the Elections Act is a mandatory, substantive requirement that cannot be waived by the court and is not curable under Article 159(2).
  • Service of an election petition within the prescribed 15 days is fundamental; failure to serve in the prescribed manner and time is fatal.
  • Electoral dispute resolution timelines are not mere procedural technicalities under Article 159(2).

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Petitioner's application (for waiver of deposit of security) is dismissed with costs
  2. 2.The applications by the 2nd Respondent and the Interested Parties are allowed
  3. 3.The Petition is struck out with costs
  4. 4.Costs capped at 500,000/-: 2nd Respondent entitled to 250,000/- and the Interested Parties to 250,000/-, to be taxed by the Executive Officer

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 48, 56(a), 87(1), 159(2), 174(e)
  • Elections Act, 2011Sections 76(1)(a), 78(1), 78(2), 78(2)(c), 78(3)
  • Election (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition RulesRules 5, 11(1), 21(1)

Cases cited (17)

  • LYDIA MAITHA VS NAISULA LESULIDA
    (2013) EKLR
  • NICHOLAS KORIR SALAT VS IEBC
    (2013) EKLR
  • KIRINYAGA UNITED BAR OWNERS VS COUNTY SECRETARY KIRINYAGA COUNTY GOVERNMENT
    (2014) EKLR
  • PATRICK KIMANZI VS MARCUS MUTUA
    (2013) EKLR
  • JACINTA MWATELA VS IEBC & 3 OTHERS
    (2013) EKLR
  • IBRAHIM AHMED VS IEBC
    (2017) EKLR
  • NORRIS MUINDI VS NAOMI SHABAN & OTHERS
    (2017) EKLR
  • RAILA ODINGA VS IEBC AND OTHERS
    Supreme Court Petition No.5 of 2013
  • ROZA AKINYI NUYU VS IEBC & 2 OTHERS
    CA 40 of 2013 Kisumu
  • CHARLES KIMUREN VS GRACE CHELAGAT
    Election Petition No.1 of 2013 Eldoret
  • PETER GATIRA MUNYA VS DICKSON GITHINJI
    Petition No.2'b' of 2014
  • PAUL ABWORA VS IEBC
    CA 52/2013
  • MARY WAMBUI VS PETER GICHUKI
    Petition 7/2016
  • LEMANKEN ARAMAT VS HARUN LEMPAKA & 2 OTHERS
    Subordinate Court Petition 5/2014
  • MORRIS MUTISA VS NAOMI SHABAN
    (2017) EKLR
  • JANE NJERI KAMANDE VS ANTHONY NJOMO MAINA & OTHERS
    Election Petition No.1 of 2017
  • IN THE MATTER OF ACT PEOPLE ACT, 1983 & IN THE MATTER OF THE MAYORAL ELECTION FOR THE LONDON BOROUGH OF TOWER HAMLETS BETWEEN ANDREW ERLAM VS MOHAMED LUFTUR RAHMAN AND JOHN WILLIAMS
Jurisdiction invoked
Election petition against a Member of County Assembly under the Elections Act, 2011 and the Election (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Regina Chepkemboi Chumba v Jubilee Party & 16 others [2018] KEMC 69 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). Election Petition No 1 of 2017. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2018/69/eng@2018-01-26

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.