Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
MagistrateAllowedElection Petition (Njukiini Ward), ruling on Notice of Motion dated 5/8/2013· [2013] KEMC 69 (KLR)

Wilson Waweru Wambugu v IEBC & 3 others [2013] KEMC 69 (KLR)

Resident Magistrate's Court (Election Court)
16 August 2013
4,047 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~16 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan election court allowed a recount at two polling stations where a candidate's agent was ejected and result forms conflicted, with only 17 votes separating the candidates.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a ruling within a magistrates' court election petition concerning the election of the Member of County Assembly for Njukiini ward, delivered by T.M. Mwangi, PM, at Gichugu on 16th August 2013. The petitioner had sought scrutiny and recount of all votes cast in the ward; by Notice of Motion dated 5/8/2013, made after close of trial but before judgment, he sought scrutiny and recount limited to Kanjuu and Ngiriambu Primary School Polling Stations. The court confirmed its jurisdiction under Sections 2 and 75(1A) of the Elections Act read with Rule 6 of the Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013. It held that a partial scrutiny could be ordered despite a wide petition prayer, particularly since the parties had consented at pre-trial to limit scrutiny to the two stations. It also held that unpleaded evidence could support the application, invoking Section 80(1)(d) and the wide discretion in Section 82. On the evidence, the unchallenged ejection of the petitioner's agent at Kanjuu, and errors and discrepancies between forms 35 and 36 at Ngiriambu - including two differing, unsigned second forms 36 - together with a narrow margin of 17 votes, laid sufficient foundation for scrutiny. The court held Section 83 of the Act was a matter for judgment, not the interlocutory stage, and that the applicant need not prove his case to the balance of probabilities. The court ordered scrutiny and recount in both stations under the Registrar's supervision, with two agents per side, commencing 19th August 2013, costs to abide the petition's outcome.

Key legal issues

#
01

Jurisdiction of the court to hear the election petition

Holding

The court, as a Resident Magistrate's Court designated by the Chief Justice, had jurisdiction under Sections 2 and 75(1A) of the Elections Act and Rule 6 of the Petition Rules.

Reasoning

Section 2 defines an Election Court to include the Resident Magistrate's Court designated by the Chief Justice under Section 75 of the Act. Section 75(1A) vests questions on validity of election of a Member of a County Assembly in such designated court, and Rule 6(1)(b) requires the court to be composed of a Resident Magistrate so designated. This court was gazetted by the Chief Justice for this petition.

p. 3
02

Whether partial scrutiny is permissible despite a wide prayer in the petition

Holding

Yes; a partial scrutiny limited to a few polling stations may be allowed if sufficient reasons are put forth.

Reasoning

The court reasoned that the wide petition prayer did not preclude partial scrutiny, that Rule 4 requires just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution, that the parties had consented at pre-trial to limit scrutiny to the two stations, and that narrowing the issue did not prejudice the respondents.

p. 5
03

Whether unpleaded evidence may support a scrutiny application

Holding

Yes, in the circumstances of this case, given the court's mandate under Section 80(1)(d) to decide matters without undue regard to technicalities and the wide discretion in Section 82.

Reasoning

Although material facts regarding Ngiriambu station were not pleaded, the court agreed with Majanja J that relevant evidence should not be locked out on technical grounds, since the prime concern is whether the election was free, fair and transparent and reflected the will of voters. The discretion under Section 82 must, however, be exercised judiciously.

p. 5
04

Whether the evidence disclosed sufficient reason for scrutiny of the two stations

Holding

Yes; the ejection of the petitioner's agent at Kanjuu and the discrepancies between forms 35 and 36 at Ngiriambu, plus the narrow 17-vote margin, laid a foundation for scrutiny.

Reasoning

DW3's evidence that he was called to replace the ejected PW2, together with PW2's evidence of ejection at the 4th respondent's request, laid sufficient reason for Kanjuu. At Ngiriambu, errors between form 35 and two differing forms 36 - including one unsigned by agents - required the court to ascertain the integrity of the results. The margin of 17 votes was narrow.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • A court may order a partial scrutiny limited to specific polling stations notwithstanding a wide prayer in the petition, if sufficient reasons are advanced.
  • Sufficient reasons must exist before a court permits scrutiny or recount of votes.
  • Scrutiny may be founded on irregularities in the voting process, not only on complaints about counting.
  • Errors in forms 35 and 36 justify scrutiny even if they could not alter the outcome.
  • A narrow margin of votes lays a foundation for scrutiny.
  • Section 83 of the Elections Act is a saving clause to be considered at judgment stage, not at an interlocutory scrutiny application.
  • At the scrutiny application stage the applicant need not prove his case to the balance of probabilities.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.There shall be scrutiny and recount to ascertain the number of votes each candidate obtained in Kanjuu Primary School Polling Station and Ngiriambu Primary School Polling Station
  2. 2.The scrutiny and recount shall be undertaken under the supervision of the Registrar of the Election Court
  3. 3.The petitioner and the respondents shall each be allowed 2 agents present during the exercise
  4. 4.The scrutiny shall commence on 19th August 2013 at 9.00am and proceed on a day-to-day basis until conclusion
  5. 5.The case to be mentioned on 22/8/2013 at 9.00am for further directions
  6. 6.Costs to abide the outcome of the petition

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 165(a); Article 163(3)(a); Article 81
  • Elections ActSection 2; Section 75(1A); Section 80(1)(d); Section 82(1); Section 83
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013Rule 4; Rule 6(1), 6(2); Rule 33(1), 33(2)
  • Election (General) Regulations 2012Regulation 83

Cases cited (7)

  • Jared Odoyo Okello – vs – I.E.B.C. and Other
    Kisumu Election Petition Number 1 of 2013
  • William Maina Kamanda – Vs – Margaret Wanjiru Kariuki
    Nairobi E.P. No. 5 of 2008
  • Ngata Kariuki Case
  • Richard Kalembe Ndile and Anor. – vs – Dr. Patrick Musimba Mweu
    Machakos H.C.E.P. No. 1 & 7 of 2013
  • Philip Osore Ogutu – vs – Michael Ongaro Aringo and 2 others
    Busia H.C.E.P. No. 1/2013
  • Richard Hamid Ahmed Amana – vs – IEBC and 2 Others
    Malindi H.C.E.P. No. 6/2013
  • John – vs – Nyange
    (2006) eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Sections 2 and 75(1A) of the Elections Act read with Rule 6 of the Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013; Resident Magistrate's Court designated by the Chief Justice

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Wilson Waweru Wambugu v IEBC & 3 others [2013] KEMC 69 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2013). Election Petition (Njukiini Ward), ruling on Notice of Motion dated 5/8/2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kemc/2013/69/eng@2013-08-16

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.