Mghendi v Governor, Taita Taveta County & another (Cause E133 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 1960 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court ruled a county secretary's firing was unfair, but because he tampered with his own contract, he won only one shilling in compensation.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Validity of the 5-year contract and alterations to the appointment letter
The claimant admitted altering page 2 of his 4-year contract to reflect a 5-year term; the alterations were not sanctioned by the 1st respondent or vetted by the County Assembly, and the second contract bore the signature details of a different Governor, amounting to alteration of official records, a criminal offence and gross misconduct under Section 44(4)(g).
The appointing authority for County Secretary is the Governor with County Assembly approval under Section 44 of the CGA. Neither was privy to the alterations. The second contract purportedly bore the hand of the former Governor with the same dates, which the claimant failed to explain. Criminal conduct against the employer's detriment attracts summary dismissal under Section 44(4)(g) of the Employment Act.
Whether the claimant misled the Board into converting two employees' contracts
The claimant was culpable: using his position as chairperson of the County human resources advisory committee, he misled the 2nd respondent into converting Samuel Mwanyasi's and Peter Salai's term contracts to permanent and pensionable terms, amounting to abuse of office.
The claimant knew the two officers served under term contracts, yet by letters and clarifications induced the Board to convert them. Motive existed since Mwanyasi and Salai had played key roles in altering the claimant's own contract and IPPD records. This was contrary to constitutional principles and the law.
Whether retirement in the public interest was a valid reason for termination
The public-interest reason was baseless: the misconduct findings related to internal matters within the 1st respondent's office, no complaint from the public was lodged or investigated, and altering the disciplinary findings to a different cause of action rendered the termination unfair under Section 45.
Applying D.K. Njagi Marete, a public employer must show objective, demonstrable grounds driven by public policy, with a complaint initiated, investigated and answered. Here the grounds were gross misconduct within the Governor's own office, with no public complaint. The substitution of the disciplinary committee's findings lacked basis in law or fact, hence unfair termination.
Remedies despite unfair termination
Although termination was procedurally wanting, the claimant's gross misconduct and abuse of office justified only nominal compensation of one shilling, following Lillian W. Mbogo-Omollo.
Save for the defective reasons, the claimant received due process and valid grounds existed for summary dismissal. He was offered an ex gratia payment. Under Section 45(5) his conduct must be weighed, and rewarding misconduct with substantial compensation would be inappropriate; nominal damages of one shilling were awarded.
Legal principles established
#- Retirement in the public interest is a form of termination requiring the employer to show objective, demonstrable and justified grounds; it cannot be invoked merely as a label.
- Under Section 43 of the Employment Act, the onus is on the employer to prove the reasons for termination, on a partly subjective test of reasons genuinely believed to exist.
- In awarding remedies under Section 45(5), the court must take into account the employee's conduct, even where due process was wanting.
Court orders
#- 1.Declaration that the claimant's employment was terminated unfairly
- 2.Compensation of Ksh.1 (one Shilling)
- 3.The claimant to access his gratuity through the pension scheme rules and regulations
- 4.Costs of Ksh.10,000 to the claimant
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original employment and labour relations jurisdiction under the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and Article 162(2) of the Constitution (not expressly cited in the judgment)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Mghendi v Governor, Taita Taveta County & another (Cause E133 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 1960 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Cause No E133 of 2023. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2024/1960/eng@2024-07-04
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.