Mudanya v Hiddig Hotels Nairobi Company Limited (Employment and Labour Relations Cause E518 of 2020) [2024] KEELRC 1654 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan hotel's Covid-19 redundancy was lawful in reason but unlawful in process, costing it over Kshs 600,000 in court-ordered payments.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether there was a valid reason for termination on grounds of redundancy
Valid reason established: the respondent's business was adversely affected by Covid-19 and there was a genuine operational need to scale down operations and reduce the wage bill.
The court took judicial notice of the Covid-19 pandemic and its effects. It found that restaurants were shut down and the hotels operated at a much lower scale. The fact that the claimant was not required to report to work or perform continuous work for about three months (April to June 2020) demonstrated a valid operational reason to reduce staff and costs.
Whether the redundancy procedure under section 40 of the Employment Act was followed
The procedure was not followed; the termination was un-procedural despite the valid reason.
The respondent failed to issue one-month notice to the claimant and the labour office of the intended redundancy; failed to engage the claimant on the selection criteria and reasons for his selection; and failed to calculate and pay accrued leave. Only notice pay and a token were paid. The respondent therefore failed the procedural test.
The appropriate remedy for the un-procedural redundancy termination
Compensation equivalent to two months' salary (Kshs 200,000/=) under section 49(1)(c) and (4), considering the short service period of 8½ months and the Supreme Court decision in Kenfrieght East Africa Ltd v Benson K. Ngut.
The court distinguished between awards under section 40 and remedies under section 49, holding that a court exercising discretion under section 49 must be guided by section 49(4) factors, including the employee's short period of service, non-contribution to the termination and non-payment of terminal benefits. Renewal of the fixed-term contract was discretionary and created no legitimate expectation.
Claims for unpaid salary, ½ month salary, leave and underpayment
Unpaid salary for April, May and June 2020 (Kshs 300,000/=), ½ month salary to 13th July 2020 (Kshs 50,000/=) and 26 days' leave not taken (Kshs 100,000/=) were proved and awarded; underpayment for October 2019 was dismissed.
The claimant proved he was not paid salary for April to June 2020 at Kshs 100,000/= per month and that ½ month's salary to 13th July 2020 was unpaid. Having served over 8 months, he had earned his full leave. However, the contract expressly stated a gross salary of Kshs 70,000/=, so the October 2019 underpayment claim failed.
Claim of discriminatory remuneration
Dismissed for failure of proof.
The claimant alleged he was paid less than junior staff on grounds of tribe, race and religion. The court found the salaries of the other employees (Kshs 113,000/=, 106,000/= and 125,000/=) not drastically different from the claimant's Kshs 100,000/=, and that job descriptions and length of service could account for differences. The burden under sections 107 and 108 of the Evidence Act was not discharged.
Respondent's counter-claim for breach of confidence
No damages awarded on the counter-claim; the final orders made no provision for it.
The respondent alleged the claimant disclosed confidential financial records and documents in the suit, breaching fiduciary duties. The judgment's determination and final orders do not address or grant any relief on this counter-claim, and judgment was entered only in favour of the claimant.
Legal principles established
#- An employer relying on redundancy must strictly comply with the procedure in section 40 of the Employment Act, including one-month notice to the employee and the labour office, discussion of selection criteria, and payment of accrued leave; failure renders the termination un-procedural and attracts compensation under section 49.
- Compensation for un-procedural termination is discretionary and to be exercised judiciously under section 49 of the Employment Act, having regard to the factors in section 49(4), including length of service.
- A discretionary contractual salary enhancement does not alter the contracted salary retroactively and cannot found a claim for underpayment of the originally contracted amount.
- The burden of proving discrimination lies on the employee under sections 107 and 108 of the Evidence Act, Cap 80.
Court orders
#- 1.Judgment entered in favour of the claimant against the respondent for Kshs 200,000/= in compensation for the un-procedural termination on grounds of redundancy.
- 2.Kshs 350,000/= arrear salary for the months of April, May and June up to 17th July 2020.
- 3.Kshs 100,000/= in lieu of 26 leave days not taken.
- 4.Kshs 10,000/= underpayment for 5 months.
- 5.Total award of Kshs 600,060/=.
- 6.Interest at court rates from the date of judgment till payment in full.
- 7.Costs of the suit to the claimant.
- 8.Notice pay and token declared already duly paid to the claimant and not awarded.
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Employment and Labour Relations Court jurisdiction over employment disputes under the Employment Act, 2007
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Mudanya v Hiddig Hotels Nairobi Company Limited (Employment and Labour Relations Cause E518 of 2020) [2024] KEELRC 1654 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Not stated in the judgment as provided. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2024/1654/eng@2024-06-27
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.