Ngoci v Broadview Security Limited (Employment and Labour Relations Appeal E038 of 2022) [2024] KEELRC 544 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Employment Court ruled that a phone-call dismissal with no hearing is unfair termination, overturning a finding that the accountant had resigned.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the appellant voluntarily resigned or was unfairly dismissed
The appellant was unfairly dismissed by the respondent's HR Manager; he did not resign.
The respondent filed no defence and tendered no evidence. The appellant's uncontroverted testimony was that his services were terminated by phone call by the HR Manager, followed by a text message directing handover of company property, with no reason given and no hearing. The Court therefore found dismissal, not resignation, proved on a balance of probability. The trial court had wrongly rested its resignation finding on a trade union letter that was never formally produced.
Whether reliance on a document not produced as an exhibit vitiates the trial judgment
Yes; the trial court erred in relying on a document marked for identification/withdrawn and never produced.
Following Kenneth Nyaga Mwige v Austin Kiguta & 2 others, the Court held that a trial court must not base its decision on a document not formally produced as an exhibit. The trial court relied on a trade union letter appearing on the claimant's list of documents but never produced during trial, which was a fatal error.
Whether the termination was unfair and unlawful
The termination was unfair within section 45 of the Employment Act; the respondent failed to prove a valid reason and fair procedure.
Under sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, the employer bears the burden of proving a valid and fair reason and fair procedure, including hearing the employee. The uncontroverted evidence was that the appellant was dismissed over the phone without reasons, notice or a hearing. The respondent having adduced no evidence, unfair termination was established.
What remedies the appellant is entitled to under section 49
Two months' salary (Kshs.42,000.00) as compensation, plus refunds of Sacco deductions and other amounts upheld.
Under section 49 the appellant elected monetary compensation. Having worked for less than two years with a clean record, two months' salary was awarded. The trial court's awards for salary for October/November 2019 and cash guarantee were upheld at the appellant's own request, and the claim for Kshs.17,000 Sacco deductions was granted as unrebutted and corroborated by pay slips.
Legal principles established
#- A trial court errs by basing its decision on a document marked for identification but never formally produced as an exhibit.
- On a first appeal the court must re-evaluate the evidence on record and reach its own independent conclusions.
- Uncontroverted evidence that an employee was dismissed without a reason or a hearing proves unfair termination under section 45 of the Employment Act.
Court orders
#- 1.Appeal allowed; the impugned judgment of the trial court set aside
- 2.Compensation for unfair termination of Kshs.42,000.00
- 3.Salary for October and November 2019 of Kshs.42,000.00
- 4.Cash guarantee refund of Kshs.7,500.00
- 5.Refund of Sacco deductions of Kshs.17,000.00
- 6.Total award of Kshs.106,500.00 in favour of the appellant
- 7.Costs of the appeal and the court below plus interest at court rate from the date of judgment
- 8.Award subject to statutory deductions
- 9.Certificate of service (as awarded by the trial court, undisturbed in respect of what the appellant asked to be upheld)
- On appeal from
- Trial court (Principal Magistrate's Court)
- Not stated
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appellate jurisdiction of the Employment and Labour Relations Court over the trial court's judgment (appeal against judgment in employment claim under the Employment Act)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Ngoci v Broadview Security Limited (Employment and Labour Relations Appeal E038 of 2022) [2024] KEELRC 544 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Not stated in judgment (ELRC appeal from trial court, Nyeri). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2024/544/eng@2024-03-08
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.