Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCStruck OutPetition No E005 of 2023· [2024] KEELRC 33 (KLR)

Lubengu v Ottichilo & 2 others (Petition E005 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 33 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
25 January 2024
6,074 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~24 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Employment Court struck out a Vihiga County adviser's petition because he first had to appeal his termination to the Public Service Commission.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Petitioner, formerly the Legal and Policy Advisor in the Office of the Governor of Vihiga County, petitioned the Employment and Labour Relations Court at Kakamega challenging the termination of his appointment by the County Secretary by letter dated 9th October 2023. He sought declarations that the termination violated Articles 41, 47, 50, 27 and 236 of the Constitution, an order of judicial review quashing the decision, declarations that the County Secretary's continued occupation of office was unlawful from 31st May 2023, and damages. The Respondents raised a Notice of Preliminary Objection contending that the Court lacked jurisdiction because the dispute was appealable to the Public Service Commission under Section 77 of the County Governments Act and Section 87(2) of the Public Service Commission Act, which bars court proceedings before exhaustion of that statutory appeal process. The Petitioner argued the termination was by the County Secretary - allegedly illegally in office - and not by the County Public Service Board, and that his constitutional claims were not amenable to the PSC pre-appeal process. The Court held that Section 77(2) extends appealability to decisions made by a person in the purported exercise of disciplinary control, including the County Secretary as Head of County Public Service. Applying the Supreme Court jurisprudence in Abidha Nicholus and the Court of Appeal in Ramogi, the Court found the real issue was the fairness of termination, adequately covered by the Employment Act, and that mere citation of constitutional provisions could not oust the statutory mechanism - a case of constitutional avoidance. The Preliminary Objection was upheld, the Petition struck out for prematurity, and each party ordered to bear its own costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the dispute over the Petitioner's termination falls within the Public Service Commission's appellate jurisdiction

Holding

Yes. Section 77 of the County Governments Act extends the appeal mechanism to decisions made by a person in the purported exercise of disciplinary control, including the County Secretary acting as Head of County Public Service.

Reasoning

The Court distinguished between section 77(1), which restricts appeals to Board decisions, and section 77(2), which does not restrict the appellate function to Board decisions only. The termination letter was authored by the County Secretary as Head of County Public Service in the purported exercise of disciplinary control. The identity or legality of the decision-maker's office does not exclude the dispute from the PSC appeal route under section 77(2)(e).

p. 8
02

Whether constitutional citations exempt the Petitioner from exhausting the PSC appeal mechanism

Holding

No. The real issue was fairness of termination, adequately covered by the Employment Act; mere citation of Articles 41, 47 and 50 does not invoke the Court's jurisdiction.

Reasoning

Relying on the Court of Appeal in Ramogi and the Supreme Court in Abidha Nicholus, the Court held that exceptions to exhaustion are exceptional and restrictive. Since the petition disclosed no constitutional violation beyond the fairness of termination - a matter fully covered by the Employment Act and section 49 remedies - the doctrine of constitutional avoidance applied and the exhaustion requirement stood.

p. 13
03

Whether the County Secretary was illegally in office such that his termination decision was a nullity

Holding

The Court declined to examine this issue, finding its jurisdiction was not properly invoked and the challenge to the County Secretary's tenure should first go to the Public Service Commission under section 85 of the PSC Act.

Reasoning

The Petitioner relied on a letter indicating the County Secretary's term lapsed on 31st May 2023, but the Respondents produced a letter of 25th April 2023 showing the term was revised to five years pursuant to a court order and a statutory amendment. The Petitioner did not rebut this. The Court found no evidence the 3rd Respondent held office illegally and was not disputed to have been in office when authoring the termination letter.

p. 9

Legal principles established

#
  • Decisions on removal or disciplinary control in county public service, whether made by the County Public Service Board or a person in the purported exercise of such control, are first appealable to the Public Service Commission.
  • Citation of constitutional provisions alone does not oust the exhaustion requirement where the real dispute is a statutory employment matter.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 26th October 2023 by the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd Respondents is upheld
  2. 2.The Petition dated 13th October 2023 is struck out for being prematurely brought before the Court
  3. 3.Each party is to bear own costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • County Governments ActSection 77(1) and (2)
  • County Governments ActSection 44
  • Public Service Commission Act, No. 10 of 2017Section 87(2)
  • Public Service Commission Act, No. 10 of 2017Sections 85, 86
  • Public Service Commission Act, No. 10 of 2017Part XV
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 10, 23, 27, 41, 47, 50, 232, 234(2)(i), 236
  • Employment ActSection 49
  • Mutunga Rules (Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) and the Enforcement of the Constitution) Practice and Procedure RulesNot specified

Cases cited (18)

  • Owners of Motor Vessel 'Lillian S' v Caltex Oil Kenya Limited
    (1989) eKLR
  • Secretary, County Public Service Board & Another v Hulbhai Gedi Abdille
    (2017) eKLR
  • Lukale Moses Sande v Governor, County of Kakamega & 3 Others
    (2022) eKLR
  • Martin Kabubii Mwangi v County Government of Laikipia
    (2019) eKLR
  • Robert Khamala Situma & 8 Others v Acting Clerk of the Nairobi City County Assembly
    (2022) eKLR
  • Abdikadir Suleiman v County Government of Isiolo & Another
    (2015) eKLR
  • Paul Kimeto Cheruiyot v Governor Narok County & 3 Others
    (2020) eKLR
  • Kenya National Union of Nurses v Vihiga County Public Service Board
    (2021) eKLR
  • Sammy Kalundu v Ag. Clerk of the Nairobi City County Assembly
    (2022) eKLR
  • James Akelerio alias Muguu & Another v Moses Kasaine Lenolkilal & 3 Others
    (2014) eKLR
  • William Odhiambo Ramogi & 3 Others v Attorney General & 4 Others; Muslims for Human Rights & 2 Others (Interested Parties)
    [2020] eKLR
  • R v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (I.E.B.C) Ex Parte National Super Alliance (NASA) Kenya and 6 Others
    [2017] eKLR
  • Night Rose Cosmetics (1972) Ltd v Nairobi County Government & 2 Others
    [2018] eKLR
  • Abidha Nicholus v Hon Attorney General and Others
    SC Pet. No. E007 of 2023
  • Albert Chaurembo Mumbo & 7 Others v Maurice Munyao & 148 Others
    SC Petition No 3 of 2016, [2019] eKLR
  • R v National Environmental Management Authority
    CA No 84 of 2010; [2011] eKLR
  • NGOs Co-ordination Board v EG & 4 Others; Katiba Institute (Amicus Curiae)
    (Petition 16 of 2019) [2023] KESC 17 (KLR)
  • Josephat Ndirangu v Henken Chemicals (EA) Limited
    2013 eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Constitution of Kenya, 2010 and the exhaustion doctrine under Section 87(2) of the Public Service Commission Act, No. 10 of 2017 as read with Section 77 of the County Governments Act, 2012

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Lubengu v Ottichilo & 2 others (Petition E005 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 33 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Petition No E005 of 2023. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2024/33/eng@2024-01-25

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.