Chirchir & 32 others v Jonathan Siwanyang, County Secretary West Pokot County Government & 2 others (Cause E001 of 2023) [2023] KEELRC 3346 (KLR)
The bottom line
#The court found county officers blocked workers from their jobs, but dismissed the contempt case because the applicants couldn't show exactly who did what.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the respondents were in contempt of the orders of February 15, 2023
Contempt was not proved against any of the named contemnors because the applicants failed to identify the specific role played by each of them, despite proving that the respondents had knowledge of the orders and that the applicants were prevented from accessing their workplaces.
The respondents admitted knowledge of the injunction and did not claim ambiguity, so the remaining elements were breach and deliberateness. The court accepted on the evidence that the applicants were barred from their workplaces, but the affidavit did not attribute any act to any individual contemnor. Contempt exposes individuals to loss of liberty and fines and must therefore be specifically proved against each cited person, not merely by virtue of the office held. The application accordingly failed.
Admissibility of electronic evidence (CDs) said to have been obtained illegally and uncertified
The court sidestepped detailed admissibility findings because the CDs were on file without a supporting affidavit reference and the further affidavit in which they were to be produced was never filed.
The respondents contested the electronic evidence as illegally obtained and uncertified under the Evidence Act. The court observed that although CDs were on the file, the affidavit filed with the application made no reference to them, and the further affidavit for which leave was granted was not on record, leaving unclear how the respondents obtained copies. Rather than rule on admissibility, the court found that even the rest of the evidence did not identify which contemnor did what.
Standard of proof applicable to contempt applications
The standard is higher than the balance of probabilities but does not reach the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
Relying on Gatharia K Mutitika v Baharini Farm Ltd, the court reiterated that contempt is an offence of criminal character for which a person may be imprisoned, so guilt must be proved with strictness consistent with the gravity of the charge - almost, but not exactly, beyond reasonable doubt. The court also noted reluctance-based caution: committal jurisdiction is arbitrary and unlimited and should be exercised with the greatest reluctance where another mode of doing justice exists.
Legal principles established
#- The elements of contempt are: clear and unambiguous terms of the order binding on the defendant; knowledge or proper notice of the terms; breach of the terms; and deliberate conduct.
- The standard of proof in contempt proceedings is higher than the balance of probabilities but below the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
- Contempt must be specifically proved against each cited person; liability cannot attach merely by virtue of office held.
- Court orders must be obeyed; a party dissatisfied with an order must seek to vary, discharge or appeal it - defiance is not an option.
Court orders
#- 1.The contempt application is dismissed with no orders as to costs
- 2.The County Secretary is directed to personally ensure that the orders of February 15, 2023 are obeyed by the respondents, failing which the court will not shy away from holding him in contempt should there be another similar application
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Inherent contempt jurisdiction of the Employment and Labour Relations Court to enforce its own orders of February 15, 2023
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Chirchir & 32 others v Jonathan Siwanyang, County Secretary West Pokot County Government & 2 others (Cause E001 of 2023) [2023] KEELRC 3346 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2023). Cause No E001 of 2023. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2023/3346/eng@2023-12-11
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.